The Captain America Casting Thread

[Spider-Fan]

Pine works fine in a solo Cap movie. The problem is I don't think he has to screen presence to lead the likes of RDJ, Edward Norton and his dad.

And Jensen Ackles does?

[Webhead2006]

if it was down to pine/mcpartin/murray/jensen. I would perfer mcpartin/jensen. Though with jensen if supernatural is picked up for 6th i doubt he would have the time for cap and his show, Pine still another solid actor but i dont know if would end up with the role. Plus with trek 2 and when avengers is likely filming, plus what ever his plans are this summer/fall for films. So really out of those 4 names only two i see probably easily have time in schedule is murray and mcpartin. But who knows how its going to turn up. Maybe it will be one of those, or it could be a total swirl and be someone we dont even know of right now.

[KangConquers]

http://www.bored.com/makecountdowns/show.php?id=197015

[ultimatefan]

Pine is a fine actor, but after the success of ST he may be a bit too expensive for a new franchise like this. Plus it oesn´t match Johnston´s statement that it will be an unknown.

[hame4479]

Even though I doubt chris will get it becuz of his schedule, Id be completely fine with him taking the role. He impressed the hell outa me with Star Trek and was the best element of Smoking Aces. I think he could be a worthy Steve Rogers even if I do wish we could get a younger Unknown in the role, but if they do that he must be a damn commanding actor. Am I the only one who thinks Thor prolly shoulda been cast as cap instead?

[That person]

Even though I doubt chris will get it becuz of his schedule, Id be completely fine with him taking the role. He impressed the hell outa me with Star Trek and was the best element of Smoking Aces. I think he could be a worthy Steve Rogers even if I do wish we could get a younger Unknown in the role, but if they do that he must be a damn commanding actor. Am I the only one who thinks Thor prolly shoulda been cast as cap instead?

I would agree with you, but he's an Aussie, and the fallout from fans alone would be enough reason to not desire such a decision.

[Steve Holt]

Wait, how old is Alex Skarsgard? and is he an AMERICAN citizen?

[Compi716]

Wait, how old is Alex Skarsgard? and is he an AMERICAN citizen?
30-something, and no.

[Aesop Rocks]

Oh YOU guys.

[ultimatefan]

Okay, this obsession with the actor being American is getting borderline xenophobic. Yeah I know Cap is an American icon,and so is Batman, who´s currently played by a Welsh actor. James Bond is an English icon who has been played by a Scottish actor and an Irish actor. Many English people will be very pissed if you try to imply it´s all the same cuz they´re Brittish, and yet they have accepted these actors. Sherlock Holmes, also an English icon, is currently played by an American actor, do Americans want to complain about that too?

[Son of Coul]

Well no, but Sherlock isn't a character that represents the English dream with English values and beliefs. Having Batman be played by a Welsh actor is completely different. He's Captain America.

And I don't even care if they don't go American, I just don't know why people keep bringing up Sherlock Holmes.

[Aesop Rocks]

But it's the simple fact that they SAID he's going to be an American actor. If they said that for Batman, the same thing would happen.

[Rage]

Even though I doubt chris will get it becuz of his schedule, Id be completely fine with him taking the role. He impressed the hell outa me with Star Trek and was the best element of Smoking Aces. I think he could be a worthy Steve Rogers even if I do wish we could get a younger Unknown in the role, but if they do that he must be a damn commanding actor. Am I the only one who thinks Thor prolly shoulda been cast as cap instead?

I agree! I think Hemsworth would be perfect for Cap and Skars could have been Thor. I don't feel that an American needs to play Captain America any more than a Scott needs to play William Wallace or a Brit needs to play Sherlock Holmes or a Canadian needs to play Wolverine... or a South African playing Mandella. ;)

If the actor truly understands Cap's motivations and can nail the accent and look...isn't that more important?

[Aesop Rocks]

I agree with you Rage. But then again, Worthington would have a STRONG possibility to be Cap.

Now, do we want Worthington for Cap, mate?

[ultimatefan]

Well no, but Sherlock isn't a character that represents the English dream with English values and beliefs. Having Batman be played by a Welsh actor is completely different. He's Captain America.

And I don't even care if they don't go American, I just don't know why people keep bringing up Sherlock Holmes.

Sherlock Holmes represents England as much as any character, cerebral, sophisticated, controlled - well, most of the time.

[ultimatefan]

But it's the simple fact that they SAID he's going to be an American actor. If they said that for Batman, the same thing would happen.

I know, so that makes any argument of that kind useless anyway. It´s a fact he´s gonna be American, so discussing actors from other countries and engaging in arguments about which country an actor has to be from to play a partwon´t lead us anywhere.

[Webhead2006]

the whole thing with the being american for the role has been THE mandate for the film from the studio and we know the director is looking for that too. Plus i am sure marvel doesnt want to go through all the bad press of oh they hired an ausssie/french/etc...... actor for cap. Or other reasons.

[ChinoXL]

I don't care if Captain America is a non American actor as long as he's someone who can pull the role off nicely

[That-Guy]

I don't care if Captain America is a non American actor as long as he's someone who can pull the role off nicely

Agreed.

i.e., not Worthington.

[jab1118]

Okay, this obsession with the actor being American is getting borderline xenophobic. Yeah I know Cap is an American icon,and so is Batman, who´s currently played by a Welsh actor. James Bond is an English icon who has been played by a Scottish actor and an Irish actor. Many English people will be very pissed if you try to imply it´s all the same cuz they´re Brittish, and yet they have accepted these actors. Sherlock Holmes, also an English icon, is currently played by an American actor, do Americans want to complain about that too?

No let the English complain about there own icons we are here to complain about the guy with America in his name

[Project862006]

http://www.**************.com/fansites/MarvelFreshman/news/?a=14971

[TikkiEXX]

nevermind. rumor debunked. lol

[Chewy]

Not really, "no offer at all" from his reps means no formal offer, not that he isn't in the running.

And as for Johnston saying he wanted to cast an "unknown", once upon a time Jon Favreau said he wanted to cast an "unknown" as Iron Man, and then proceeded to cast Robert Downey, Jr. in the role because he was the best man for the job, regardless of star status.

[Aesop Rocks]

again. sam jackson denied being in iron man

[Webhead2006]

i still doubt it would be pine. But if we will know by march 1st we will know soon enough.

[Rage]

I wouldn't hate Chris Pine as Cap... but hoping for something better :D

[Majik1387]

again. sam jackson denied being in iron man
He probly didn't consider a cameo as being in a movie.

[TikkiEXX]

Not really, "no offer at all" from his reps means no formal offer, not that he isn't in the running.

And as for Johnston saying he wanted to cast an "unknown", once upon a time Jon Favreau said he wanted to cast an "unknown" as Iron Man, and then proceeded to cast Robert Downey, Jr. in the role because he was the best man for the job, regardless of star status.
good point. guess we,ll have to wait for an official announcement the way its going. i figured thered be more info leaks by now for this and Thor. they have stuff locked down pretty good.

[TheWatcher]

#1-Jensen Ackles
#2-Chris Pine
#3-Ryan Mcpartlin

Does anyone have some new Baron Zemo suggestions?

