The Official Superman Casting & Discussion Thread

[Project862006]

25- 30 supes is what we should get - hammer fits there

Bale was 30 when he was cast as Batman

[Dark Raven]

After watching Chuck last night I'm kind of thinking Zack Levi might be an out of the box choice! He has the height, voice and mannerisms to pull it off! If anyone has a screen shot of him with Clark glasses from last night you would know what I mean.
:word:

Levi is listed as 6'4", yet he looks taller on screen than Lou Ferrigno, who is apparently 6'5". Has Ferrigno shrunk? And if so, how is that possible? Or was he never really 6'5"?

[Red Cherry Lips]

I can tell you all this, forget all these other names mentioned, especially those guys who have their own thread. An announcement will made soon that Armie Hammer has been cast as the Man of Steel. What the public doesn't know is being kept under wraps. Details are being worked out right now, multiple picture deals etc. long process. Hammer threw everyone that curve ball the other day for a reason. You'll all know why he said that soon. Everything is calculated in Hollywood.

Stay tuned.

http://lh6.ggpht.com/_lLsdaCVk3Kk/SQpR7f3uZNI/AAAAAAAAno4/EHVeGArX98Q/ArmieHammer05.jpg :supes:

Be sweet in my book if this comes true.

[Night Owl]

I think he would be amazing as Supes :wow:

http://img13.imageshack.us/img13/1513/armiesup.jpg

[Eze]

Back when Glasses weren't his disguise? :huh:

No, back when Clark Kent wasn't the most muscular guy working at the Daily Planet.

But the best part of Golden Age Superman is his work ethic.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_vj2e1m7Hlgw/S--Imk_hK7I/AAAAAAAAlvA/vEH2PAXWzp8/s400/golden+age+superman+2.jpg
Whoa there Superman, easy big fella.

http://xroads.virginia.edu/~ug02/yeung/actioncomics/images/page2.jpg

Here Superman is racing to get a confession that he strong-armed from the blonde woman to the governor. Notice the manner in which he hoists the poor civil servant overhead? Boy Scout my @ss.

Superman used to be a pulp hero, the ultimate tough guy. I'd rather see an interpretation of that character, than yet another rehash of Messiah Clark and his woeful trek from Smallville to find his place in the World.

Now he'll be planning revenge on those responsible for Krypton's destruction!:whatever:

Golden> Modern.

[Zack Snyder]

I think he would be amazing as Supes :wow:

http://img13.imageshack.us/img13/1513/armiesup.jpg

:up: His face looks like Superman there. Nice.

[GoblinWhirlwind]

He has the same dead behind the eyes look in every picture I've seen. Man, I hope he doesn't get it.

[Zack Snyder]

I'm not that familiar with Hammer's acting. I'm just commenting that in that manip, his face works for Superman.

[GoblinWhirlwind]

I've never seen him in anything myself, personally I just don't like how he looks. He looks like a Ken doll in that church picture someone posted.

[Parker Wayne]

^ Well I have have seen in him in films and he's not as stoic as you think. He was great in the social network and this short film I've seen with him in it.

[SuperMike335!!]

Levi is listed as 6'4", yet he looks taller on screen than Lou Ferrigno, who is apparently 6'5". Has Ferrigno shrunk? And if so, how is that possible? Or was he never really 6'5"?

Lou is almost 60 years old.

[SuperMike335!!]

After watching Chuck last night I'm kind of thinking Zack Levi might be an out of the box choice! He has the height, voice and mannerisms to pull it off! If anyone has a screen shot of him with Clark glasses from last night you would know what I mean.
:word:


I'd be ok with him too.

I'm finding better and better choices being suggested here.

Ryan McPartlin is my current favorite, but not so far ahead that if a guy like Levi, or Hammer got picked I would be dissapointed in any way.

[Rick-El]

Of all the suggestions so far, Daniel Cudmore has the best look for what I want in a new Superman. He will be 31 in 2012, is 6' 8'' (will require a bit of camera trickery), and has a fantastic build and presence. The only thing I am not so sure of are his acting chops (please give your opinions, those who have seen his work).

I firmly believe if Snyder & Nolan can work their magic with Cudmore, this movie could be awesome! http://www.**************.com/images/users/uploads/15614/DanielCudmore_medium.jpg
http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Superman.jpg

[GG44]

me again...sorry.

Lets be real here:

Superman Begins needs its bale. A fantastic actor who can embody superman and bring real emotion to the role and just "known" enough for some...

