If this isn't Mary Jane Watson then I'm blind

[Equint77]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg

For potential sequels.... if this isn't Mary Jane then I don't know who is.

Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst

[Morg]

It's Lindsay Lohan and she will never play MJ.

[Equint77]

It's Lindsay Lohan and she will never play MJ.


Morg... you can't tell me she doesn't have the look.

The hair.. the green eyes.... the face.

[Morg]

I don't ****ing care, she is too young looking, they going to make MJ regress her age in SM4?

[Odin's Lapdog]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg

For potential sequels.... if this isn't Mary Jane then I don't know who is.

Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst

ahahhahahahhahahhahahahha

man:D

[Equint77]

You know what.. since I'm in the minority now... Just kill off MJ and have Peter go out with Betty. :rolleyes: :)

Spider-man 4 won't be anywhere until 2009 maybe.

She's 18.. Kirsten is only like 22. Not that huge of a difference. I don't know.. I think she could pull it off. The part.. her clothes... whatever.

[Morg]

and you want her to sing some of the Spider-Man songs too?

[Odin's Lapdog]

put up your hands Equint, and step away from the dream....

[Morg]

It's wonldn't be a dream Odin but a nightmare.

[Odin's Lapdog]

i don't have the right equipment to deal with nightmares:(

[Equint77]

put up your hands Equint, and step away from the dream....


congradulations...even my dreams are mocked... :( :p


Leave Young Lohan alone.... she never hurt anyone... LOL

[Odin's Lapdog]

Whoa, i think you are a teeny bit too old to be dreaming about lohan:o

and she probably won't until she plays mj in a spidey movie, then we'll want her head on a platter. You wouldn't want to put her through that would you????

[American_Hobo]

Whoa, i think you are a teeny bit too old to be dreaming about lohan:o

and she probably won't until she plays mj in a spidey movie, then we'll want her head on a platter. You wouldn't want to put her through that would you????
Whoa, i think you are a teeny bit too old to be dreaming about lohan:o
LOL.....

[Odin's Lapdog]

i don't dream about lohan!!!!

:mad:


i dream about jojo

;)

[Franklin Richards]

MJ shouldn't sound like she smoked an entire pack of Lucky's.


:thing: :doom: :thing:

[American_Hobo]

i don't dream about lohan!!!!

:mad:


i dream about jojo

;)
who's jojo?

[blind_fury]

lohan looks 100 times more like MJ than dunst. kirsten dunst looks more like the lizard than mary jane watson. snaggle toothed beeyoch.

[American_Hobo]

lohan looks 100 times more like MJ than dunst. kirsten dunst looks more like the lizard than mary jane watson. snaggle toothed beeyoch.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v130/TheLizard/kirstengator.jpg


hmm....

[Odin's Lapdog]

who's jojo?

somebody very very young:o

the less you know the better:(

[terry78]

I admit, Dunst is not who I envision when I think of the Mary Jane Watson from the comics, looks wise, she seems very bland to me. Though she has acting skills though, and that's what is needed in the role. So as far as looking like MJ, she doesn't, but as far as getting her persona down, she's pretty close.

[Odin's Lapdog]

and you didn't even happen to mention her nipples, brilliant

:up:

:D

[blind_fury]

if dunst was gwen stacy and lohan was MJ it would be a vast improvement.

that way MJ would be played by a natural red head who could covincingly play an unattainable hottie. and dunst would have died in spidey one. someting i could watch over and over on dvd.

[Equint77]

Whoa, i think you are a teeny bit too old to be dreaming about lohan:o

and she probably won't until she plays mj in a spidey movie, then we'll want her head on a platter. You wouldn't want to put her through that would you????


Lohan's legal and already a boozing party girl... You might not think she can play MJ but she sure is living MJ's life.

Party girl.. twisted father.... green eyes... red hair....her personality is loose just like her XXXXXXX.

You get the point.

Young Lohan for MJ....

[Chris Wallace]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg

For potential sequels.... if this isn't Mary Jane then I don't know who is.

Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst
Where shall I send your cane?

[Wiseman]

I didn't know Mary Jane was such a slut

[terry78]

See, the thing is...I was looking at Alex Ross' Romita homage drawing, and the way he does MJ....I'm starting to see why Lohan does resemble her....

http://www.alexrossart.com/gallery/misc/homage/romita_mj_lg.jpg

[American_Hobo]

See, the thing is...I was looking at Alex Ross' Romita homage drawing, and the way he does MJ....I'm starting to see why Lohan does resemble her....

http://www.alexrossart.com/gallery/misc/homage/romita_mj_lg.jpg
MJ looks good here

[freelancer]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg

For potential sequels.... if this isn't Mary Jane then I don't know who is.

Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst

You're right in one thing, you're blind! :p

[Demogoblin]

I keep thinking of Lohan as MJ, too.

[Kmack]

Lohan seems a little too young when coupled with Tobey....and Kirsten ROX damnit!:mad:

[American_Hobo]

Lohan seems a little too young when coupled with Tobey....and Kirsten ROX damnit!:mad:
what are you ralking about?
Tobey only looks like 19 to me, and Lohan looks like 21 to me

[DACrowe]

I'll wait until I see her act more. Maybe.

And SM4 will not come out until 2010 so she will be much older for the "too young" crowd.

[TEDDY]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg

For potential sequels.... if this isn't Mary Jane then I don't know who is.

Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst
Besides the red head part, I don't see it. Besides, in the world of film, 18 year olds can't play 18 year olds. They have to play 13 year old girls, that way they can dress up in skimpy dresses and convincing men they're pedophiles.

[spideyboy_1111]

well u people who say shes to young do realise spidey 4 wont be out till at least 2010... and she will be in her 20's, tobey will be to old, or to old for a fifth... so he may be recasted too for spidey 4.. so lohan wouldnt be a problem.

[Spidergurl4302]

is it just me or do people that became famous when they were younger just never seem mature? i don't know its hard to explain

but besides the red hair Lohan doesnt look too much like MJ

now if this isn't Mary Jane Watson then i must be blind....
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v314/Jess5302/MJ.jpg

[freelancer]

I just don't understand the big fuss with this phisical resemblance... can someone explain me why? What's that got to do with performance?

[Spidergurl4302]

I just don't understand the big fuss with this phisical resemblance... can someone explain me why? What's that got to do with performance?they do need to act well but they do have to look somewhat like the comic i mean thats like having spider-man wearing a superman outfit but performing well as spider-man :confused:

[freelancer]

Tobey doesn't look like comic Peter and look where he is now!

[Spidergurl4302]

Tobey doesn't look like comic Peter and look where he is now!i think Tobey looks like comic Peter not so much Romita's Peter (even though i think he could pull it off and they didnt make his character so geeky) but Ditko's Peter

[dmcnx]

i don't dream about lohan!!!!

:mad:


i dream about jojo

;)

You should be ashamed...;)

[spideyboy_1111]

i think Tobey looks like comic Peter not so much Romita's Peter (even though i think he could pull it off and they didnt make his character so geeky) but Ditko's Peter
I agree 100%, tobey can look alot better then he does in the spidey movies, ive seen him better looking. And he looks like Peter when he looks good looking. Raimi keeps trying to due the ditko feel and i think he needs to get out of that mode. I think the movies should evolve just like the comics. Lohan though to me definately looks like Romita's MJ, hell not only that but shes freaking living an almost parrallel life to MJ... shes got the hair, the classic eyes, the skin, the smile, the green eyes, the body, shes a party girl, shes an actress, and shes got the f*d up father. now tell me this isnt MJ?

http://www.picturedot.com/FetchImageJPG.asp?ImageType=P&ImageFormat=H&ImageID=137243

http://www.picturedot.com/FetchImageJPG.asp?ImageType=P&ImageFormat=H&ImageID=137244

http://www.picturedot.com/FetchImageJPG.asp?ImageType=P&ImageFormat=H&ImageID=137245

http://www.picturedot.com/FetchImageJPG.asp?ImageType=P&ImageFormat=H&ImageID=137246
this one is just to show she can have the strait hair too

[Odin's Lapdog]

You should be ashamed...;)

as if you wouldn't:rolleyes:

and don't give me this trollocks that it's alright cause you are closer to her age.

if it's wrong for me, it's wrong for you:p

[Spidergurl4302]

I agree 100%, tobey can look alot better then he does in the spidey movies, ive seen him better looking. And he looks like Peter when he looks good looking. Raimi keeps trying to due the ditko feel and i think he needs to get out of that mode. I think the movies should evolve just like the comics.ya like in this pic i think he looks like Romita's Peter :up:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v314/Jess5302/RomitaPP-moviePP.bmp
Lohan though to me definately looks like Romita's MJ, hell not only that but shes freaking living an almost parrallel life to MJ... shes got the hair, the classic eyes, the skin, the smile, the green eyes, the body, shes a party girl, shes an actress, and shes got the f*d up father. now tell me this isnt MJ?i dont know i just cant see her as MJ but thats just me im not saying she looks nothing like her, or wont be old enough, or cant pull it off, etc.

[zanos]

Tobey doesn't look like comic Peter and look where he is now!

he doesn't look like comic book Peter but it's not so way off that it's unacceptable. The reason why ppl are so hung up on MJ's looks is because KD is way off. On top of that she's not even attractive in these films not is her character even written or acted well.