[terry78]

Sherlock Holmes represents England as much as any character, cerebral, sophisticated, controlled - well, most of the time.

Basically the rule of thumb is, if the ****er has the name of the country in his codename, prolly not a good idea to cast a foreigner.

[Spider-Fan]

No offer at all doesn't mean he is not in the running or hasn't been contacted. That just means he has no offer from Marvel yet. That doesn't mean he won't get the role. Notice they used the word "offer" and not that he isn't in the running or we have had no contact with anyone about Cap.

[Young Superman]

My to three Cap picks are:
#1-Teddy Sears
#2-Garrett Hedlund
#3-Chad Michael Murray

[Docker2.0]

Whoa! You have CMM before Jensen Ackles?!? Dude what the f***!??! :huh: :argh:

[Rage]

I also noticed the word "offer" meaning that Marvel didn't offer the role to him... or "offer" him a contract... but they NEVER said that he didn't talk or test for the role with Marvel.

[terry78]

I'll level with you...out of all these choices, Pine is the only one I could see actually looking like he could stand his ground with Downey's Iron Man.

[Spider-Fan]

I also noticed the word "offer" meaning that Marvel didn't offer the role to him... or "offer" him a contract... but they NEVER said that he didn't talk or test for the role with Marvel.

Exactly. Statements are carefully made by agents. They pick their language for a reason. I think the fact he said "offer" may mean that Pine being a candidate for Cap is true.

[Chewy]

The fact that the statement isn't "Nope, this is ********, he's not involved at all!" seems to heavily imply there is some truth to it.

[The Kryptonian]

Chris Pine won't play Captain America, I'm sure of it. To many things go against him from what Johnston said in interviews. Every actor mentioned thus far probably won't get the role either. It's gonna be someone no one's thinking of.

[The IronMan]

I was asked to play cap but i cant get the time off from work

[TikkiEXX]

I'll level with you...out of all these choices, Pine is the only one I could see actually looking like he could stand his ground with Downey's Iron Man.
man im starting to feel the same way. i didnt realise Pine was 6,1, thats more than tall enough. and i loved him in Star Trek. hes still not very well known compared to the Damons and Decaprios. i think if hes actually trying to get the role he,ll end up with it. we just dont know the exact situation.

[terry78]

Stark and Rogers are going to be the ones on the team that are somewhat in a power struggle when it comes to ideals and leadership, Banner will be the reluctant milquetoast/uncontrollable trump card when he turns into Hulk, Thor will be the somewhat alien/naive newcomer with the supernatural power and mentality.

[ImWithTeamConan]

I'll level with you...out of all these choices, Pine is the only one I could see actually looking like he could stand his ground with Downey's Iron Man.

This is why I'd like Pike.

[Webhead2006]

sure we dont know if he has offered to do the role, or even tested, but in the end pine isnt likely to get it. it will probably be either a full unknown that we havent heard of, or someone like ryan/jensen has a good background on tv work and done a few films.

[TheVileOne]

What makes you guys so sure? It's almost never the precious pet favorite TV actors you guys suggest.

[KangConquers]

http://trekweb.com/stories.php?aid=4b7b2c7354ceb

Well apparently it's NOT Pine.

[flickchick85]

That was already posted. Many have noted the interesting (read: specific) choice of wording in the "denial," which is why it's still being discussed.

[KangConquers]

That was already posted. Many have noted the interesting (read: specific) choice of wording in the "denial," which is why it's still being discussed.

That's kind of ridiculous.

[Triad]

Besides, anybody ever notice that Pine's face looks like it got hit with a cheese grater?

[Webhead2006]

well just going by what joe has stated he wants to go with either an uknown or someone with has some tv/film work(ie folks like a jensen or ryan type) its probably going to be like that. But i am sure we will probably have a few more names talked about in the next two weeks before we get the real name.

[afrayedknot]

Besides, anybody ever notice that Pine's face looks like it got hit with a cheese grater?

I said the same thing . . . but I was a bit kinder. I said that he didn't look good in close-ups and that he didn't have a very strong profile.

Also, I thought most people wanted Cap to have the physique of a perfect athlete. I'm not sure if Pine has the body type to acquire that type of physique.

[MilkmanDan]

Sherlock Holmes represents England as much as any character, cerebral, sophisticated, controlled - well, most of the time.

I don't know... He has the classic English "stiff upper lip", that is true. However, I think he is too much of an outsider to represent English character and values the way Cap is supposed to represent the ideals of America. That's why Holmes' eccentric bohemian qualities are complemented by Dr Watson, who is is very much the quintessential English officer and a gentleman.

Also, it should be noted Holmes is up there with Dracula when it comes to most filmed fictional characters. RDJ is yet another actor doing yet another interpretation of Sherlock Holmes. This movie, however, is going to be the first Captain America movie of real significance. It is going to define the character to much of the movie audience for a considerable time. So, loyalty to the spirit of the source material is arguably more important than it is with Holmes.

[FlawlessVictory]

Just cast Ryan Reynolds and get this thing over with already.

[Rage]

Everyone loves Chris Pine right now... but last year the guy was a nobody who had done a bad Lindsey Lohan movie and a bit part in Smoking Aces. Who's to say that whomever JJ casts as Cap won't become a star (like everyone thinks Pine is now)

How does Pine have the "chops" to stand in there and act with RDJ and Norton after working with Lohan, Affleck and Quinto? Not exactly like working with De Niro and Pacino.

The only difference right now is that Pine got a break (being cast under the gun in a franchise type movie at the last minute) and our Cap (whomever it will be) is still out there waiting to book his next gig (like Pine was 2 years ago)

[Rage]

Stupid DP.

Well, since I'm here... Viggo for Red Skull (JJ and Viggo did Hedalgo together) :D

[Deaths Head II]

Everyone loves Chris Pine right now... but last year the guy was a nobody who had done a bad Lindsey Lohan movie and a bit part in Smoking Aces. Who's to say that whomever JJ casts as Cap won't become a star (like everyone thinks Pine is now)

Agreed. This is why I'm glad the director and crew have more sense and are looking to cast an unknown. If it was up to the fans the same actors would be cast over and over again. People only want Pine because he was in Star Trek but the unknown they cast for Cap might easily become the next Chris Pine.

[flickchick85]

That's kind of ridiculous.
Not really, it's par for the course in Hollywood. They're not gonna say anything that's not a done deal. It's bad form. But when they say something so specific as "there's been no offer," it's like they're intentionally NOT denying that there have been talks/considerations.

That said, I don't think it'll be Pine. Even if they did want him, I don't get the impression that he'd be interested in another major franchise.

[blinkuldhc]

Good points about Pine.

I'm highly anticipating this casting announcement and all, but at this point I think what are more important are direction and the writing. I think if there's one thing studios and publishers have gotten right in the past decade, it's casting (excluding the Fantastic 4 and Ghost Rider...hmmm...the common factor between those two?).

IMO:

Thomas Jane was great as The Punisher. Ron Perlman perfect as Hellboy. RDJ is the living Tony Stark.

