Spider-Man Elimination Game Suggestion Box

[Themanofbat]

Hello,

Since many of you are familiar with Quentin Beck's Spider-Man Elimination Game, and since he's always asking for suggestions for a new round, I figured a Suggestion Box Thread might be a good idea.

Here are the previous games done...

Round 1: Villains
Round 2: Grade B Villains
Round 3: Goblins
Round 4: Peter's Family and Friends
Round 5: Villains named after Animals
Round 6: Villain Teams
Round 7: Allies
Round 8: Allies Part 2
Round 9: Story Arcs
Round 10: Costumes
Round 11: The Final. All top 10 winners battle off.
Round 12: Doesn't exist... never happened... either deleted by mods or the game was never played. :cmad:
Round's 13 to 16 were just random villains and characters.
Round 17: Writers
Round 18: Clones
Round 19: Best Single Story Issue
Round 20: C Listed Supporting Characters
Round 21: Best deaths
Round 22: Best gadgets
Round 23: Best Spidey Artists Round 1
Round 24: Best Spidey Artists Round 2
Round 25: Best Alternate Spideys
Round 26: Lamest Joke Character
Round 27: Best Spider-Man Centenial Issue
Round 28: Best Stan Lee story arc
Round 29: Best Spider-Man One Shot
Round 30: Best Spidey Video game
Round 31: Best Member of the Sinister Six/Seven
Round 32: Best Spider-Man '67 episode Season One
Round 33: Best Spider-Man '67 episode Seasons 2 & 3
Round 34: Best Spider-Man & his Amazing Friends episode Season One
Round 35: Best Spider-Man & his Amazing Friends episode Seasons 2 & 3
Round 36: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season One
Round 37: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Two
Round 38: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Three
Round 39: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Four
Round 40: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Five
Round 41: Best Character introduced in Untold Tales of Spider-Man
Round 42: Best Spooky Character Spider-Man Team-Up
Round 43: Best Spider-Man 1 Movie Scene
Round 44: Best Spider-Man 2 Movie Scene
Round 45: Best Spider-Man 3 Movie Scene
Round 46: Best Villain for Spider-Man 4
Round 47: Best Secondary Spider-Man Comic Title
Round 48: Best Steve Ditko ASM Cover
Round 49: Best Jazzin' Johnny Romita Sr. ASM Cover


Feel free to toss in your own ideas or modify any ones that are in here.

Cheers...

:)

[Norman Osborn]

Have we ever done a "Women in Parker's Life" game?...we must have?

Gwen Stacy
MJ Watson
Aunt May
Spider-Woman
Betty Brant
Gloria Grant
Debra Whitman
May Parker (Daughter...no one ever said this was strcitly an ASM game)
Jean DeWolfe
Jessica Carradine (sp?)

[Red X]

I wish someone would make me a suggestion box for the Superman Elimination Game

[Kraven]

I liked Mister J's idea a few Elimination games back, I think it was artists, that sounded cool.

[Themanofbat]

I liked Mister J's idea a few Elimination games back, I think it was artists, that sounded cool.

Here would be the list to use, and you can't include Romita Sr nor Ditko, because it would just be a battle of those two.

1. Keith Pollard
2. Ron Frenz
3. Todd MacFarlane
4. Eric Larsen
5. Marc Bagley
6. John Romita Jr.
7. Ross Andru
8. John Byrne
9. Mike Deodato
10. Mark Texiera

:confused:

[Themanofbat]

bump.

:)

[Quentin Beck]

Wow thanks for making the thread manofbat! :) and no we haven't had a woman in peter's life elimination game yet. So I probably do the C list character round next and then the woman in peter's life. Thanks for the suggestions you guys! :)

[Red X]

Artist, should be the next round as suggested above.

[Norman Osborn]

Just another that popped into my head...The "Death Becomes them" elimination game....the best written deaths

Gwen Stacy ASM 121
Harry Osborn SSM 200
Aunt May ASM 400
Doc Ock ASM 398?
Uncle Ben AF 15 (May want to consider "not" using this one for obvious reasons)
Norman Osborn ASM 122
Spiderman FNSM 3
Carnage New Avengers 2
George Stacy ASM 90

[Themanofbat]

Just another that popped into my head...The "Death Becomes them" elimination game....the best written deaths

Gwen Stacy ASM 121
Harry Osborn SSM 200
Aunt May ASM 400
Doc Ock ASM 398?
Uncle Ben AF 15 (May want to consider "not" using this one for obvious reasons)
Norman Osborn ASM 122
Spiderman FNSM 3
Carnage New Avengers 2
George Stacy ASM 90

Great idea, but I'd drop Gwen from the list because she's the obvious winner.

Maybe add Ned Leeds in the Spidey/Wolverine One-Shot...

And also add Kraven the Hunter in ASM #295.

