Thor vs. Superman

[Fresh Prince]

Who would really win in a fight? No popularity or anything. Who is the strongest and who would win in a fight?

[Cdnmouse]

Well i would say if Thor had Mjolnir in hand, then he would prevail. But if Sups can seperate Thor and hammer, I think Sups would win. And I don't mean this as Thor reverting back to Donald Blake, i mean weaponless Thor.

[OnedetachedonE]

Thor. Don't believe that JLA/Avengers crossover baloney. Editorial sabotage. If Superman can be cut by Wonder Woman's magic tiara or pierced by a magical arrow, imagine the effects of a magical hammer wielded by someone of equal or greater super human strength than Superman.

I'm not saying he would win every time they fought.

I give it to Thor 7 or 8 out of 10 fights.

[Panthro]

Thor. Don't believe that JLA/Avengers crossover baloney. Editorial sabotage. If Superman can be cut by Wonder Woman's magic tiara or pierced by a magical arrow, imagine the effects of a magical hammer wielded by someone of equal or greater super human strength than Superman.

I'm not saying he would win every time they fought.

I give it to Thor 7 or 8 out of 10 fights.
Agreed.

[NewAvenger4]

If they had 10 fights it would be 5-5
strength-equal
speed-supes
durability-equal
magic-thor
nuff said,they should never fight there too equal

[dnno1]

Thor. Don't believe that JLA/Avengers crossover baloney. Editorial sabotage. If Superman can be cut by Wonder Woman's magic tiara or pierced by a magical arrow, imagine the effects of a magical hammer wielded by someone of equal or greater super human strength than Superman.

I'm not saying he would win every time they fought.

I give it to Thor 7 or 8 out of 10 fights.

Belive it or don't, "JLA Avengers" is considered canon, and I don't believe that Thor would win even 5 out of 10 fights.

[TheCorpulent1]

JLA/Avengers is only considered canon for DC and it was written by Kurt Busiek, who's consistently underestimated Thor in everything I've seen him write the character in.

Personally, looking at each at their relative best (not including pre-Crisis for Supes), I'd call it even. Maybe 6 out of 10 for Supes, unfortunately. Thor tends to get the short end of the stick a lot, and there comes a point when you can't just keep chalking it up to the writers not "getting" him. Unlike most heroes, Thor's power level has actually dropped over the years.

[Panthro]

JLA/Avengers is only considered canon for DC and it was written by Kurt Busiek, who's consistently underestimated Thor in everything I've seen him write the character in.

Clearly he should not be allowed to write for Thor.


Personally, looking at each at their relative best (not including pre-Crisis for Supes), I'd call it even. Maybe 6 out of 10 for Supes, unfortunately. Thor tends to get the short end of the stick a lot, and there comes a point when you can't just keep chalking it up to the writers not "getting" him. Unlike most heroes, Thor's power level has actually dropped over the years.
That's terrible. :csad: