The Captain America Casting Thread

[Aesop Rocks]

Hype Members Converted to John Krasinski as Captain Ameirca:
WillardNation
HappyPalooza
Chewy
Da-Scribe
NightAvenger4
OB12
Parker Wayne
RachelDawes
JP
Colossal Spoons.

I'LL GET YOU, SPOONS! :argh:

[RachelDawes]

I wasn't pleased when I first heard that Krasinski was cast but the more I think of it the more I realize that he could possibly blow us away. I hope he can project a commanding presence.

[Parker Wayne]

Hype Members Converted to John Krasinski as Captain Ameirca:
WillardNation
HappyPalooza
Chewy
Da-Scribe
NightAvenger4
OB12
Parker Wayne
Colossal Spoons.

I'LL GET YOU, SPOONS! :argh:

Keeping a list for converters = win :yay:

[JP]

I have so much faith in Kraz, I really do.

I believe in John Krasinski for Captain America

[Aesop Rocks]

added you to the "list" :o

[JP]

Me? I was never a disbeliever! I wanted him since his name came up a couple days ago!

[Aesop Rocks]

Well you're a believer! That's all that matters! :o :oldrazz:

[Chewy]

That list will continue to grow and grow as people realize the potential of the Halpert

[KangConquers]

I love John...but still...no way.

[RetroNaz]

Having read all of this, it would be funny if The Halpert doesn't get the gig.

[Sawyer]

Rainn Wilson for Red Skull!!! :cool::up:

[Docker2.0]

Krasinski or Porter. Noone from Gossip Girl or Privaleged! :argh:

[Webhead2006]

i so want to hear the official word. if john does score the role, i am open to him. i am sure he will get in the right shape for the role, and he will probably do the role well. Marvel studios hasnt disapointed me yet.

[Aesop Rocks]

Having read all of this, it would be funny if The Halpert doesn't get the gig.

Eh, I won't cry myself to sleep or anything. But I just really like him compared to the rest of who we have to "deal" with.

[Parker Wayne]

Having read all of this, it would be funny if The Halpert doesn't get the gig.

Oh man that would suck at this point. I am actually excited for Krasinski.

Well I wouldn't mind if Scott Porter got the job.

[Mr. Todd]

Krasinski or Porter. Noone from Gossip Girl or Privaleged! :argh:

QFT. Cap should'nt be an uber pretty boy, but he should still definitely be good looking at the same time. And either of those choices fits the bill IMO.

Except I've fallen in love with the idea of JK as Cap now, even though nothings official.

[Chewy]

Twitter Guy seems pretty positive Krasinski has the gig, and Cinematical heard word that he is "all but certain to land the role" a day before his name came out as being on a shortlist.

[RetroNaz]

Eh, I won't cry myself to sleep or anything. But I just really like him compared to the rest of who we have to "deal" with.

I'm pretty much in the same boat as you.

I have the biggest confidence in the world with the people that cast the marvel flicks these days, so I'm sure it will be fine if not awesome!

[Majmun]

http://i50.tinypic.com/29nb6eg.jpg

[Mr. Todd]

Twitter Guy seems pretty positive Krasinski has the gig, and Cinematical heard word that he is "all but certain to land the role" a day before his name came out as being on a shortlist.

Can we trust him? :brucebat:

And here's another pic that's 1940s-ish for the non JK believers. Sorry it it's been posted:

http://img189.imageshack.us/img189/4662/1993362119933628large.jpg

[Wolfwood]

It'd be interesting to see Halpert bulk up a bit....I'm down for the casting choice.

[flickchick85]

Eh, I won't cry myself to sleep or anything. But I just really like him compared to the rest of who we have to "deal" with.
This is me as well. He's not suddenly my #1 choice, and he's far from the ideal Cap, imo, but I just like him better than anyone else on that list.

[Docker2.0]

Me to Mr. Todd even though JK looks nothing like Cap. Either him or Porter is a win. But..............JJ is unpredictable and we might get a Chase Crawford for Cap which would suck more than a hooker at a hot dog eating contest.

[Aesop Rocks]

Hype Members Converted to John Krasinski as Captain Ameirca:
WillardNation
HappyPalooza
Chewy
Da-Scribe
NightAvenger4
OB12
Parker Wayne
RachelDawes
JP
RetroNaz
Docker2.0
Colossal Spoons.

I'LL GET YOU, SPOONS! :argh:

[Rock Sexton]

Can we trust him? :brucebat:

And here's another pic that's 1940s-ish for the non JK believers. Sorry it it's been posted:

http://img189.imageshack.us/img189/4662/1993362119933628large.jpg

He's a dumbo. Resembles absolutely nothing close to Cap. Sure he fits in as a 1940's guy .....but they're not casting a movie called "1940's Guy" ..... Rogers never had semitic features.

Not a shred a resemblance to this.......

http://www.fusedfilm.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/x-captain-america-cc1.jpg

[Mr. Todd]

Me to Mr. Todd even though JK looks nothing like Cap. Either him or Porter is a win. But..............JJ is unpredictable and we might get a Chase Crawford for Cap which would suck more than a hooker at a hot dog eating contest.

I have no idea how good of an actor Chase Crawford is, but I think he's a little too pretty. Not quite believable, IMO, as a 1940s era WWII soldier.

But if he gets the role and is, in fact, a good actor, I'm sure it'd be fine.

[Aesop Rocks]

He's a dumbo. Resembles absolutely nothing close to Cap. Sure he fits in as a 1940's guy .....but they're not casting a movie called "1940's Guy" ..... Rogers never had semitic features.

Not a shred a resemblance to this.......

http://www.fusedfilm.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/x-captain-america-cc1.jpg

You're probably the guy in the comics that rejected Steve Rogers from the military. :o

[Project862006]

starting to like him but his ears are so damn big lol

[Aesop Rocks]

Dear "He Has To Look The Part" people, I present to you, your demise.

http://i47.tinypic.com/2z8buj6.jpg

[bunk]

They can do better than JK. He doesn't look much like how Steve Rogers is typically portrayed, and he hasn't displayed any above average acting talent, so I don't see the point.

[Mr. Todd]

He's a dumbo. Resembles absolutely nothing close to Cap. Sure he fits in as a 1940's guy .....but they're not casting a movie called "1940's Guy" ..... Rogers never had semitic features.

Not a shred a resemblance to this.......

http://www.fusedfilm.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/x-captain-america-cc1.jpg

Ok, maybe I didn't choose the greatest picture. But...

http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/9092/tn2johnkrasinski4.jpg
http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/7637/johnpeople.jpg
http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/9548/tumblrkvr9png50t1qa2x7v.jpg

[JP]

I like JK because I think he DOES look the part. :huh:

[Dr. Sid Jawtug]

Ok, maybe I didn't choose the greatest picture. But...

http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/9092/tn2johnkrasinski4.jpg
http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/7637/johnpeople.jpg
http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/9548/tumblrkvr9png50t1qa2x7v.jpg

Ugh

[I Am Jack's...]

I just realized the sheer magnitude of people who are going to put "I believe in John Krasinski for Captain America" and "I don't believe in John Krasinski for Captain America" if he is cast. Look, it's already started! :wow:

I too started out with a :barf: when I first saw him on the list, but I've sort of come around and turned more :cool: as I thought about it. He's still not anywhere near my top choice, but I'd give him a shot if he does get chosen.

[captaintass]

Ugh

Hear, hear! Wow...so Cap may be a jug-eared, wide-nosed guy?

Screw it, let's just cast Martin Short as the Red Skull while we're at it.

[KangConquers]

I'm going to see Cap regardless of who is cast...but I definitely have my opinions.

[Lobo]

I'm sure my boy Bling$ is going nuts with Scott Porter in consideration.

My top two and they're tied for me are

Scott Porter and Mike Vogel

And as for Chace Crawford, I always so potential in him and he was my Nightwing choice, but he could be Bucky Barnes ;).

[Rock Sexton]

They can do better than JK. He doesn't look much like how Steve Rogers is typically portrayed, and he hasn't displayed any above average acting talent, so I don't see the point.

Ya, I don't get the boastful compliments about his acting. He's soft. He doesn't command the screen with authority, neither does his voice.

[RetroNaz]

The last time this kind of casting buzz happened, most people ended up with egg on their face. (Ledger as the Joker).

Keep it in mind folks, these guys do know what they're doing.

[Docker2.0]

Man I hope Porter gets it. Just that quickly I'm off the JK bandwagon. The guy looks nothing like Cap.

[Rock Sexton]

The last time this kind of casting buzz happened, most people ended up with egg on their face. (Ledger as the Joker).

Keep it in mind folks, these guys do know what they're doing.

Retro,

In all fairness that is such an over-generalized blanket statement. I've seen plenty of miscasts with important characters in Hollywood. I pointed out Hayden Christiansen as Anakin Skywalker earlier today.

[flickchick85]

Ew, Krasinski is NOT Hayden Christensen. He can speak properly for one.

[louiebling$]

I'm sure my boy Bling$ is going nuts with Scott Porter in consideration.

My top two and they're tied for me are

Scott Porter and Mike Vogel

And as for Chace Crawford, I always so potential in him and he was my Nightwing choice, but he could be Bucky Barnes ;).
O Yea I went Nuts lol


Had a Geekasm :o

[Lobo]

I'll agree with that.

Porter or Vogel all the way! I'm starting to lean more towards Porter.

[Lobo]

O Yea I went Nuts lol


Had a Geekasm :o

It's going in my sig Porter for Cap!

[RetroNaz]

Retro,

In all fairness that is such an over-generalized blanket statement. I've seen plenty of miscasts with important characters in Hollywood. I pointed out Hayden Christiansen as Anakin Skywalker earlier today.

True, it was. But I'm keeping it in the context of comic book films...which have generally been pretty good as of late with casting.

I'm just saying it's advisable to keep an open mind when it comes to these things. Not having a go at anyone for having an opinion though.

[Rock Sexton]

True, it was. But I'm keeping it in the context of comic book films...which have generally been pretty good as of late with casting.

I'm just saying it's advisable to keep an open mind when it comes to these things. Not having a go at anyone for having an opinion though.