:up:

[Norman Osborn]

Great idea, but I'd drop Gwen from the list because she's the obvious winner.

:up:

Gwen obious over Uncle Ben and Cap'n Stacy?.....maybe....

.....I think..*looks around for Symbiotica....can't be found* Carnage'll win :)

[Symbiotica]

* * *

[Themanofbat]

Gwen obious over Uncle Ben and Cap'n Stacy?.....maybe....

Well, I wouldn't include Uncle Ben's death for the same reason, even Captain Stacy's (maybe)

I would also include Ben Reilley & Nathan Lubensky (who died trying to save May from the Vulture).

:up:

[Norman Osborn]

.... You honestly think I would vote for Carnage's "death" in Nude Avengers issue 2 to be one of the all-time best/most meaningful deaths in the Spider-verse?

You would be most sadly mistaken, I fear.

In fact I would flip that around and suggest an "All-Time WORST deaths" poll. God knows there's enough to pick from.

Lol,..I was being sarcastic :).....Carnage's entry in this game is what I like to call the "whipping boy" entrant.......that entrant that everyone attacks immediately....to warm the game up.....not unlike "Other" being part of the "Greatest arc" game and "JMS" being part of the "Writers" game....

[Themanofbat]

So as far as a "Best Death" contest, we'd have ...

Kraven the Hunter ASM #295
Harry Osborn SSM #200
Aunt May ASM #400
Nathan Lubensky ASM #336
Norman Osborn ASM #122
Spiderman FNSM #3
Carnage New Avengers #2
Ben Reilley PPSM #75
Ned Leeds SM/WOL One Shot
Alison Mongrain ASM #441

[Norman Osborn]

So as far as a "Best Death" contest, we'd have ...

Kraven the Hunter ASM #295


I can't freaking believe I forgot KRAVEN!!...I'm such a tool :(...and I agree, the Stacy's deaths are too iconic to be included...list looks good now

[Themanofbat]

I can't freaking believe I forgot KRAVEN!!...I'm such a tool :(...and I agree, the Stacy's deaths are too iconic to be included...list looks good now

I'm sure we could nail a coupel more token Spidey deaths...

Didn't Madam Web die in the Gathering of the Five story?

:confused:

Actually, it was Alison Mongrain who died in issue #441.

I just checked.

:o

[Norman Osborn]

I'm sure we could nail a coupel more token Spidey deaths...

Didn't Madam Web die in the Gathering of the Five story?

:confused:

Hmmm... I know she became young again...and maybe even contacted Matte Franklin/SpiderGirl afterwards...can't remember if she died though......

...isn't Mysterio dead?

[Themanofbat]

Hmmm... I know she became young again...and maybe even contacted Matte Franklin/SpiderGirl afterwards...can't remember if she died though......

...isn't Mysterio dead?

That's hard to tell... apparantly, there's two Mysterio's running around the Marvel Universe these days...

:confused:

[Norman Osborn]

That's hard to tell... apparantly, there's two Mysterio's running around the Marvel Universe these days...

:confused:

Are you counting the "psychic" guy from "The Evil that Men do?" as one of the Mysterios?.....to me he's just a wannabe that bought a suit from KingPin

[Kraven]

Are you counting the "psychic" guy from "The Evil that Men do?" as one of the Mysterios?.....to me he's just a wannabe that bought a suit from KingPin

The original shot himself and died, but the second one from way back in the 100's came back in the relaunch, but has gone into limbo.

[Themanofbat]

Someone should put a list of the previous 19 Spidey Games so that I can put them in the first post.

That way, we don't see repetetive lists.

:)

[Quentin Beck]

Ok themanofbat here they are:

Round 1: Villains
Round 2: Grade B Villains
Round 3: Goblins
Round 4: Peter's Family and Friends
Round 5: Villains named after Animals
Round 6: Villain Teams
Round 7: Allies
Round 8: Allies Part 2
Round 9: Story Arcs
Round 10: Costumes
Round 11: The Final. All top 10 winners battle off.
Round 12: I forgot :p
Round's 13 to 16 were just random villains and characters.
Round 17: Writers
Round 18: Clones
Round 19: Best Single Story Issue
Round 20: C Listed Supporting Characters

[Venom.X]

The top ten famous deaths/ressurections?

[Kraven]

The top ten famous deaths/ressurections?
For deaths we could have:
1. Gwen Stacy
2. Arthur Stacy
3. Norman Osborn (GG1)
4. Aunt May (temporary)
5. Kraven the Hunter
6. Harry Osborn (GG2)
7. Jean Dewolf
8. Ned Leeds
9. Uncle Ben (maybe, but he'd win by a landslide)
10. Ben Reilly
11. Ezekial (If you didn't use #9)

[CaptainStacy]

Girlfriends -

1) Liz Allen
2) Betty Brant
3) Gwen Stacy
4) Mary Jane Watson
5) Glory Grant
6) Felicia Hardy
7) Deb Whitman
8) Cissy Ironwood
9) Jean DeWolff
10) Joy Mercado

(yeah, i know a few here never made it past the actual "friend" stage, but they still had potential, so work with me)...