[Spidergurl4302]

he doesn't look like comic book Peter but it's not so way off that it's unacceptable. The reason why ppl are so hung up on MJ's looks is because KD is way off. On top of that she's not even attractive in these films not is her character even written or acted well.good point and just wondering zanos who would you want to play peter if Tobey has to be replaced? because your pick for MJ (based on looks) was really good :up:

[spideyboy_1111]

he doesn't look like comic book Peter but it's not so way off that it's unacceptable. The reason why ppl are so hung up on MJ's looks is because KD is way off. On top of that she's not even attractive in these films not is her character even written or acted well.
YA and i hate it because Kirsten Dunst can look REALLY hot and can act really well... its just Kirsten as Mj looks half asleep and giddy, and she acts cheesey. Kirsten has it in her, its just i don't feel her heart is in this movie and in her character. Shes the type of "popular" girl in highschool who has grown up thinking comics are dorky yadda yadda yadda and i have never heard her researching MJ in the comics or anything of the sort, where as Jennifer Garner, Jessica Alba, Femke Jenssen (sp?), and even Halle Berry have been quoted as picking up the comics and researching there characters, and actually falling in love with there character in the process...

[spideyboy_1111]

See, the thing is...I was looking at Alex Ross' Romita homage drawing, and the way he does MJ....I'm starting to see why Lohan does resemble her....

http://www.alexrossart.com/gallery/misc/homage/romita_mj_lg.jpg
i love the pic, but... im really not digging her nose in that pic.. it looks way off

[dmcnx]

as if you wouldn't:rolleyes:

and don't give me this trollocks that it's alright cause you are closer to her age.

if it's wrong for me, it's wrong for you:p

Itll never be wrong for me...NEVER!:p

[Spidergurl4302]

i love the pic, but... im really not digging her nose in that pic.. it looks way offya i think that was thanks to Alex Ross' coloring cause when it comes to drawing MJ Romita is the best :up:

[Chris Wallace]

what are you ralking about?
Tobey only looks like 19 to me, and Lohan looks like 21 to me
Lohan looks about 15 or 16; tobey's pushing 30 in real life,

[American_Hobo]

Lohan looks about 15 or 16; tobey's pushing 30 in real life,

Lohan looks that young?
well Tobey only looks like 19 or 20 to me....

[spideyboy_1111]

Lohan looks about 15 or 16; tobey's pushing 30 in real life,
dude... you need to go back to highschool or something... shes about my age and looks it... if girls if freshman and sophmores in high school looked like that we'd have a hell of alot of young mothers in the world

[spideyboy_1111]

Lohan looks that young?
well Tobey only looks like 19 or 20 to me....
i think you even more so need your eyes checked...

[American_Hobo]

i think you even more so need your eyes checked...he's f**king 19 in the movie you know...

[Abaddon]

You naysayers just don't like Lohan.She looks like MJ,and she'll be old enough to look the part by the time SM4 rolls around.The only questionable thing is her acting skills.

[Spidergurl4302]

You naysayers just don't like Lohan.She looks like MJ,and she'll be old enough to look the part by the time SM4 rolls around.The only questionable thing is her acting skills.i dont hate Lohan i just cant see her playing MJ

[Abaddon]

i dont hate Lohan i just cant see her playing MJ


Maybe its because of her credentials.

[American_Hobo]

I don't think Lohan got better acting than Dunst

[spideyboy_1111]

he's f**king 19 in the movie you know...
actually there probably 21... Harry was drinking you know, and this is 2 years after spidey one... and he graduated (most graduate at 18) and then he was in his first year of college (most are 19 by then)

[spideyboy_1111]

I don't think Lohan got better acting than Dunst
your right, but not for the MJ part, Kirsten is a very good actress, but she really sux as MJ, if you go watch virgin suicides, small soldiers, jumanji, bring it on, and crazy beautiful and compare it to MJ in spidey one and 2, you will be like wtf? Kirsten just simply does not have her heart in it. and any actress could play her part that she has done...

[Spidergurl4302]

your right, but not for the MJ part, Kirsten is a very good actress, but she really sux as MJ, if you go watch virgin suicides, small soldiers, jumanji, bring it on, and crazy beautiful and compare it to MJ in spidey one and 2, you will be like wtf? Kirsten just simply does not have her heart in it. and any actress could play her part that she has done...ya i agree there, she doesnt seem to enjoy her character, the story, or even Tobey

[spideyboy_1111]

ya i agree there, she doesnt seem to enjoy her character, the story, or even Tobey I mean she acts when shes interviewed like she speaks as if its programmed, or as if she doesnt care, she just isnt taking her part seriously... i wonder how she even got the part... was there any one else who tried out for MJ?

[Spidergurl4302]

I mean she acts when shes interviewed like she speaks as if its programmed, or as if she doesnt care, she just isnt taking her part seriously... i wonder how she even got the part... was there any one else who tried out for MJ?ya but a lot turned it down (not knowing how much of a success it would be) but i think what really got her not into it anymore was because i think she hates Tobey now :confused:

[Diamondhead]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg

For potential sequels.... if this isn't Mary Jane then I don't know who is.

Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst
You're damn right !
Carmen Electra is the spitting image of Mary Jane ,specially when the Spiderman comics was drawn by the Romitas
she's a bit too old to play Mary Jane now .
and beside...even though I think she's beautiful and all ,
I never like her
so I don't think it's a great lost.

[Diamondhead]

Is that the Spanish guy from the seventies show's girlfriend or Carmen Electra ?
the Olympic swimmer champ who won 6 or 7 gold medals wanted too meet her
personally I thought he should have gotten a better grip of himself
because he was acting like a loser "for a champion"

for god' sake man the girl already has a boyfriend , don't go and profess your love for her like that on national TV because it sound pathetic ,same goes for that Harry potter guy on Carmen Diase

[spideyboy_1111]

omg.. its freaking lindsay lohan its not carmen elektra who is not MJ AT ALL nor is it the girl from that 70's show.. GRRRRR

[spideyboy_1111]

she was dating fez thought from that 70's show... though

[Diamondhead]

omg.. its freaking lindsay lohan its not carmen elektra who is not MJ AT ALL nor is it the girl from that 70's show.. GRRRRR
No need to sound so upset !
forgive me if I don't spend that much time in front of a TV you dim witted sonofacur .

[Spidergurl4302]

forgive me if I don't spend that much time in front of a TV you dim witted sonofacur .no offense but Equint77 even said in his post:

"Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst"

[American_Hobo]

I mean she acts when shes interviewed like she speaks as if its programmed, or as if she doesnt care, she just isnt taking her part seriously... i wonder how she even got the part... was there any one else who tried out for MJ?
maybe Kirsten Dunst didin't want to play MJ, but they offered her lots of guarantees, so she couldn't refuse...

[spideyboy_1111]

maybe Kirsten Dunst didin't want to play MJ, but they offered her lots of guarantees, so she couldn't refuse...
if thats the case then sony was moronic

[Chris Wallace]

dude... you need to go back to highschool or something... shes about my age and looks it... if girls if freshman and sophmores in high school looked like that we'd have a hell of alot of young mothers in the world
1-I probably shouldn't go back to high school since I entered high school in 1986.
2-I stick by my assessment.
3-There ARE a lot of young mothers in the world!

[spideyboy_1111]

1-I probably shouldn't go back to high school since I entered high school in 1986.
2-I stick by my assessment.
3-There ARE a lot of young mothers in the world!
ahh that make sense then... in the 80 you all looked like 30 year olds ur senior year

[zanos]

your right, but not for the MJ part, Kirsten is a very good actress, but she really sux as MJ, if you go watch virgin suicides, small soldiers, jumanji, bring it on, and crazy beautiful and compare it to MJ in spidey one and 2, you will be like wtf? Kirsten just simply does not have her heart in it. and any actress could play her part that she has done...


Well the part kind of sucks but I don't think that has anything to do with it at all. She's just not that great an actress. I think this may actually be more her personality than anything else because I didn't necessarily notice these things when she was young. She's got odd habits and mannerisms in the way she expresses emotion thru her face and in the way she delivers her lines depending on the scene.

[TheVileOne]

I haven't seen any convincing arguments on this forum for why Lohan should play MJ other than that she "looks" like her.

[Equint77]

OK OK.

Looks wise....which is WHAT MANY SM fans complained about once they knew Kirsten was gonna play MJ.. Lohan physically looks more similar to MJ than does ever can... Face.. hair...eyes....body...even her personality relates more to MJ.

[Equint77]

OK OK.

Looks wise....which is WHAT MANY SM fans complained about once they knew Kirsten was gonna play MJ.. Lohan physically looks more similar to MJ than does ever can... Face.. hair...eyes....body...even her personality relates more to MJ.

Acting wise.. sure she can't compete with Dunst acting wise but physical looks...translating the look of MJ from the comic to screen... in my opinion Lohan is it.

[ViscaBarcaInter]

Maybe that's because Mary Jane is supposed to be a goddess-like dream for all the Peter Parker type "losers in love" guys who could never hope to have such a perfect woman. You know, instead of a REAL woman. ANYONE who was cast as MJ was going to be criticised because there would be some thing about her that isn't as good as the vision of perfection that Mary Jane is.

