X4 Would be stupid if.....

[batman7289]

X4 Would Be A Bad Idea Only If They Brought Back The Orignal Cast. not a New Generation

[Majik1387]

You just contradicted yourself.

[Aren]

Haha, yes you did.

[Psylocke8]

I think they should do the original x cast ( whatever is is left of it anyway) lol. But introduce some new characters Gambit and Psylocke.

[Angamb]

the complete original cast won't be in X4. Jean and Scott are dead, so...

[Cosmic Mind]

not necesarly.......they are so many plot holes left by Ratner, that they should solve it on X4

[ico]

I feel it would be fitting to move on from the older characters; Logan, Cyclops, Jean, Xavier, Storm, Magneto, and start to focus on the younger characters like Bobby, Colossus, Rogue, Kitty and introduce some new younger members. Maybe upgrae Siryn, and Jubilee.

[Decay]

I think they should do the original x cast ( whatever is is left of it anyway) lol. But introduce some new characters Gambit and Psylocke.
agree with that.

[JeanGrey12]

I think they should do the original x cast ( whatever is is left of it anyway) lol. But introduce some new characters Gambit and Psylocke.

^^^i agree with it too. i mean i like the older cast. they are my favorite characters. it just doesnt feel right without them or with them as backround characters. i think there is more than enough people pulling for gambit ( i mean he is one of the more popular characters that hasnt really been in the movie ) and even psylocke has enough of a following.


anyway, i like the older characters. i don't think focusing on them necesarily means it would be bad. it would never shock me if they did place focus on the younger characters though :(

[batboy99]

the complete original cast won't be in X4. Jean and Scott are dead, so...read the comics,her name isnt phoenix for nothing,she will rise from the ashes

[genufine]

X4 Would Be A Bad Idea Only If They Brought Back The Orignal Cast. not a New Generation

I think youre stupid. The general movie audience really doesnt care about the new generation x-men. Infact if they make xmen with the new generation only- the movie will bomb. I can completely guarantee it.

[Voli23]

yep. A guarnteed bomb.

[xii22_loop]

ewww

[Majik1387]

X4 Would Be A Bad Idea Only If They Brought Back The Orignal Cast. not a New Generation

This guy is contradicting himself. He says it would be a bad idea if the original cast returned and he also says not a new generation. So basically a movie with no X-Men would be a good X-4 in his eyes.

[*Dark_Phoenix*]

come on a new generation?? then it wouldn't be a X4, and besides remeber some people watch the movies because they want to and dont bringing the elder cast will make the movie be lame for this people. I think that us as x-men fans want to watch a lot but hey. remember hollywood is about $$$$ so suck it. i hope we can have jean grey back, besides she never dies! and for the new x-men i hope they involved gambit and jubilee.

[NinjaTurtleFan]

I think they should do the original x cast ( whatever is is left of it anyway) lol. But introduce some new characters Gambit and Psylocke.

Psylocke was already introduced. She was the black chick with the tattoo on her cheek and the stud in her chin.

It's time we get Gambit, the Hellfire Club, Mr. Sinister, Omega Red, a better Sabretooth, The Sentinels, and a real all out war between the humans and mutants.

Let Wolvie have his own movie and exclude Storm from the cast or just say "she ran off to Wakanda to be with her love T'Challa (Black Panther)." But have all the rest of the cast return, have Mystique join up with the X-Men but her motives be questioned, have Professor X come back, have Magneto set up a new Brotherhood of Mutants with: The Blob, Avalanche, Quicksilver, and Scarlet Witch, and lastly let Iceman be Iceman. Don't give us a quick "ice-out" moment. Let him be a decked out Iceman. Let Colossus actually have more lines and make him do more. Let Rogue quit being a shy, punk *****, and actually do stuff as well.

Let Nightcrawler and Scott come back too. Scott becomes leader again, Beast takes over for Wolverine, and Iceman and Rogue being the veteran mutants can take care of the younger kids.

[GL1]

"Main X-Man"

Cyclops -- Assumed Dead
Jean -- Very Dead
Phoenix Force -- Never existed
Xavier -- In a new (actor) powerless body
Storm -- In charge of Institute
Wolverine -- Last seen giving Bad speeches and not being feral

Hmm... bringing back Cyclops, Stewart's Xavier and Jean WOULD be stupid...

If you guys noticed Iceman, Colossus and Shadowcat are THIS Generation of X-Men... If they aren't front and center in X4 (along with Storm and Wolverine) then the franchise is disjointed... noncontinuous... 'stupid.'

It was X3 with Ice, Ro, Kit and Colossus, it'll be X4 with them too...
Psylocke was killed (didn't stop her before either), and she's the asian girl with purple hair... the black chick is callisto

X4 will also be stupid if they stick with the humans vs mutants theme as the main issue since X3 showed us very clearly that that had been resolved... I think it's time to deal with mutant issues like Apocalypse and Sinister...

[NinjaTurtleFan]

"Main X-Man"

Cyclops -- Assumed Dead
Jean -- Very Dead
Phoenix Force -- Never existed
Xavier -- In a new (actor) powerless body
Storm -- In charge of Institute
Wolverine -- Last seen giving Bad speeches and not being feral

Hmm... bringing back Cyclops, Stewart's Xavier and Jean WOULD be stupid...