Being that suits always have a say and if they do want younger actor for story reasons AND sequels, acting wise our best bets are:

RYAN GOSLING or JAKE GYLLENHALLCavill.

You don't have to stray as far from "the look" as Gosling or Gyllenhaal to get what you're describing.

[Parker Wayne]

Welcome to the hype, I guess you don't know the rule about "Those who must not be named" around here yet.

[Rick-El]

A few more pics

http://www.examiner.com/images/blog/EXID13198/images/Daniel_Cudmore_blue_shirt_sitting_small.jpg
http://www.contactmusic.com/pics/lc/new_moon_la_prem_14_171109/daniel_cudmore_5387304.jpg
http://idolmag.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/TestBP-3-copybnw.jpg

[Slugster]

I wouldnt mind Hammer as Sups at all but... I will believe it when I ee it.

[SuperMike335!!]

Of all the suggestions so far, Daniel Cudmore has the best look for what I want in a new Superman. He will be 31 in 2012, is 6' 8'' (will require a bit of camera trickery), and has a fantastic build and presence. The only thing I am not so sure of are his acting chops (please give your opinions, those who have seen his work).

I firmly believe if Snyder & Nolan can work their magic with Cudmore, this movie could be awesome!


He has stated his height is actually 6'7". His build looks a lot like that of Joe Manganiello, but Cudmore has a better face for the role, IMHO.

Most of Cudmore's roles, that I know of, he tends to have very few speaking lines.

Not that this means he cannot handle more challenging roles, simply he has not been given any yet. Curse of his towering stature.

So, IF he were to audition and hit it out of the park, as in turn out to have some strong acting talent, then his height would not be an issue for the Superman part of the role.

It would however be getting into the area of needing a few camera tricks, and other things to cheat, and hide his height while playing the Clark role.

Little things like have a step stool for other actors when needed for face to face shots with Clark.

The Clark shoes would need to have flat soles, so he is hardly taller than his barefoot height. He would also need to hold his posture in a way that takes 1-2" off his height.

Having the other actors around Clark with a 2-3" shoe lift would be a smart idea too.

Here is a picture of Clint Walker, 6'6", and an example of a very simple old school trick, to make other guys look closer to Clint's height.

http://img510.imageshack.us/img510/8275/146711e8358a2089large.jpg

So other than the production team having to use a couple old school height hiding tricks for the Clark scenes, I'm fine with giving Cudmore a serious Audition, and would not complain if they cast him.

[Slugster]

I will fix the pic above see you in a bit.

[GG44]

Welcome to the hype, I guess you don't know the rule about "Those who must not be named" around here yet.What do you mean? Oh, and thanks for the welcome :)

[SuperMike335!!]

What do you mean?

He meant read the stickies. There are 3 names that have already been given their own threads, because those three kept hijacking this one to the point nobody else was getting talked about between endless pages of picture spamming.

[Parker Wayne]

No mentions of Cavil, Routh, or Weiling as Superman. There are separate forums for those 3.

[Eze]

So with a big man like Cudmore, Manganiello, or Hammer we can expect the rest of the cast to be running around in something like this?

http://www.tvworthwatching.com/blog/2010/03/31/GLEE-10-Stilts.jpg

Ya that'll look natural.:doh:

Up in the sky, LOOK!
It's a bird!
No, it's a plane!
No, it's Rick Malambri!

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_ImkJ9Ym4Byc/TE3GkRud0PI/AAAAAAAAA3s/IpLNckNgOhI/s400/Rick%2BMalambri.jpg

http://cdn.buzznet.com/media-cdn/jj1/headlines/2009/12/rick-malambri-august-man-december-2009.jpg

An unknown you could believe in.

[Slugster]

an update
http://img838.imageshack.us/img838/1513/armiesup.jpg

[Eze]

Creepy perv who doesn't look like Superman. It's Hammer's face man, not you.

[Slugster]

RYAN GOSLING or JAKE GYLLENHALL
:doh:WHAT!?:facepalm:oh brother........

[M.O.Steel]

Not that I know of, nope. Where did you get the info from?

i'll look for it.

[Night Owl]

I will fix the pic above see you in a bit.

Fix??? Heres a thought. Do your own!!

[Zack Snyder]

Scary to think they probably will consider Jake :-/

[RachelDawes]

Scary to think they probably will consider Jake :-/

Not scary at all, really. I think he's got the likability for the role, I'm just not sure he could play an intimidating Superman.