Ben Affleck as DD

Thomas Jane as The Punisher in '04 ......

They were both awful.

Who do we really have to go off of besides Edward Norton and RDJ in more recent times? I mean those are two top flight actors. Doesn't take a genius to sign those guys up. The jury is still out on Hemsworth, but it is pretty clear they were going for the "hunk" factor with that one.

[louiebling$]

It's going in my sig Porter for Cap!
Yay we will be Sig Buddies :highfive:

[samsnee]

I can and I can't see JK in the role. I think in terms of personality, he'll be a nice contrast to RDJ whenever Avengers gets made. You don't want two cocky superheroes running around, and as others have said, JK has an everyman quality. At the same time, he needs to have the believability that he is a leader, which he doesn't have right now based on his past work. In terms of look, he does need to bulk up a bit.

[Aesop Rocks]

Yay we will be Sig Buddies :highfive:

You're making me cry. :csad:

[RetroNaz]

Ben Affleck as DD

Thomas Jane as The Punisher in '04 ......

They were both awful.

Who do we really have to go off of besides Edward Norton and RDJ in more recent times? I mean those are two top flight actors. Doesn't take a genius to sign those guys up. The jury is still out on Hemsworth, but it is pretty clear they were going for the "hunk" factor with that one.

Thomas Jane was fine as the Punisher I thought. The script and direction were what let that thing down.

Ben Afleck...well I'll never defend that guy.

You could also add half of the Fantastic Four cast to that list too IMO.

I'm simply going off the two choices you highlighted, under the new marvel regime. I'm not even saying JK is the perfect choice, simply to keep the mind open to the idea he MIGHT be the official pick. And if you recall, there were a LOT of people that were against RDJ when he was first being considered.

[Silvermoth]

Did anyone watch the "30 rock" episode where they talked about the Hornberger method? Basically it's when you're asked to choose about four or five actors for the executives to look at but you really want one of them to get it. Basically the idea is that you surrond one possible actor choice with a couple of bad choices in order to make sure your favourite gets the part.

I can't help but think Marvel is using the Hornberger method so that someone like Scott Porter gets the job and John Krasinski and Chace Crawford to make him look good.

[RetroNaz]

Did anyone watch the "30 rock" episode where they talked about the Hornberger method? Basically it's when you're asked to choose about four or five actors for the executives to look at but you really want one of them to get it. Basically the idea is that you surrond one possible actor choice with a couple of bad choices in order to make sure your favourite gets the part.

I can't help but think Marvel is using the Hornberger method so that someone like Scott Porter gets the job and John Krasinski and Chace Crawford to make him look good.

lol I remember that! And it's possible.

Good to see another Aussie too mate :up:

[That-Guy]

I really, really can't see Krasinski or Crawford in the role, so I hope that this Hornberger theory is what's happening.

Ironically, the one guy they mentioned in that article that I would be pulling for (Hedlund) is the one who apparently has no shot at getting it anymore.

[The Squirrel]

John Krasinski can not be a serious consideration. I refuse to believe that.

[Lobo]

Yay we will be Sig Buddies :highfive:

:highfive:

Now where is it in your sig? :cmad: :oldrazz:

[That-Guy]

John Krasinski can not be a serious consideration. I refuse to believe that.

Gld to know that I'm not the only one who sees it this way.

[Majik1387]

John Krasinski can not be a serious consideration. I refuse to believe that.

Gld to know that I'm not the only one who sees it this way.
Totally agree

[louiebling$]

You're making me cry. :csad:
Hey I'm down with JK... no hate but I've been Gunning for Porter since day one and I'm still gunning for him.

[JP]

Hey I'm down with JK... no hate but I've been Gunning for Porter since day one and I'm still gunning for him.
I think Scott Porter is a terrible choice for Cap though. :csad:

[Deaths Head II]

I think I'm moving to the JK side.

It's just so crazy it might work.

[Webhead2006]

another thing to remember most of us are probably basing our like/dislike on john as his current look of right now. But if he is picked we dont know how he will sound, or look as cap once he bulks up and has hair colored/cut/etc... and how he will be in costume and all that.

[danger]

For some reason, people are thinking Jim Halpert is the one that's up for the role.

[That-Guy]

another thing to remember most of us are probably basing our like/dislike on john as his current look of right now. But if he is picked we dont know how he will sound, or look as cap once he bulks up and has hair colored/cut/etc... and how he will be in costume and all that.

You're being far too optimistic! We need more pessimism, pronto! This movie is going to suck, I tell you! SUUUUUCK!!!! :hehe:

[Webhead2006]

well lets just wait to we have the official call, then who will be the supporting cast, then how said cap actor will actually look. Sure i am optimististic cause i am hoping for the best. So far i havent been disapointed by marvel studios films.

[KangConquers]

I have serious doubts about this movie heh. None of these choices are hitting me...which is sad cause Cap is my favorite superhero.

[Compi716]

I wonder if Marvel's pretty low offer has anything to do with casting. Though, as stated in the Deadline article, JK would get more than $300K.

[JP]

You know, Zac Efron only got $100k for Hairspray.

[Lobo]

I think Scott Porter is a terrible choice for Cap though. :csad:

Well, then you have to stop thinking that :oldrazz:

[louiebling$]

Well, then you have to stop thinking that :oldrazz:
:lmao:

Yea what Lob said

[hugekent]

Any hope that it won't be Krasinski? I'm trying my best but I just can't see his big doofy head as Captain America.

[ImWithTeamConan]

Krasinski as Captain America, leading the Avengers: Iron Man (RDJ), War Machine (Don Cheadle), Thor (Chris Hemsworth) with SHIELD agents Clint Barton (Jeremy Renner, if the rumors are correct), Black Widow (Scarlett) and SHIELD head Nick Fury (Sam F'n Jackson) as backup against a Loki (can't remember his name but he'll be awesome) controlled Hulk (Edward Norton).


SIGN ME UP TODAY!

[blinkuldhc]

Here's the thing...

Whoever it is, Johston loves the casting. Marvel loves it. The producers love it. Everyone involved with the movie loves it.

They must all be seeing something that the fanboy detractors don't see, and that's probably why they're the ones making money for making these decisions, and why we are behind the computer saying John Krasinski is not good looking.

Marvel & Co. has either made and/or significantly contributed to a good number of high quality comic book movies in the last decade or so. We are just taking it for granted. I think they've earned the benefit of the doubt by now...!!

[Majik1387]

Eh, if JK is anywhere near being cast as CA, consider me on Red Skull's team.:o

[Webhead2006]

well i doubt the pay is much of an issue. we known for awhile they were not going to go with a huge A lister and go with a more unknown actor. Now say for example any of the tv actors most i believe usually get 100-300k deals per episode/season (more so if its a long running show like a friends(they got 1mill per episode near the end)). So that is probably not much of an issue. The deadline is probably not much of an issue as we known in the past few weeks they have been nailed down to a bunch of folks most were probably one the list we got yesterday. So its probably been an ongoing process for awhile.

[flickchick85]

Whenever they make it official, whoever it turns out to be, I can't wait for the first joint photo shoot with the actors from the other movies, so we can at least see all the main Avengers actors together in one room. Just one picture from that shoot would probably be enough to make my inner-geek die of happiness.

[Wolvieboy17]

I'm really intrigued by the idea of Krasinski as Cap. It just seems like such unusual casting. I'd much prefer they choose him instead of some of the others who, lets be honest, are essentially just safe options, nothing special. They're just attractive, athletic blondes who could look the part, but Krasinski as a suggestion, makes me think that they're looking at other, more interesting qualities for Steve Rogers character. I think while some of the others may look like Cap, I could see Krasinksi looking great as Steve Rogers (if you know what I mean.)

[RetroNaz]

I'm really intrigued by the idea of Krasinski as Cap. It just seems like such unusual casting. I'd much prefer they choose him instead of some of the others who, lets be honest, are essentially just safe options, nothing special. They're just attractive, athletic blondes who could look the part, but Krasinski as a suggestion, makes me think that they're looking at other, more interesting qualities for Steve Rogers character. I think while some of the others may look like Cap, I could see Krasinksi looking great as Steve Rogers (if you know what I mean.)

:up:

[richardmvela]

Ok, here's an idea. I'm not happy with Krasinski being Cap at all. So I figure this would be a good way to picture it..

This is a clip from 300 where Leonidas has just been cut on his eye but picks up his helmet and turns around with the Spartans behind him. Now imagine this is Cap and those are the Avengers, replace Leonidas with Krasinski....yeah doesn't fit IMO. Now put Ackles in there and let him yell Avenger's Assemble and yeah you have your Captain America.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f6HkW-kGZQk&feature=related#t=5m43s

[Rage]

For the record.... I am not opposed to JK. If he were cast... I could get behind that. There are alot of qualities that he can bring to the role... and they should have no problem getting his ears to stick out of the mask/helmet. I think that the idea is just crazy enough to work. I do have a bit of a problem with his height (almost too tall) but they could easily lift Thor a bit and Cap does need to be taller than both RDJ and Norton.

He has a wide shoulder base to build on and a decent chin... he just needs to cut some body fat and put on some muscle. I would assume that they would use another actor and Benjamin Button JK's face onto that actor (ideally) for the PRE SSS version of Steve Rogers.

That being said... of all those listed, I still hope that either Porter or Hedlund get the role (I LOVE FRIDAY NIGHT LIGHTS OKAY!!) I just think that this news and the acceptance of the news is too easily swallowed at this point and I just think that something is going to happen (like Hedlund and Marvel agreeing on Money like Jackson and Rourke eventually did)

If this movie moves forward with JK... I'll get on board because I trust what Marvel Studios has been doing. If someone else is cast, I will probably get behind them too. I just have a hard time with Mike Vogel (height) and those other Pretty actors. Porter never really came across to me as pretty and Hedlund has proven that he can bulk up and play troubled characters (FNL he put on 30 lbs of muscle to play the FB)

I am officially on the fence. I got burnt on Skarsgard/Hemsworth and I don't want to put myself out there and have my hopes dashed again :D

[Lobo]

Krasinski is not Cap, at least not yet. We also know the other fianlists of which Ackles is not included. So, I'd recommend choosing your favorite of Scott Porter, Mike Vogel, Michael Cassidy, and Patrick Flueger

[flickchick85]

Ok, here's an idea. I'm not happy with Krasinski being Cap at all. So I figure this would be a good way to picture it..