If you guys noticed Iceman, Colossus and Shadowcat are THIS Generation of X-Men... If they aren't front and center in X4 (along with Storm and Wolverine) then the franchise is disjointed... noncontinuous... 'stupid.'

It was X3 with Ice, Ro, Kit and Colossus, it'll be X4 with them too...
Psylocke was killed (didn't stop her before either), and she's the asian girl with purple hair... the black chick is callisto

X4 will also be stupid if they stick with the humans vs mutants theme as the main issue since X3 showed us very clearly that that had been resolved... I think it's time to deal with mutant issues like Apocalypse and Sinister...

Yeah, my bad Callisto was the black chick and Psylocke was the Asian chick.

Apocalypse I think would be impossible to have on the screen because Singer and Ratner have formulated these movies in reality so Sinister would work, but Apocalypse you'd have to make him like some all-powerful mutant instead of an intergalatic conqueror.

[Dwarf lord]

Yeah, my bad Callisto was the black chick and Psylocke was the Asian chick.

Apocalypse I think would be impossible to have on the screen because Singer and Ratner have formulated these movies in reality so Sinister would work, but Apocalypse you'd have to make him like some all-powerful mutant instead of an intergalatic conqueror.

He... is an all-powerful mutant...

[NinjaTurtleFan]

He... is an all-powerful mutant...

Right I know that but what I am saying is most of what we know about Apocalypse would have to be changed so he could be just that (an all-powerful mutant.)

The whole him being a intergalactic being would have to be thrown out the window because it wouldn't coexist with Singer's and Ratner's realm of reality.

[Dwarf lord]

As far as I know, he isn't an intergalactic being.

[Diamondhead]

X4 Would Be A Bad Idea Only If They Brought Back The Orignal Cast. not a New GenerationWTF

[muertevilla]

all the xmen were played by midgets

[Diamondhead]

[QUOTE=GL1]"Main X-Man"

Cyclops -- Assumed Dead
Jean -- Very Dead
Phoenix Force -- Never existed
Xavier -- In a new (actor) powerless body
Storm -- In charge of Institute
Wolverine -- Last seen giving Bad speeches and not being feral

Hmm... bringing back Cyclops, Stewart's Xavier and Jean WOULD be stupid...









not if apocalypse has something to to with it !
and he has to for the love of mike!
as for the phoenix force !...it was all there, just as powerfull as in the comics but in a more realistic way ,thank you !
what did you expect ? a stupid cgi bird around famke ?!
anyway I'd like her to come back ,she won me over as the dark phoenix
she was kind of sexy this time :o

[Dwarf lord]

It's a bloody comic book. If it were meant to be realistic, she wouldn't have powers in the first place, thank you very much.

[ISHMAEL]

Psylocke was already introduced. She was the black chick with the tattoo on her cheek and the stud in her chin.

It's time we get Gambit, the Hellfire Club, Mr. Sinister, Omega Red, a better Sabretooth, The Sentinels, and a real all out war between the humans and mutants.

Let Wolvie have his own movie and exclude Storm from the cast or just say "she ran off to Wakanda to be with her love T'Challa (Black Panther)." But have all the rest of the cast return, have Mystique join up with the X-Men but her motives be questioned, have Professor X come back, have Magneto set up a new Brotherhood of Mutants with: The Blob, Avalanche, Quicksilver, and Scarlet Witch, and lastly let Iceman be Iceman. Don't give us a quick "ice-out" moment. Let him be a decked out Iceman. Let Colossus actually have more lines and make him do more. Let Rogue quit being a shy, punk *****, and actually do stuff as well.

Let Nightcrawler and Scott come back too. Scott becomes leader again, Beast takes over for Wolverine, and Iceman and Rogue being the veteran mutants can take care of the younger kids.

now that sounds like a x-men movie :xmen:

[NinjaTurtleFan]

As far as I know, he isn't an intergalactic being.

"X-Men Evolution" made him one and I believe so did the original 90's series.

"X-Men Evolution" had him as an intergalactic being that became a pharaoh like "Stargate" and ruled Egypt and the Middle East until he was finally imprisoned only to be later released again.

[Dwarf lord]

"X-Men Evolution" made him one and I believe so did the original 90's series.

"X-Men Evolution" had him as an intergalactic being that became a pharaoh like "Stargate" and ruled Egypt and the Middle East until he was finally imprisoned only to be later released again.

X-Men Evolution is not real. And he's time traveling. He has nothing to do with Space.

[GL1]

not if apocalypse has something to to with it !
and he has to for the love of mike!
as for the phoenix force !...it was all there, just as powerfull as in the comics but in a more realistic way ,thank you !
what did you expect ? a stupid cgi bird around famke ?!
anyway I'd like her to come back ,she won me over as the dark phoenix
she was kind of sexy this time :o

Meh. Famke's been Meh since the 90s. If I was closer to 40 I'm sure I'd feel differently... and Apocalypse did have a monstrously beastly spaceship in the 90s cartoon, though I have trouble recalling him being very spacefaring in the comics...

I did expect to see a sprout of flames that could be interpreted as wings by a fan... I saw no such thing...

And while in a world of mutants (The premise of the films) having a mutant is more realistic or faithful to the premise that a cosmic entity inhabiting or being or being confused with a mutant woman. That said, Jean's split personality in X3 is nowhere near as powerful as the Phoenix being from the comics. Not by a long shot.