On the other side, Bale is good enough to play BW/Batman, and Routh was a good choice, too -- especially if the intent was to pay homage to Donner/Reeve.

Then you have some other controversial choices at the time of casting. Tobey Maguire may have been a household name among critics, but he certainly wasn't that well-known among the targeted demographic. I think he played PP just fine. At least, he did well enough to let the 1st two films do well, and the 3rd film was just poor direction and even worse writing.

Heath Ledger was best known for being a gay cowboy at the time of being cast as Joker. Now? His performance as the Clown Prince borders on legendary.

Hugh Jackman was an unknown, too. He was and is an Aussie song and dance man, but he played Wolverine to a tee. (despite being about a foot too tall).

So, if you look at the recent CBM history of casting, I think studios and publishers have gotten it right more often than not. Other than the Fox Studio abortions Ghost Rider and Fantastic Four, I think all casting choices have been nearly spot-on... especially when you look at the most important CB characters (Spider Man, Batman, Superman, Wolverine, Prof X, Joker, et al.)


The point is, I'm sure there will be initial backlash and/or shock when the next Steve Rogers is announced, but I think that he will turn out to be the right choice, no matter how BAD the movie turns out (Thomas Jane and the Punisher, still a guilty favorite of mine).


So here's to Chris Pine or the unknown. If Pine does get it -- which seems unlikely at this point -- I'd root him on. I think he CAN stand next to RDJ and hold his own, but I'm sure none of us would have said that one year ago. In a few years, we'll all probably say the same about Ackles/McPartlin/Hammer/whoever after we see the FA:CA movie, and the actor is mentioned for the next big part in a Star Wars reboot or whatever franchise is next to get the big start or reboot.

[Lobo]

I'm betting on Murray to get the part, him or McPartlin

[Webhead2006]

yea just going by how things have go so far for the MARVEL STUDIOS marvel films it has all been pretty solid casting from top to bottom. So i am sure they are not going to muck it with cap. As for who is cap i hope it will be a good pick, if its a full unknown with little work i wish him the best of luck with cap. If its someone a little bit known from tv or a few films like murray/ackles/mcpartlin good luck for them too. I cant wait to we know.

[blinkuldhc]

Found this interesting tidbit at **************.com:

http://i47.tinypic.com/2mrxtw1.jpg

McPartlin at Joe Johnston's movie premiere?

Here's the link to the fansite article: http://www.**************.com/fansites/joshw24/news/?a=15004


The guy makes a good point/counterpoint. Sure, anyone worth mentioning can simply attend a premiere, but it should be noted that Zach Quinto and Chris Pine attended JJ Abrams Cloverfield premiere...

Who knows? But the speculation is fun. As for McPartlin, I've never seen him act (I don't watch Chuck), but (1) He certainly looks the part and (2) apparently he's Captain Awesome.

[Jake Cassidy]

Interesting....

[Rage]

Interesting :D

I am not holding my breath... I remember that Skarsgaard had a lunch with Brannah and was rumored to be the director's choice for the role.

[BETArayBill]

nice i hope hes cap

[Project862006]

This just in

will smith was at the premiere
AWW HELL YEAH
http://www.slashfilm.com/wp/wp-content/images/will-smith.jpg

[Aesop Rocks]

This just in

You need to chill out

http://i46.tinypic.com/34gu176.jpg

[Mr. Earle]

This just in

will smith was at the premiere
AWW HELL YEAH
http://www.slashfilm.com/wp/wp-content/images/will-smith.jpgThis just in

You need to chill out

http://i46.tinypic.com/34gu176.jpg
:lmao:

[HUMANIMAL]

mc partlin fit's the role!

[jab1118]

Mcpartlin looks perfect but I dont think he can act at all. I completely dont buy him on Chuck any time he needs to be serious or when he needs to do doctor stuff. Hes funny on the show but judging from interviews I have seen him in thats just him hes got kind of a goofy personality and he basically plays himself and when he needs to do some real acting hes far from awesome........... see what I did there

[BETArayBill]

I don't know how much longer I can take this i need to know who's playing cap!

[Young Superman]

I don't know how much longer I can take this i need to know who's playing cap!
Me too, it's driving me crazy.

[BETArayBill]

Watch they'll probably drag it out till mid march before they make an announcement too.

[hame4479]

What the hell is taking so long!!!!!!!!! I want a name god dammit!

[BETArayBill]

The article just got taken down on comicbook movie maybe it's was hitting a little to close to the truth?

[blinkuldhc]

The article just got taken down on comicbook movie maybe it's was hitting a little to close to the truth?

You may be onto something...

Also, here's an index of some of the pics taken at the Wolfman Premiere:

http://www.aceshowbiz.com/movie/wolfman_the/premiere.html

Other than Craig Robinson, McPartlin seems like the oddest fit there. I was going to say John Krasinski, but he's dating the female lead in the movie. Other than that, it looks like pics of the producers, Johnston, the actors in Wolfman, and that's about it.

Not sure about how many stars would show up to a February premiere, and even weirder that Ryan McPartlin would be there.

[KangConquers]

I think this maybe something...

[Deaths Head II]

*crosses fingers*

Come on, McPartlin...

[Lobo]

The fact thta the article was taken down so quickly definitely says something. IF it pans out I will be thrilled.

[blinkuldhc]

While we are at it, I suggest Anton Yelchin for Bucky:

http://www.antonyelchin.org/images/Anton-Yelchin-Picture.jpg
http://www.iwatchstuff.com/2007/08/08/anton-yelchin-chekhov.jpg


He has already acted as the younger mentee in a big budget film (Terminator Salvation) and did pretty well in Star Trek.

[Rage]

I can see why Craig Anderson is there...friends of John Krasinski from the Office...but Ryan McPartlin does seem odd.... ODDER STILL THAT THEY TOOK DOWN THE ARTICLE.

I think that Ryan McPartlin could bulk up and look the part... I just worry about his dramatic chops, having only seen him in Chuck where he is a totally over the top goofball.

[Rage]

DP:wall:

[Young Superman]

Ryan McPartlin would make a great Cap.

[tamron]

I think that Ryan McPartlin could bulk up and look the part...

I really don't think he needs to bulk up. He's got the right combo of bulk and definition, imho. Cap's gotta be flexible.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v115/superherofan/chuck106/chuck106sandworm02.jpg http://img200.imageshack.us/img200/6961/captainamerica6.jpg

[blinkuldhc]

http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/892/ca1n.jpg

[Rage]

Hahaha. He looks like a Ken Doll in that photo. I think if he actually put on about 15 pounds of muscle mass (if he could in such a short period of time) he'd look really good as Cap.

[Webhead2006]

if ryan gets the role i would be happy for him and hope he does the best he can.

[JP]

I hope McPartlin gets the McPart.

[Aesop Rocks]

Why the hell is John Krasinski there? :funny:

[louiebling$]

Captain Awesome would be awesome :awesome:

[louiebling$]

Why the hell is John Krasinski there? :funny:
Bucky :huh:

[Carlo Comicus]

Come on, Ryan!