This is a clip from 300 where Leonidas has just been cut on his eye but picks up his helmet and turns around with the Spartans behind him. Now imagine this is Cap and those are the Avengers, replace Leonidas with Krasinski....yeah doesn't fit IMO. Now put Ackles in there and let him yell Avenger's Assemble and yeah you have your Captain America.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f6HkW-kGZQk&feature=related#t=5m43s
Yeah...that little experiment doesn't really work for Ackles any better than Krasinski. And Steve Rogers and Leonidas are completely different characters who require a completely different type of presence, imo, so the comparison is pretty pointless. Not all "leader" types are the same - here, we're talking a young outsider who becomes a leader as the story progresses. Leonidas was an established (older) king of a ruthless culture of elite warriors. Apples and oranges.

[Rage]

I lean toward Porter because the dude is actually a comic fan and a fan of Captain America. The guy has played a troubled character with a disability in FNL and was Really REALLY convincing.

Maybe I can do a manip... my Zach Levi one started making believers out of him and he's almost as crazy an idea as JK ;P

[flickchick85]

If it's someone other than Krasinski on that list, I'd be fine with Porter or Vogel. I'd just be less excited about their potential dynamic with the Avengers, because they really do seem like kids/boys to me when compared to the others (even Hemsworth, who's actually younger). RDJ and Krasinski, on the other hand, could be golden together, imo.

But there's still a big part of me that's hoping it'll be a left-field choice NOT on the list, though. Because that list is kinda sad.

[Jake Cassidy]

I'm sad that the 2 best choices imo, Ackles and Hedlund, can't do it. :csad:

Now I'm hoping for Porter.

[RetroNaz]

I'm still bummed that Pine is out of the running. I wonder if they just couldn't match his asking salary.

[TheFuture]

And Ive seen Porter, Hedlund, and Vogel act. And Im sure they can do beyond a good job.

The key difference is that I've seen Pine actually do a role that in some ways is very similar to Captain America. That's what sets Pine a part from the pretty boys you mentioned. :cwink:

[Project862006]

Heatvision updated there article and now added Wilson Bethel(Generation Kill) to the list

http://cache3.asset-cache.net/xc/90898675.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=77BFBA49EF878921CC759DF4EBAC47D02126371140A9DD55 697CBC9E9BDAFE09862C36D0E0119CF9E30A760B0D811297

[RetroNaz]

lol thought he was familiar, he's also on the Young and the Restless.

No...I don't watch the show intentionally! ;)

[Dave40]

Im keeping my fingers crossed that Krasinski doesnt get it

Me too!!.He is a horrible choice :doh:.

[The Kryptonian]

I'd rather kill myself than rely on Krasinski to lead The Avengers. I don't know if there's some kind of virus affecting everyone's brains, because this Krasinski as Captain America thing is a joke. Seriously, can you really picture his head on Cap's body? We had the likes of Ryan McPartlin, Jensen Ackles and Robert Buckley all in contention, and this is the best they can do? Marvel is lost to me.

I like the guy, but him testing for one of the most important roles in comic movie history is most disturbing. What happened to the 23-32 actor range? Was Johnston lying the whole time or what? Everyone on this list for contention is very disappointing. Most were fan suggestions, and horrible ones at that, and now they're testing for the role?

My faith and interest in this movie has officially died. How dare Marvel do this to one of it's most devoted fans of Captain America.

[RetroNaz]

It's not official yet mate, so there's no sense in jumping the hate wagon just yet.

[drax]

Heatvision updated there article and now added Wilson Bethel(Generation Kill) to the list

http://cache3.asset-cache.net/xc/90898675.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=77BFBA49EF878921CC759DF4EBAC47D02126371140A9DD55 697CBC9E9BDAFE09862C36D0E0119CF9E30A760B0D811297

For the moment imo the best choice, I'm not really happy with these names, specially with John Krasinski, I don't hate him, but he don't really look like the blonde blue eyes hero like Steve Roger.

So wait and see, don't forget that we don't have the complete actors list, it's just some fews name, Johnson have already said that they want somebody not very well know for the role, so there are a big chance that Krasinski don't have the role.

[That person]

I'm still somewhat skeptical. I am happy that Hedlund is in consideration, and I'm not totally convinced he's out of the running, given that we're dealing with internet rumors. That being said, internet rumors pegged Hemsworth before Marvel announced it, so it wouldn't suprise me if it does wind up being JK. If that is the case, I can see why he would be desirable, and I would support him, as Marvel seems to know what they're doing based on what we've seen in the past.

[ultimatefan]

John Krasinski seems entirely wrong for the part IMO - imagine Cap doing a speech about the importance of ideals with that cynical, bratty kid attitude Krasinski plays in TO -, not to mention he´s not an unknown. Can´t comment on the others.

[tallsy_1]

I'm not saying that I've lost faith. But if Krasinski is cast it's going to need good buzz for me.

I wouldn't mind Bethel, Porter, or Vogel. Or some of the other unknown names.

Of course, now every agent in Hollywood is leaking that their client auditioned for the role to gin up interest for other parts.

[Young Superman]

Dude Vogel's only 5'10"

[Brian Braddock]

I'm definately not a Krasinski/Cap advocate; but if he was cast, my interest in the movie wouldnt wane in the slightest as I'm a Cap fan, 1st and foremost.

I am curious as to this '1940's look' that everyone bangs on about though.

Surely anyone who's hair is styled the way it was in that era and dressed in clothes of that time would have a '1940's' look to them. Just what is it about someones face in the 1940's that is so different a face of today?

[Blackman]

^^ and?@ Young Superman
also the 300k pay us messed up if true. Even Routh got 1 mill for SR plus percentage of profits

[ultimatefan]

I'm definately not a Krasinski/Cap advocate; but if he was cast, my interest in the movie wouldnt wane in the slightest as I'm a Cap fan, 1st and foremost.

I am curious as to this '1940's look' that everyone bangs on about though.

Surely anyone who's hair is styled the way it was in that era and dressed in clothes of that time would have a '1940's' look to them. Just what is it about someones face in the 1940's that is so different a face of today?

The square jaw, classic masculine type was more common, or at least was more used in movies and TV, as opposed to the current obsession with boyish metrossexual types.

[Blackman]

I'm definately not a Krasinski/Cap advocate; but if he was cast, my interest in the movie wouldnt wane in the slightest as I'm a Cap fan, 1st and foremost.

I am curious as to this '1940's look' that everyone bangs on about though.

Surely anyone who's hair is styled the way it was in that era and dressed in clothes of that time would have a '1940's' look to them. Just what is it about someones face in the 1940's that is so different a face of today?

On 1940s look: I think most actors could pull it off. People I think are singling Krasinski out because hes not a "pretty boy"

[Maze]

One important point imo is there

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/z0D07dQ018o&hl=fr_FR&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/z0D07dQ018o&hl=fr_FR&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>

Krasinski imo has a commanding presence, naturally.

[Project862006]

I hope it is Hedlund but the 300,000 mark should not be for him he is the biggest name on the list.You know with working with Kevin Bacon/Brad Pitt/John Goodman/Mark Whalberg/Eric Bana/ in his past film.Also not to mention he is the Star Of TRON:Legacy and his upcoming films has him working with Stanley Tucci/Gwenyth Paltrow/Jeff Bridges/so i think he should get more money if he is considered.

[JP]

One important point imo is there

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/z0D07dQ018o&hl=fr_FR&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/z0D07dQ018o&hl=fr_FR&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>

Krasinski imo has a commanding presence, naturally.
He's just perfect.

[JP]

My problem with Garrett Hedlund, Scott Porter, and the others is that they all look like boys. Cap is a man.

[Project862006]

I still cant shake his Goofiness it is like casting Jason Segel as the Flash

[DocHoliday]

I hope it is Hedlund but the 300,000 mark should not be for him he is the biggest name on the list.You know with working with Kevin Bacon/Brad Pitt/John Goodman/Mark Whalberg/Eric Bana/ in his past film.Also not to mention he is the Star Of TRON:Legacy and his upcoming films has him working with Stanley Tucci/Gwenyth Paltrow/Jeff Bridges/so i think he should get more money if he is considered.

I'd argue that until Tron is released that Krasinski is. He was barely in Troy while JK played a lead opposite George Clooney and on one of the most acclaimed series on Television.

[Project862006]

My problem with Garrett Hedlund, Scott Porter, and the others is that they all look like boys. Cap is a man.

look like boys WTF maybe the other guys from CW do but not those 2

Krasinski looks like a goofball i cant take him serious

[craigdbfan]

One important point imo is there

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/z0D07dQ018o&hl=fr_FR&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/z0D07dQ018o&hl=fr_FR&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>

Krasinski imo has a commanding presence, naturally.

Just keep picturing how well Downey and Krasinski could play off each other (via improvising) in The Avengers.

He's tall, strong voice and most important of all just a Steve Roger/Cap swagger. That's what Marvel may be looking for based on their winning formula Iron Man. To find a lead actor with natural charisma and charm without the need of a model face. Just like Downey, Krasinski is no stranger to witty improv.

http://onemoreoption.files.wordpress.com/2007/08/captain-america-michell-breitweiser.jpg

Some hate this Cap iteration but I can defintely see Krasinski there.

[JP]

look like boys WTF maybe the other guys from CW do but not those 2

Krasinski looks like a goofball i cant take him serious
ESPECIALLY those two. :huh:

[DocHoliday]

ESPECIALLY those two. :huh:

Garret Hedlund looks like a surfer guy. They ever remake Point Break he could play Bodhi.

[Project862006]

so you prefer krasinski with his huge nose gigantic ears and all around goof ball face

Not to mention he looks absolutely nothing like steve rogers i can understand not being exactly like your character.But hell there has to be a point where you have to resemble the character a little bit.

[DocHoliday]

so you prefer krasinski with his huge nose gigantic ears and all around goof ball face

Not to mention he looks absolutely nothing like steve rogers i can understand not being exactly like your character.But hell there has to be a point where you have to resemble the character a little bit.

