who should play supergirl

[NERD]

who should play supergirl

[NERD]

i think sarah michelle gellar would be good

http://www.whedon.info/IMG/jpg/sarah-michelle-gellar-supergirl-artwork.jpg

[Junfan]

i think sarah michelle gellar would be good

http://www.whedon.info/IMG/jpg/sarah-michelle-gellar-supergirl-artwork.jpg

I could see that, but an unknown would probably be better.

[Shawn_Short]

What is the god damn obession with unknowns that all you people seem to have.

[BH/HHH]

I'd get an unknown here's my rough start to my script I am doing:

Meteor shower hits Metropolis, people screaming. Suddenly a Red and Blue blur comes flying past and stops in mid-air. He looks worried but at the same time amazed. He flies around stopping pieces of meteor in mid-air and averting disasters, etc. A meteor is about to hit the daily planet it’s a massive one he flies under it straining to hold it up but he manages to do so he flies the meteor up towards space and pushes it away. Then something moves past him at lightning speed, he looks at it “it’s a spaceship” he follows it but even it is to fast for the man of steel, it crashes into the ocean and creates a wave. He looks to the ocean then back at the land where the big wave is about to hit, he turns around to stop the wave. He freezes the wave just before it hits the land and it freezes. The meteor shower has ended. He flies over the police squadrons “is everything all right” police officer “yes, thanks Superman”. Superman smiles and flies off. He then turns back to the ocean and flies down into it. He swims down into the murky depths and notices the pod. He grabs hold of it and pushes as fast as he can through the ocean. He arrives the Fortress of Solitude (FOS). He comes up out of the water with the pod and places it onto the crystalline floor. On top of the pod there is a large chunk of rock; he pulls it off with his hand. On it is a Kryptonian symbol the familiar \S/. He stands up thinking “what’s in this pod?”. He notices what looks like a viewing window, he wipes it with his hand. He looks inside. It’s a girl, blonde, slim probably about 16, 17. Superman puts his hand on each side of the pod, ready to pull it off. He pulls at it but it doesn’t give. He tries again. “It must have been built on Krypton”. He rubs his hand along the \S/ shield on the pod. It lights up. The \S/ becomes Embossed and the door begins to open. The door splits down the middle and then fold into the pod. The girl remains there covered by a red blanket. She is asleep. Superman reaches to touch her as she awakens. She sits up stunned, looks at him, feeling scared. “Don’t be scared” She notices the symbol on his chest and reaches to touch it. Then she passes out. Superman catches her in his arms.

[Shawn_Short]

Shouldn't the best actor for the part be cast, known or unknown?

unnecessary--Dew

[Deadman666]

i think sarah michelle gellar would be good

http://www.whedon.info/IMG/jpg/sarah-michelle-gellar-supergirl-artwork.jpg

Way too old. If they ever brought Supergirl in, she'd be played by an unknown teenage actress.

[BH/HHH]

Shouldn't the best actor for the part be cast, known or unknown?

And BH/HHH, there is a reason your not a writer, and thats because your very dull and uncreative.

Getting personal now are we?

[Shawn_Short]

Nope, just informative!

[DOG LIPS]

Nope, just informative!
Knock it off.

[NERD]

I'd get an unknown here's my rough start to my script I am doing:

Meteor shower hits Metropolis, people screaming. Suddenly a Red and Blue blur comes flying past and stops in mid-air. He looks worried but at the same time amazed. He flies around stopping pieces of meteor in mid-air and averting disasters, etc. A meteor is about to hit the daily planet it’s a massive one he flies under it straining to hold it up but he manages to do so he flies the meteor up towards space and pushes it away. Then something moves past him at lightning speed, he looks at it “it’s a spaceship” he follows it but even it is to fast for the man of steel, it crashes into the ocean and creates a wave. He looks to the ocean then back at the land where the big wave is about to hit, he turns around to stop the wave. He freezes the wave just before it hits the land and it freezes. The meteor shower has ended. He flies over the police squadrons “is everything all right” police officer “yes, thanks Superman”. Superman smiles and flies off. He then turns back to the ocean and flies down into it. He swims down into the murky depths and notices the pod. He grabs hold of it and pushes as fast as he can through the ocean. He arrives the Fortress of Solitude (FOS). He comes up out of the water with the pod and places it onto the crystalline floor. On top of the pod there is a large chunk of rock; he pulls it off with his hand. On it is a Kryptonian symbol the familiar \S/. He stands up thinking “what’s in this pod?”. He notices what looks like a viewing window, he wipes it with his hand. He looks inside. It’s a girl, blonde, slim probably about 16, 17. Superman puts his hand on each side of the pod, ready to pull it off. He pulls at it but it doesn’t give. He tries again. “It must have been built on Krypton”. He rubs his hand along the \S/ shield on the pod. It lights up. The \S/ becomes Embossed and the door begins to open. The door splits down the middle and then fold into the pod. The girl remains there covered by a red blanket. She is asleep. Superman reaches to touch her as she awakens. She sits up stunned, looks at him, feeling scared. “Don’t be scared” She notices the symbol on his chest and reaches to touch it. Then she passes out. Superman catches her in his arms.