[DrMylesOBoogie]

Ugh no way would I like to see Lohan as MJ. She's way overrated in terms of looks and talent.

[spideyboy_1111]

Well the part kind of sucks but I don't think that has anything to do with it at all. She's just not that great an actress. I think this may actually be more her personality than anything else because I didn't necessarily notice these things when she was young. She's got odd habits and mannerisms in the way she expresses emotion thru her face and in the way she delivers her lines depending on the scene.
you know ive realised that too... she seemed to be alot better when she was younger... i wonder if anything really bad has happened to her life... because i dunno.. she has this depressed emotion thing going on... it seems to me that like the movies before spider-man.. were good... and she was a good actress.. her movies after? (spider-man 1 & 2, that cat's meow, mona lisa smile, eternal sunshine, and wimbeldon) she i dunno.. she just... she seems to not be as believable as an actress as she once was.

[spideyboy_1111]

I want Lohan because of Looks and the fact she can act. Listen we already know Kirsten is leaving after 3. Thats reality. I am a guy and could play Kirstens part better then she is... So i consider this a time to fix what has already been done. Lohan can act very well and do exactly what Kirsten has done at least.

[terry78]

I know people hate Lohan for the same reason they hate Will Smith, Vin Diesel, Jennifer Lopez, etc. Most of these people have pretty good acting abilities, but their overrated-ness gives off a bad vibe to people. I did see Mean Girls, and that was the first time I can honestly say I did not find Lohan annoying, as she played the character to the hilt as far as realism. I wouldn't storm off crying if she landed the role or anything, though.

[TheVileOne]

Whatever, I think they captured MJ's character pretty well in the movies. They showed her deep down, she was an anguished, troubled woman who wears social masks in public. That's the real MJ. The real MJ is not a "party girl" like Lindsay Lohan, that's just how she is on the surface. So whatever, I don't think Lohan is hot potatoes though.

[Spidergurl4302]

They showed her deep down, she was an anguished, troubled woman who wears social masks in public. That's the real MJ.they only did that at least twice in the movie though :(....(when her dad yells at her but then her friends come and shes all happy again and after the argument with her parents and then sees Flash's new car, given she did have a conversation with Pete to cheer her up :))

[TheVileOne]

they only did that at least twice in the movie though :(....(when her dad yells at her but then her friends come and shes all happy again and after the argument with her parents and then sees Flash's new car, given she did have a conversation with Pete to cheer her up :))
They do it in the second movie as well. One good example is the billboard she modeled for. She's still putting on a face for others, Peter is the only one that knows and loves the real Mary Jane, who she truly is. And that's why she loves and accepts Peter.

[terry78]

If Lohan starts doing things like Dunst's Virgin Suicides and The Cat's Meow, then I think they'd be more apt to accept her as MJ if the time ever came.

[GL1]

i don't dream about lohan!!!!

:mad:


i dream about jojo

;)

HAHAHA... terrifying...

oh, and by the way, Lohan would kick tail as MJ in about four years... (when Spidey four would be out) no need for any age regression...

[Kroc1138]

you know ive realised that too... she seemed to be alot better when she was younger... i wonder if anything really bad has happened to her life... because i dunno.. she has this depressed emotion thing going on... it seems to me that like the movies before spider-man.. were good... and she was a good actress.. her movies after? (spider-man 1 & 2, that cat's meow, mona lisa smile, eternal sunshine, and wimbeldon) she i dunno.. she just... she seems to not be as believable as an actress as she once was. I agree. Dunst was great early in her Career. She was perfect in IWTV. But Lately she is nothing special and in The Spidey movies subpar. She gives little to the role, but at the same time she isn't written all that well.

[Kroc1138]

As for Lohan, I can't really say that she has done anything that I have seen that show she's a standout actress. But she does LOOK better than Kirsten, but I hate recasts, so I would be against it just for that.

[Equint77]

As for Lohan, I can't really say that she has done anything that I have seen that show she's a standout actress. But she does LOOK better than Kirsten, but I hate recasts, so I would be against it just for that.


Recasts are inevitable. Besides Kirsten said she's out after SM3. From interviews promoting SM2 I could tell she's sick of being MJ... FINE. I don't want someone in the movie who doesn't want to play their part.

As far as Lohan's acting....she's only 18 and YES she hasn't had the career Dunst has..but then who does?

In my opinion...looks wise (which was HUGE when the were casting Mary Jane) Lohan is as close as anyone in Hollywood.

[Kroc1138]

Recasts are inevitable. Besides Kirsten said she's out after SM3. From interviews promoting SM2 I could tell she's sick of being MJ... FINE. I don't want someone in the movie who doesn't want to play their part.True, but why not end the series like others suggested. If they can pull of a recast (Like they did w/ 007) it could work. I doubt it could or would, seeing as how the James Bond series is the only one that could pull it off.

As far as Lohan's acting....she's only 18 and YES she hasn't had the career Dunst has..but then who does? As for my comment on Lohan's acting, she like you said hasn't done much quality work in her early career and currently. (that shows off her acting) Kirsten on the other hand has done some work that shows that she is good, but the past several years she hasn't impressed me at all.

In my opinion...looks wise (which was HUGE when the were casting Mary Jane) Lohan is as close as anyone in Hollywood.Perhaps.

[spider-jide]

Another Lohan for MJ thread? equates to bull ****.

[Chris Wallace]

Here's something a lot of you are overlooking; Dunst wasn't hired for glamour. She was hired for chemistry. She connects w/Tobey onscreen. Who's to say whether LiLo would or not?

[THE LIZARD#1]

THE EARTH IS DOOMED!!

So live life to its fullest

[zanos]

Here's something a lot of you are overlooking; Dunst wasn't hired for glamour. She was hired for chemistry. She connects w/Tobey onscreen. Who's to say whether LiLo would or not?


Newsflash she probably got the nod over anyone else because Raimi liked her in Jumanji or some movie she did before. I refuse to believe that Kirsten Dunst is the only actress alive who has chemistry with Tobey Mcguire. Did she blow him during her audition? WTF.

[screech_turbo]

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v130/TheLizard/kirstengator.jpg


THIS SUMMER....


KIRSTEN DUNST IS....


THE CROCODILE HUNTRESS

CRIGEY!!!

just kidding. i wish i were that crocodile, though. :up: peace.

[RabbitSamurai]

Lohan as MJ. :rolleyes:

It'd be another Michael Douglas/Catherine Zeta-Jones affair....but with substantially less talent.

[spider-jide]

http://us.movies1.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/movie_pix/mtv/mtv_movie_awards_backstage_2004_photos/_group_photos/lindsay_lohan15.jpg

I was totally against the idea of lohan being MJ but the girl CAN act and she's like 18 or 19 so yeah, in future spidey films the potential is there for her to be MJ.

[spider-jide]

Oh yeah, and she's HOTT!

[Spider-Mania2]

I have read all the fors and againsts for lindsey lohan being MJ Watson, and I am very much a big fan of Kirtsen Dunst, and how she has portrayed the love interest of spidey, but having said that, i do believe dunst was mis-cast, even she said herslef she thought she was gonna be gwen stacy. I believe that in the comic books that MJ was a tall beautiful red head model, now neither lohan or dunst fit that bill, and in my mind the one girl that should have landed the role but didnt due to deficiency in her acting ability was Shannon Elizabeth. I dont know about u guys, but i believe she has the look, but i guess after being the naked foreign chick in American Pie would have shot down any hope of her being MJ, how can u take her seriously enough for a serious role like that, after seeing her in all her glory.http://www.superherohype.com/forums/images/smilies/spidey.gif

[Kal-El 8]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg

For potential sequels.... if this isn't Mary Jane then I don't know who is.

Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst

Yeah she looks like Mj, only she's too young.

[RabbitSamurai]

EXACTLY.

See, nobody seems to think this is a valid point. I don't get it. Why should Spidey look like a pedophile?

[spideyboy_1111]

u people still dont get it, She wouldnt be MJ till spidey 4... wich prob wont be out till at least 2010. Tobey will be recasted and lohan will be old enough... for gods sakes she'll be 24

[RabbitSamurai]

And Tobey will be...what? 30-something?

Sorry, but she'll still look out of place, IMO.

[spideyboy_1111]

tobey will be recasted.. he will be in his mid 30s.... sry but he'd be getting to old to play a college student

[Equint77]

Yeah she looks like Mj, only she's too young.


OK for arguement's sake... SM4 will be sometime around 2010...

Lohan is gonna be 19 this year.... meaning she'll be 22-23 by the time they start filming SM4.

With the recast cause Tobey will be way too old for the role anymore...

I said it looks wise she has the red hair, the green eyes, and the body of comic MJ. And she has the party personality MJ is supposed to have... not the "girl Next door' Raimi portrayed her as.

[spideyboy_1111]

OK for arguement's sake... SM4 will be sometime around 2010...

Lohan is gonna be 19 this year.... meaning she'll be 22-23 by the time they start filming SM4.

With the recast cause Tobey will be way too old for the role anymore...

I said it looks wise she has the red hair, the green eyes, and the body of comic MJ. And she has the party personality MJ is supposed to have... not the "girl Next door' Raimi portrayed her as.
exactly... you'd be a moron not to see how she is MJ...