Tall, all-American and most important a great actor. Check, check done. All that matters to me.

[Project862006]

so is will smith and brad pitt it is like you people have never seen a picture of steve rogers lol

[JP]

so you prefer krasinski with his huge nose gigantic ears and all around goof ball face

Not to mention he looks absolutely nothing like steve rogers i can understand not being exactly like your character.But hell there has to be a point where you have to resemble the character a little bit.
I think he has the perfect look for Cap.

[DocHoliday]

so is will smith and brad pitt it is like you people have never seen a picture of steve rogers lol

Oh I agree but they are too old. Brad Pitt would have been perfectly fine 15 years ago. I have seen comics bro. The only thing I don't simply look to the physical qualities of characters. Roy Scheider *is* Chief Bordy, yet Brody was a fat man in the novel Jaws. Even so he still embodies the qualities that make the character great.

[craigdbfan]

so is will smith and brad pitt it is like you people have never seen a picture of steve rogers lol

It's like you've never seen a different opinion.

[Project862006]

it is hard to take some opinions serious with all the cap bandwagon jumpers when people jumped on a different actor each time they were rumored and saying they are perfect.

1 week it was all pine
next week it was all ackles
next week it was all mcpartlin
etc.

[craigdbfan]

it is hard to take some opinions serious with all the cap bandwagon jumpers when people jumped on a different actor each time they were rumored and saying they are perfect.

1 week it was all pine
next week it was all ackles
next week it was all mcpartlin
etc.

I for one didn't want any of the people you mention. In fact I'm against almost every single suggestion in this thread.

Pine I haven't though about since Captain America was first announced.

Out of all the names thrown out there Krasinski has defintely come across as the most intriguing but is becoming clear if he is on top of Marvel's shortlist due to his personality, acting and presence despite your dislike for his facial features.

You want the traditional chiseled Anglo features for Captain America. Who says he can't be played by an American actor who happens to be Jewish?

Not only that but Krasinski fits the bill of the NBC pick that Marvel made which will defintely seem like a head scratcher for some.

[DocHoliday]

Yeah I said that Pine would do good (and he would have) but... almost two years ago Is aid John Krasinski would be an interesting choice. I can also say with certainty I have never been on the McPartlin/Hedlund/Ackles band wagon.

[NIGHTSWING]

I don't know about the rest of you guys, but am kind of lost! As soon as the short list hit yesterday, Twitter guy comes out clean and states JK has it? Other sites are just posting the short list like even the Hype did. So I guess my question is if John Krasinski has been cast per Twitter guy's inside soucre. Then why did the story break yesterday of the short list and screen testing just starting this week? Are we getting news that is days old or even weeks? I know for a fact the last time JJ's note about his so called short list broke a couple of weeks agao dozen more guys read for the part that week. Also, who was the guy that said Pine was on the short list? Cause now his name is gone. I love this game, but I really want the real name to be given to us soon.

[DocHoliday]

I don't know about the rest of you guys, but am kind of lost! As soon as the short list hit yesterday, Twitter guy comes out clean and states JK has it? Other sites are just posting the short list like even the Hype did. So I guess my question is if John Krasinski has been cast per Twitter guy's inside soucre. Then why did the story break yesterday of the short list and screen testing just starting this week? Are we getting news that is days old or even weeks? I know for a fact the last time JJ's note about his so called short list broke a couple of weeks agao dozen more guys read for the part that week. Also, who was the guy that said Pine was on the short list? Cause now his name is gone. I love this game, but I really want the real name to be given to us soon.

cinematical reported that the screen test is nothing more than a formality. In other words JK is their man...according to twitter guy/cinematical.

[Project862006]

i am waiting for March 1st because i think we all remember this article a week before Thor was cast

http://www.latinoreview.com/news/is-kenneth-branagh-close-to-choosing-his-thor-6337

[OB12]

I think people are definitely jumping on the JK bandwagon. It is only natural because he is such an unconventional choice that most people automatically dismiss it out of hand and then after thinking about it a while people begin to see his potential. When people say that they can't see him leading a team, I don't really understand that. If you watch his character on the Office, he really is the leader of that office. Amidst all of the craziness that happens he is usually the voice of reason, usually trying to steer Michael in the right direction as he is delving into some sort of chaos.

I think most would get behind other actors but JK has the potential to really do something special with the role. The way I see it, some of the names that have popped up recently have been good and some not so good.

Pine - Way overhyped and too busy, not a fan of him for Cap at all
Ackles - I like him but he seems to have a little too much attitude for Cap
McPartlin - Great look but also a little bland, I could support him though
Buckley - Great physical condition and face has character, but his acting is suspect
Porter - Has a very generic look, could be good but nothing stands out about him
Hedlund - Someone said it before, he is effeminate looking, not a fan of him for Cap
Crawford, Vogel, Cassidy, et al - Just pretty faces with no real screen presence

[Maze]

Just keep picturing how well Downey and Krasinski could play off each other (via improvising) in The Avengers.

He's tall, strong voice and most important of all just a Steve Roger/Cap swagger. That's what Marvel may be looking for based on their winning formula Iron Man. To find a lead actor with natural charisma and charm without the need of a model face. Just like Downey, Krasinski is no stranger to witty improv.

http://onemoreoption.files.wordpress.com/2007/08/captain-america-michell-breitweiser.jpg

Some hate this Cap iteration but I can defintely see Krasinski there.

Ditto, i keep imagining how well he could have chemistry with Downey.

As for jumping on the bandwagon, i came to this thread days ago having heard that cap would be cast soon. Two rumored actors seemed interesting for me: Pine and Krasinsky. (Porter would be an ok choice imo.. now, again a Porter/ Cap standing against Downey Jr/Stark? can't see it, Porter is not so mature yet)

[NIGHTSWING]

i am waiting for March 1st because i think we all remember this article a week before Thor was cast

http://www.latinoreview.com/news/is-kenneth-branagh-close-to-choosing-his-thor-6337


Very good point!

[SpiderByte]

Ackles is a good actor, but his voice wouldn't work for Cap. That's the only reason I don't think he would be a good Cap. He would play the part great, but his voice wouldn't quite be Cap.

[mjdiddy1]

From CBR
John Krasinski [Art by Bryan Hitch]

http://www.comicbookresources.com/assets/phpThumb/phpThumb.php?src=/assets/images/articles/1267045322.jpg&h=200 (http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?disp=img&pid=1267045322)

Best known for playing the scruffy everyman romancer Jim Halpert on NBC's hit sitcom "The Office," Krasinski is perhaps the most recognizable name in the running thanks to that series success as well as his own turns as leading man for smaller comedy films (http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=24973#) like "License To Wed" and "Away We Go." But will those successes easily translate to a widescreen action movie hero?
Patrick Flueger [Art by Marcos Martin]

http://www.comicbookresources.com/assets/phpThumb/phpThumb.php?src=/assets/images/articles/1267045711.jpg&h=200 (http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?disp=img&pid=1267045711)

Flueger's biggest role came with the USA Network's sci-fi ensemble "The 4400" where over the course of four seasons he took the character of Shawn Farrell from uncertain teenager to power suit-wearing religious leader. Whether or not those skills mean he'll land a chance of taking Steve Rogers from scrawny enlistee to super solider is hard to say.
Chase Crawford [Art by Ron Garney]

http://www.comicbookresources.com/assets/phpThumb/phpThumb.php?src=/assets/images/articles/1267046134.jpg&h=200 (http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?disp=img&pid=1267046134)

The dreamy "Gossip Girl" star certainly is a hit with teenager viewers of the CW drama, but the real test to see if Crawford can provide a little box office boost will come next year when he takes Kevin Bacon's role in the remake of "Footloose." And as THR pointed out, at this point the actor (http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=24973#) is in talks to screen test, though his rolling with Rogers lines in his mouth is not a done deal.
Scott Porter [Art by Tim Sale]

http://www.comicbookresources.com/assets/phpThumb/phpThumb.php?src=/assets/images/articles/1267046373.jpg&h=200 (http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?disp=img&pid=1267046373)

Porter's inclusion on this list should come as no shocker to comic aficionados. The "Friday Night Lights" actor is a card-carrying member of the fanboy nation, attending plenty of comics conventions and often speaking of his desire to play superhero parts including citing Steve Rogers as a particular interest. Though wanting a part and getting one are two very different things.
Mike Vogel [Art by Olivier Coipel]

http://www.comicbookresources.com/assets/phpThumb/phpThumb.php?src=/assets/images/articles/1267046558.jpg&h=200 (http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?disp=img&pid=1267046558)

While he starred in solid genre hit "Cloverfield," many movie goers may be unfamiliar still with Vogel thanks to a certain 40-story scene-steeling co-star. But the actor will soon appear in the comedy "She's Out of My League" showing whether or not he can draw enough interest to play Cap.
Michael Cassidy [Art by Butch Guice]

http://www.comicbookresources.com/assets/phpThumb/phpThumb.php?src=/assets/images/articles/1267046783.jpg&h=200 (http://www.comicbookresources.com/prev_img.php?disp=img&pid=1267046783)

Cassidy presents an interesting case of superhero movie "coulda been" as the actor was once in talks to play the Man of Steel when director McG was prepping a Superman relaunch. In the meantime, he's been waiting for his big break appearing in TV series including a seven-episode stint as Grant Gabriel in "Smallville."
The Hollywood Reporter also noted (http://www.heatvisionblog.com/2010/02/captain-america-contenders-krasinski-cassidy-vogel-fluger-more.html) that Garret Hedlund of the upcoming "Tron Legacy" and "Supernatural" star Jenson Ackles were both in consideration for screen testing, however currently both actors have scheduling conflicts that may make them unavailable to take the role. And of course, considering the many rounds of casting it took Marvel Studios and Kenneth Branagh to cast the unknown Hemsworth as Thor, none of the above candidates may finally take the red, white and blue shield for a spin.
Until it's known for sure, sound off in the CBR forums and look back for more "Captain America" news as it becomes available.

[ultimatefan]

Based on looks, I´d vote for Chase Crawford. The rest, we´ll see.