[CaptainStacy]

Best Gadget -

1) Webshooters
2) Spider Signal
3) Spider Tracer
4) Spider Mobile
5) Spider Armor (WOS #100)
6) Impact webbing
7) Stingers

[CaptainStacy]

Pals -

1) Harry Osborn
2) Flash Thompson
3) Hobie Brown (Prowler)
4) Randy Robertson
5) Johnny Storm
6) Matt Murdock
7) Phillip Chang
8) Ben Reilly
9) Curt Conners
10) Tony Stark

[Mister J]

Best Gadget -

1) Webshooters
2) Spider Signal
3) Spider Tracer
4) Spider Mobile
5) Spider Armor (WOS #100)
6) Impact webbing
7) Stingers

Have there been any instances where Spidey makes Web Fists (enveloping one or both hands in webbing for extra oomph)? I've only seen it in video games and I'm not well-versed enough in the comic history to say 100% yay or nay on that.

[Quentin Beck]

Wow nice suggestions Captain Stacy! :)

[Kraven]

Have there been any instances where Spidey makes Web Fists (enveloping one or both hands in webbing for extra oomph)? I've only seen it in video games and I'm not well-versed enough in the comic history to say 100% yay or nay on that.
Actually, I just read an issue yesterday where he did that, #311 with Mysterio.

[trustyside-kick]

Maybe it will be easier to nominate stuff for the elimination rounds if you list the ones already done. In the Batman one I nominated something that I was unaware of being done already. And the latest Spider-Man one is Round 20 I believe...so kind of hard to nominate something.

[Mister J]

Maybe it will be easier to nominate stuff for the elimination rounds if you list the ones already done. In the Batman one I nominated something that I was unaware of being done already. And the latest Spider-Man one is Round 20 I believe...so kind of hard to nominate something.
The previous rounds for the Spidey games are listed in the first post of this thread. It's updated as of the start of Round 20. I don't think QB has selected the theme for Round 21 yet, so feel free to suggest something.

[trustyside-kick]

Thanks, I cannot believe I missed that. I guess the only thing I can think of that is not already in the first 20 rounds are the symbiotes? But that would be an incredibly short round...

But maybe the best of the Sinister Six? It is really hard when so many have already been chosen lol. I mean we are doing C Listed Supporting Actors at the moment for Christ sake.

Is Story Arcs like saying Graphic Novels? I noticed one of the rounds already done was Story Arcs and I am just wondering if that is the same thing. If not then I guess best Graphic Novel.

Maybe we could also do best Spider-Man artist? Like choose the top 15 and go from there.

[Mister J]

Artists is a good suggestion.
Symbiotes would likely come down to Venom and Carnage in no time, but it could be done.
Best member of any incarnation of the Sinister Six could be fun.
Story Arc and Graphic Novel are pretty much the same deal, but we could go with other choices than the ones that were used for that round.

[Themanofbat]

Thanks, I cannot believe I missed that. I guess the only thing I can think of that is not already in the first 20 rounds are the symbiotes? But that would be an incredibly short round...

But maybe the best of the Sinister Six? It is really hard when so many have already been chosen lol. I mean we are doing C Listed Supporting Actors at the moment for Christ sake.

Is Story Arcs like saying Graphic Novels? I noticed one of the rounds already done was Story Arcs and I am just wondering if that is the same thing. If not then I guess best Graphic Novel.

Maybe we could also do best Spider-Man artist? Like choose the top 15 and go from there.

I don't have a problem with any of your ideas and suggestions, but the problem with doing ANYTHINg concerning a game like this in the Spidey mythos is that you have to avoid the "big" things.. like Gwen & Doc Ock & Venom & the Green Goblin & Aunt May and Stan Lee... because ultimately, the results will always gravitate towards them.

I like the idea of Spidey artists, but you'd have to avoid adding Romita Sr. & Ditko because it would just be a battle between those two. it's also why Stan Lee wasn't on the writers game we played.

I like the idea of the C-list characters, because there are no clear cut favorites, so people actually vote for who they like, rather than who was so famous that "have" to like them.

Just my two cents.. :)

[Themanofbat]

Artists is a good suggestion.
Symbiotes would likely come down to Venom and Carnage in no time, but it could be done.
Best member of any incarnation of the Sinister Six could be fun.
Story Arc and Graphic Novel are pretty much the same deal, but we could go with other choices than the ones that were used for that round.

Wasn't there a bunch of symbiotes created in the Lethal Protector mini-series?