[Spidergurl4302]

exactly... you'd be a moron not to see how she is MJ...this girl though looks a lot more like MJ then Lohan

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v314/Jess5302/theperfectMJ.bmp

the only thing though is her age because spider-man 4 wont be for awhile and she would have to do 3 movies.....

we probably cant pick anyone now because there too young and i would rather have a no-name actress play MJ....

[OtepApe]

Ok she could play MJ due to the age and everything but there is one HUGE factor that is going to prevent this girl from ever playing MJ, she's not that good of an actress. The films I have seen her in have been crap and that's largly due to her performance. She will never play anything more then stupid girlie high school movies.

[zanos]

Considering she's only been in two films with just a tiny part in one and the other is so obscure I don't think even think more than 10 ppl have seen it I'd have to say you're talking out the other side of your ass. I'm not going to say she's a great actress but if you're going to say she's bad at least provide a convincing argument for it and not something you made up. She's average as far as I can tell although she was terrific in stargate sg-1. Kirsten Dunst the actress who is currently playing MJ is average to below average as an actress. But that's not really as distracting as her looks which seems to be progressively getting worse year by year. If anything Kirsten should be the one that should stick to playing girlie high school movies.

[Spider-X]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg

For potential sequels.... if this isn't Mary Jane then I don't know who is.

Lohan looks more like MJ than Dunst



....because of you....i hate the world...

[OtepApe]

Considering she's only been in two films with just a tiny part in one and the other is so obscure I don't think even think more than 10 ppl have seen it I'd have to say you're talking out the other side of your ass. I'm not going to say she's a great actress but if you're going to say she's bad at least provide a convincing argument for it and not something you made up. She's average as far as I can tell although she was terrific in stargate sg-1. Kirsten Dunst the actress who is currently playing MJ is average to below average as an actress. But that's not really as distracting as her looks which seems to be progressively getting worse year by year. If anything Kirsten should be the one that should stick to playing girlie high school movies.


Hahahahah

Oh your serious. Well i'm not about to get into an argument over Lindsay Lohan. I'm talking on the other side of my ass because I have not enjoyed her perfrmances??? Well ok but only because you seem to be an expert. :rolleyes:

I agree that Kirsten is a bad actress and that she shouldn't be playing MJ, I have been a supproter of that notion ever since she turned up in SM1.

However I can say that I don't enjoy Lindsay Lohan other then to look at. I believe that is an opinion and I expressed my opinion. So I can talk out of the other side of my ass because it's my ass and I can do exactly what I please with it.

[spideyboy_1111]

Ok she could play MJ due to the age and everything but there is one HUGE factor that is going to prevent this girl from ever playing MJ, she's not that good of an actress. The films I have seen her in have been crap and that's largly due to her performance. She will never play anything more then stupid girlie high school movies.
and kirsten dunst was a great actress in spidey 1 and 2? please... im a guy and could do a better job

[spideyboy_1111]

Considering she's only been in two films with just a tiny part in one and the other is so obscure I don't think even think more than 10 ppl have seen it I'd have to say you're talking out the other side of your ass. I'm not going to say she's a great actress but if you're going to say she's bad at least provide a convincing argument for it and not something you made up. She's average as far as I can tell although she was terrific in stargate sg-1. Kirsten Dunst the actress who is currently playing MJ is average to below average as an actress. But that's not really as distracting as her looks which seems to be progressively getting worse year by year. If anything Kirsten should be the one that should stick to playing girlie high school movies.
2 movies egh? where you been....

parent trap
(some movie with tyra banks as a barbie doll come to life)
freaky friday
confessions of a teenage drama queen
Mean girls (wich was a break out hit that critics were surprised they liked so much)
and Herbie the love bug this summer....

[zanos]

Hahahahah

Oh your serious. Well i'm not about to get into an argument over Lindsay Lohan. I'm talking on the other side of my ass because I have not enjoyed her perfrmances??? Well ok but only because you seem to be an expert. :rolleyes:

I agree that Kirsten is a bad actress and that she shouldn't be playing MJ, I have been a supproter of that notion ever since she turned up in SM1.

However I can say that I don't enjoy Lindsay Lohan other then to look at. I believe that is an opinion and I expressed my opinion. So I can talk out of the other side of my ass because it's my ass and I can do exactly what I please with it.

It looks like we are talking about two completely different ppl because I was not referring to Lohan in my post, who btw is a horrible choice to play MJ anyway.

[OtepApe]

It looks like we are talking about two completely different ppl because I was not referring to Lohan in my post, who btw is a horrible choice to play MJ anyway.
Nope, I was referring to Lohan.

[OtepApe]

and kirsten dunst was a great actress in spidey 1 and 2? please... im a guy and could do a better job

As I stated in a previous post, I don't like Dunst. I believe she is a terrible actress and have been a supporter of trashing her name as much as I can on these boards.

[Kevin Roegele]

I'd take Lohan over Dunst....but I'd rather take them both at the same time.

Eh-heh-heh-heh-heh-yes.

[Equint77]

this girl though looks a lot more like MJ then Lohan

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v314/Jess5302/theperfectMJ.bmp

the only thing though is her age because spider-man 4 wont be for awhile and she would have to do 3 movies.....

we probably cant pick anyone now because there too young and i would rather have a no-name actress play MJ....


Erica Durance would be my pick for MJ but I think she's like 24 now so with filming and stuff she's gonna be well into 28 by the time SM4 is released.

My point of starting this thread is point out that Lohan is the physical manifestation of Mary Jane Watson. Aside from her crummy career... she's got the hair, the eyes, the body to play MJ.

Kirsten Dunst is not Mary Jane... she doesn't look it.. and Raimi did a bad job of writing her character.

[Spider-Mania2]

i still say that from the start shannon elizabeth could have been MJ, she has the height the hair, and the look. had she been in it, we definitely could have had room for Gwen, and done the comics justice.

Lindsey Lohan Might possibly make a good MJ, i believe in many cases, actors perform according to the direction that they r being given, and i think even tho Lindsey may not be the perfect actress, i believe that with the right direction in a Spider-Man film she could do great things.

[spideyboy_1111]

umm but shanon has brown hair... brown eyes... and doesnt share any facial features of MJ...?

[Spidergurl4302]

dunst had blonde hair blue eyes, MJ usually has green eyes, plus all you need is color contacts and a dye job (not saying i want shannon elizabeth but we shouldnt have to limit actresses because they werent born with red hair and green eyes)

[spideyboy_1111]

and kirsten looks like *****, bad example

[Spidergurl4302]

hey i didnt cast her, she looks like ***** because of who she is but her dye job in spider-man 1 was just fine

[zanos]

Well actually it was a wig. I'm not exactly sure why they decided to go that route since Kirsten didn't have a problem with dying her hair. Anyway while we're on the topic of recasting, let's recast the director as well. I liked SM2 but I actually want to see a REAL Spider-man movie with the actual characters from the comic book, not some wannabe superhero movie pretending to be Spider-man.

[Spider-Mania2]

can any one else name a tall, good looking, good performing actress who could have done a better job than dunst in the first two films?

personally some of u may not like what im a bout to say, but here it goes:

I think the thing we all have to remember here about the comic book films is that no matter what they may do to try and please us into making a good film, they rnt going to please everyone. i have stated before that i dont like the fact that they target a wider audience for these films insted of us comic book readers. thing is we represent only a fraction of the total audience out there, and the rest of those who no nothing would prefer to see a simple laid out film that wont screw their brain around in every direction. thats what studios in the majority of times try to aim for, of course there are anomalies out there, but i believe if marvel was its own super-film making company, then yeah id say we would have what we want tied with a bow, but itll never happen when head honchos at fox, sony, universal, or any of the others see the big $$$$ that come with the marketing associated with the films.

[spideyboy_1111]

ummm no offence but kirsten has dissapointed more then she has pleased so... i dont get exactly what your sayin

[elvislennon2005]

My opinion is that Lindsay Lohan would do a great job as MJ but you can't replace Dunst because she played MJ in 1 and 2, that is like replacing Framke for the X-men movies if they will do some after 3. Keep the original cast unless you can't get them at all. Oh by the way I have heard some reports that Halle Berry might be reprising her role as Storm. Dunst, Framke, Berry, or any of them you just can't replace because they played the characters twice. Why would you want to replace Dunst. She is the same age as me but i'm a few months older than her.

[Spider-Mania2]

ummm no offence but kirsten has dissapointed more then she has pleased so... i dont get exactly what your sayin

what i'm really saying is two things

1. Not everybody can be pleased everyday.
2. You cant always get what you want.

third thing i wanna say is, who did u want to see play MJ from the start if not Kirsten Dunst? cos ur all offering up who should play MJ after dunst quits.

[spideyboy_1111]

what i'm really saying is two things

1. Not everybody can be pleased everyday.
2. You cant always get what you want.

third thing i wanna say is, who did u want to see play MJ from the start if not Kirsten Dunst? cos ur all offering up who should play MJ after dunst quits.

i get what you mean but hardly anyone even non comic fans were pleased.
and who cares if we cant get what we want, at least let us get something decent.

And I for one couldnt really pick who i wanted for MJ considering they had already casted them when i found out a spider-man movie was getting made.