[Aesop Rocks]

Bucky :huh:



He plays Jim Halpert in The Office. And that's all he needs to play.

[Aesop Rocks]

I'm beginning to think Ryan McPartlin has the role. Hopefully he can bulk up a little bit more.

[KangConquers]

He plays Jim Halpert in The Office. And that's all he needs to play.

Exactly!

[Aesop Rocks]

I mean, I really enjoyed him in Away We Go frankly because I love indie hipster films.

But him as Cap? No way. Not at all. I'll be expecting Red Skull to be Dwight Schrute (Rainn Wilson) and them playing games with each other.

****, Pam would be Sharon Carter and Michael Scott would end up being Nick Fury.

I'm about to cast the entire Office as an Avenger. Someone stop me. :csad:

[KangConquers]

I mean, I really enjoyed him in Away We Go frankly because I love indie hipster films.

But him as Cap? No way. Not at all. I'll be expecting Red Skull to be Dwight Schrute (Rainn Wilson) and them playing games with each other.

****, Pam would be Sharon Carter and Michael Scott would end up being Nick Fury.

I'm about to cast the entire Office as an Avenger. Someone stop me. :csad:

Creed Bratton as Baron Strucker!

[blinkuldhc]

Why the hell is John Krasinski there? :funny:

I can't tell if you're joking, but just in case... Krasinski is engaged to Emily Blunt, who is the lead actress in The Wolfman

[louiebling$]

He plays Jim Halpert in The Office. And that's all he needs to play.
T'was a Joke sir :o

[Brian Braddock]

McPartlin's got a head start over most in terms of acquiring the Cap body, seeing that he's already in great shape and he's a qualified physical trainer.

[afrayedknot]

If Ryan McPartlin gets the role, it leads me to believe there will be a lot of comic relief in the film, and "Captain America" doesn't need comic relief. I think that's what ruined the Indiana Jones franchise.

[Brian Braddock]

Lol, you make it sound like McPartlin's a comedian or something. Sure, he's got comedic qualities but I think there's more to him than that.

Anyways, the Indy franchise may have embraced humour more as the movies rolled on, but there was still humour in the 1st (and best imo) movie. Given that Johnson's own Rocketeer movie had it's occasional comedic moment and Marvel's movies tend to have moments of comedy in them, we're probably likeley to get something of the same tone.

I'd say you'd better brace yourself for the occasional laugh.

[afrayedknot]

Lol, you make it sound like McPartlin's a comedian or something. Sure, he's got comedic qualities but I think there's more to him than that.

Anyways, the Indy franchise may have embraced humour more as the movies rolled on, but there was still humour in the 1st (and best imo) movie. Given that Johnson's own Rocketeer movie had it's occasional comedic moment and Marvel's movies tend to have moments of comedy in them, we're probably likeley to get something of the same tone.

I'd say you'd better brace yourself for the occasional laugh.

McPartlin's no comedian, but he isn't well known for any serious roles. I don't mind occasional laughs, but I don't want Cap to be a caricature.

[Blackman]

McPartlin has the look, but Im not so sure about his acting skills

[afan]

If Ryan McPartlin gets the role, it leads me to believe there will be a lot of comic relief in the film, and "Captain America" doesn't need comic relief. I think that's what ruined the Indiana Jones franchise.

Comic relief is inserted in a fairly serious film just to break up the tension.

Raiders did this masterfully, "Asps very dangerous....you go first.":cwink:the rest of the franchise efforts somewhat less so..."I've come to view the tapestries.":doh:.

Comic relief would certainly have a place in an action/adventure WWII period film, but no doubt it can be disasterously overdone.

[Young Superman]

Does anyone know if Scott Porter has auditioned for the the role of Captain America? Because he's another actor who I think would make a good Cap. He can act and he looks the part see?

http://www.**************.com/images/users/gallerypictures/5148L.jpghttp://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/4/37732-2400-42300-1-captain-america_super.jpg

[FlawlessVictory]

^biolumen posted this over in the GL section:

You’re a noted comic book fan. Is it true that you auditioned for certain superhero roles?
It is. I tested for the Flash in the Justice League movie which is now defunct, but the hope is that if they ever do a solo movie I can get in on that and give it another whirl.

Any other ones?
I went in for the Green Lantern, and currently they’re casting Captain America. I really went hard after this movie called The Losers, which is based on a Vertigo book that is just fantastic. I have my eyes on a lot of comic book characters so one of them has got to pan out at some point.

Would that be a dream for you?
It would be. I specifically said when I was presenting my award at the Saturn Awards last year, “As a kid growing up anyone who wants to be an actor probably has certain characters they’d like to play at the top of their list, or certain movies they’d like to be a part of. Sports stars? I played one. Superhero? Not yet, but I see the creators of Heroes sitting over there, so keep me in mind.”
http://www.blackbookmag.com/article/from-jason-street-to-wall-street-scott-porter-on-his-new-movie-the-good-guy/16185

[Compi716]

I have a feeling Porter is the next Cavill...tries out for all the top roles, but never gets them.

[Son of Coul]

You may be onto something...

Also, here's an index of some of the pics taken at the Wolfman Premiere:

http://www.aceshowbiz.com/movie/wolfman_the/premiere.html

Other than Craig Robinson, McPartlin seems like the oddest fit there. I was going to say John Krasinski, but he's dating the female lead in the movie. Other than that, it looks like pics of the producers, Johnston, the actors in Wolfman, and that's about it.

Not sure about how many stars would show up to a February premiere, and even weirder that Ryan McPartlin would be there.
so then it's confirmed that CRAIG ROBINSON IS CAPTAIN AMERICA

[Aesop Rocks]

Brilliant casting, if you ask me.

[louiebling$]

Does anyone know if Scott Porter has auditioned for the the role of Captain America? Because he's another actor who I think would make a good Cap. He can act and he looks the part see?

http://www.**************.com/images/users/gallerypictures/5148L.jpghttp://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/4/37732-2400-42300-1-captain-america_super.jpg
I've been Petitioning for him for quite some time now :cwink:

[Rage]

Scott Porter is not a bad choice. I would not be unhappy with him as Cap.

[Webhead2006]

yea i wouldnt mind porter myself, i wish him the luck one of these days to nab a hero role.

[louiebling$]

yea i wouldnt mind porter myself, i wish him the luck one of these days to nab a hero role.
Yea if he doesn't get the cap gig *crosses fingers* he had better get The Flash.

[terry78]

Porter does look like him already. They wouldn't even really need to do that much to him.

[Changeling]

Thats interesting McPartlin was at the Wolfman premiere...hmmm

[marcvader]

So who's it going to be, boys?

[Blackman]

Porter really reminds me of Wally West, but Ill be really happy if he gets Cap

[marcvader]

Dp dammit!

[blinkuldhc]

Captain Awesome as Captain America pretty much markets itself.

I personally would want Chris Pine for the role, but McPartlin isn't too shabby. Better than Ackles, Hammer or CMM, IMO.

[Chewy]

HOLY ****!

I scored me a Marvel scoop!http://twitter.com/elmayimbe

It's either Cap or something related :awesome:

[marcvader]

Let's hope so.