We could do a symbiote round WITHOUT Venom & Carnage... that would either be really cool, or extremely boring.

:(

[trustyside-kick]

Thanks, heh. It amazes me how many different rounds you have come up with. The Batman and Superman ones are not nearly as many as these. And I think X-men is way way behind...but then again a different kind of system. They got like parts to the rounds? Something odd like that.

[Mister J]

These are all the symbiotes I could come up with outside of Venom and Carnage. If the decision is made to avoid the distinctively 'popular' choices, then maybe Gargan (Scorpion) should be left out too.

Phage
Riot
Lasher
Shriek
Scream
Toxin
She-Venom I (Ann Weying)
She-Venom II/Venom Clone Host (Patricia Robertson)
Venom II (Angelo Fortunato)
Venom III (Mac Gargan)

[CaptainStacy]

These are all the symbiotes I could come up with outside of Venom and Carnage. If the decision is made to avoid the distinctively 'popular' choices, then maybe Gargan (Scorpion) should be left out too.

Phage
Riot
Lasher
Shriek
Scream
Toxin
She-Venom I (Ann Weying)
She-Venom II/Venom Clone Host (Patricia Robertson)
Venom II (Angelo Fortunato)
Venom III (Mac Gargan)

I thought She-Venom II was sexy as HELL.

That entire arc had very strong sexual overtones, imo.

(And damn creepy artwork)

[trustyside-kick]

Lmao.

[trustyside-kick]

We need a round 21 now! Round 20 just ended. What will it be?

[trustyside-kick]

Okay Round 21 has been over for some time...Round 22 maybe? :)

[Darren Daring]

I like the gadgets:up:

[Spidey-Jason]

Gadgets would be nice:spidey:

[Quentin Beck]

Ok I'll do Gadgets

[Themanofbat]

Here would be the list to use, and you can't include Romita Sr nor Ditko, because it would just be a battle of those two.

1. Keith Pollard
2. Ron Frenz
3. Todd MacFarlane
4. Eric Larsen
5. Marc Bagley
6. John Romita Jr.
7. Ross Andru
8. John Byrne
9. Mike Deodato
10. Mark Texiera

:confused:

Let's have a Best Artist Elimination Round next...

Feel free to modify.

:)

[Iceman/Psylocke]

This is getting really vague but -

characters from Maximum Carnage?


Is that too specific?

[Rabid_Rust]

These are all the symbiotes I could come up with outside of Venom and Carnage. If the decision is made to avoid the distinctively 'popular' choices, then maybe Gargan (Scorpion) should be left out too.

Phage
Riot
Lasher
Shriek
Scream
Toxin
She-Venom I (Ann Weying)
She-Venom II/Venom Clone Host (Patricia Robertson)
Venom II (Angelo Fortunato)
Venom III (Mac Gargan)

Correct me if i'm wrong, but like.. didn't the first five in that list like combine to make a symbiote named "Hybrid" or something stupid like that?

[Mister J]

Correct me if i'm wrong, but like.. didn't the first five in that list like combine to make a symbiote named "Hybrid" or something stupid like that?
I'm too lazy to recall specifics as to who, but yeah, a number of them got together to form Hybrid...like forming Devastator, only not as cool.

[trustyside-kick]

So wait what will be next round? :confused:

[Mister J]

It's up to QB, but I think the existing suggestions are Artists, Symbiotes and Girlfriends.

[trustyside-kick]

Ok. I know I suggested Symbiotes but the list of them is not too long..would be a short round.

Maybe instead of just girlfriends we can do Girls in Spider-Man period?

[Kraven]

I know we've done story arcs, but just as an idea, maybe best Stan Lee story? Or Silver Age story? Maybe not the origin ones necisarily, but like Asm 31-33, or 39-40 etc.

[trustyside-kick]

"Best Old School story" you are basically saying? :P

[Kraven]

"Best Old School story" you are basically saying? :P
Well... to put it simply yes. :O

[Iceman/Psylocke]

As QB doesn't seem to be around at the moment, I don't mind setting up the next game if someone has a list.

[Venom.X]

Suggestion 1:

Best Alternate Spider-Man

Spider-Man Unlimited
Spider-Man 2099
Manga Spider-Man (New Mangaverse)
Earth X Spider-Man
Spider-Ham
Insect-Man
House of M Spider-Man
Yu Komori Spider-Man (Spider-Man Manga)
Legend of the Spider-Clan Spider-Man
Pavitr Prabhakar (Spider-Man India)

DO NOT use Ultimate Spider-Man as a choice because it would be an unfair blowout!
-------------------------------------
Suggestion 2

Lamest Joke Character (or is that Best Loser Character?)