[JAK®]

John Krasinski will give Captain America some character that will appeal to audiences beyond comic fans.

[DocHoliday]

i am waiting for March 1st because i think we all remember this article a week before Thor was cast

http://www.latinoreview.com/news/is-kenneth-branagh-close-to-choosing-his-thor-6337

That was several months before he was cast. March is when the article was posted. Star Trek didn't even some out until May and I believe it was a few weeks after that when Hemsworth was announced.

[Project862006]

still he was the rumored front runner of a list of unknown actors and look what happened i am just gonna wait for the announcement

[DocHoliday]

still he was the rumored front runner of a list of unknown actors and look what happened i am just gonna wait for the announcement

No I get your point, about waiting. Just saying they HAVE to have someone cast by March 1st. There were two and half months we heard nothing about Thor after that report, in thi case there would likely be a week.

[Project862006]

But Thor also was delayed a year

[Dave40]

so you prefer krasinski with his huge nose gigantic ears and all around goof ball face

Not to mention he looks absolutely nothing like steve rogers i can understand not being exactly like your character.But hell there has to be a point where you have to resemble the character a little bit.

Agree:yay:

[scifiwolf]

still he was the rumored front runner of a list of unknown actors and look what happened i am just gonna wait for the announcement

Because he had lunch with the director. Every time i have lunch with my girlfriend she gets cast as Wonder Woman.

[DocHoliday]

I can't remember did we get Loki/Thor casting at the same time? Maybe we will get Red Skull soon too. If they are going for a big name maybe they'll book hima few months in advance and we'll get a peak...

Oh and to be fair to him Nikki Finke reported that it was down to Skarsgaard and the dude from Green Street Hooligans. Although I'm not sure how close it really was.

[Project862006]

^ it was like the same week i beleive it was real quick

[paulogonza]

then the screen tests only begin this week? then we still wait weeks before the real decision, and krasinski is noto officially cast, because all sites is taking this like contenders.

[RetroNaz]

They'd almost have to screen test Cap and Red Skull against each other (see how well they play off one another). So hopefully we get both official announcements around the same time.

[FaT_tONle]

I'm down with JK... as soon as they went NBC I figured it was either Levi or JK. Levi probabbly has even less a look than JK for the part but I still thought he'd be the guy. Not gonna cry at all about JK. Damn solid pick IMO. I could see Hedlund, but Ackles looks like a douche. Let him workout for Hawkeye if anything. Porter just sucks... he's like the Vin Deisel of the genre. You won't find a bigger fan among actors/celebrities, but I just get the feeling he stinks up the joint when it's time to audition for a role.

[Son of Coul]

John Krasinski seems entirely wrong for the part IMO - imagine Cap doing a speech about the importance of ideals with that cynical, bratty kid attitude Krasinski plays in TO -, not to mention he´s not an unknown. Can´t comment on the others.
Do you... even watch the Office?
One important point imo is there

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/z0D07dQ018o&hl=fr_FR&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/z0D07dQ018o&hl=fr_FR&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>

Krasinski imo has a commanding presence, naturally.
This. This solidified it for me (my opinion, not my penis). Watch it and be entranced by Captain America in an interview (plugging his show "The Office").

And even though it's been said a million times, I completely agree that he'd have great chemistry with Downey, which is essential to the character. With the other contenders I feel like RDJ would be talking to some ambitious little boy, Krasinski has this rare look where he looks young, but at the same time has a maturity about him.

[OB12]

^^ Yeah I am not sure where the misconception is coming from that JK plays this really goofy, bratty character on the Office. He is basically the moral compass of the show, sure he instigates some jokes aimed at Dwight, but on the whole he is the voice of reason.

[Son of Coul]

Yeah, being sarcastic and not-into-selling-paper doesn't make you cynical nor bratty. Like you said, he's the voice of reason and the everyman of the show. He just happens to have a sense of humor.

[paulogonza]

we have to wait more than march 1st, and in my opinion dont be krasinski, but weeks to go until the real official announcement.

[DocHoliday]

I do not doubt Porter's geek cred, I just think he plays it up a bit to get online support. Not that I'd do it differently. Nic Cage is a big fan too and it's not like Ghost Rider was good.

[Chewy]

still he was the rumored front runner of a list of unknown actors and look what happened i am just gonna wait for the announcement
And then we heard not too long after that that Skars was no longer in the running because Branagh felt he was too old

People act like it was a big shocker when the announcement came and it wasn't Skars, but if you were following the casting process all signs ended up pointing away from him. This is a different situation

[Son of Coul]

That's one thing. No matter who they get for this movie, even if it's Steven Seagal, just take solace in knowing one thing-

at least it's not Nicholas Cage

[redlion2]

I think whomever they choose is going to need enough stage presense to not be overshadowed by RDJ, Sam Jackson and the likes of Don Cheadle (hopefully Ed Norton too). Not only that, he has to look youthful but have a certain amount of maturity to actually make you believe he can command their respect and lead these guys into battle. The acting is the major part but looks will play a significant role too and by looks, I mean, he can't look like a Robin leading Batman (Chris O'Donnell taking the lead over Val Kilmer or George Clooney, for example) the audience might not buy it.

The more I think about it, Krasinski fits the bill.

[NoirMan82]

I'm a fan of JK, but I don't see him as right for the role.

[DocHoliday]

I think whomever they choose is going to need enough stage presense to not be overshadowed by RDJ, Sam Jackson and the likes of Don Cheadle (hopefully Ed Norton too). Not only that, he has to look youthful but have a certain amount of maturity to actually make you believe he can command their respect and lead these guys into battle. The acting is the major part but looks will play a significant role too and by looks, I mean, he can't look like a Robin leading Batman (Chris O'Donnell taking the lead over Val Kilmer or George Clooney, for example) the audience might not buy it.

The more I think about it, Krasinski fits the bill.

Agreed. But Batman's failings came more from the script and direction than anything. Kilmer/Clooney are good actors. Watch Tombstone/The Doors or any Clooney film since then lol.


But I think out of the list given that JK is easily the best actor. Not only do you have to have someone that we respect as an actor but also the other veteran actors respect. JK is that guy.

[OB12]

At this point I would be disappointed if JK didn't get the part. I could get behind one or two of the other candidates, but for the most part they are all very vanilla. Most look too coiffed, manucured and stylized to really make me feel like I would want to hang out with them, let alone go into war with them.

[Lobo]

Wilson Bethel is a name that his been inserted to the heatvision link from THR he's got a good look. I still support Porter and Vogel for the part.

[redlion2]

Agreed. But Batman's failings came more from the script and direction than anything. Kilmer/Clooney are good actors. Watch Tombstone/The Doors or any Clooney film since then lol.


But I think out of the list given that JK is easily the best actor. Not only do you have to have someone that we respect as an actor but also the other veteran actors respect. JK is that guy.

Most definately I believe Kilmer and Clooney are good actors and that wasn't a pop at them or O'Donnell either. Just the idea and image of O'Donnell wearing the Batman suit and leading veteran actors such as Kilmer or Clooney which is one of the hurdles of a guy playing the part of a hero that's been frozen in ice and stuck at the same youthful appearnce as he was since WWII. He has to look and come off as young but not too young that he can't be taken serious as a leader among gods, monsters and heroes.

[That-Guy]

Agreed. But Batman's failings came more from the script and direction than anything. Kilmer/Clooney are good actors. Watch Tombstone/The Doors or any Clooney film since then lol.


But I think out of the list given that JK is easily the best actor. Not only do you have to have someone that we respect as an actor but also the other veteran actors respect. JK is that guy.

See, I think that this is where I have to disagree. I'm not saying that JK is a bad actor, but I do have a lot of trouble seeing him as a commanding presence and a leader. Maybe it's just that I haven't seen him in that type of role, but trying to imagine him barking orders at RDJ and Don Cheadle just seems impossible.

[scifiwolf]

Maybe this is exactly what John needs to quit being typecast and be taken serioiusly as an actor with range. Look at Jim Carrey with The Truman Show, or Tom Hanks with Philadelphia.

[Deaths Head II]

Maybe this is exactly what John needs to quit being typecast and be taken serioiusly as an actor with range. Look at Jim Carrey with The Truman Show, or Tom Hanks with Philadelphia.

I think if he is able to pull off Cap, his career will really take off.

See, I think that this is where I have to disagree. I'm not saying that JK is a bad actor, but I do have a lot of trouble seeing him as a commanding presence and a leader. Maybe it's just that I haven't seen him in that type of role, but trying to imagine him barking orders at RDJ and Don Cheadle just seems impossible.

Thats the thing though. You haven't seen him in those type of roles. The people behind this film saw him audition and something made them go "wow." We won't know what that is until the film comes out.

[redlion2]

See, I think that this is where I have to disagree. I'm not saying that JK is a bad actor, but I do have a lot of trouble seeing him as a commanding presence and a leader. Maybe it's just that I haven't seen him in that type of role, but trying to imagine him barking orders at RDJ and Don Cheadle just seems impossible.

See, I actually belive he's closer to the ideal than the rest of those guys on the short list, as it relates to the ensemble cast of the Avengers. To be honest, as someone else said, the rest just look waayyy too young.

[Project862006]

See, I think that this is where I have to disagree. I'm not saying that JK is a bad actor, but I do have a lot of trouble seeing him as a commanding presence and a leader. Maybe it's just that I haven't seen him in that type of role, but trying to imagine him barking orders at RDJ and Don Cheadle just seems impossible.

i agree

[DocHoliday]

See, I think that this is where I have to disagree. I'm not saying that JK is a bad actor, but I do have a lot of trouble seeing him as a commanding presence and a leader. Maybe it's just that I haven't seen him in that type of role, but trying to imagine him barking orders at RDJ and Don Cheadle just seems impossible.

haha fair enough. I think Leatherheads (even though it's a comedy) shows that he can hold his own against those caliber actors. have you seen it? Also, to be honest with you I'm not sure if we are going to get CAP barking orders like Joe Montana anyway. My question is do you see him having the ability to make an inspirational speech?

Also I must say that you are civil on here, which not all the JK doubters are. Also I too am looking forward to Money Never Sleeps!