nice!:)

[matthooper]

This girl:

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0005297/

[BH/HHH]

nice!:)

Thanks :up: its gotta be better than my last one, lol.

[Kid_Kaos]

Depends on the story and the used artwork ....

1. Starting with a young Kara who's discovered by Superman (like the S:TAS) I'd go with Ariell Kebbel (http://ariellekebbel.fanhost.com/)

Pic -->
http://www.hidebehind.com/img/F0683320.jpg

2. Staring with a rather mature Kara with an origin like the old movie I'd go with Sarah Carter (http://www.thatblondegirl.net/)

Pic -->
http://www.hidebehind.com/img/A4F5FE45.jpg

(Note: the pics are hosted on hidebehind.com - you may need to turn off your firewall to see them)

[Deadman666]

This girl:

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0005297/

:down :down crap

[Deadman666]

Jessica Lowndes; born 1988

http://imdb.com/name/nm2057726/

With dyed blonde hair of course.

[matthooper]

:down :down crap


What a wonderful and insightful comment.

A moron says what?

[BH/HHH]

This girl:

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0005297/

Yeah I remember her in That 70s Show. I think shes a decent choice.

[Deadman666]

What a wonderful and insightful comment.

A moron says what?

.......

[elvislennon2005]

I could see Scarlett Johansson playing Supergirl. She is in her early 20s and has the body. I think she could play a very good Supergirl. But this is my opinion. Sarah Michelle Geller could play Supergirl but she is in her late 20s. Supergirl should be played by someone around 18 to 22.

[BH/HHH]

i think its gotta be an unknown.

[charl_huntress]

I'm sold on Cuthbert because of the avatars...lol.

[Mr. Credible]

This girl:

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0005297/

holy crap... she's pretty.

[twylight]

What is the god damn obession with unknowns that all you people seem to have.


Unknowns have a clean background. Meaning when you watch it you don't sit there and think: "Wow, that was so totally Buffy..wait.."

Also in the end they are a way to void all opinions of casting. ;)

Jessica Lowndes; born 1988

http://imdb.com/name/nm2057726/

With dyed blonde hair of course.

She was suggested for WW a while ago.

[Deadman666]

wow twylight. wtf are you doing here?

[buggs0268]

Hillary Duff

http://www.hilary-duff.it/foto/4.jpg

[Deadman666]

Ew yuck

http://www.deansplanet.com/images/celebs/broads/hillary_duff/hillary_duff-nomakeup.jpg

http://www.juicyrumors.com/images/hillary_duff-corpse_bride.jpg

I cant take you seriously anymore man...

[buggs0268]

You must not have seen many women without makeup on. That is why women call it "putting on their faces"

[Deadman666]

It's not just about the makeup. She looks like a horse with her new fake teeth. Her weight loss is a bit scary. Her voice is so *not* that of a superhero and comes off annoying.

Her acting ability limits her to playing only ditzy roles.

This just isnt a good role for her, unless the film was a comedy.

Realistically, I dont think the fanbase and community at large would take the film seriously either with her as Supergirl.

[buggs0268]

Well Supergirl usually starts out more Naieve and also a lot younger than Clark as she comes from Kandor. Unless I am missing something. And no, I am not going just by the movie. That was how she was played in the comics when she first arrives too, except for way way back when when she is as mature as Superman.

yeah she needs to put on some weight. I didn't know she got this thin. Damn.