[Son of Coul]

Right after...
Making confirmation calls, give me a minute...these days you gotta triple check...Wouldn't be surprised if it's Cap.

[KangConquers]

Who is this tweeter? Why are they considered credible?

I have my doubts...

[craigdbfan]

http://twitter.com/elmayimbe

It's either Cap or something related :awesome:

Crossing my fingers its who's been casted as Cap. :wow:

Who is this tweeter? Why are they considered credible?

I have my doubts...

From Latino Review. He is very trust worthy.

He along with the site has broke a ton of casting picks. While their writing sucks for the most part, the scoops they get are solid.

[Chewy]

El Mayimbe from LatinoReview. Castings he has broken in the past include Heath Ledger as the Joker, Aaron Eckhart as Two-Face, Jason Mamoa as Conan and Brandon Routh as Superman

[terry78]

El Mayimbe from LatinoReview. Castings he has broken in the past include Heath Ledger as the Joker, Aaron Eckhart as Two-Face, Jason Mamoa as Conan and Brandon Routh as Superman

Meh, what has he done for me LATELY? :o

[KangConquers]

El Mayimbe from LatinoReview. Castings he has broken in the past include Heath Ledger as the Joker, Aaron Eckhart as Two-Face, Jason Mamoa as Conan and Brandon Routh as Superman

Thanks for clarifying, Chewy!

[blinkuldhc]

It'd be hilarious if SHH.com was his source

[KangConquers]

meh looks like it's unsubstantiated.

[KangConquers]

****...

[blinkuldhc]

The big scoop is about the Spider Man reboot being Utlimate SM

[That person]

Crossing my fingers its who's been casted as Cap. :wow: If I got Civilization 5 screenshots, Cap casting, and science fair on the same day, I'm not sure I could contain the nerdgasms :awesome:
Edit: Damn crosspost! Oh well, two out of three isn't bad.
Edit again: But maybe three out of three is better?

[KangConquers]

The big scoop is about the Spider Man reboot being Utlimate SM

He just tweeted that it's NOT spidey.

[blinkuldhc]

The big scoop is about the Spider Man reboot being Utlimate SM

Or not.

[ImWithTeamConan]

COME ON Latino Review! I'm seriously jonesing (sp?) for any Cap news, I need something!

So instead of clicking refresh on your homepage (like I have for the last 20 minutes), I am going to go to class. And hopefully by the time I get back bedlam will have overtaken this thread.

[KangConquers]

Dammit...my girlfriend's getting off work soon...and she's going to want to talk. I want to follow this story.

[blinkuldhc]

This is exactly how rumors get started....

http://www.worstpreviews.com/

[craigdbfan]

Hmm.

McPartlin at Wolfman premiere and LationReview's scoop on something of importance over at Marvel.

I may be reaching here but the casting decision could be close.

[Changeling]

... :)

[blinkuldhc]

It would be awesome if this thread started the ball rolling on their announcement.

McPartlin or not, I feel like Captain America has already been cast for weeks. There have been no other actors' tweets or other announcements about reading for the part.

[Maze]

elmayimbe
Got another corny email. Kellan Lutz as Captain America? ***** please. The kid can't act wet in a pool or hot in a fire.

http://twitter.com/elmayimbe

[louiebling$]

http://twitter.com/elmayimbe
noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

[Nightwing]

Please no Twilight actors. Please.

[Chewy]

That's obviously not his scoop, we're still waiting

Hopefully he posts it soon

[flickchick85]

He was just responding to someone's speculation.

[FaT_tONle]

***crosses fingers***... C'MOONNNNNNNN T. Lautner...

[Chewy]

This guy (http://twitter.com/Schofizzy) is someone who I've been following on Twitter for a while and he definitely 100% knows someone close to Cap's production and has tweeted about it periodically for a few months. A few days ago he tweeted that the decision has been made but he's sworn to secrecy. I feel fairly confident in believing him that the decision has been made, at this point we're just waiting to hear who it is.

[Compi716]

The big scoop can ONLY be Spidey casting or Cap casting. I can't see what other possibilities there are.

[KangConquers]

The big scoop can ONLY be Spidey casting or Cap casting. I can't see what other possibilities there are.

Avengers director.

[flickchick85]

I don't think it's Spidey, based on that previous tweet.

[Compi716]

This guy (http://twitter.com/Schofizzy) is someone who I've been following on Twitter for a while and he definitely 100% knows someone close to Cap's production and has tweeted about it periodically for a few months. A few days ago he tweeted that the decision has been made but he's sworn to secrecy. I feel fairly confident in believing him that the decision has been made, at this point we're just waiting to hear who it is.
Right, and he posted this:
@elmayimbe if you got the Cap's casting, I bet your happy. It's a pretty sweet choice! I've sworn not to run it.
So we could very well get our Cap actor tonight...and it seems it's someone that is at least somewhat known.

[ComicBookGuy]

This guy (http://twitter.com/Schofizzy) is someone who I've been following on Twitter for a while and he definitely 100% knows someone close to Cap's production and has tweeted about it periodically for a few months. A few days ago he tweeted that the decision has been made but he's sworn to secrecy. I feel fairly confident in believing him that the decision has been made, at this point we're just waiting to hear who it is.

And notice down on his page
@elmayimbe (http://twitter.com/elmayimbe) if you got the Cap's casting, I bet your happy. It's a pretty sweet choice! I've sworn not to run it.

This sucks.

[KangConquers]

****! I'm so upset...no Casting today... :cmad:

[Compi716]

Marvel scoop dead. Unsubstantiated. I'm not running rumors. Next.
Well there goes that.

[rcazzy]

Aww.. :( excitement then letdown!

[Nightwing]

****.

[Project862006]

This guy (http://twitter.com/Schofizzy) is someone who I've been following on Twitter for a while and he definitely 100% knows someone close to Cap's production and has tweeted about it periodically for a few months. A few days ago he tweeted that the decision has been made but he's sworn to secrecy. I feel fairly confident in believing him that the decision has been made, at this point we're just waiting to hear who it is.


here is the tweet

http://twitter.com/Schofizzy/status/9301072699

[KangConquers]

****.

********ing Mother******

[Son of Coul]

Hahaha, that sucks.

[Nightwing]

*****ucking mother****er!
Not that far. :p

[Young Superman]

That's freaking sucks.

[BETArayBill]

If cap is cast I wish they would just release the damn name

[louiebling$]

:argh::wall::cmad::wall:

[Chewy]

here is the tweet

http://twitter.com/Schofizzy/status/9301072699
Actually I was referring to this one from a few days ago

I'm dying to spill the beans on the THE FIRST AVENGER: CAPTAIN AMERICA casting, but I promised to keep it under wraps. Its a doozy!
http://twitter.com/Schofizzy/status/9150924709

I hadn't seen the new one when I posted that :awesome:

[Young Superman]

:argh::wall::cmad::wall:
I agree with this guy.

[Blackman]

Damn I was hoping for casting news tonight

Anyway my top choices are Hedlund, McLaughlin, and McKenzie

[BETArayBill]

Someone needs to tell that guy promises were meant to be broken.