Also I thought Kirsten would have been great at first... till i saw spidey 1... and then began to hate her in spidey 2.. I think there are many actresses who could take over her spot easily

[Spider-Mania2]

well i pretty much get that feeling in here that no one likes her, but i talk to a few ppl here, where i live with no connection to comics at all and they find her to be a pretty decent actress.

look i know how u hard core fans feel about these kinds of things, and your right, but i mean at the end of the day the films have made millions and millions of dollars, have recieved fantastic reviews, and are two of the better recent comic book films that have been made behind the two xmen films.

[Visionary]

My opinion is that Lindsay Lohan would do a great job as MJ
Yeah, she can lip-sync her lines like she does her horrible music.:cool:

*Takes out gun and points it towards your head*

[Visionary]

well i pretty much get that feeling in here that no one likes her, but i talk to a few ppl here, where i live with no connection to comics at all and they find her to be a pretty decent actress.
The keywords here are " no connection to comics" which usually means that they're 'smarter' than the average 'geek.':spidey:

[spideyboy_1111]

well i pretty much get that feeling in here that no one likes her, but i talk to a few ppl here, where i live with no connection to comics at all and they find her to be a pretty decent actress.

look i know how u hard core fans feel about these kinds of things, and your right, but i mean at the end of the day the films have made millions and millions of dollars, have recieved fantastic reviews, and are two of the better recent comic book films that have been made behind the two xmen films.
thats funny... all my non comic fans did like her and found her tits hot in spidey 1 but they all made fun of her lines and then had a ball with how bad she looked in most the scenes in 2 and how fake she came off

[Spidergurl4302]

its funny how Kirsten actually thought she looked better in 2 :rolleyes:

[American_Hobo]

she looked better in Spiderman1 I think.....

[Spidergurl4302]

i think everyone thinks she looked better in 1...shes the only one who thought she looked better in 2

[American_Hobo]

i think everyone thinks she looked better in 1...shes the only one who thought she looked better in 2

why?

[spideyboy_1111]

i agree... she looked and acted better in spider-man one... and i think thats because she had fun with it. In spider-man 2 she was quoated as saying "spider-man should die" and that she didn't want to be in a 4th movie. Spider-man 2 was more of a "job" for her she didn't have her heart in it. Hell if you watch one of her interviews she seems oblivious and repetitive on all her feeling on spider-man 2, like she was force fed them. It reminded me of a student trying to explain themselves to a teacher

[Spidergurl4302]

heres looking foward to Spider-man 4 :up: :p

[spideyboy_1111]

*gives high 5*

[Spider-Mania2]

maybe she had felt the way she did because she had never done a sequel before. I mean if u think about it, it must be a daunting task to have to get urself to act, and try and portray feelings again in a sequel, where as she has never before, that with spider-man it would pull at ur emotions and stuff, if u know what i mean.

i guess the key to it is that to do the job, u gotta be able to have fun with what ur doing. and if ur not, then it will seem like hard work.

it could be that there was truth to a rumour i had read, that said dunst hated mcguire because when the first movie was made they were linked in real life, and he used her as a devise to lift his image. so that also could have made it harder.

[M.E.H.Z.E.B]

i think everyone thinks she looked better in 1...shes the only one who thought she looked better in 2

she is progressively getting uglier...

damn u raimi! cast someone who fits MJ's description!!!!!!!

[alright... i need to calm down :)]

[spideyboy_1111]

i find it hilarious because MJ in the comics and in the movies is a model and Kirsten... she hasn't looked like a model in the movies at all...

[Equint77]

i find it hilarious because MJ in the comics and in the movies is a model and Kirsten... she hasn't looked like a model in the movies at all...


It goes back to what I've been saying all along.... Movie MJ is not even a shadow of Comic MJ.

What we have in both SM movies is a Mary Jane/Gwen Stacy/Betty Brant hybrid. Raimi dropped the ball a bit on her character.

[spideyboy_1111]

well her history is very much the same, and in spider-man 1 she was fine. But spidey 2, while becoming an actress and model like MJ... Kirsten did not act like MJ

[TheFly32]

no, thats not right at all.
espeically her voice its all....painfully irritating
shes not a very good actor
she looks different in every other picture, espicially those gross ones of the fake tan.

she doesn't sound or look anything like mj should.
kirsten is a good mj, and if you dont like her well its to late, there not going to recast her


imo

[Spidergurl4302]

but shes leaving after three so like i said heres looking foward to spider-man 4 :up: :p

[spideyboy_1111]

no, thats not right at all.
espeically her voice its all....painfully irritating
shes not a very good actor
she looks different in every other picture, espicially those gross ones of the fake tan.

she doesn't sound or look anything like mj should.
kirsten is a good mj, and if you dont like her well its to late, there not going to recast her


imo
dude ur blind if u think Kirsten look more like MJ then lohan

[Spidergurl4302]

im not a fan of Lohan but i could have even played MJ better then Kirsten in spider-man 2 :rolleyes:

[terry78]

im not a fan of Lohan but i could have even played MJ better then Kirsten in spider-man 2 :rolleyes:
I believe it.

[spideyboy_1111]

im not a fan of Lohan but i could have even played MJ better then Kirsten in spider-man 2 :rolleyes:
ya im a guy and could play a better MJ lol Lohan looks the part, will be old enough and ANYONE can act like MJ as long as the have fun with it and know who there character is like...

[Boom]

http://musicmedia.ign.com/music/image/lindsaylohanartist_092704.jpg
*Face melts off*

[spideyboy_1111]

some one once said the greatest actors are those who can make others laugh.
Lohan is pretty entertaining and even funny in some of her movies. Hell watch her SNL episode she hosted...

theres not one singal doubt in my mind that she couldnt pull of a great MJ

[TheFly32]

im not a fan of Lohan but i could have even played MJ better then Kirsten in spider-man 2 :rolleyes:

i dissagree, lohan looks different in every picture, half her pictures are airbrushed to hell. i personally dont understand why people think lohan is so attractive. shes one of the most mediocure people i've ever seen.
http://scribbleking.typepad.com/scribble_king/images/lindsay_lohan.jpg
http://www.noticine.com/noticine/images_ftp/album/fotos/spider06.jpg
http://www.chronologyproject.com/mj.jpg
i think dunst wins by a longshot.

*is ready for flames*

[wetgorilla]

I think we should all just come to grips that as soon as Tobey quites, the Spiderman franchise will have to shut down. This series will have the brains not to overextend its welcome into our imagination. If they try to draw it out beyond Tobey it will end up like a terrible sequel series in the same way other cheesy sequals have done without their original cast. Recent example - Son of the Mask. So, it doesn't matter who has played or can play MJ.

Wetgorilla
:wolverine

[spideyboy_1111]

I think its time people started posting the gross pics of kirsten again... ive seen more lately..

[Equint77]

I think we should all just come to grips that as soon as Tobey quites, the Spiderman franchise will have to shut down. This series will have the brains not to overextend its welcome into our imagination. If they try to draw it out beyond Tobey it will end up like a terrible sequel series in the same way other cheesy sequals have done without their original cast. Recent example - Son of the Mask. So, it doesn't matter who has played or can play MJ.

Wetgorilla
:wolverine

you're comparing the Mask 2 to the Spider-man Franchise??

[TheFly32]

I think its time people started posting the gross pics of kirsten again... ive seen more lately..

you can find equally as gross pictures of lohan

[Spidergurl4302]

i dissagree, lohan looks different in every picture, half her pictures are airbrushed to hell. i personally dont understand why people think lohan is so attractive. shes one of the most mediocure people i've ever seen.i agree which is why in my post i said im not a fan of Lohan im just saying that Dunst in the second movie looked horrible ;)

[RabbitSamurai]

I think we should all just come to grips that as soon as Tobey quites, the Spiderman franchise will have to shut down. This series will have the brains not to overextend its welcome into our imagination. If they try to draw it out beyond Tobey it will end up like a terrible sequel series in the same way other cheesy sequals have done without their original cast. Recent example - Son of the Mask. So, it doesn't matter who has played or can play MJ.

Wetgorilla
:wolverine

I think Mask 2 has a helluva lot more problems than just the cast, personally.

[wetgorilla]

i agree which is why in my post i said im just saying that Dunst in the second movie looked horrible ;)

I'd have to disagree, S.G. - I thought Kirsten looked fine. While, Lohan, in my opinion is too teeny-bopper. If she tried to play a character that is supposed to be a "woman" and a working one at that, it would fail. At this point in her career, she's only believable as a high-school kid at best.

Wetgorilla
:wolverine

[wetgorilla]

you're comparing the Mask 2 to the Spider-man Franchise??

I was just trying to emphasize the point that NO sequal of any kind that has changed characters from an original hit has ever done anything other than make audiences vomit. LOL.

Wetgorilla
:thing:

[Spidergurl4302]

I'd have to disagree, S.G. - I thought Kirsten looked fine. While, Lohan, in my opinion is too teeny-bopper. If she tried to play a character that is supposed to be a "woman" and a working one at that, it would fail. At this point in her career, she's only believable as a high-school kid at best.

Wetgorilla
:wolverineeh Dunst needed better clothes, hair color, and make-up in 2. I feel the same way about Lohan, even if the movie wont be for awhile and Lohan by then will be old enough she'll always be a "teeny-bopper" to me

[spideyboy_1111]

but isn't MJ one who has the social image of a "teeny bopper" as well? both have the same "partying" characteristics

[Spider-Mania2]

im happy that there are ppl who finally agree with the fact lohan wouldnt make a good mj. i dont think that she has either the style or sophistication to play a character like mj. maybe they made a mistake with dunst, whose to say, i mean theres a couple of things to consider. 1. availability of other actresses. 2. quality of those other actresses.