[Jlandsw]

Jennifer Aniston for Supergirl!! :up:

http://www.askmen.com/specials/2005_top_99/celebs/15_jennifer_aniston.jpg

http://images.askmen.com/galleries/actress/jennifer-aniston/pictures/jennifer-aniston-picture-1.jpghttp://www.eefoof.com/image/medium/7536/images

[LostSon88]

http://x8d.xanga.com/8abd133508c3773576849/w49592108.jpg

Clark and Kara. :up:

[DrMylesOBoogie]

^^Who is that chick?

[Mentok]

Looks like Kristen Bell from VERONICA MARS.

[LostSon88]

Yes it is.

I'm tellin ya' she'd be a pretty good Kara IMO.

http://www.riverselkie.com/yoda/kristen3.jpg

[Mentok]

Yeah, she could work :up:

[Jlandsw]

What about Sarah Michelle Gellar?

http://www.planetafamosas.com/fotos/smgsuper_200105/783.jpg

[Dr. Fate]

Estella Warren.
http://www.celebopedia.com/estella-warren/images/estella-warren.jpg

[KingOfDreams]

Elisha Cuthbert

[SuperIabou]

how about me!!

Im an actress whose 5'11" and supergirl was 6'

here are my pics, although im a bit skinnier now

http://www.billboard.net/ia/IMG_4150_4x6.jpg
http://www.billboard.net/ia/IMG_4223_4x6.jpg

its actually my dream to play supergirl since i had a supergirl bathingsuit I wore under my clothes to school in elementary school

[SUPERSEBAS]

Milla Jovovich!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :yay:

[BH/HHH]

how about me!!

Im an actress whose 5'11" and supergirl was 6'

here are my pics, although im a bit skinnier now

http://www.billboard.net/ia/IMG_4150_4x6.jpg
http://www.billboard.net/ia/IMG_4223_4x6.jpg

its actually my dream to play supergirl since i had a supergirl bathingsuit I wore under my clothes to school in elementary school

5 out of 5. :wow:

[KalMart]

how about me!!

Im an actress whose 5'11" and supergirl was 6'

here are my pics, although im a bit skinnier now

http://www.billboard.net/ia/IMG_4150_4x6.jpg
http://www.billboard.net/ia/IMG_4223_4x6.jpg

its actually my dream to play supergirl since i had a supergirl bathingsuit I wore under my clothes to school in elementary school
Do you have a new suit?

[SuperIabou]

actually i need to take my suit in and take new pictures....hmmm thats what I can do this weekend

[BH/HHH]

actually i need to take my suit in and take new pictures....hmmm thats what I can do this weekend

;) :up:

[Parker]

I always saw Alicia Silverstone as Supergirl. Even before she was *cringe* BATgirl.

[Parker]

how about me!!

Im an actress whose 5'11" and supergirl was 6'

here are my pics, although im a bit skinnier now

http://www.billboard.net/ia/IMG_4150_4x6.jpg
http://www.billboard.net/ia/IMG_4223_4x6.jpg

its actually my dream to play supergirl since i had a supergirl bathingsuit I wore under my clothes to school in elementary school

Highlight your hair and you actually could have a shot. No joke.

[SuperIabou]

Wow, thank you so much!

I thought about dying my hair blonde for a month to see how I look, but I get new headshots in a few weeks and if my hair is blonde in them, then it has to stay blonde.

hmm as for highlights...this reminds me...i need to get them updated, its been awhile...

Ia for Supergirl...hmmm i need to start a campaign page :P

[BH/HHH]

Wow, thank you so much!

I thought about dying my hair blonde for a month to see how I look, but I get new headshots in a few weeks and if my hair is blonde in them, then it has to stay blonde.

hmm as for highlights...this reminds me...i need to get them updated, its been awhile...

Ia for Supergirl...hmmm i need to start a campaign page :P

i'll sign. :woot:

[SuperIabou]

haha, I bet you think Im jokign, but I'm not! :)

[Danger Mouse]

You definitely have the look, SuperIabou. And I must say that you're very attractive. :)

Of course, with all due respect, I haven't seen you act...

[BH/HHH]

haha, I bet you think Im jokign, but I'm not! :)

Seriously from look alone and body stature (yes you are hot!!) you could play this role, I'd have to see your acting though.

[The Shredder]

Estella Warren.
http://www.celebopedia.com/estella-warren/images/estella-warren.jpg

She rocked as Lynda Carter's daughter on Law & Order!

Yeah, either Estella, or Kristanna Loken.