[Double Down]

Hype Members Converted to John Krasinski as Captain Ameirca:
WillardNation
HappyPalooza
Chewy
Da-Scribe
NightAvenger4
OB12
Parker Wayne
RachelDawes
JP
Colossal Spoons.

I'LL GET YOU, SPOONS! :argh:


I was supporting Krasinski on Monday night. I should be on the list!

http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?t=327870&page=168

[redlion2]

haha fair enough. I think Leatherheads (even though it's a comedy) shows that he can hold his own against those caliber actors. have you seen it? Also, to be honest with you I'm not sure if we are going to get CAP barking orders like Joe Montana anyway. My question is do you see him having the ability to make an inspirational speech?

Also I must say that you are civil on here, which not all the JK doubters are. Also I too am looking forward to Money Never Sleeps!

Exactly. He has proven that he can hold his own with that calibre of an actor and I think he would fit in well with the rest of the cast of Avengers.....that is, if he's chosen at all.

[afan]

So............

Captain America is handsome.....true.
John Krasinski is handsome........true.
Therefore John Krasinski is Captain America.........true.

Ok this argument also supports
http://redriverautographs.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/schwimmer-david-photo-xl-david-schwimmer-6221730.jpg

David Scwhimmer??????

Krasinski may be handsome, but just like Schwimmer he does not look like Cap!

[That-Guy]

haha fair enough. I think Leatherheads (even though it's a comedy) shows that he can hold his own against those caliber actors. have you seen it? Also, to be honest with you I'm not sure if we are going to get CAP barking orders like Joe Montana anyway. My question is do you see him having the ability to make an inspirational speech?

Also I must say that you are civil on here, which not all the JK doubters are. Also I too am looking forward to Money Never Sleeps!

No, I haven't seen Leatherheads. I'll likely watch it soon though, since it might give me a better idea of why JK is receiving so much support here.

Heh, well, I guess I've always pictured Cap as the ultimate military hardass. Not cruel or psychotic like Sgt. Hartman in Full Metal Jacket, but just stern as hell and the kind of guy that people don't really like, but they respect like hell.

Also, thanks for the compliment. I try to keep an open mind about this stuff, although sometimes there are certain rumors that I simply CANNOT get behind (for example, when Timberlake was rumored for Green Lantern, I about lost my friggin' mind).

[Prison Mike]

I think I will reserve judgement until Krasinski is cast and footage of him in the role comes out. Honestly, if he gets Captain America...I will be expecting Dwight in a Red Skull costume to pop out.

[DocHoliday]

So............

Captain America is handsome.....true.
John Krasinski is handsome........true.
Therefore John Krasinski is Captain America.........true.

Ok this argument also supports
http://redriverautographs.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/schwimmer-david-photo-xl-david-schwimmer-6221730.jpg

David Scwhimmer??????

Krasinski may be handsome, but just like Schwimmer he does not look like Cap!

Except one is a higher quality actor than the other. Also, Schwimmer played douche bag pretty well in Band of brothers. But still by your approximation casting JK is like casting Jason Biggs.

[The Squirrel]

I have judgement now. JK is not Cap material. Casting him would be Marvel's first mistake in making their own films.

[That-Guy]

Except one is a higher quality actor than the other. Also, Schwimmer played douche bag pretty well in Band of brothers. But still by your approximation casting JK is like casting Jason Biggs.

Jason Biggs for Bucky! :hehe:

[Aesop Rocks]

Hype Members Converted to John Krasinski as Captain Ameirca:
WillardNation
HappyPalooza
Chewy
Da-Scribe
NightAvenger4
OB12
Parker Wayne
RachelDawes
JP
RetroNaz
Docker2.0
Double Down
FaT_toNle
ImWithTeamConan
Colossal Spoons.

http://img294.imageshack.us/img294/1518/familyguygood20good.gif

I'LL GET YOU, SPOONS! :argh:

[flickchick85]

Also, for the record, Krasinski is FAR more attractive than David Schwimmer ever was.

[ComicBookGuy]

Maybe this is exactly what John needs to quit being typecast and be taken serioiusly as an actor with range. Look at Jim Carrey with The Truman Show, or Tom Hanks with Philadelphia.

Don't forget Adam Sandler in Reign Over Me. I think JK would be an ok choice. Perfect, no. My choice? No. Would anyone other than Steve Rogers himself be perfect in this role? No (and with the picky people on this site I think they'd find something to ***** about if Rogers happened to fall out of a vortex and into Marvels casting room). But in the past few years Marvel has done a damn good job finding who they think fits and short of Channing Tatum or Will Smith (who we don't have to worry about thanks to that list) I'll see this movie on opening day with whoever they cast.

[Aesop Rocks]

Loved Reign Over Me. :cmad:

[That-Guy]

Whoa, thank you for reminding me of something. THANK ALMIGHTY GOD that Channing Tatum isn't in the running. I was seriously worried that he would be, since G.I Joe didn't flop (like it should have) and because apparently there are enough stupid teenage girls in America to make Dear John a hit.

[mjdiddy1]

JK does have a certain Matt Salinger look to him

http://img.freebase.com/api/trans/image_thumb/wikipedia/images/en_id/4205456?errorid=%2Ffreebase%2Fno_image_png&maxheight=200&mode=fit&maxwidth=150http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:6ixkGyep7oRGGM:http://www.moviecatcher.net/images/captain-america4.jpg (http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.moviecatcher.net/images/captain-america4.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.moviecatcher.net/worst-superhero-movies-ever-made/&usg=__wiOlKqis4o3GbPr8u_-hr1eCYZM=&h=353&w=276&sz=42&hl=en&start=21&itbs=1&tbnid=6ixkGyep7oRGGM:&tbnh=121&tbnw=95&prev=/images%3Fq%3DMatthew%2BSalinger%26start%3D18%26hl% 3Den%26safe%3Dactive%26sa%3DN%26gbv%3D2%26ndsp%3D1 8%26tbs%3Disch:1)

[flickchick85]

Whoa, thank you for reminding me of something. THANK ALMIGHTY GOD that Channing Tatum isn't in the running. I was seriously worried that he would be, since G.I Joe didn't flop (like it should have) and because apparently there are enough stupid teenage girls in America to make Dear John a hit.
On that point, we most CERTAINLY agree. :up:

[The Squirrel]

Is it to late to get Matt Damon? :awesome:

[JP]

CkbzEuaY-rE

[OB12]

Damon has a lot of things going against him, namely being too old, too expensive and too short.

[Project862006]

Krasinski would have to go one the Hugh Jackman work out regime

http://idiosyncraticcharm.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/hugh-jackman-20060825-155170.jpg http://www.splendicity.com/sheknowsbest/files/2008/10/hugh-jackman-14oct08-nc-thumb.jpg
this is the ideal cap physique imo

[Aesop Rocks]

JK does have a certain Matt Salinger look to him

http://img.freebase.com/api/trans/image_thumb/wikipedia/images/en_id/4205456?errorid=%2Ffreebase%2Fno_image_png&maxheight=200&mode=fit&maxwidth=150http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:6ixkGyep7oRGGM:http://www.moviecatcher.net/images/captain-america4.jpg (http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.moviecatcher.net/images/captain-america4.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.moviecatcher.net/worst-superhero-movies-ever-made/&usg=__wiOlKqis4o3GbPr8u_-hr1eCYZM=&h=353&w=276&sz=42&hl=en&start=21&itbs=1&tbnid=6ixkGyep7oRGGM:&tbnh=121&tbnw=95&prev=/images%3Fq%3DMatthew%2BSalinger%26start%3D18%26hl% 3Den%26safe%3Dactive%26sa%3DN%26gbv%3D2%26ndsp%3D1 8%26tbs%3Disch:1)

Oh you mean a certain better look?

[Aesop Rocks]

Krasinski would have to go one the Hugh Jackman work out regime

http://idiosyncraticcharm.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/hugh-jackman-20060825-155170.jpg http://www.splendicity.com/sheknowsbest/files/2008/10/hugh-jackman-14oct08-nc-thumb.jpg
this is the ideal cap physique imo

John is already fit. Probably the same sort of build of pre-Thor hemsworth.

It can be done.

[flickchick85]

Krasinski would have to go one the Hugh Jackman work out regime

http://idiosyncraticcharm.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/hugh-jackman-20060825-155170.jpg http://www.splendicity.com/sheknowsbest/files/2008/10/hugh-jackman-14oct08-nc-thumb.jpg
this is the ideal cap physique imo
I really only think Jackman got that big to make up for all the flack about his build being all wrong for short, stocky Wolverine. Cap's not supposed to be short and stocky, just ripped, so I don't think Krasinski (or whoever's cast) would need to get quite that beefy. But I do think with his height and broad shoulders, that Krasinski would have a pretty intimidating build after he packs on some muscle.

[Double Down]

CkbzEuaY-rE

Nice. :up:

[Son of Coul]

So............

Captain America is handsome.....true.
John Krasinski is handsome........true.
Therefore John Krasinski is Captain America.........true.

Ok this argument also supports
http://redriverautographs.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/schwimmer-david-photo-xl-david-schwimmer-6221730.jpg

David Scwhimmer??????

Krasinski may be handsome, but just like Schwimmer he does not look like Cap!
This argument against Krasinski is so absurd and flawed in so many ways I'm not even gonna start to rebuttal. Unless you're just kidding, I honestly can't tell.

[Aesop Rocks]

So............

Captain America is handsome.....true.
John Krasinski is handsome........true.
Therefore John Krasinski is Captain America.........true.

Ok this argument also supports
http://redriverautographs.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/schwimmer-david-photo-xl-david-schwimmer-6221730.jpg

David Scwhimmer??????

Krasinski may be handsome, but just like Schwimmer he does not look like Cap!

David Scwhimmer as Cap? Nah, he'd be a better Bruce Wayne/Batman

[Deaths Head II]

Oh you mean a certain better look?

I think Matt Salinger was a pretty good choice for Cap. It's just the movie he was in was so poopy.

[afan]

John is already fit. Probably the same sort of build of pre-Thor hemsworth.

Hemsworth
http://i733.photobucket.com/albums/ww332/MrsDirt09/Chris_02.jpg

Krasinski....
http://www.towleroad.com/images/2007/10/08/john_krasinski_shirtless_1.jpg

Probably not.........