As i said i know how hardcore fans feel about comic book characterisations in movies, and i understand. but i guess sometimes we have to make compromises, i mean think about it if stan the man or mr arad didnt like dunst they would have said no, but they didnt, and the thing to remember is that much of the movie is a mish mash of 40 years of comic book history, and u cant possibly expect them to retrace every single step exactly as it was laid, so stan himself must have given approval to what was written, or else it wouldnt have gone ahead, considering that hes an executive producer of the film. admitedly there are somethings i would like to see added in the films that the first two r lacking. but thats life.

[terry78]

To be honest, aside from the extreme *****y-ness, Lohan acts in real life the exact same way MJ in the comics does, or used to.

[RabbitSamurai]

but isn't MJ one who has the social image of a "teeny bopper" as well? both have the same "partying" characteristics

....I don't know the definition of "teeny-bopper," but I can't see Lohan trying out for an off-Broadway number...which MJ frequently starred in, back in the day.

[spideyboy_1111]

....I don't know the definition of "teeny-bopper," but I can't see Lohan trying out for an off-Broadway number...which MJ frequently starred in, back in the day.


o i see... Lohan would be more likely to try out for an on broadway performance... hell one of her fellow "disney teeny boppers" (christi carlson romano (see even stevens" was staring as belle in beauty and the beast...))

[kittykatkr]

no Lohan ever in a spider-man movie!!!

[spideyboy_1111]

you people make me sad... Lohan at least looks and has the characteristics of MJ when Kirsten is just plain garbage... it's so sad you would rather have someone who isn't MJ rather then someone who is.

[Spider-Mania2]

dunst may not be mj by any stretch of the imagination, but lohan is not in that mould of person she just doesnt fit with that kind of character. when i look at her all i think first off is the parent trap in which she starred when she was a child. dunst atleast has the acting credentials to be able play the part which requires her to do stage which as one other forum member pointed out she has a history of doing in real life. lohan is like a floozie, who just swifts in and out of careers (first shes an actress now she sings, then shes an actress, i mean really how can u take her seriously.) I made a point earlier on this board of asking who else would possibly fit that mould of character, and im asking again who, who would u like to see play mj. and if anyone says lohan, ill scream.

[Spidergurl4302]

after watching a couple of episodes of smallville shes still my pick

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v314/Jess5302/MJ.jpg

the only problem is age because of how far apart the movies might be :(

[Mike]

WTF? Lohan? LOL! Hell No! What are some of you thinking? Kirsten may not be right for the role but come on Lohan? I would've thought this thread was going to be about Jessica Biel or some other hot chick who could act. But Lohan? If your seriously think she should be in a Spider-Man movie period, you guys seriously need to listen to that White Lines song by Grand Master Flash. You guys got to be smoking something.

[spideyboy_1111]

dunst may not be mj by any stretch of the imagination, but lohan is not in that mould of person she just doesnt fit with that kind of character. when i look at her all i think first off is the parent trap in which she starred when she was a child. dunst atleast has the acting credentials to be able play the part which requires her to do stage which as one other forum member pointed out she has a history of doing in real life. lohan is like a floozie, who just swifts in and out of careers (first shes an actress now she sings, then shes an actress, i mean really how can u take her seriously.) I made a point earlier on this board of asking who else would possibly fit that mould of character, and im asking again who, who would u like to see play mj. and if anyone says lohan, ill scream.
sometimes i wonder what MJ you guys think of... the movies are of young MJ... not MJ in the comics right now... and lohan fits the young MJ... and by young MJ i mean the MJ before the smoking and more adult MJ of the 90's

[spideyboy_1111]

WTF? Lohan? LOL! Hell No! What are some of you thinking? Kirsten may not be right for the role but come on Lohan? I would've thought this thread was going to be about Jessica Biel or some other hot chick who could act. But Lohan? If your seriously think she should be in a Spider-Man movie period, you guys seriously need to listen to that White Lines song by Grand Master Flash. You guys got to be smoking something.
biels face looks nothing like MJ but she'd be better then kirsten, ill admit that

[terry78]

http://www.telegraaf.nl/multimedia/archive/00432/lindsay_lohan_july3_432551c.jpg

When she gets older, it could be workable.

[Mike]

Okay, Tobey Maguire looks nothing like Peter Parker. They're comic book drawings man. Jessica Biel would of at least made the Pete and Mary Jane scenes watchable. You know you'll be like,"man, I wish I could get her," Instead of cringing likeyou, me and everybody else does when Kirsten is in the Pete and Mary Jane scenes.

[Mike]

Hey Terry..........No. That's like having Britney Spears as Felicia Hardy. Or Christina Aguilera as Gwen Stacey. Lohan is too Pop sinsation.And please dont tell me you want Hilary Duff as Gwen.

[spideyboy_1111]

Okay, Tobey Maguire looks nothing like Peter Parker. They're comic book drawings man. Jessica Biel would of at least made the Pete and Mary Jane scenes watchable. You know you'll be like,"man, I wish I could get her," Instead of cringing likeyou, me and everybody else does when Kirsten is in the Pete and Mary Jane scenes.
correction... he does when his hair and makeup is done right... so does kirsten.. personally i think its the blue contacts that through them off.. wich is just stupid on raimis part.. if you can find the spider-man 1 entertainment weekly pic wither tobey and kirsten in black... they both look like they could easily be peter and MJ... im starting to think that the makeup and hair person who works on the movies should be fired.

[Mike]

Can you give me a pic of Tobey and Kirsten looking like Pete and Mary Jane. Because I really cant see it. Tobey is Parker, but he looks nothing like the Peter Parker of the comics, which is kind of a good thing because some artist make him out to be too much of a pretty boy.

[spideyboy_1111]

Hey Terry..........No. That's like having Britney Spears as Felicia Hardy. Or Christina Aguilera as Gwen Stacey. Lohan is too Pop sinsation.And please dont tell me you want Hilary Duff as Gwen.
she is so not a pop sensation... shes nothing compared to spears, or hilary by anymeans... you dont hear little girls running around being lohan fans... its all about hilary... lohan is not the "goody girl" disney wanted her to be.. shes her own person. sure she did parent trap when she was little and freaky friday and now herbie.. but her other 2 movies and her album were break aways from the disney mold... has hilary even done that i dont think so... lohan is down to earth where hilary is almost like a clone/merge of mandy moore and jessica simpson.

[spideyboy_1111]

Can you give me a pic of Tobey and Kirsten looking like Pete and Mary Jane. Because I really cant see it. Tobey is Parker, but he looks nothing like the Peter Parker of the comics, which is kind of a good thing because some artist make him out to be too much of a pretty boy.
peter is a pretty boy now... hes suppose to look GQ now... its what happened as he grew up.. its quite common actually... in high school jennifer garner looked like a geek and now shes hot as hell. ill try to find the pic if i can.. but ill see what i can do

[Cyclops]

People think Lohan's hot because she suffers from severe Nipplexpositis.

[spideyboy_1111]

http://image.pathfinder.com/ew/itlist/2001/img/dunstmaguire.jpg


they look more like peter and MJ in this pic

[spideyboy_1111]

People think Lohan's hot because she suffers from severe Nipplexpositis.
na boobs mean nothin to me...

the only people i have heard love kirsten are those who suffer from the rain seen and have fun with themselves after seeing her wet shirt

[Mike]

For a guy you seem to know your Lohan. Ummmmm okaaay! But love the avatar though.

[spideyboy_1111]

umm well lohan is pretty damn hot.. and she is my age.. haha

but seriously dude.. i would so kill to know her lol


and thanx

[Mike]

What? That's the pic? They look like Tobey and Kirsten man. What I really ment was to post a pick of them and Peter Parker and Mary Jane.

[spideyboy_1111]

well Kirsten had MJ's eyes in that pic and tobey looks like peter in that..

[Mike]

Hey Spideyboy, Im bored man you know where I can read some Free Internet comics of Ultimate Spider-Man or Classic Spider-Man. Your Avatar has me itching to read one, plus there is no comic book shop where I live.

[spideyboy_1111]

Hey Spideyboy, Im bored man you know where I can read some Free Internet comics of Ultimate Spider-Man or Classic Spider-Man. Your Avatar has me itching to read one, plus there is no comic book shop where I live.
im sry bud i dont... theres some guy who has several issues online ill see if i can find his link...

as for MJ this is how i see her most look like in face
http://www.samruby.com/Spiderverse/MaryJane/MJYes.JPG

as for peter it varies alot more on artist... up through the 70 he had a lil curl or strand of hair down his face... in the 80's he had more curly hair and in the 90's its been more of a clean cut or messed up look with his hair... i couldnt find a pic i really liked

[Mike]

Hey, that sort of looks like Kirsten from Spider-Man 1 where they go on that feild trip. You proved me wrong on one of them but I dont think you'll get me with Tobey.