[SuperIabou]

You definitely have the look, SuperIabou. And I must say that you're very attractive. :)

Of course, with all due respect, I haven't seen you act...

hehe wow, guys, thanks for the compliments!

as for the acting part, the best example of my acting I can give, is that during my first professional acting class, the teacher said i had natural talent, and kept making me do cold reads in front of the entire class...he basically spent the whole class on me and forgot anyone else was there, even at the end he rushed through everyones two man script to get to mine, then made the other person in the skit sit down, and he took her place.

the room was quiet and with a one page short skit somehow I had people almost teary eyed....

I hope that helps.

[BH/HHH]

hehe wow, guys, thanks for the compliments!

as for the acting part, the best example of my acting I can give, is that during my first professional acting class, the teacher said i had natural talent, and kept making me do cold reads in front of the entire class...he basically spent the whole class on me and forgot anyone else was there, even at the end he rushed through everyones two man script to get to mine, then made the other person in the skit sit down, and he took her place.

the room was quiet and with a one page short skit somehow I had people almost teary eyed....

I hope that helps.

Well if I was the director, you'd have the part and you'd be starring next to Brandon Routh.

[BT18]

3 reasons why Scarlett Johansson might have been meant to play Supergirl in a Superman Returns sequel:

Scarlett was born 1 day before the theatrical release of Supergirl the movie.

Kate Bosworth, who's due to reprise her role as Lois Lane made her motion picture debut as Scarlett Johanssons best friend in The Horse Whisperer.

Few people could argue there's a more popular young blonde star with a great body for it (super proportions) who can act well (super credibility atleast compared to any actresses her age).

http://img138.imageshack.us/img138/6797/505scarlettjohansson195aa2pg1.jpg
http://img138.imageshack.us/img138/83/39sq7.jpg
http://img165.imageshack.us/img165/6789/37cscarlettjohansson125de1.jpg
http://img99.imageshack.us/img99/4593/scarlettj040cw2zq7.jpg

[SuperIabou]

3 reasons why Scarlett Johansson might have been meant to play Supergirl in a Superman Returns sequel:

Scarlett was born 1 day before the theatrical release of Supergirl the movie.

Kate Bosworth, who's due to reprise her role as Lois Lane made her motion picture debut as Scarlett Johanssons best friend in The Horse Whisperer.

Few people could argue there's a more popular young blonde star with a great body for it (super proportions) who can act well (super credibility atleast compared to any actresses her age).



just wanted to remind you that she is 5'4" and Kara/Linda was 6'

if Brandon Routh had an apearance in the film, it would definitely show.

[Majik1387]

How about we cast a girl as Supergirl instead of a woman?
My suggestion, Alyson Michalka.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v338/Majik1387/Vampire%20Zombie%20horror/Dream%20Cast/AlysonMichalka.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v338/Majik1387/supergirl.jpg
If not, I like the suggestion of Estella Warren.

[BT18]

^ it says she doesn't believe in evolution. She might be too stupid even to have a movie career.

[Majik1387]

^ it says she doesn't believe in evolution. She might be too stupid even to have a movie career.
What are you talking about?:confused:

[BT18]

What are you talking about?:confused:

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=ISO-8859-1&safe=off&q=Alyson+Michalka+evolution

[Majik1387]

^What the hell does that have to do with Supergirl? Many people don't believe in the evolutionary theory.

[ScottishFogg]

http://x8d.xanga.com/8abd133508c3773576849/w49592108.jpg

Clark and Kara. :up:

she would be fantastic!! i've loved her in "Veronica Mars" and she was superb in her short stint on "Deadwood." i'd love to see her crash into "Smallville" as Kal's cousin and give the girls of "Smallville" a run for their money.

i'd especially like to see the way she reacts/interacts with Lex. introducing her (whatever actress it is) could be a fantastic inclusion on the show. they almost introduced her back in Season 4 but then . . . it was just some crazy girl.

[matthooper]

^Many people don't believe in the evolutionary theory.

Yeah, why let the overwhelming eveidence and fact of evolution get in the way of somebody's opinion. She could believe in the boogeyman for all I care. She's amazing. Sure she's off her rocker, but who cares.

[Majik1387]

Yeah, why let the overwhelming eveidence and fact of evolution get in the way of somebody's opinion. She could believe in the boogeyman for all I care. She's amazing. Sure she's off her rocker, but who cares.
I'm not gonna get in the evolution/creation debate, I was just saying not thinking to cast Aly because she doesn't believe in the evolutionary theory is stupid.

