Should Hulk Talk in the Avengers?

[Khemik@L]

Tell me what you guys think.

[Wesley Dodds]

Yep. But not too much. Stuff like "Hulk SMASH little shiny man!"
I also want more of a clear dilineation between him and Banner.
At least once i want him to say "Puny Banner!"

[[A]]

I'd love to hear how he'd refer to Nick Fury :hehe:

[Spider-Fan83]

it kinda depend on which direction they go with him...

if he's say the bad guy of the movie
this would imply that Bruce has lost complete control to theHulk
there for theHulk would be more primitive they ever
so, he would speak very lil if at all... maybe 1 or 2 words here or there

But, if say, Bruce starts to learn to gain control of theHulk more, and joins the team... then I could see him speaking more, possibly even full sentences (probably not proper sentences, but, still)

though, I'd almost like to see both of these happen over the course of the movie(s)

[[A]]

Puny One-Eyed Man!

[Obi-Ron]

Hulk needs to talk. He has yet to be depicted as his own personality, and not just "retarded Banner".

[Khemik@L]

Yep. But not too much. Stuff like "Hulk SMASH little shiny man!"
I also want more of a clear dilineation between him and Banner.
At least once i want him to say "Puny Banner!"

I would like to hear him say that too. And by the way when I say conversations I'm mainly talking about exchange of words between him and other Avengers but he can still keep his simple way of speaking. Maybe for example something like:

Ironman: Hey Hulk Can you disable that security bot my hands are kindah full here
Hulk:Hulk can. Hulk is strongest there is! RAAAAWWWW!
Iron ManThanks a lot Big Guy.

Something like that

[karnyboy]

I thought the Hulk was supposed to be just anger and rage and a limited vocal capacity because of that...I mean honestly from a realistic standpoint...the last time you were raging mad at something were you spitting off the dictionary fluently at someone?

Talk ...but don't have a conversation...I agree with what most have said, small bits...but nothing like a monologue...TIH did it well, and timed it perfectly.

[Spider-Vader]

I think it should be sentences but in "Hulkese".

Hulk can destroy long hair man! (Referring to Thor)
Stuff like that, unless Banner is completely in control in which he should be talking correctly with Banner's voice except deeper.

[Khemik@L]

I thought the Hulk was supposed to be just anger and rage and a limited vocal capacity because of that...I mean honestly from a realistic standpoint...the last time you were raging mad at something were you spitting off the dictionary fluently at someone?

Talk ...but don't have a conversation...I agree with what most have said, small bits...but nothing like a monologue...TIH did it well, and timed it perfectly.

Hulk is Anger and rage but if you look at a lot of the comics he talks quite a lot. Not fluently as you mentioned but in limited vocabulary but still enough to hold a conversation. Sort of like talking to a 2-3 year old child.

He would not say something like. "I am very upset your action is causing my blood to boil. And now I will pound you to a pulp" instead he will say something like "HULK MAD! NOW HULK SMASH!!!!"

I did like the way TIH did it but I would like to see a lil bit more and maybe 2 conversations the most. Very short conversations though in the heat of battle. I think having him talk a little will give him some personality and maybe we can even express his rage in a few short words

[nogap87]

He should talk. The Hulk is one of the most arrogant characters in comics and the movies have failed to capture that since they seem to be reluctant to let him hold any kind of conversation.

[louiebling$]

Yep. But not too much. Stuff like "Hulk SMASH little shiny man!"
I also want more of a clear dilineation between him and Banner.
At least once i want him to say "Puny Banner!"

I would like to hear him say that too. And by the way when I say conversations I'm mainly talking about exchange of words between him and other Avengers but he can still keep his simple way of speaking. Maybe for example something like:

Ironman: Hey Hulk Can you disable that security bot my hands are kindah full here
Hulk:Hulk can. Hulk is strongest there is! RAAAAWWWW!
Iron ManThanks a lot Big Guy.

Something like that

I think it should be sentences but in "Hulkese".

Hulk can destroy long hair man! (Referring to Thor)
Stuff like that, unless Banner is completely in control in which he should be talking correctly with Banner's voice except deeper.

Nuff Said :o

[Spider-Vader]

He also better say "HULK IS THE STRONGEST THERE IS!!!!".

[[A]]

Puny french guy make silly Hulk movie!!.

[Wesley Dodds]

"Puny [A] not understand base visceral thrills provided by perfectly enjoyable Hulk movie!!"

"Hulk wan't sequel in which to expand and develop interesting ideas laid down in aforementioned first installment!"

[Khemik@L]

Too much big words. Hulk Head hurt.

[[A]]

Chinese guy made Hulk movie too good for puny comicbook fans!!.

[louiebling$]

;17150982']Chinese guy made Hulk movie too good for puny comicbook fans!!.
:dry:

[Wesley Dodds]

"Silly Chinese man Hulk movie, whilst thematically complex, lacked necessary thrills inherent to comic book genre! Also lacked cohesive narrative! Silly Chinese man Hulk movie fall apart in third act!!"

[louiebling$]

"Silly Chinese man Hulk movie, whilst thematically complex, lacked necessary thrills inherent to comic book genre! Also lacked cohesive narrative! Silly Chinese man Hulk movie fall apart in third act!!"

Exactly!

[Obi-Ron]

;17150982']Chinese guy made Hulk movie too good for puny comicbook fans!!.