[블라스]

Ever since I've head of John Krasinski as Cap, man, I've been so excited. I can totally see it.

Oh, and the haters' excuses are just hilarious...

"He plays a smartass guy on TV!" He's an actor.
"He's not all muscley!" There are gyms and fitness experts.
"He's not handsome" Oy...

:hehe:

[ultimatefan]

Okay, to be sreally old on Krasinski, I´d have to see him in something serious, cuz so far I only know him from The Office, where he plays more or less the opposite character of Captain America, and a couple romantic comedies that looked so bad I didn´t bother to see them. Any good suggestions? If not, I´ll keep seeing his name with reservations.

[OptimusPrime114]

Did you know that B.J. Novak, John's co-star on the Office co-starred in Inglorious Basterds? A WWII film which received critical acclaim?

If anything, I don't see anything wrong with the Kraz playing Captain America.

[ultimatefan]

Did you know that B.J. Novak, John's co-star on the Office co-starred in Inglorious Basterds? A WWII film which received critical acclaim?

If anything, I don't see anything wrong with the Kraz playing Captain America.

BJ Novak is one actor, Krasinski is another. I´m not saying he could never pull it off - I mean, if Heath Ledger blew the world away as The Joker, who knows - but he´s not a name that I´d immediately jump on board with.

Plus it seems doubtful that at this point of his career he´d go for the 300k salary they´re allegedly willing to pay. That´s for guys who haven´t had a breakthrough beyond guest appearances and soapies yet.

[Chewy]

Plus it seems doubtful that at this point of his career he´d go for the 300k salary they´re allegedly willing to pay. That´s for guys who haven´t had a breakthrough beyond guest appearances and soapies yet.
Uh
There's a salary scale, but if you're not a known quantity like Crawford or Krasinski, the offer is around $300,000 for the first film.
That's the direct quote from Deadline.com, the original source of all of this. $300K would be for the complete unknowns, guys like Krasinski and even Chase Crawford's offers would be higher.

[Aesop Rocks]

Hemsworth
http://i733.photobucket.com/albums/ww332/MrsDirt09/Chris_02.jpg

Krasinski....
http://www.towleroad.com/images/2007/10/08/john_krasinski_shirtless_1.jpg

Probably not.........

That's an older picture, PAL. :argh:

He's been seen going to the gym quite a lot lately.

[OB12]

Okay, to be sreally old on Krasinski, I´d have to see him in something serious, cuz so far I only know him from The Office, where he plays more or less the opposite character of Captain America, and a couple romantic comedies that looked so bad I didn´t bother to see them. Any good suggestions? If not, I´ll keep seeing his name with reservations.


Again, I don't really understand what people are seeing when they watch Jim Halpert. He really isn't the opposite of Steve Rogers, in fact he possesses many of the qualities that Steve Rogers should have. He is a likeable guy, wholesome, unflinchingly moral, and he displays leadership qualities. The fact that Halpert is a character in a comedy probably takes people out of the mindset, but if you breakdown his character they are not that dissimilar.

[FaT_tONle]

Uh

That's the direct quote from Deadline.com, the original source of all of this. $300K would be for the complete unknowns, guys like Krasinski and even Chase Crawford's offers would be higher.

Why won't I be suprised if this Krazinski thing stalls because (go figure)... Marvel/JK's agents can't agree to terms financially. Don't be sitting all day in front of your comp waiting for confirmation is all I can say.

[Aesop Rocks]

OB12, Roy almost killed Jim and Jim didn't do a thing.

[Chewy]

Why won't I be suprised if this Krazinski thing stalls because (go figure)... Marvel/JK's agents can't agree to terms financially. Don't be sitting all day in front of your comp waiting for confirmation is all I can say.
Because you always jump to conclusions and assume the worst of Marvel based on very little actual info?

[Aesop Rocks]

Uh-oh.

[KangConquers]

Because you always jump to conclusions and assume the worst of Marvel based on very little actual info?

:hehe:

What do you think about John, Chewy?

[Chewy]

What do you think about John, Chewy?
He wouldn't be my first choice, but I think he has the potential to do interesting things with the role and surprise the hell out of a lot of people.

[Son of Coul]

Again, I don't really understand what people are seeing when they watch Jim Halpert. He really isn't the opposite of Steve Rogers, in fact he possesses many of the qualities that Steve Rogers should have. He is a likeable guy, wholesome, unflinchingly moral, and he displays leadership qualities. The fact that Halpert is a character in a comedy probably takes people out of the mindset, but if you breakdown his character they are not that dissimilar.
I don't see Jim as much of a leader, especially considering his attempts as co-manager this season. He's not that commanding and is more laid-back. Definitely not much of a go-getter either. There are qualities close to Cap, but they ain't that similar.

[ultimatefan]

Again, I don't really understand what people are seeing when they watch Jim Halpert. He really isn't the opposite of Steve Rogers, in fact he possesses many of the qualities that Steve Rogers should have. He is a likeable guy, wholesome, unflinchingly moral, and he displays leadership qualities. The fact that Halpert is a character in a comedy probably takes people out of the mindset, but if you breakdown his character they are not that dissimilar.


Okay, maybe not the opposite, but he´s also has a cynical, smartass, sometimes bored and sloppy attitude towards his job. He often seems like a guy who gave up whether his calling or his dream was to sell paper and he hates it, so he keeps playing pranks and making fun of Dwight and other co-workers and making up games and whatnot to put up with it. That´s not Cap.

[OB12]

OB12, Roy almost killed Jim and Jim didn't do a thing.


Yeah, I remember that, but then again this is a comedy series. What Jim is not is a take action guy. He is played up as the good guy, no reason to also make him the toughest guy in the office.

[Stripesy Strip]

So............

Captain America is handsome.....true.
John Krasinski is handsome........true.
Therefore John Krasinski is Captain America.........true.

Ok this argument also supports
http://redriverautographs.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/schwimmer-david-photo-xl-david-schwimmer-6221730.jpg

David Scwhimmer??????

Krasinski may be handsome, but just like Schwimmer he does not look like Cap!

I agree.

First of all, those that likes Cap, that have read the comics would never support Krasninski as Cap. NEVER. Because he looks nothing like him.

[FaT_tONle]

Because you always jump to conclusions and assume the worst of Marvel based on very little actual info?

I am calling it right now...


"We have learned that Marvel and Johnston have set their sights on John Krasinski as their lead man in the upcoming TFA:CA, but Krasinski's reps have apparently balked at an initial low ball offer of 400K. Stay tuned for further word..."

[OB12]

Okay, maybe not the opposite, but he´s also has a cynical, smartass, often bored and sloppy attitude towards his job. He often seems like a guy who gave up whether his calling or his dream was to sell paper and he hates it, so he keeps playing pranks and making fun of Dwight and other co-workers to put up with it. That´s not Cap.

I agree, but then again we are not asking Jim Halpert to be Cap, we are asking John Krasinski to play Cap. John plays the part and the character that is written for him.

[Aesop Rocks]

I am calling it right now...

Didn't Chewy post that JK would get MORE?

[KangConquers]

I am calling it right now...

Marvel should do percentage points if they want to low ball actors "You get half a million, but after we break even, you start getting 5%."

[Chewy]

I am calling it right now...
Yeah, and they'll negotiate it up. Just like with RDJ. Just like with Favs. Just like with Rourke. Just like with SLJ. Just like with Johnston himself.

[BETArayBill]

I agree.

First of all, those that likes Cap, that have read the comics would never support Krasninski as Cap. NEVER. Because he looks nothing like him.

Thank you! I really hate all this john kranski as cap talk I've tried to see the good in it but i cant i don't wan't him as cap at all everytime i look at the guy all i see is a live action sherk with that face.

[ultimatefan]

I agree, but then again we are not asking Jim Halpert to be Cap, we are asking John Krasinski to play Cap. John plays the part and the character that is written for him.

Again, I´m not saying there´s no way he can do it, just that he´s not in a place where he´s masterfully played such a similar part or is such an already accomplished actor that I´d say, "that guy is the perfect Captain America".

[Rock Sexton]

Maybe this is exactly what John needs to quit being typecast and be taken serioiusly as an actor with range. Look at Jim Carrey with The Truman Show, or Tom Hanks with Philadelphia.

Ya, because Jim Carey has done so many serious roles since then .... :whatever:

[Aesop Rocks]

Yeah, and they'll negotiate it up. Just like with RDJ. Just like with Favs. Just like with Rourke. Just like with SLJ. Just like with Johnston himself.

And Rockwell. YOU CAN'T EVER FORGET SAM ROCKWELL. :cmad:

[OptimusPrime114]

I agree, but then again we are not asking Jim Halpert to be Cap, we are asking John Krasinski to play Cap. John plays the part and the character that is written for him.

You tell 'em, OB!

[FaT_tONle]

Yeah, and they'll negotiate it up. Just like with RDJ. Just like with Favs. Just like with Rourke. Just like with SLJ. Just like with Johnston himself.

I am not saying they won't ever finalize the deal. I am more curious to see how it will play out when it's time for sequels, like when SJ wants a bump to 4-5 million for a Black Widow spinoff or something. Then it will get interesting.

[Stripesy Strip]

Thank you! I really hate all this john kranski as cap talk I've tried to see the good in it but i cant i don't wan't him as cap at all everytime i look at the guy all i see is a live action sherk with that face.

Hey I don't want my Captain America to look like Donkey from Shreck.

[Chewy]

And Rockwell. YOU CAN'T EVER FORGET SAM ROCKWELL. :cmad:
Haha, exactly.

FaT_tONIe, we've had this similar discussion too many times to count, about how Marvel's lowballs would "ruin" their flicks and the actors' agents would balk. And each time the discussion has come up, the actor has ended up signing on anyway, after negotiations. I'm not sure why you feel it's a discussion that needs to be had again

[Deaths Head II]

Ya, because Jim Carey has done so many serious roles since then .... :whatever:

Is this a joke? He also did:

The Majestic
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
The Number 23
Man on the Moon

I actually think I prefer Carrey more as a serious actor.