Grizzly
Gibbon
The Spot
Frog-Man
Leapfrog
The White Rabbit
The Bombastic Bag-Man
The Walrus
Typeface
Big Wheel

[Iceman/Psylocke]

Does anyone have any feedback / objections against an interim round using the list below suggested by I.R. Venom. Also post any additions you want to see on the list. If I don't hear anything in the next 12 hours I'll post it and QB can continue the games from the round after.


Best Alternate Spider-Man

Spider-Man Unlimited
Spider-Man 2099
Manga Spider-Man (New Mangaverse)
Earth X Spider-Man
Spider-Ham
Insect-Man
House of M Spider-Man
Yu Komori Spider-Man (Spider-Man Manga)
Legend of the Spider-Clan Spider-Man
Pavitr Prabhakar (Spider-Man India)

[Venom.X]

I don't have a suggestion this time. I'm just bumping this thread so others can get the next game started.

[Venom.X]

Themanofbats, here's for future referrence since the first topic hasn't been updated.

Round 1: Villains
Round 2: Grade B Villains
Round 3: Goblins
Round 4: Peter's Family and Friends
Round 5: Villains named after Animals
Round 6: Villain Teams
Round 7: Allies
Round 8: Allies Part 2
Round 9: Story Arcs
Round 10: Costumes
Round 11: The Final. All top 10 winners battle off.
Round 12: I forgot
Round's 13 to 16 were just random villains and characters.
Round 17: Writers
Round 18: Clones
Round 19: Best Single Story Issue
Round 20: C Listed Supporting Characters
Round 21: ???
Round 22: ???
Round 23: Best Spidey Artists
Round 24: Best Spidey Artists Round 2
Round 25: Best Alternate Spider-Man
Round 26: Lamest Joke Character
Round 27: Best Spidey Centennial Issue

[Themanofbat]

Themanofbats, here's for future referrence since the first topic hasn't been updated.

Round 1: Villains
Round 2: Grade B Villains
Round 3: Goblins
Round 4: Peter's Family and Friends
Round 5: Villains named after Animals
Round 6: Villain Teams
Round 7: Allies
Round 8: Allies Part 2
Round 9: Story Arcs
Round 10: Costumes
Round 11: The Final. All top 10 winners battle off.
Round 12: I forgot
Round's 13 to 16 were just random villains and characters.
Round 17: Writers
Round 18: Clones
Round 19: Best Single Story Issue
Round 20: C Listed Supporting Characters
Round 21: ???
Round 22: ???
Round 23: Best Spidey Artists
Round 24: Best Spidey Artists Round 2
Round 25: Best Alternate Spider-Man
Round 26: Lamest Joke Character
Round 27: Best Spidey Centennial Issue

That Round 12 with "I forgot" was a classic elimination round... ;)

Anybody have any cool ideas?

:o

[Venom.X]

Best "Company crossover" crossover?
1- Superman vs. the Amazing Spider-Man
2- Superman & Spider-Man
3- Spider-Man & Batman
4- Batman/Spiderman
5- Spider-Man/Backlash
6- Spider-Man/Bardock
7- Spider-Man/Gen 13
8- Ultraforce/Spider-Man
9- Spider-Boy (Marvel vs. DC)
10- Spider-Boy Team Up (Marvel vs. DC)

[Themanofbat]

Best "Company crossover" crossover?
1- Superman vs. the Amazing Spider-Man
2- Superman & Spider-Man
3- Spider-Man & Batman
4- Batman/Spiderman
5- Spider-Man/Backlash
6- Spider-Man/Bardock
7- Spider-Man/Gen 13
8- Ultraforce/Spider-Man
9- Spider-Boy (Marvel vs. DC)
10- Spider-Boy Team Up (Marvel vs. DC)

Not bad... but the first Spidey/Supes one should win, though many may vote for the Bags drawn Batman/Spidey book.

I'll keep this in mind. :up:

:)

[Kraven]

I know we've done story arcs, but just as an idea, maybe best Stan Lee story? Or Silver Age story? Maybe not the origin ones necisarily, but like Asm 31-33, or 39-40 etc.
Best Old School Story, by Mr. Lee himself?

[Venom.X]

Not bad... but the first Spidey/Supes one should win, though many may vote for the Bags drawn Batman/Spidey book.

I'll keep this in mind. :up:

:)

I've had lots of ideas lately but I don't want to be accused of taking the games over so this'll be the last one for now.

[Themanofbat]

I've had lots of ideas lately but I don't want to be accused of taking the games over so this'll be the last one for now.

Don't worry about it... feel free to share. :up:

:)

[Themanofbat]

We just did the Best Stan Lee tales...

Anyone got a good idea?

:)

[Kraven]

Best mini? Quite a few to choose from though.... maybe just another random assortment of characters.

[Venom.X]

I got it! Best...Spider-Man...Vidja Game!