[spideyboy_1111]

here u go, have fun

http://www.newjumpswing.com/spiderman/index.htm

[spideyboy_1111]

Hey, that sort of looks like Kirsten from Spider-Man 1 where they go on that feild trip. You proved me wrong on one of them but I dont think you'll get me with Tobey.

listen i think ur a lil confused.. and its confusing me as well... i want lohan to replace kirsten cuz i dont think in the movies she not only doesnt play a good MJ but she doesnt look much like her (in the movies) she did look more like MJ in spidey 1 and both look more like there counter parts on the magazine cover.

[Mike]

I see where your coming from. They did kind of F-ed up the Mary Jane. But maybey, just maybe they'll get Mary Jane right in the third.

[spideyboy_1111]

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v643/spideyboy_1111/up.jpg



http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v643/spideyboy_1111/spideysad.bmp


i think MJ and peter should look similar to this...

ive always thought peter has a younger look to his face then what age he really was... i think thats important. he also usually has bangs that are a little messy in the front and sometimes stick up or curl down... in the movies tobey usually has his hair come'd back... for some reason there still making him look like a geek

[spideyboy_1111]

i just think lohan looks the most like MJ out of any actress ive ever seen... and she should only look more like her when she gets older

[Mike]

I've always loved the Nerd Parker drawings. I'm looking at Donald Thomas's(Cool Guy) website and all I can find are comic covers no issues. I guess I'll keep looking but thanks a lot man. I've seen Donald Thomas on these forums. where is he? I would like to thank him for such a cool site. Makes me want to start collecting Spider-Man comics. This guy is pretty cool. I would really like to chat with this guy.

[spideyboy_1111]

eh.. the nerdy parker has been gone since the end of the 60's hes been more "hip" if you will ever since he met MJ

[Mike]

My fave of all the eras. It was what Stan Lee and Ditko were trying to present. Parker as the everyman not the GQ man. But I still like all the eras after that.

[spideyboy_1111]

there ok... but the reason i like the new art is because its more realistic in how people look.. there more human i guess .. its more detailed then the silver age... its harder to pull off that look compared to now

[spideyboy_1111]

i do like the writing though

[spider-jide]

You know whats ironic. Kirsten Dunst sort of lives a similar lifestyle to MJ in that she's a party girl and can look hot but when playing MJ, a character she should be able to pull off, she fails mbig time. How freakin sad. DIPSET

[Mike]

I thought Kirsten was uptight.

[spideyboy_1111]

You know whats ironic. Kirsten Dunst sort of lives a similar lifestyle to MJ in that she's a party girl and can look hot but when playing MJ, a character she should be able to pull off, she fails mbig time. How freakin sad. DIPSET
i never really here about kirsten being the party girl though... and the only time she looks hot is in certain movies and magazines... all pics iver ever seen of her walking around town look like ****.. and it will make you want to vomit


lohan on the other hand i havent ever seen her look bad, she really is a party girl, she also has a no good father who only wants to be in her life for the money. Still sounds more like MJ to me....

[spideyboy_1111]

I thought Kirsten was uptight.
u can see it in spidey 2... she just simply didnt want to be there... i just watched spidey 1 the other day and she was alot happier.. she seemed as if she had alot more fun playing MJ... in spidey 2 it was so fake

[Mike]

Kirsten's Mary Jane just doesnt come off as a girl you could fall in love with. Maybe if Eliza Dushku had played the "REAL" Mary Jane then it would of been believable. I was watching "The New Guy" movie(which sucked by the way) and I saw the Mary Jane elements when she was playing the popular chick. I would of loved to see her play Mary Jane, and yes even over Jessica Biel. But for Lohan, she's hot but there's no attraction. She seems kind of fake especially in that video she has with her t1t cleavage showing. She's too Teeny Boppish just like Britney Spears and Christina. You dont really have to be the good girl Hilary Duff type to still be a Teeny Poper Pop star. For god sakes man Lohan SCREAMS TEENY BOPPER. Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen? That new Love Bug movie? I hope to god she's not ins a spider-man movie. Have the teeny bopper brat pack of the new millenium out of any superhero movie, please.

[Spidergurl4302]

the only reason i watch smallville is because of Lois i mean everytime i watch it i always say "know THATS the personality MJ should of had and THATS who should have played her!!" :p

[Mike]

Dammit, why didnt I think of that? Lois from smallville. Not a bad choice man beautiful spunky and can act. Thats the only reason I watch Smallville, well her and Kristen Kruek. I use to watch Charmed because of Alyssa Milano. I stoped watching it because it got way too stupid. Damn if Alyssa Milano was younger she could of played Mary Jane. *****, Damn it Raimi.

[Spidergurl4302]

Not a bad choice manjust to let you know i am a girl :p i watch it because of Lois though because how of much she reminds me of MJ and MJ is one of my fav characters. when it comes to watching the show because of someones looks i would watch it because of Tom Welling :D :p

o ya and credit goes to zanos he was the first to bring her up

[kittykatkr]

lohan on the other hand i havent ever seen her look bad, she really is a party girl, she also has a no good father who only wants to be in her life for the money. Still sounds more like MJ to me....

LOL that's wrong... her personal problems don't make her any better for a certain role, than others... it's acting. Did MJ have tons of freckles all over her body and face?

[spideyboy_1111]

Kirsten's Mary Jane just doesnt come off as a girl you could fall in love with. Maybe if Eliza Dushku had played the "REAL" Mary Jane then it would of been believable. I was watching "The New Guy" movie(which sucked by the way) and I saw the Mary Jane elements when she was playing the popular chick. I would of loved to see her play Mary Jane, and yes even over Jessica Biel. But for Lohan, she's hot but there's no attraction. She seems kind of fake especially in that video she has with her t1t cleavage showing. She's too Teeny Boppish just like Britney Spears and Christina. You dont really have to be the good girl Hilary Duff type to still be a Teeny Poper Pop star. For god sakes man Lohan SCREAMS TEENY BOPPER. Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen? That new Love Bug movie? I hope to god she's not ins a spider-man movie. Have the teeny bopper brat pack of the new millenium out of any superhero movie, please.
ummm if christina is a teeny bopper then i want to barf

[spideyboy_1111]

LOL that's wrong... her personal problems don't make her any better for a certain role, than others... it's acting. Did MJ have tons of freckles all over her body and face?
ummm no but she was pale and looked half asleep... and lohan doesnt have frekles all over anymore.. that was when she was in the parent trap

[spideyboy_1111]

any ya personal problems can help tap into the personality of the character.... Personally i dont think Kirsten has ever looked up and researched MJ of the comics

[Mike]

Actually Kirsten has read some comics. Remember when she thought she was going to play Gwen? Plus Lindsay still has freckles all over her body. She just put that orange tan stuff to hide it. Christina Aguilera is Teeny Bopper man so is little Kim. They're just the wanna be bad girls for wanna be bad Teeny Boppers. You know like how Good Charllet and Avril Lavigne say they're punk rock but sing Pop music. Lindsay Lohan is a Teeny Bopper man and should not be in a spider-man movie. Do you actually want all those Teeny Bopper kids ruining your showing of Spider-Man 4? Well if you want her she's going to attract all those Freaky Friday Cadets to talk and say oh my gosh during the whole damn movie. She looks to fake man. She looks like one of those plastic surgey Porn Stars who dont bounce or jiggle when they walk. Come on man that's like have Britney Spears as Felicia. You cant see that at all? It would be like the Batman and Robin of the Spider-Man movies.

[spideyboy_1111]

Kirsten is more fake then Lohan will ever be im afraid

[Mike]

Lindsay Lohan trys to hide her natural beauty, her freckles and tries so hard to show that she is mature and older and can be sexy. She prances around in the video with he boobs ready to pop out of he shirt, plus she's in some kind of stripper cage trying to look sexy, and for god sakes man she dated wilmer. I would of also preferred Scarlett Jo hansen as Mary Jane. But I seriously cant see Lohan as Mary Jane. She may have the looks but she has her own crowd which I hope. Have you seen Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen. It was god awful and will pop up in my head if she is cast as Mary Jane. She could probably play Starfire but Mary Jane? No!

[kittykatkr]

No Lohan ever in a Spider-Man movie...

[TheSlag]

Actually Kirsten has read some comics. Remember when she thought she was going to play Gwen? Plus Lindsay still has freckles all over her body. She just put that orange tan stuff to hide it. Christina Aguilera is Teeny Bopper man so is little Kim. They're just the wanna be bad girls for wanna be bad Teeny Boppers. You know like how Good Charllet and Avril Lavigne say they're punk rock but sing Pop music. Lindsay Lohan is a Teeny Bopper man and should not be in a spider-man movie. Do you actually want all those Teeny Bopper kids ruining your showing of Spider-Man 4? Well if you want her she's going to attract all those Freaky Friday Cadets to talk and say oh my gosh during the whole damn movie. She looks to fake man. She looks like one of those plastic surgey Porn Stars who dont bounce or jiggle when they walk. Come on man that's like have Britney Spears as Felicia. You cant see that at all? It would be like the Batman and Robin of the Spider-Man movies.

*exactly*

[terry78]

Teenyboppers already crowd the Spider Man movies anyway.

[Mike]

Yeah, but do you want more? Well if Hell gets it's way and Lohan gets the part for Mary Jane, it'll happen. Screaming lip glossy, skater hair due wearing,bow wow posers, running in to see Spidey. Man you might as well cast one of those shaggy skater hair due guys from degrassi as Peter. God I would hate if that would've happen. Please Sony keep Tobey or cast Topher, both are good choices, just dont cast any sk8ter boys as Pete. ARAAAAHGGGRRHRRG!!!!