[batboy99]

my choice is joanna krupa,i like your choice too majik

[04nbod]

Micha barton was considered for the role by warner. they said if superman returns did well we would get our supergirl movie- i doubt that will happen now but i would love to see her in smallville or an upcoming superman film

[SuperIabou]

how about this supergirl:

http://www.billboard.net/ia/headshots/Ia_Brueckman_photo5i.jpg
http://www.billboard.net/ia/headshots/Ia_Brueckman_photo15i.jpg
http://www.billboard.net/ia/headshots/Ia_Brueckman_photo10i.jpg
http://www.billboard.net/ia/headshots/Ia_Brueckman_photo11i.jpg
http://www.billboard.net/ia/headshots/Ia_Brueckman_photo7i.jpg

[Majik1387]

^She doesn't have the right face.

[Bruce_Wayne29]

Pascale Hutton.

[Sloth7d]

who should play supergirl
A random girl from the bunny ranch. Anyone of them would be perfect.
That or Jennifer Love Hewitt.

[04nbod]

She may be blonde but it doesnt mean she needs a playboy centrefold to play her. i'd say micha barton
http://content.answers.com/main/content/wp/en/thumb/9/93/220px-OC_Promo.jpg
she's a lot like the new DC incarnation
http://www.historyguy.com/comicshistory/supergirl.jpg

[Moviefan2k4]

Mischa is the best option I've seen from all the listed suggestions. I do hope, though, that they use the older origin story, and none of that 1990s protoplasm crap. As for the city, if she's born on Kanodr, Argo City, wherever; i don't really care so long as she's a full-blooded Kryptonian like Kal-El. The 1984 "Supergirl" film had its faults, but the origin was cool, so doing something similar would be a step up in my book.

If I remember correctly, Kara's parents were named Simon Zor-El and Allura. I also read somewhere that Simon was Jor-El's brother, hence the "cousin" aspect.

[captain_jimbo]

Well they're all pretty hot, that's for sure. But I think they should go for an unknown, just like they did with Christopher Reeve and Brandon Routh.

[project13]

If you want a REAL supergirl, this girl fits perfectly:http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0192505/:oldrazz:

[Majik1387]

How about Hayden Panettiere?
http://www.starrymag.com/uploads/HaydenHeadShot2.jpg

[Cannibal Feast]

I was just about to suggest Hayden Panetteire before I clicked on page 4 and saw your post, Majik.
She gets my vote.

[04nbod]

Mischa is the best option I've seen from all the listed suggestions. I do hope, though, that they use the older origin story, and none of that 1990s protoplasm crap. As for the city, if she's born on Kanodr, Argo City, wherever; i don't really care so long as she's a full-blooded Kryptonian like Kal-El. The 1984 "Supergirl" film had its faults, but the origin was cool, so doing something similar would be a step up in my book.

If I remember correctly, Kara's parents were named Simon Zor-El and Allura. I also read somewhere that Simon was Jor-El's brother, hence the "cousin" aspect.

where did the simon come from. its not very kryptonian:huh:. its just zor-el:woot:

[04nbod]

How about Hayden Panettiere?

can she act- whats she been in?

[Cannibal Feast]

can she act- whats she been in?
She's on Heroes. She's pretty damn good, too. She's been acting since she was pretty little.

[onesurvive]

If Sarah Michelle Gellar played Kara I'd shoot myself...

[Eddie Dean]

Sarah Mason
http://img209.imageshack.us/img209/5240/sarahmason600x400vz1.jpg

[project13]

hayden reminds me of the pre-crisis supergirl that died to save the universe,maybe there's hope for her.

[04nbod]

she looks like a chavvy page 3 girl in that photo though-id need to see more to be convinced

[Majik1387]

http://z.about.com/d/movies/1/0/0/2/6/rcst1b.jpg
http://us.tv1.yimg.com/tv.yahoo.com/images/he/photo/tv_pix/nbc/heroes/hayden_panettiere/heroes_haaseth.jpg
http://ffmedia.ign.com/filmforce/image/raisinghelen_hayden_cotd3_1086199382.jpg

[04nbod]

the last one is really good for the role

[matthooper]

If Sarah Michelle Gellar played Kara I'd shoot myself...