1- Spider-Man (Atari 2600)
2- Spider-Man: Return of the Sinister Six (NES)
3- Amazing Spider-Man (GB)
4- Amazing Spider-Man 2 (GB)
5- Amazing Spider-Man 3 (GB)
6- Sega Presents: Spider-Man the Video Game (Arcade)
7- The Amazing Spider-Man vs. the Kingpin (SCD)
8- Spider-Man & the X-Men: Arcade's Revenge (SNES/GEN)
9- Spider-Man/Venom: Maximum Carnage (SNES/GEN)
10- Venom/Spider-Man: Separation Anxiety (SNES/GEN)
11- Spider-Man: Web of Fire (32X)
12- Spider-Man (based of the Animated Series) (SES/GEN)
13- Spider-Man (PS/DC/N64)
14- Spider-Man (BGC)
15- Spider-Man 2: Enter the Sinister Six (GBC)
16- Spider-Man 2: Enter Eletro (PS)
17- Spider-Man: Mysterio's Menace (GBA)
18- Spider-Man: the Movie (PS2/GC/XB)
19- Spider-Man 2: the Movie (PS2/GC/XB)
20- Ultimate Spider-Man (PS2/GC/XB)

I think the Spidey games should at least once in a blue moon have as many options as the Batman and Superman games.

[Venom.X]

Have the games been discontinued?

[Themanofbat]

New game up....

:)

[CaptainStacy]

Best "Company crossover" crossover?
1- Superman vs. the Amazing Spider-Man
2- Superman & Spider-Man
3- Spider-Man & Batman
4- Batman/Spiderman
5- Spider-Man/Backlash
6- Spider-Man/Bardock
7- Spider-Man/Gen 13
8- Ultraforce/Spider-Man
9- Spider-Boy (Marvel vs. DC)
10- Spider-Boy Team Up (Marvel vs. DC)

I like this suggestion!

Only thing i can think of is best Spider-Man action figure/line?


1) Mego Spider-Man
2) Secret Wars Spider-Man
3) Spider-Man The Animated Series
4) Spider-Man Famous Covers
5) Spider-Man Classics
6) Spider-Man Marvel Legends FA
7) Spider-Man: The Movie
8) Spider-Man 2
9) 18 inch super-poseable Spider-Man
10) Marvel Legends Super Hero Showdown


Is that a bit much? I think only a total Spidey maniac (like myself) would be even REMOTELY familiar with HALF the toylines on that list, lol...

[trustyside-kick]

^There is a round going on at the moment for Spider-Man incase you didn't know.

[Norman Osborn]

How about Best Spidey 67' Collections Episode?

1/ Revolt In The Fifth Dimesion (ia)
2/ The Menace of Mysterio
3/ Never Step on a Scorpion
4/ Dr. Noah Body
5/ The Slipper Doctor Von Slick
6/ Home
7/ SkyBoy
8/ Doc Ock Nullifier
9/ The Witching Hour - Green Goblin
10/ Where Crawls the Lizard

[CaptainStacy]

^There is a round going on at the moment for Spider-Man incase you didn't know.

I know.

But my old man always told me to plan for the future.

[CaptainStacy]

How about Best Spidey 67' Collections Episode?

1/ Revolt In The Fifth Dimesion (ia)
2/ The Menace of Mysterio
3/ Never Step on a Scorpion
4/ Dr. Noah Body
5/ The Slipper Doctor Von Slick
6/ Home
7/ SkyBoy
8/ Doc Ock Nullifier
9/ The Witching Hour - Green Goblin
10/ Where Crawls the Lizard

That's a GREAT idea! We could do the 80's and 90's animated series as well.

Heck, i bet we could get a COUPLE rounds out of each show! Themanofbat; I have a complete list of the 60's, 80's, and 90's episodes if you need one.

[Norman Osborn]

That's a GREAT idea! We could do the 80's and 90's animated series as well.

Heck, i bet we could get a COUPLE rounds out of each show! Themanofbat; I have a complete list of the 60's, 80's, and 90's episodes if you need one.

I had a great back and forth Spidey 60's cartoon...trivia game going last night with a Lou2099 poster last night......brought back so many cool memories *wipes tear from eye!!*

[Venom.X]

If we do the 90's show, the multipart eps should be counted as one entry.

Example:

instead of having "The Alien Costume pt 1, 2, & 3" take up 3 spots, list it as one big episode in one entry.

[Ebil Gig]

How about a Greatest Episode Of Season 1 for the 90s cartoon?:o

1.Night of the Lizard
2.The Sting of the Scorpion
3.The Spider Slayer
4.The Return of the Spider-Slayers
5.The Menace of Mysterio
6.Doctor Octopus Armed and Dangerous
7.The Alien Costume, (Part One, two, & three)
8.Kraven The Hunter
9.The Hobgoblin, (Part One & two)
10.Day of the Chameleon

[Themanofbat]

That's a GREAT idea! We could do the 80's and 90's animated series as well.