[ComicBookGuy]

Post the rummor dammit just throw us a f**king bone!!

[Chewy]

Here's the situation as I see it

Marvel has decided on their actor, and are likely currently negotiating his contract with him. So we are waiting for either
a) Someone who's willing to leak the info to find out who it is and, well, leak it
or
b) Marvel to finalize negotiations and make the announcement themselves

Either way I think we're at most a couple of days from knowing who it is

[flickchick85]

Assuming the guy who's claiming to know it really does...did anyone else find it interesting that he said "I bet you're happy. It's a pretty sweet choice" to elmayimbe when he thought he had the scoop? That makes it sound like its not an entirely unknown actor that we're dealing with here.

[louiebling$]

Assuming the guy who's claiming to know it really does...did anyone else find it interesting that he said "I bet you're happy. It's a pretty sweet choice" to elmayimbe when he thought he had the scoop? That makes it sound like its not an entirely unknown actor that we're dealing with here.
Good Observation :up:

[BETArayBill]

No cap casting is making me angry :bh:

[jab1118]

Oh for christ sake isnt there a less upstanding person out there willing to print a rumor?

[Compi716]

So it seems that if one source is to be believed, the actor playing Cap is not a complete unknown. This begs the question, is he someone mentioned on this board, or an out-of-left-field choice like Ledger?

God, could you guys imagine the hell that would break loose if it's Ackles? Half the board would be ecstatic, and the other half would be mad with rage. It would be war!

[richardmvela]

Man I hope it is Ackles. I think he'd be cool to watch.

[Aesop Rocks]

With is annoyingly deep voice.

[blinkuldhc]

Will Smith would be the doozy of viable doozies.

Besides, there are varying degrees of unknown. I think Chris Hemsworth could be considered an unknown, relative to Ed Norton and RDJ. Then again, McPartlin is an unknown compared to Hemsworth.

I still think it's going to be McPartlin. Although, if I were McPartlin and already cast weeks ago, I (along with my agent) would have a very hard time keeping it secret.

[BrlntDsgse]

Filming a giant summer blockbuster: 150 Million $

Price of a movie ticket: 8$

Finding the perfect leading man...............AWESOME:woot:


In all seriousness though, I get the feeling that McPartlin has this locked up. Considering his appearance at the Wolfman premiere and as was pointed out a few posts ago, the tweets of "bet you'll be happy" & especially "it's a doozy" do seem to suggest that they have not picked a COMPLETE unknown. Personally if it does turn out to be McPartlin I couldn't be happier, the guy is the SPITTING IMAGE of Steve Rogers and I feel he can pull off more than just his comedy relief role on Chuck. Scott Porter wouldn't be bad either, could live with Ackles(even though he'd be a MUCH better fit as Hawkeye). Anyway it'll all be a moot point soon if we can all survive a few more days without our heads exploding.

[blinkuldhc]

http://scifiwire.com/assets_c/2009/03/SuperCapers_RyanMcPartlin-thumb-550x393-15058.jpg

[TikkiEXX]

im sorry but i dont think McPartlin is considered a 'doozy" to very many people. i have no clue who he is and i myself wouldnt get too excited about any TV actor. if it really is a "doozy" it makes me think its Pine or maybe even Damon. he looks ultra bad ass in Green Zone. think big people. the fun,ll be over in a few days when they probably announce who has the role. lol

[Rage]

If we are to "think BIG" that would exclude Matt Damon ;)

[HUMANIMAL]

http://scifiwire.com/assets_c/2009/03/SuperCapers_RyanMcPartlin-thumb-550x393-15058.jpg

http://img638.imageshack.us/img638/715/supercapersryanmcpartli.jpg (http://img638.imageshack.us/i/supercapersryanmcpartli.jpg/)

[Rage]

Hahahaha... good manip :D

[tamron]

The 'doozy' tweet makes me think it a Ledger-type casting. A guy who will seem out of left field upon announcement, but hopefully knock it out of the park.

A name like Damon, Pine, even Pitt, I wouldn't call a 'doozy' they've all been discussed. I'm thinking it will be something that catches us off guard.

[Rage]

I do like the style of the wings though...That is what I picture the wings looking like (except chrome)

He needs ears though (IMO)

[I Am Jack's...]

Personally, I don't think it should be McPartlin, as he hasn't impressed me with his acting on Chuck at all, even with his as-of-late expanded role in Chuck's spy life. But, I have a really nagging feeling that it's going to be him :csad:

But, now with that whole "it's a doozy" thing, I don't really know what to anticipate. I wouldn't put McPartlin in the "doozy" category, even if I did think he's an okay choice for Cap. It's weird, the "doozy" thing really puts a new spin on things, as it makes it look like Johnston isn't going for an unknown, contrary to what he actually said himself, and it looks like it's going to be a big announcement, not that it already wouldn't be a big one, as this is Cap we're talking about, but the actor himself will be a big reveal.

It's getting exciting, to say the least :yay:

[HUMANIMAL]

oh right the ears...its just a quick mock up its not supposed to be convincing

[Rage]

I got that you weren't doing "photorealistic" It just kinda reminds me of the old Republic serials Cap (with no ears)

[BETArayBill]

Wow that's a good manip!

[flickchick85]

Considering his appearance at the Wolfman premiere and as was pointed out a few posts ago, the tweets of "bet you'll be happy" & especially "it's a doozy" do seem to suggest that they have not picked a COMPLETE unknown.
Wait, I'm already behind - who tweeted "it's a doozy"??

[Rage]

Someone who says he has a friend who works for Marvel (I think) but he has sworn secrecy on the issue... but he tweeted another guy (from Latino Review) who claimed to have a Marvel Scoop and asked if it was Cap... and if it was...wasn't it a doozy

something along those lines.

[Rage]

Someone who says he has a friend who works for Marvel (I think) but he has sworn secrecy on the issue... but he tweeted another guy (from Latino Review) who claimed to have a Marvel Scoop and asked if it was Cap... and if it was...wasn't it a doozy

something along those lines.

[flickchick85]

Someone who says he has a friend who works for Marvel (I think) but he has sworn secrecy on the issue... but he tweeted another guy (from Latino Review) who claimed to have a Marvel Scoop and asked if it was Cap... and if it was...wasn't it a doozy

something along those lines.
Oh, if it's the one I was talking about earlier, then the exact quote was:

"if you got the Cap's casting, I bet your happy. It's a pretty sweet choice! I've sworn not to run it."

I think the "doozy" thing could be a little misleading.

[ImWithTeamConan]

Back from class and...........no Cap news.

C'mon Latino Review just give us the rumor.

I need something.

The "sweet casting" comment makes it seem like someone no one has talked about yet will make everybody go "that's actually a good idea". Something along the lines of Ledger.

[Young Superman]

Back from class and...........no Cap news.

C'mon Latino Review just give us the rumor.

I need something.

The "sweet casting" comment makes it seem like someone no one has talked about yet will make everybody go "that's actually a good idea". Something along the lines of Ledger.

I'm thinking the same thing.