[ultimatefan]

Thank you! I really hate all this john kranski as cap talk I've tried to see the good in it but i cant i don't wan't him as cap at all everytime i look at the guy all i see is a live action sherk with that face.

But then again, as far as looks go, a lot of people complained that Heath Ledger was "too pretty" to play Joker, that Hugh Jackman was too tal for Wolverine, and don´t even get people started on Michael Keaton as Batman.

[BETArayBill]

Deaths head is that john locke as a navi'a because thats awesome.

[Chewy]

I am not saying they won't ever finalize the deal. I am more curious to see how it will play out when it's time for sequels, like when SJ wants a bump to 4-5 million for a Black Widow spinoff or something. Then it will get interesting.
Fair enough. But they had no problem bumping Downey's paycheck way the **** up, so I don't think they'd have a problem doing similar for Cap or Thor or BW if their characters are popular and warrant more solo flicks.

[Son of Coul]

Hey Stripesy, it's fine that you don't want Krasinski as Cap but you don't have to be such a child about it.

[Deaths Head II]

Deaths head is that john locke as a navi'a because thats awesome.

Yep. :woot:

[BETArayBill]

But then again, as far as looks go, a lot of people complained that Heath Ledger was "too pretty" to play Joker, that Hugh Jackman was too tal for Wolverine, and don´t even get people started on Michael Keaton as Batman.

i never really had a problem with ledger and i was to young to complain about jackman or keaton but cap is my favorite superhero behind batman man and i have an image of him ingrained in my head and kranski is not it at all and i just cant get over it.

[louiebling$]

Edit

[Aesop Rocks]

@ HappyPalooza: Please edit your post. I don't want you to get banned. I'm starting to like you. :csad:

[Stripesy Strip]

Hey Stripesy, it's fine that you don't want Krasinski as Cap but you don't have to be such a child about it.

Another Captain America hater. :woot:

[Son of Coul]

Very well, just for you. That and I've been banned like ten times for inappropriate language, this place is pretty uptight on that.

[Son of Coul]

dubz.

[Aesop Rocks]

Another Captain America hater. :woot:

You really really really need to stop saying that.

[Stripesy Strip]

You really really really need to stop saying that.

I want to see Cap on screen, the Cap i've seen since my childhood. THE Captain America. You don't want to see Cap on screen, then you hate Cap. :woot:

Mathematics.

Would a chaved head Jason Alexander be Professor X?

[Spider-Fan]

Again, I´m not saying there´s no way he can do it, just that he´s not in a place where he´s masterfully played such a similar part or is such an already accomplished actor that I´d say, "that guy is the perfect Captain America".

Who did Ledger play before the Joker that was similar?

You don't need to have done the role before to be able to do it or be great at it. That's why you audition.

[FaT_tONle]

I want to see Cap on screen, the Cap i've seen since my childhood. THE Captain America. You don't want to see Cap on screen, then you hate Cap. :woot:

Mathematics.

Would a chaved head Jason Alexander be Professor X?

You are lost if you think that is a valid comparison...:doh:

[Son of Coul]

The way I see it, the fact that Marvel is so heavily considering such a potentially controversial choice among fans says he must have done something really impressive in the auditions.

[Stripesy Strip]

He must have flipped his ears and fly like Dumbo.

[DocHoliday]

The way I see it, the fact that Marvel is so heavily considering such a potentially controversial choice among fans says he must have done something really impressive in the auditions.

Agreed. He clearly did something the other candidates did not. If they were s skilled at whatever he did, then they wouldn't go this route.

[Artistsean]

So maybe he doesn't look EXACTLY like Steve Rogers, and he is my pick for Ted Kord/Blue Beetle. But I think he could pull of the Steve Rogers character perfectly. He could play the all American soldier, the born leader, super soldier. I think he is a good enough actor too for the part, unlike some of the other choices I have heard.
If he is picked I wouldn't be unhappy. Plus, we could do SO MUCH worse.

Plus, he is 6'3. If he bucked up, and made his hair blond.

I say, good choice.

[Spider-Fan]

The way I see it, the fact that Marvel is so heavily considering such a potentially controversial choice among fans says he must have done something really impressive in the auditions.

Exactly. If we just hired people based on what we've seen him do publicly, then we would have no actors branching out. They'd all be stuck playing the same character.

I think if JK is the chosen actor, he had a great audition. Which is why you hold auditions in the first place. To see what people can do.

[Rock Sexton]

Exactly. If we just hired people based on what we've seen him do publicly, then we would have no actors branching out. They'd all be stuck playing the same character.

I think if JK is the chosen actor, he had a great audition. Which is why you hold auditions in the first place. To see what people can do.

Apparently George Lucas thought Hayden Christiansen had a great audition too!

Sorry, if people are gonna keep playing the over-generalized Heath Ledger card, then I'm going to keep bringing up Hayden.

[Spider-Fan]

Apparently George Lucas thought Hayden Christiansen had a great audition too!

Sorry, if people are gonna keep playing the over-generalized Heath Ledger card, then I'm going to keep bringing up Hayden.

But again, George Lucas also made TPM before that film and casted an annoying kid as Anakin and made Jar Jar Binks. We can't compare him to Nolan, whom was smart in his choice. Marvel has been smart about their cast. They've shown more Nolan and less Lucas.

[Deaths Head II]

Apparently George Lucas thought Hayden Christiansen had a great audition too!

The thing that makes this comparison flawed is that Hayden was never likable in any of his roles and he was never a good actor.

We know John can be likable and we know he's a good actor. We just don't know if he'll pull of Cap, but Marvel picking him is nowhere near Lucas picking Hayden.

[TikkiEXX]

Apparently George Lucas thought Hayden Christiansen had a great audition too!

Sorry, if people are gonna keep playing the over-generalized Heath Ledger card, then I'm going to keep bringing up Hayden.
thats a terrible comparison. what had Lucas done besides Star Wars which were 20 years old by the time he prequels came out. Marvel has Iron Man and The Incredible Hulk. both movies were highly rated and had great actors. and both came out very recently.

[drax]

But then again, as far as looks go, a lot of people complained that Heath Ledger was "too pretty" to play Joker, that Hugh Jackman was too tal for Wolverine, and don´t even get people started on Michael Keaton as Batman.

Imo it's not the same thing, Ledger have lot of make up, Jackman is in fact too tall but he can look like Wolverine (black hairs and dark eyes) and for Keaton, Batman is more important that Bruce Wayne, unlike Captain America, this character have clearly a double identity, there are also the fact that Keaton have a strange look who could fit with the weird world of Batman.

But Krasinski don't look like Steve Roger imo, and Steve Roger is Captain America, his physical appareance is very important like Superman, because he is the symbol of a perfect human against the so-called superior race (the nazi).
He don't have the perfect "angel" face of Steve Roger, he have a big noise and have a really special face, he can be handsome, but he is not clearly the "perfect" man like Steve Roger.

[Stripesy Strip]

The thing that makes this comparison flawed is that Hayden was never likable in any of his roles and he was never a good actor.

We know John can be likable and we know he's a good actor. We just don't know if he'll pull of Cap, but Marvel picking him is nowhere near Lucas picking Hayden.

Again there's no proof that Office guy is that good. So the comparison makes sense. I didn't think he was that good in Leatherheads. He was just ok.

[Spider-Fan]

All of you complaining about him not being the perfect man, you have a flaw in this argument. No man is the perfect man, so casting the perfect man is impossible. If you're talking about a model, they can't act and even they are not "the perfect man." Stop getting hung on this idea of him not looking perfect and look at his acting chops. If he can act like Steve Rogers and have that "it" factor and natural leadership ability, he is Captain America. Screw the "perfect man" look. Acting > appearance.

[DocHoliday]

Again there's no proof that Office guy is that good. So the comparison makes sense. I didn't think he was that good in Leatherheads. He was just ok.


Away We Go. He was very good in that.

[Stripesy Strip]

Imo it's not the same thing, Ledger have lot of make up, Jackman is in fact too tall but he can look like Wolverine (black hairs and dark eyes) and for Keaton, Batman is more important that Bruce Wayne, unlike Captain America, this character have clearly a double identity, there are also the fact that Keaton have a strange look who could fit with the weird world of Batman.

But Krasinski don't look like Steve Roger imo, and Steve Roger is Captain America, his physical appareance is very important like Superman, because he is the symbol of a perfect human against the so-called superior race (the nazi).
He don't have the perfect "angel" face of Steve Roger, he have a big noise and have a really special face, he can be handsome, but he is not clearly the "perfect" man like Steve Roger.

Pretty much. Rogers should be a modern-day Robert Redford. Only bigger physically.

[FlawlessVictory]

Acting > appearance.

Why can't we have both? Why do I need to compromise one for the other?

[ultimatefan]

Imo it's not the same thing, Ledger have lot of make up, Jackman is in fact too tall but he can look like Wolverine (black hairs and dark eyes) and for Keaton, Batman is more important that Bruce Wayne, unlike Captain America, this character have clearly a double identity, there are also the fact that Keaton have a strange look who could fit with the weird world of Batman.

But Krasinski don't look like Steve Roger imo, and Steve Roger is Captain America, his physical appareance is very important like Superman, because he is the symbol of a perfect human against the so-called superior race (the nazi).
He don't have the perfect "angel" face of Steve Roger, he have a big noise and have a really special face, he can be handsome, but he is not clearly the "perfect" man like Steve Roger.

And a lot of fanboys used similar arguments against these other choices, like that it was important that Bruce Wayne was a babe magnet playboy due to his facade, or that Wolverine being short was a trademark of the character and maybe part of his rage was a form of compensation, etc.

I´m not a fan of Krasinski as Cap myself, but I´ve followed these movies long enough to know that sometimes choices that seem absurd when they´re announced end up working.

[Stripesy Strip]

All of you complaining about him not being the perfect man, you have a flaw in this argument. No man is the perfect man, so casting the perfect man is impossible. If you're talking about a model, they can't act and even they are not "the perfect man." Stop getting hung on this idea of him not looking perfect and look at his acting chops. If he can act like Steve Rogers and have that "it" factor and natural leadership ability, he is Captain America. Screw the "perfect man" look. Acting > appearance.

Christopher Reeve was the perfect man.