Heck, i bet we could get a COUPLE rounds out of each show! Themanofbat; I have a complete list of the 60's, 80's, and 90's episodes if you need one.

Fire away...

Give me the lists...

:)

[CaptainStacy]

Fire away...

Give me the lists...

:)

Ok!

I see we've started season one of the sixties show...do you want to do seasons two and three next in succession, or move on to the 80's or 90's show?

[Themanofbat]

Ok!

I see we've started season one of the sixties show...do you want to do seasons two and three next in succession, or move on to the 80's or 90's show?

I have the 60's toon covered....

Give me the 80's and 90's lists please. And if you can give them by Season, perhaps we can add more games.

Thanks...

:)

[CaptainStacy]

'kay.

Im off to work now, but i'll pm you later today with the info...E-mail would be better though. You have mine, right?

[Themanofbat]

I need suggestions people.... :cmad:

:csad:

:yay:

[Mister J]

Eps from the 90's animated series.

[Themanofbat]

Eps from the 90's animated series.

Captain Stacy was supposed to provide me with a list... unless someone else can post them here, that'd be great.

:yay:

[trustyside-kick]

Themanofbat

I know you guys have done a few more rounds then the Batman Elimination Games (by like...11?), but perhaps you would like to go to our suggestion box thread and see if there are any ideas from there you could impliment here.

[Mister J]

Eps with the parentheses were technically multi-parters, but I think they could stand out on their own (as opposed to mutli-part eps like The Alien Costume, The Hobgoblin or The Return of Hydro-Man where all parts were titled the same). Your call, either way.

Season 1
Night of the Lizard
The Spider Slayer (1)
Return of the Spider Slayers (2)
Doctor Octopus: Armed and Dangerous
The Menace of Mysterio
The Sting of the Scorpion
Kraven The Hunter
The Alien Costume
The Hobgoblin
Day of the Chameleon

Season 2 - Neogenic Nightmare
The Insidious Six (1)
Battle of the Insidious Six (2)
Hydro-Man
The Mutant Agenda (1)
Mutants' Revenge (2)
Morbius (1)
Enter The Punisher (2)
Duel of the Hunters (3)
Blade, the Vampire Hunter (1)
The Immortal Vampire (2)
Tablet of Time (1)
Ravages of Time (2)
Shriek of the Vulture (1)
The Final Nightmare (2)

Season 3 - Sins of the Fathers
Doctor Strange
Make a Wish (1)
Attack of the Octobot (2)
Enter the Green Goblin
The Rocket Racer
Framed (1)
The Man Without Fear (2)
The Ultimate Slayer
Tombstone
Venom Returns (1)
Carnage (2)
The Spot
Goblin War! (1)
Turning Point (2)

Season 4 - Partners in Danger
Guilty
The Cat (1)
The Black Cat (2)
The Return Of Kraven
Partners
The Awakening (1)
The Vampire Queen (2)
The Return of the Green Goblin
The Haunting Of Mary Jane Watson
The Lizard King
The Prowler

Season 5
The Wedding
Six Forgotten Warriors (1)
Six Forgotten Warriors (2): Unclaimed Legacy
Six Forgotten Warriors (3): Secrets of the Six
Six Forgotten Warriors (4): The Six Fight Again
Six Forgotten Warriors (5): The Price of Heroism
The Return of Hydro-Man
Secret Wars (1): Arrival
Secret Wars (2): The Gauntlet of the Red Skull
Secret Wars (3): Doom
Spider Wars (1): I Really, Really Hate Clones
Spider Wars (2): Farewell, Spider-Man

[Themanofbat]

Thanks...

:yay:

[Mister J]

No problem.

:joker:

[trustyside-kick]

Do they have those released on DVDs? You know, like they do for the DC Timmverse cartoons.

[Themanofbat]

I think they've just released them by certain story arcs (thanks to the movies that have been released)... Green Goblin, DareDevil, and the Venom Saga.

:huh:

[Mister J]

The Season One of the 90's series round is up (http://www.superherohype.com/forums/showthread.php?t=254287)

[Themanofbat]

Time for some ideas folks...

Check out the first post to see what's been done thus far...

:yay:

[CaptainStacy]

Hello,

Since many of you are familiar with Quentin Beck's Spider-Man Elimination Game, and since he's always asking for suggestions for a new round, I figured a Suggestion Box Thread might be a good idea.

Here are the previous games done...