[Blackman]

I have a feeling that itll be Pine

[Majik1387]

It won't be Pine

[I Am Jack's...]

I have a feeling it'll be McPartlin :csad:

[Majik1387]

I'd be fine with McPartlin.

[ImWithTeamConan]

Out of sheer boredom I've tried to make up a list of people that weren't in the poll that might be interesting choices. These aren't guys I would want for Cap, but general "outside the box" choices that could be up for the part. That comment (assuming it is truthful) really makes it seem like its not an unknown.

Chris Evans
Ryan Gosling
Ben Foster
Emile Hirsch (NO)
Jake Gyllenhaal
Chris Pratt (comedic actor, I was kinda desperate for names)

[cerealkiller182]

Out of sheer boredom I've tried to make up a list of people that weren't in the poll that might be interesting choices. These aren't guys I would want for Cap, but general "outside the box" choices that could be up for the part. That comment (assuming it is truthful) really makes it seem like its not an unknown.

Chris Evans
Ryan Gosling
Ben Foster
Emile Hirsch (NO)
Jake Gyllenhaal
Chris Pratt (comedic actor, I was kinda desperate for names)

Chris Pratt is a really bad choice. If he were in the running, he would be in desperate need of a personal trainer. Although he does have the shorts for it
http://poponthepop.com/images/gallery/chris-pratt-is-anna-faris-husband_532x798.jpg

[Majik1387]

:barf:

[I Am Jack's...]

Out of sheer boredom I've tried to make up a list of people that weren't in the poll that might be interesting choices. These aren't guys I would want for Cap, but general "outside the box" choices that could be up for the part. That comment (assuming it is truthful) really makes it seem like its not an unknown.

Chris Evans
Ryan Gosling
Ben Foster
Emile Hirsch (NO)
Jake Gyllenhaal
Chris Pratt (comedic actor, I was kinda desperate for names)

If Evans wasn't already Human Torch, I think he'd be a decent Cap actually. He was great in Sunshine with the no-comedy role he had.

[flickchick85]

Yep, if he wasn't already Human Torch, Evans would probably be one of my top choices, actually. But alas, he is, so...oh well.

I'd be happy with McPartlin, too.

[ImWithTeamConan]

If Evans wasn't already Human Torch, I think he'd be a decent Cap actually. He was great in Sunshine with the no-comedy role he had.


Taking into account Reynolds is GL and Deadpool, and we have the same dude playing The Punisher and Volstagg, AND there will be a Fantastic Four reboot, I wouldn't mind Evans.

Thinking about it, I really wouldn't mind any of the following:
Chris Pine
Chris Evans
Garrett Hedlund

I guess you could actually put me in the anti-McPartlin camp. I like the show, but I don't see him as Cap. I liken him to Bomer/Superman from years ago. He looks like he could do it but I'd be much happier with someone else.

Knowing my luck (and the fact that McPartlin was at the Wolfman premiere) we'll get Awesome as Cap. :doh:

[BETArayBill]

Please never post that picture on the other page again please.

[Chewy]

Oh, if it's the one I was talking about earlier, then the exact quote was:

"if you got the Cap's casting, I bet your happy. It's a pretty sweet choice! I've sworn not to run it."

I think the "doozy" thing could be a little misleading.
Same guy, earlier tweet:

"I'm dying to spill the beans on the THE FIRST AVENGER: CAPTAIN AMERICA casting, but I promised to keep it under wraps. Its a doozy!"

http://twitter.com/Schofizzy/status/9150924709

[Blackman]

Pratt is hilarious on Parks and Recreation
but that picture made me cry

[Son of Coul]

I had tears of JOY.

[louiebling$]

Pratt is hilarious on Parks and Recreation
but that picture made me cry
He was hilarious on The O.C too

[flickchick85]

Same guy, earlier tweet:

"I'm dying to spill the beans on the THE FIRST AVENGER: CAPTAIN AMERICA casting, but I promised to keep it under wraps. Its a doozy!"

http://twitter.com/Schofizzy/status/9150924709
Ah, thanks. I missed that part. Hmmm...I wouldn't consider McPartlin "a doozy" so now I don't even have the slightest suspicion of who it might be. :(

[Triad]

Well there's also the chance that he really doesn't have any info, but still wants some attention too. Can't wait for the official announcement...could be any day now cuz Johnston said they have to have it locked down by March 1st. Damn anticipation!

[Rage]

Reminds me of the Superman Returns forums waiting for Singer to cast Superman back in the day :D

As far as a "doozy" goes. Who knows what this guy thinks. We have no idea what/who this guy considers a doozy... maybe he is a huge fan of Chuck... or The Fresh Prince of Bel Air ;)

[Rage]

"These double posts are making me thirsty!!"



Stupid double posts!

[Silvermoth]

Is there perhaps some sort of fan convention soon? They often like to reveal major casting announcements at comic-cons.

[louiebling$]

I think Wondercon is this weekend in San Fransisco

[Nirvana]

Oh man...if Cap is cast I hope they'll reveal him in the next few days. Hell, even the next few hours...

[Young Superman]

Mr Too.

[Webhead2006]

yea i am sure too they probably have their pick selected already and either its leaked out before marvel makes it official, or marvel makes its official. I agree if they have their pick selected its probably just getting all finalized and all that. I doubt we will see a huge name like pitt/damon/smith. Since its been stated via marvel and joe they are looking more for the unknown/semi known actor and build up rest of cast with more known folks like thor did. I am sure also its probably not going to be the kellan dude from twilight, or chris pine who i wouldnt mind. I do think its likely going to be someone like jensen ackles/ryan mcpartlin or others like them. Who has solid tv background and maybe a few films under their belts. like how pine was prior to trek.

[blinkuldhc]

it's too bad guys like mark valley, aaron eckhart, and thomas jane are too old.... they'd make better Caps than any of the guys being mentioned, IMO

[Lobo]

I'm 99% it will be Awesome as Cap America

[afrayedknot]

I'm 99% it will be Awesome as Cap America

If it's McPartlin, I'll be really disappointed. I mean, really? That's the best they could come up with? I just don't think he's proven himself a good enough actor, along with many other names thrown around on this forum. He just seems like more of a goofball or wiseguy than the leader of the Avengers. I think they should cast according to acting ability first, and looks second.

[blinkuldhc]

How are we so sure McPartlin can't act?

It's not like Chuck is really allowing McPartlin to explore his acting range. For **** sake his character is named Captain Awesome.... I don't think a Captain Awesome is ever going to win an Emmy.

How many movies did Christopher Reeve log under his belt before being cast as Superman?

I don't know how anyone can be "really disappointed" with anyone that Marvel casts. I think they deserve the benefit of the doubt... have any of their casting choices turned out to be "really disappointing" in other movies?

[blinkuldhc]

I'm one of the cool kids now!

[Lobo]

What makes you think they didn't? Maybe he lands the part and he knocks it out of the park. He auditioned, and maybe his was the best? I am guessing though. The **************.com article getting taken down so quickly is why I feel it will be McPartlin

[Project862006]

it was'nt taken down the guy accidentally deleted it

it is back up

http://www.**************.com/fansites/joshw24/news/?a=15032

[afrayedknot]

How are we so sure McPartlin can't act?