I think you should go ahead with that no matter who plays Supergirl.

[Brainiac 2009]

Haydens too short. Shes like 5'0. That would look strange next to Routh.

But shes the right age. Supergirl should be played by a female actress under 18.

16-17 preferably.

[TwilightPro101]

I'd still say Elisha Cuthbert, even after all this time.

[Majik1387]

^
1. She sucks as an actress
2. She's too old to be considered a girl

[Eddie Dean]

Sarah Mason
http://img209.imageshack.us/img209/5240/sarahmason600x400vz1.jpg
Anyone?

[Majik1387]

^Bleh

[TwilightPro101]

^
1. She sucks as an actress
2. She's too old to be considered a girl

Okay, as much as I hate to say it. Just saying she sucks as an actress isn't a form of validating your arguement. Second one yes, but the first one is strictly your opinion.

Third, Hollywood does have a tendency to cast older actresses in the part of younger roles. Still does in fact.

[Eddie Dean]

Why bleh?

[Majik1387]

Okay, as much as I hate to say it. Just saying she sucks as an actress isn't a form of validating your arguement. Second one yes, but the first one is strictly your opinion.
An opinion based on fact.:o
No one's saying you have to agree.
Third, Hollywood does have a tendency to cast older actresses in the part of younger roles. Still does in fact.
Agreed, but that doesn't mean we have to continue it for every single movie.
Why bleh?
She doesn't impress me by what I've seen her in, I'd give her a chance though.

[TwilightPro101]

Finally someone who can give reasons for their arguements. Something that was far lacking back on my days of Ksite. I'm amazed to see it at long last!

Sorry, I just had to say it.

[Brainiac 2009]

Third, Hollywood does have a tendency to cast older actresses in the part of younger roles. Still does in fact.

They arent going to cast someone the same age as Bosworth (who looks way older) as Supergirl.

It will be a teen girl, likely unknown if anything.

[TwilightPro101]

They arent going to cast someone the same age as Bosworth (who looks way older) as Supergirl.

It will be a teen girl, likely unknown if anything.

Oddly enough, I strangely agree with those odds, but I always like putting in my old favorite...okay, not that old, but anyway.

If they do go the unknown route, I expect at least the supporting characters to be at least known to the industry in some form. Much like Peter O' Toole was in the Salkind production.

[Majik1387]

Something that was far lacking back on my days of Ksite.
What's Ksite?

[TwilightPro101]

Kryptonsite.

[Brainiac 2009]

Oddly enough, I strangely agree with those odds, but I always like putting in my old favorite...okay, not that old, but anyway.

If they do go the unknown route, I expect at least the supporting characters to be at least known to the industry in some form. Much like Peter O' Toole was in the Salkind production.

The thing is, Im confident Supergirl wont get her own film. It was tough enough for Superman to do the 200 mil thing, Supergirl seems impossible.

If anything, she would appear within the Superman films....and an unknown kid actor would likely play her....around the same age as Bender in SR.

[TwilightPro101]

Bender?

At the moment, it's really up in the air and it's anybody guess as to what the studios are thinking and planning. It's like gambling blind in Las Vegas. Sure, there are sure things, but the chances are still there.

[Kebab gud]

My choice is Kristen Bell.. she might be 26 but she looks like shes 20
so shes perfect for a Post-crises Kara.
she can do the bored little girl this aswell ..

http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/6369/kristenbell4rq5.jpg

the only problem is that she is a tad bit short.. 5'1.... Routh is 6'2 :P
(and as you saw in the picture on page 2 or 3 .. Tom Welling is alot taler.. at 6'3 (same as me))
the funny thing is that she auditioned for the role of Chloe Sullivan on smallville :P

[Majik1387]

^I see Harley Quinn.

[Brainiac 2009]

the only problem is that she is a tad bit short.. 5'1.... Routh is 6'2 :P
(and as you saw in the picture on page 2 or 3 .. Tom Welling is alot taler.. at 6'3 (same as me))
the funny thing is that she auditioned for the role of Chloe Sullivan on smallville :P

Routh and Welling are both 6'3

I dont think Bell actually resembles Supergirl enough aside from having blonde hair.

[04nbod]

she's too short- supergirl is tall and lean. i think helen slater was 5,8 or 5,9

[Kebab gud]

^I see Harley Quinn.
also valid.... or maybe even better..