Round 1: Villains
Round 2: Grade B Villains
Round 3: Goblins
Round 4: Peter's Family and Friends
Round 5: Villains named after Animals
Round 6: Villain Teams
Round 7: Allies
Round 8: Allies Part 2
Round 9: Story Arcs
Round 10: Costumes
Round 11: The Final. All top 10 winners battle off.
Round 12: Doesn't exist... never happened... either deleted by mods or the game was never played. :cmad:
Round's 13 to 16 were just random villains and characters.
Round 17: Writers
Round 18: Clones
Round 19: Best Single Story Issue
Round 20: C Listed Supporting Characters
Round 21: Best deaths
Round 22: Best gadgets
Round 23: Best Spidey Artists Round 1
Round 24: Best Spidey Artists Round 2
Round 25: Best Alternate Spideys
Round 26: Lamest Joke Character
Round 27: Best Spider-Man Centenial Issue
Round 28: Best Stan Lee story arc
Round 29: Best Spider-Man One Shot
Round 30: Best Spidey Video game
Round 31: Best Member of the Sinister Six/Seven
Round 32: Best Spider-Man '67 episode Season One
Round 33: Best Spider-Man '67 episode Seasons 2 & 3
Round 34: Best Spider-Man & his Amazing Friends episode Season One
Round 35: Best Spider-Man & his Amazing Friends episode Seasons 2 & 3
Round 36: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season One
Round 37: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Two
Round 38: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Three
Round 39: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Four
Round 40: Best Spider-Man TAS cartoon episode: Season Five

Feel free to toss in your own ideas or modify any ones that are in here.

Cheers...

:)

How about;

Best Ditko arc?
Best Romita Sr. Arc?
Best Gil Kane Arc?
Best Ross Andru Arc?

Etc.,...?

[Themanofbat]

The next three rounds will be Best Spidey Movie scenes from Spidey 1, 2 & 3.

We're going to do Spidey 1 now, Spidey 2 in April, and Spidey 3 in May.

Obviously, that last one will have spoilers in it, so player beware.

:yay:

[Themanofbat]

Ok, in April, I'm going to set up the best movie scenes for Spidey 2...

Any suggestions on which ones I can use?

Thanks...

[Joker]

Ok, in April, I'm going to set up the best movie scenes for Spidey 2...

Any suggestions on which ones I can use?

Thanks...

Heres a few off the top of my head:

-Peter's birthday party sequence
-Octavius' demonstration scene
-Ock's hospital massacre
-Spidey vs Ock at the bank
-Planeterium party
-Spider-Man no more scene with Uncle Ben/trash can
-Ock and Harry make a deal
-Peter saving the little girl in the burning building
-Ock threatens Peter in the cafe and kidnaps MJ
-Spidey vs Ock on the clock tower/train
-Final battle in Ock's lair
-Harry finds the Goblin lair
-Go get em' tiger

[Themanofbat]

Any suggestions for Spidey 3?

:yay:

[CaptainStacy]

Peter vs Harry above Manhatten
Spider-Man Rescues Gwen Stacy
The Birth OF Sandman (Rises From The Pit)
Spider-Man vs Sandman In The Armored Car
Symbiote Spider-Man debuts
Symbiote Spidey vs Sandman in Sewer
"Kewl" Peter Strutting Down The Street
Peter vs Harry At The Mansion
Battle Royal At The Construction Site
Harry's Final Moments :csad:

[CaptainStacy]

So when's the next game starting?

[Themanofbat]

New game up...

But please keep some suggestions coming for future rounds...

Look at my first post for an updated list...

:yay:

[Themanofbat]

Any ideas for a new game?

Look at the first post for an updated list of all games played.

Cheers...

:yay:

[Spidey]

Would the "lamest joke character" count as an elmination for Spidey's worst villain?

[Themanofbat]

Would the "lamest joke character" count as an elmination for Spidey's worst villain?

Yeah, it was a list of the really stupid villains that Spidey had fought over the years; ie The Squid, The Gibbon, etc...

[CaptainStacy]

How about best Ditko cover art? Maybe the top ten key issues, or something along those lines...

Then after that, we can have a best Romita Sr. cover art, and so on...(Kane, Andru, etc.)...

[Themanofbat]

Any suggestions for best Romita Sr. cover art?

I've got my own ideas, but I'd like to get a general concensus...

:yay:

[CaptainStacy]

Any suggestions for best Romita Sr. cover art?

I've got my own ideas, but I'd like to get a general concensus...

:yay:

Some of my favorites:

ASM #43
ASM #44
ASM #50
ASM #53
ASM #62
ASM #64
ASM #69
ASM #71

ASM #72 (did Romita do this one? Not sure, but that Shocker cover is SWEET! :up: )

ASM #86
ASM #87

ASM Annual #3
ASM Annual #8
ASM Annual #9

[Themanofbat]

Those are some sweet suggestions, but don't forget that Romita also did most of the covers during Ross Andru's legendary run, so there's dome good ones in there as well.

:yay:

[Themanofbat]

And yes, Romits Sr. did do the cover to ASM #72, though John Buscema did the breakdown art inside (with finished art by Romita Sr.)

:yay:

[Themanofbat]

Any more suggestions? Shall we keep doing cover galleries?