[spideyboy_1111]

Lindsay Lohan trys to hide her natural beauty, her freckles and tries so hard to show that she is mature and older and can be sexy. She prances around in the video with he boobs ready to pop out of he shirt, plus she's in some kind of stripper cage trying to look sexy, and for god sakes man she dated wilmer. I would of also preferred Scarlett Jo hansen as Mary Jane. But I seriously cant see Lohan as Mary Jane. She may have the looks but she has her own crowd which I hope. Have you seen Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen. It was god awful and will pop up in my head if she is cast as Mary Jane. She could probably play Starfire but Mary Jane? No!
dude have u seen kirsten without makeup? the girl from the ring (YEAH THE GHOST) looks hotter then kirsten without makeup

[spideyboy_1111]

*exactly*
how does her thinking she thought she played gwen mean she read the comics? well hell it certainly shows in her acting

[spideyboy_1111]

Yeah, but do you want more? Well if Hell gets it's way and Lohan gets the part for Mary Jane, it'll happen. Screaming lip glossy, skater hair due wearing,bow wow posers, running in to see Spidey. Man you might as well cast one of those shaggy skater hair due guys from degrassi as Peter. God I would hate if that would've happen. Please Sony keep Tobey or cast Topher, both are good choices, just dont cast any sk8ter boys as Pete. ARAAAAHGGGRRHRRG!!!!
dude u do know MJ is a MODEL everything u describe screams model.. SHES SUPPOSE TO BE WHAT U DONT WANT!!!!! :p

[Mike]

HUH? WTF? If your going for Model material why not Jessica Biel, Scarlett Johanssen, Nikki Cox? But instead you want some MTV Pop sensation as Mary Jane with some obvious implants? I dont get you. I dont want a porn star I would like natural beauty for Mary Jane. You talk about Kirsten looking hideous well sometimes Lohan looks a little orange. You wanting Lohan as Mary Jane is just plain crazy. Are you that serious?You might as well have Hilary Duff in there as Gwen if your going on looks alone. What your saying is unbeliavable to me, that's like me wanting Britney Spears as Wonder Woman or Nick Cannon as Robin. Lohan should not be in a spider-man movie, and if she is, may god have mercy on our souls.

[spideyboy_1111]

nikki cox is too old now... the reason i picked younger is because spidey 4 wont be till 2010 so u know... we need people who are about 19-21 right now. and lohan LOOKS just like her. she can act decent as well and since any girl can pull a better MJ then kirsten.. i dont see why not other then ur "pop" status view of her

[Mike]

Because me and probably most people think she's going to inevitabley fade like the PG-13 horror movies. Nikki Cox looks waaaaaaaaaay better than Lohan. She's funny has spunk and would probably knock the Mary Jane role out of the park. I cant really take Lohan seriously, she to me is like Avril Lavigne. Both of their songs suck and would never like for them to be in a spider-man movie. It's not the area they should be in. If Lohan did a lot of serious roles and stop all of these teeny bopper movies she was and is still in, than I'll think about it. But you know and I know that, that aint going to happen. I really cant take her seriously right now.

[spideyboy_1111]

again all i can say is u gotta think ahead... cox is to old now and will be to old then. i dont care if u would like her or not.. im talking purely on looks and the fact Kirsten sucks so why not make MJ MJ even if the actress is a "teenie bopper"

[spideyboy_1111]

Because me and probably most people think she's going to inevitabley fade like the PG-13 horror movies. Nikki Cox looks waaaaaaaaaay better than Lohan. She's funny has spunk and would probably knock the Mary Jane role out of the park. I cant really take Lohan seriously, she to me is like Avril Lavigne. Both of their songs suck and would never like for them to be in a spider-man movie. It's not the area they should be in. If Lohan did a lot of serious roles and stop all of these teeny bopper movies she was and is still in, than I'll think about it. But you know and I know that, that aint going to happen. I really cant take her seriously right now.
umm name a pg-13 horror movie... i cant really think of a single one

[Mike]

Are you serious? The Ring 1&2 The Curse, Boogeyman,White noise,The Grudge. Come on man. And I rather have Nikki Cox as a 35 year old Mary Jane then a Teeny Bopper, perfectly round boobed, orange tan, pop singing Lohan. I'm sorry but if you think Lohan is going to still be around when she's in her mid twenties, your crazy. Well unless she does a porno or a graphic sex scene.

[spideyboy_1111]

Are you serious? The Ring 1&2 The Curse, Boogeyman,White noise,The Grudge. Come on man. And I rather have Nikki Cox as a 35 year old Mary Jane then a Teeny Bopper, perfectly round boobed, orange tan, pop singing Lohan. I'm sorry but if you think Lohan is going to still be around when she's in her mid twenties, your crazy. Well unless she does a porno or a graphic sex scene.
o ok well sry.. but hey... ummm since when is there a teeny bopper in any of those?

well hell many moore is still around and her movies are actually good... saved is one of my favorite movies of all time

[Mike]

What, you said you didnt know any Pg-13 horror movies that were made, not if they had Teeny Boppers in them. Mandy More is alright, she's different because she doesnt really put herslef out their like Lohan does. And I havent seen Mandy do crappy movies like Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen or Mean Girls. But I wouldnt want Mandy Moore in a spidey flick either. How old are you mate?

[spideyboy_1111]

actually mean girls was good... and got praised by critics...

im 19 by the way

[Mike]

So was SM2................without Lohan. Lohan will and should stick with chick flicks and Teeny Bopper Flicks.

[spideyboy_1111]

kirsten should stick with... not acting

[Mike]

I dont care about Kirsten. I just look at Lohan as another Tara Reid. Or an Ashlee Simpson. Damn I hate those bastards.

[spideyboy_1111]

tara reid is hot till she talks and puts a cigarette in her mouth... she in looks and if she was a bit younger may have been the perfect gwen... (in looks that is)

[Mike]

.......................damn you.Please dont say that again. Hey have you seen Constantine? It's real good, that's where my mind is mostly at. I cant stop thinking about that damn movie.

[spideyboy_1111]

ya that was an awsome movie... its sounds creepy but im begining to think i love movies on chrsitian mytholoy.... i guess i find them interesting...

constantine...
stigmata
the order
the nineth gate
i love them

[Equint77]

I started this thread cause I thought Lohan had the MJ look but after I saw this picture... no contest.. Erica Durance IS Mary Jane Watson.

http://www.girlskickbutt.com/images/girls//edurance//ed6.jpg

[Mike]

How in the hell didnt Raimi see this chick. She damn there looks like Mary Jane. Instead we get Kirsten? I guess because Raimi's married, everybody looks good.

[The Green Goblin]

I think Tobey was boinking her at the time, thus the reason for the so-called "chemistry".

Now there is no "chemistry" and Kirsten Dunst is slowly but surely turning into Emperor Palpatine.

[Equint77]

I think Tobey was boinking her at the time, thus the reason for the so-called "chemistry".

Now there is no "chemistry" and Kirsten Dunst is slowly but surely turning into Emperor Palpatine.

http://wso.williams.edu/~rfoxwell/starwars/pics/PalpatineHolo.jpg

how sick... :( the sad thing is I see the resemblance. :(

Poor Kirsten....

[Mike]

That is so lame that's how it went down.

[spideyboy_1111]

Palpy even looks hotter

[wetgorilla]

but isn't MJ one who has the social image of a "teeny bopper" as well? both have the same "partying" characteristics

No, I'm afraid she never has had the social image of a "teeny bopper". There is a quantum leap between a teeny bopper's sophistication and view on "partying" and that of an independant woman. Period.
Wetgorilla

[wetgorilla]

you people make me sad... Lohan at least looks and has the characteristics of MJ when Kirsten is just plain garbage... it's so sad you would rather have someone who isn't MJ rather then someone who is.

That's just the point you're mistaken on. She doesn't "look" like MJ. She might look like MJ's little sister or perhaps like MJ to a thirteen year old. But, coming from an adult perspective - no way. Night and day.

Wetgorilla

[wetgorilla]

sometimes i wonder what MJ you guys think of... the movies are of young MJ... not MJ in the comics right now... and lohan fits the young MJ... and by young MJ i mean the MJ before the smoking and more adult MJ of the 90's

That's another point in which you are mistaken on. The MJ of the seventies was ALWAYS of an independent woman. She was around twenty and would have NEVER been mistaken for a teenager.

Do some research.

Wetgorilla

[wetgorilla]

listen i think ur a lil confused.. and its confusing me as well... i want lohan to replace kirsten cuz i dont think in the movies she not only doesnt play a good MJ but she doesnt look much like her (in the movies) she did look more like MJ in spidey 1 and both look more like there counter parts on the magazine cover.

I have to agree with Spideyboy here. Although, I'm a fan of Kirsten Dunst - I must admit she looks NOTHING like MJ from any era. Period. Would I have casted her as MJ in the beginning? No. (It would have been a tough decission for me to brush her off) But, I don't believe it is good to change actors/actress in the middle of a three-movie+ series. Bad for business and bad for the audience.

Spidey has a well thought out statement here. Good job.

Wetgorilla