[Brainiac 2009]

Brittany Murphy is a better fit for Harley.

[TwilightPro101]

That I do agree, Brainiac.

[Majik1387]

Brittany Murphy is a better fit for Harley.
Ugh, hell no.

[Brainiac 2009]

There is another choice for Kara currently. Sara Paxton; recently starred in Darcy's Wild Life and Aquamarine. She has a certain outworldly look and was born in 1989;

http://www.hicelebs.com/gallery/sara_paxton/97.jpg

http://www.hicelebs.com/gallery/sara_paxton/90.jpg

http://www.hicelebs.com/gallery/sara_paxton/103.jpghttp://content.answers.com/main/content/wp/en/2/21/Photo06sarapaxton01.jpg

http://www.filmweb.no/bilder/multimedia/archive/00098/Sara_Paxton_i_Aquama_98570o.jpg

She has that height and lean figure of Slater too;

http://www.hicelebs.com/gallery/sara_paxton/95.jpg

http://www.nakepedia.com/pics/Sara_Paxton_2_1.jpg

[Brainiac 2009]

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y31/tifflover/paxton.jpg

[Majik1387]

^She looks good.

[Kebab gud]

Brittany Murphy is a better fit for Harley.
hell no .. she whould just be playing the same role yet again.. and her face is a bit too ... worn out..

Brittany Murphy is 29 and looks like shes 33.. Kristen bell is 26 and looks like shes 22, Harley is about 25 give or take

http://www.superiorpics.com/hs/brittany_murphy/main1.jpg
VS
http://www.celebritydesktop.com/images/actresses/kristen_bell.jpg



:woot:

[Brainiac 2009]

Harley wears clown makeup ...

[Kebab gud]

not all the time.. and not clown makup ..
http://www.ybfree.com/5HARLEY1.jpg


.... the funny thing is i just cant think any actress that whould fit Supergirl ..
the supergirl i like the most is the post crisis Kara Zor-El so she dosent need to be like 16-18 more like early 20s, in other words.. not really a girl..

[Lightning54SC]

http://z.about.com/d/movies/1/0/0/2/6/rcst1b.jpg
http://us.tv1.yimg.com/tv.yahoo.com/images/he/photo/tv_pix/nbc/heroes/hayden_panettiere/heroes_haaseth.jpg
http://ffmedia.ign.com/filmforce/image/raisinghelen_hayden_cotd3_1086199382.jpg

shes perfect and as well as she'll be legal too... man what i would to do to see her in a supergirl outfit posing for playboy.....:hyper:

[Kebab gud]

ohh come on! Hayden Panettiere is the same hight as Kristen bell!

[Majik1387]

I love Kristen Bell, I just can't see her as Supergirl, she's more of a Harley Quinn to me.

[Brainiac 2009]

I love Hayden, but shes a midget.


She doesnt have the physical look for Supergirl.

[Brainiac 2009]

.... the funny thing is i just cant think any actress that whould fit Supergirl ..
the supergirl i like the most is the post crisis Kara Zor-El so she dosent need to be like 16-18 more like early 20s, in other words.. not really a girl..

Dude, wasnt postcrisis Kara like 15/16 when she was unfrozen?

She was definately a minor.

[Majik1387]

^All depends on whihc you're looking for.
I think she's perfect for how Bruce Timm draws her.
http://www.hillcity-comics.com/poster_misc/animated_supergirl.jpg

[Brainiac 2009]

^All depends on whihc you're looking for.
I think she's perfect for how Bruce Timm draws her.
http://www.hillcity-comics.com/poster_misc/animated_supergirl.jpg

I think that looks more like Sarah Paxton facially and bodywise than lil Hayden P;

http://www.hicelebs.com/gallery/sara_paxton/97.jpg

[Majik1387]

Not to me.

[Brainiac 2009]

Hayden doesnt have those exaggerated cartoony bruce timm eyes.

Then again, I wouldnt want any live action portrayal based on Timm artwork.

Superman looks like a mutant pelican. That jaw is Leno to the tenth power.

[TwilightPro101]

^All depends on whihc you're looking for.
I think she's perfect for how Bruce Timm draws her.
http://www.hillcity-comics.com/poster_misc/animated_supergirl.jpg

Sums up the take. Every Director looks for something in his/her take of a character.