It's not like Chuck is really allowing McPartlin to explore his acting range. For **** sake his character is named Captain Awesome.... I don't think a Captain Awesome is ever going to win an Emmy.?

He's been in plenty of television roles. None of them memorable.

How many movies did Christopher Reeve log under his belt before being cast as Superman?

Christopher Reeve was a classically trained stage actor. Besides, if "Captain America" was a stand-alone film, I would have no problem with some of the suggestions. But, considering he will be leading the Avengers, I'd rather see someone with better acting creds.

I don't know how anyone can be "really disappointed" with anyone that Marvel casts. I think they deserve the benefit of the doubt... have any of their casting choices turned out to be "really disappointing" in other movies?

There's a first time for everything . . .

[Young Superman]

If Evans wasn't already Human Torch, I think he'd be a decent Cap actually. He was great in Sunshine with the no-comedy role he had.
I could see Evens as Cap, and as ImWithTeamConan said the FF is being rebooted so he probably won't be The Human Torch again.

[Brian Braddock]

Christopher Reeve was a classically trained stage actor who had been in plenty of television roles, none of them memorable, before he was cast as Superman.

Fiexed this for you.

:cwink:

Anyways, out of curiousity, just how much of McPartlin's work have you watched if you just think he's just a 'goofball or wiseguy'?

[afrayedknot]

Fiexed this for you.

:cwink:

I didn't think it needed fixing (or fiexing, as you put it :cwink:). I realize that Christopher Reeve was an unknown, more so than McPartlin. But, like I said, if it were a stand-alone film, I wouldn't be too disappointed if McPartlin, or some of the other suggestions, got the role.

Anyways, out of curiousity, just how much of McPartlin's work have you watched if you just think he's just a 'goofball or wiseguy'?

Like most people who have been suggesting him, I've seen him on "Chuck." But, I've also seen bits of "Super Capers" and some of his interviews. He hasn't been in any movies, and his other roles consist mainly of single episodes. And, I didn't say I thought he was a goofball or wiseguy. I said he seemed like one. He just comes across that way to me. I guess if I had an opportunity to see him in a more serious role, I'd have a different opinion.

[afan]

McPartlin sure looks and sounds the part. A little more bulk wouldn't hurt.

[flickchick85]

Like most people who have been suggesting him, I've seen him on "Chuck." But, I've also seen bits of "Super Capers" and some of his interviews. He hasn't been in any movies, and his other roles consist mainly of single episodes. And, I didn't say I thought he was a goofball or wiseguy. I said he seemed like one. He just comes across that way to me. I guess if I had an opportunity to see him in a more serious role, I'd have a different opinion.
To be honest, I used to have the same problem with McPartlin - I just felt I wouldn't be able to take him seriously, based on his work on Chuck. But then I saw his tiny appearance on Mad Men (so tiny his character didn't even have a name!) when I was re-watching S2, and while it certainly wasn't enough to convince anyone of range, it DID convince me that it was possible for me to take the guy seriously. He was Betty Draper's one-night stand in the S2 finale, and there was nothing funny about the role, as Betty was kind of a depressed mess at that point, and it was supposed to be in the midst of a national crisis (Cuban Missile Crisis), so the whole thing was pretty somber in tone. I had no clue that was him the first time I watched it, even though I was already a big fan of Chuck and there was nothing physically different about his appearance - he just seemed like a different person. But like I said, it certainly wasn't enough to prove anything to me except that it's possible for me to see the guy as something other than Captain Awesome or a goofball. From that point on, I decided to give him more of the benefit of the doubt. I really do think he may be a better actor than he's had a chance to prove yet just because he's so good at the comedic stuff.

[KangConquers]

I'm sure whoever gets the part read for it best. So I'm not worried.

[sdn]

I agree - actually, I think people tend to take comedic acting too lightly. I do acting, and I find comedic acting to be much more difficult than "dramatic" acting. You can see the same attitude displayed by the Acadamy Awards.

[Maze]

elmayimbe
Ryan McPartlin (Captain America candidate) was at the red carpet premiere of Wolfman. Coincidence?
8 minutes ago from Seesmic
About a week to go till we find out who is gonna be Captain America.
14 minutes ago from web

http://twitter.com/elmayimbe

[cas]

Good spot Maze, here's link to the pic of him at thee premier
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/gallery/gallery.jsp?slideShowId=296817#12

[flickchick85]

The guy who supposedly "knows" dropped this bombshell:

McPartlin is not the guy for Captain, but the guy who has been cast does hail from NBC!:huh: :huh: :huh:

AND this:
@DrewAtHitFix (http://twitter.com/DrewAtHitFix) Ha! Think I would roll over and die, if that was the case. Believe me, I would've never expected the choice, but its perfect!VERY interesting. Quick, someone make a rundown of NBC stars!

Was Crusoe on NBC? Cuz Philip Winchester fits the bill. Southland is formerly of NBC, but I doubt it's Ben McKenzie.

[BETArayBill]

God please don't be Zack levy he's great on chuck but not cap material.

[louiebling$]

So its a NBC Guy...... damn who the hell can it be?

[Chewy]

Crusoe was on NBC

[louiebling$]

O ****! Its Scott Porter(Friday Night Lights)!!

*Nerdgasm*

I'm ready to faint if its him cuz I have been pushing for hime since the very beggining!

[jab1118]

Take that Leno Conan is gonna be Captain America!!! Seriously though John Krazinski? I cant think of anyone on nbc who fits

[TikkiEXX]

The guy who supposedly "knows" dropped this bombshell:

:huh: :huh: :huh:

AND this:
VERY interesting. Quick, someone make a rundown of NBC stars!

Was Crusoe on NBC? Cuz Philip Winchester fits the bill. Southland is formerly of NBC, but I doubt it's Ben McKenzie.
aaaaargh! this is driving me nuts! crap im not gonna have internet access for a day or 2 to top it all off. hopefully by the time i get home it will be official. could it be someone from Heroes? i cant think of anyone from NBC that would fit the part. but i dont watch much NBC. man its starting to get good.

[BETArayBill]

O damn didn't think of Scott porter hopefully it'd him!

[Deaths Head II]

Scott Porter would be an awesome choice I think. Can't think of any other NBC guy that might fit the bill.

[TikkiEXX]

time to Google Scott Porter. lol

[flickchick85]

Yep, I'd put money on Scott Porter or Philip Winchester at this point. Both of which I'd be perfectly happy with (I'd prefer Winchester, though).

[Blackman]

Now Im feeling itll be Scott Porter which is good

[Chewy]

Hmm... Scott Porter

That could work

[I Am Jack's...]

Jesus!

Glad it's not McPartlin.

If it's actually Scott Porter, I'll be pretty satisfied. He fits the appearance, and, though I've only seen Season 1 of FNL, he seems to have a lot of potential.

Heroes is also on NBC, but I don't really see Cap in any of them at all.

Perhaps Joel McHale of Community? :woot:

I'm so excited! :wow:

[TikkiEXX]

time to Google Philip Winchester. lol