:bow:

[[A]]

Ahh you're with me on this one :cwink:

[Obi-Ron]

Ang Lee's Hulk is...unique. And because it is unique, the world will not tolerate its existence. :cwink:

[Khemik@L]

Ang Lee's Hulk is...unique. And because it is unique, the world will not tolerate its existence. :cwink:

:pal::lmao: That was very funny and creative probably the best post I have seen in a long time :applaud

[Sarg92]

This is how I think Hulk should talk and act in The Avengers and in future Hulk films but he should have the attitude and anger of Hulk from TIH.

uM9qA_OnXXY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uM9qA_OnXXY

Hulk appears at the 3:12 mark but watch the entire video 'cos it is great!

[louiebling$]

^^I agree

[[A]]

uM9qA_OnXXYWhere is that from..:wow:?

[Spider-Vader]

It's something Marvel made last year. It has the same animation as the good cutscenes in Marvel Ultimate Alliance.

[Gamma Goliath]

Yeah those vids had the perfect dialogue and hulk was the hero, I'd love to see hulk behave that way in avengers

[Artistsean]

oops wrong topic.
I think Hulk should have mild talking abiltity, but more than what they have shown in the movies.
He should be able to say things like Hulk hate puny Banner. Hulk is strongest there is. Hulk hate metal man, giant man, whoever. You all hate Hulk, things like that. Not too complex, and not Mr. Fixit dialogue, but not non verbal.

In the Ultimates Hulk's thoughts would get more and more unstable the madder he got. If Hulk wasn't angry, too much, Maybe the Hulk could say things like Everyone hate Hulk but Hulk just want to be left alone.
But when he gets madder he becomes less verbal and his dialogue can get worse, Hulk Smash!

But from a financial standpoint, not having the Hulk talk would be cheaper.

[[A]]

It's something Marvel made last year. It has the same animation as the good cutscenes in Marvel Ultimate Alliance.Cool. The action was pretty nice -- I also *love* the camera work in these animations (or most video-game animations)

[Ahura Mazda]

Hulk should speak as he did inthe Marvel video unless they go the Green Scar route.

[Gamma Goliath]

Green scar type personality would be very interesting.

[dudamundo]

Absolutely. I love the way Hulk simplifies and describes things.

[sabetoonth]

oops wrong topic.
I think Hulk should have mild talking abiltity, but more than what they have shown in the movies.
He should be able to say things like Hulk hate puny Banner. Hulk is strongest there is. Hulk hate metal man, giant man, whoever. You all hate Hulk, things like that. Not too complex, and not Mr. Fixit dialogue, but not non verbal.

In the Ultimates Hulk's thoughts would get more and more unstable the madder he got. If Hulk wasn't angry, too much, Maybe the Hulk could say things like Everyone hate Hulk but Hulk just want to be left alone.
But when he gets madder he becomes less verbal and his dialogue can get worse, Hulk Smash!

But from a financial standpoint, not having the Hulk talk would be cheaper.
betty said hs mind gets so over charged he cant proccess it when she talks to him about it, what if thats a way f showing his mind being over charged with rage, hulk no banner he should have multiple personalty disorder, the other personality(ies) being the hulk(s)

[Gamma Goliath]

Banner was diagnosed with multiple personality disorder by doc samson, with hulks as his other personalities.
doc samson later tried to merge the personalities, and he creater the "professor" hulk (aka) smart hulk.

[MilkmanDan]

I voted for not much, but I would also be fine with him not talking at all. I saw "Wolverine vs Hulk" cartoon not that long ago and I cringed everytime Hulk said something. It's like Harrison Ford once said "You can write that ***** but you sure as hell can't say it." The Hulk-talk works on paper but I honestly found it painful to listen. Also I think there's a fair chance that the non-comic fans in the audience will laugh everytime Hulk says something, and it might be a good idea for the writers to take that possibility into account.

[KangConquers]

This is how I think Hulk should talk and act in The Avengers and in future Hulk films but he should have the attitude and anger of Hulk from TIH.

uM9qA_OnXXY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uM9qA_OnXXY

Hulk appears at the 3:12 mark but watch the entire video 'cos it is great!

Hulk must say PUPPY in the movie just once.

[slothbp]

The Hulk is my favorite Marvel hero hands down. There's no one better as far as I'm concerned.I think Marvel should have dialogue for the Hulk. Maybe make him as smart as he seems to be lately. Like he said in House of M, "HULK HATE PERSONAL PRONOUNS!!" Or they could just use simple-minded Hulk. In which case his speeches should be kept to the classics. "Hulk Smash!" Hulk want to be left alone!" Stuff like That. I got upset that Ang didn't use any of his clasic lines in his movie. And when Hulk says those three lines he said in TIH, leave me alone, betty, and hulk smash, I literally hit the girl next to me in the leg when Hulk said HULK SMASH!! I still get all excited when I see that part.

[UnionJack]

Of course he should talk, it would be stupid for him his to smash stuff up and grunt now and again.

Getting him to talk with the others will show that there is more to the Hulk than just breaking things and been angry.

[sabetoonth]

"punny human"

[JeetKuneDo]

He's got to talk more. That makes him a real character instead of a walking special effect. I'm not a fan of whoever does his voice in that video though. Too "cartoony" sounding to me. A deep voice but not so "growly" all the time. I don't know why they usually draw out "Huuuuuullllllk....smaaaaaaaaaaaaaaashhhh!!" so much either.

It's all in the execution. A good filmmaker can get it right.

[sabetoonth]

idk about the gam but lou faragno did it in the movie