[project13]

How about Kaley Cuoco? :yay:

[TwilightPro101]

Now, that's an interesting one. She's about age for the role and she has the build.

[project13]

Come on guys! She may stink at charmed, but she looks good for the part. Who's with me? I wanna see some manips!!


I want to know it all, everything.
-Perry White

[TwilightPro101]

Pics please for some debatable evidence...I know who she is, but for those who don't!

[GreenKToo]

http://www.starpulse.com/Actresses/Cuoco,_Kaley/gallery/KALEYCUOCOCH01/

[04nbod]

i hate the idea of her as supergirl- maybe this could be for supergirl manips period..

[Brainiac 2009]

I hate the idea of her as Supergirl. She looks like trash nowadays.

Facially she looks more like Stargirl though.

[04nbod]

i'd say she's too fat in the face to be stargirl either- those chubby cheeks aren't in comic books.

[Brainiac 2009]

To be honest, her only visual similarity to Supergirl is blonde hair.

But ya, I suggested Stargirl cos she wears a mask :p

[04nbod]

^^good one

[project13]

She's a good choice, she just needs a makeover. Can you guys use photoshop to alter her appearance so that she lools suitable for the role?
That's why I want manips. :meow:

[Majik1387]

I like her but not at all for Supergirl.

[04nbod]

.... the funny thing is i just cant think any actress that whould fit Supergirl ..
the supergirl i like the most is the post crisis Kara Zor-El so she dosent need to be like 16-18 more like early 20s, in other words.. not really a girl..

post crisis kara zor el is 16 or 17. i'm starting to think more and more she is pre-crisis kara with artificial memories that are starting to disinegrate. in supergirl and the legion she has a memory of the crisis- thats assuming the two books have the same supergirl- but thats for elsewhere.. manips anyone? i'm awful at them.

[Brainiac 2009]

For those who wanted Hayden P as Supergirl;

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y31/tifflover/brhayden.jpg

[Majik1387]

For those who wanted Hayden P as Supergirl;

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y31/tifflover/brhayden.jpg

:up::D:up:

[Cannibal Feast]

I don't care how short she is. She would be perfect as Supergirl. I honestly don't see what the hang up is about height anyway.

[04nbod]

some tiny thing isn't going to be intimidating to grown men- its all about presence

[Brainiac 2009]

Supergirl was never intimidating

[BobbyinNashvill]

I love the idea of Angelina Jolie as Catwoman. THAT would be awesome. She should do for the new Chris Nolan film. Just a cameo at the end to set up the next movie.

[04nbod]

Supergirl was never intimidating
not in the early years but she definitely got more fierce towards the end-kara i mean. And turner's supergirl definitely had her fierce moments in panel.

[Cannibal Feast]

That's the beauty of it! She doesn't have to be intimidating. She's Supergirl! It doesn't matter if some fool is intimidated by her or not. He's going to get his ass handed to him either way. She doesn't rely on fear like Batman. Batman needs that edge because he's human. She's on a whole different level.

[Majik1387]

^Exactly.:up:

[batboy99]

I love the idea of Angelina Jolie as Catwoman. THAT would be awesome. She should do for the new Chris Nolan film. Just a cameo at the end to set up the next movie.um this is a supergirl thread:huh:

[04nbod]

i see intimidation
http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k318/04nbod/listen.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v739/Juunigou/gagreflex.gif
http://www.kryptonleague.com.pl/www/phpwcms_tmp/thumb_preview/3_222_0Cxua6YBPk.jpg
she may not scare batamn in the last one but if she did that to an average guy they would shat themselves

[Majik1387]

I just see Supergirl mad. :dry:

[04nbod]

so if supergirl got mad at you you wouldn't feel intimidated

[Majik1387]

^Not if she was being played by Kaley Cuoco.
Hayden P. on the other hand...:up::up:

[Brainiac 2009]

i see intimidation
http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k318/04nbod/listen.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v739/Juunigou/gagreflex.gif
http://www.kryptonleague.com.pl/www/phpwcms_tmp/thumb_preview/3_222_0Cxua6YBPk.jpg
she may not scare batamn in the last one but if she did that to an average guy they would shat themselves

I see pms. I'd just kryptonite *****slap her down to her place.

[04nbod]

^Not if she was being played by Kaley Cuoco.
Hayden P. on the other hand...:up::up:

i agree with the cuoco part- i'm gradually coming around to hayden P