[Zack Snyder]

Many people just don't find his face all that good for Superman. However there is that looming feeling that he will be in contention for this. If he got it, hope they get him to look right for the part.

[GG44]

He meant read the stickies. There are 3 names that have already been given their own threads, because those three kept hijacking this one to the point nobody else was getting talked about between endless pages of picture spamming.Oh, okay...

But isn't there a reason why those 3 would get discussed the most? That's meaningful if you ask me. Routh and Welling have played Superman before so of course they'd get that much support, but Cavill getting support to that extent and not even playing the part yet, that means something I think.

But okay, I won't mention him again... Shhhh...

[DorkyFresh]

Jake was Nolan's 2nd pick for Batman......but i think he's far more suited for Superman. if he had a more manly face i would love to see him play Superman. if he ends up playing Superman, i won't complain....but i know of a couple of other actors that are better suited for the role just based on looks alone.

But okay, I won't mention him again... Shhhh...
some people are just rule nazies. i saw one of the mods say that you can mention their names in passing, but don't make it a consistent occurrence. their names often end up hijacking the thread so just keep it to a minimum...that's why they've made their own individual threads.

btw, welcome to the hype

[GG44]

Jake was Nolan's 2nd pick for Batman......but i think he's far more suited for Superman. if he had a more manly face i would love to see him play Superman. if he ends up playing Superman, i won't complain....but i know of a couple of other actors that are better suited for the role just based on looks alone.


some people are just rule nazies. i saw one of the mods say that you can mention their names in passing, but don't make it a consistent occurrence. their names often end up hijacking the thread so just keep it to a minimum...that's why they've made their own individual threads.

btw, welcome to the hype

Thanks.

I'll follow the rules, but it's definitely kind of weird, though, that the actor who's obviously best-suited for the role can't even be mentioned in the "Superman casting" thread, but I guess that's why he has his own thread on a board where he's never even played Superman before, being that perfect for the role and having that much support.

Cool, cool.

[Asgard]

I cant get behind Jake for Supes. Not feeling it at all.

Plus theres the whole *********** going against him.

[Karelia]

I really don't see Jake as Superman either.

I really hope they cast somebody before the end of this year. :D

[Adenjo]

Any actor that gets the role has to have done "something" to impress the director, I can't see any director casting the wrong actor in the role of Superman, afterall who wants to be known as the man who buried Superman?

There's a lot of names being thrown around in this thread, some I can see in the role.. Some IMHO I can't.. So here's my current top 3

1. Armie Hammer, He has the look, can bulk up, i've seen him act.
2. Daniel Cudmore, based purely on his look, give him blue contacts, darken his hair and you have Superman.
3. Brandon Routh, unlikely he'll get the job after SR, but I still like the bloke.

[AntMan]

Goyer had high praise for Superman: Earth One, and if that's the type of Superman they're going for Hammer would be perfect. Otherwise, I would like someone else.

[7heBoss]

Jake was Nolan's 2nd pick for Batman......but i think he's far more suited for Superman. if he had a more manly face i would love to see him play Superman. if he ends up playing Superman, i won't complain....but i know of a couple of other actors that are better suited for the role just based on looks alone.


some people are just rule nazies. i saw one of the mods say that you can mention their names in passing, but don't make it a consistent occurrence. their names often end up hijacking the thread so just keep it to a minimum...that's why they've made their own individual threads.

btw, welcome to the hype

yeah, but i don't if all mods think the same way. because i've seen people get hit with probation for subtly dropping one of the names. oh well, i guess one just has to be careful

[Dark Raven]

Wasn't Daniel Cudmore Colossus in the X-Men movies?

[LadyVader]

I've got nothing against any of the suggestions so far, EXCEPT for Armie Hammer. I don't know. I just don't like his mug, and though it may seem shallow, I don't want them to give it to the rich kid. :p

I'm getting a deja vu feeling from the days of the Spiderman casting threads, where Logan Lerman seemed to be the fan favorite, but I just didn't like the kid. And let's hope the Superman casting will be just as fortunate as it was for Spiderman. And I'm not saying that just because Andrew Garfield was my pick for the part. As luck would have it, he was just the right guy for the job.

[x-fan]

Well I learned something, never come back to a thread that you haven't been to since they were casting SR and post in an offical casting thread. I never thought there would be a rule against certain actors being named. well two things, read the thread in question, instead of seeing that there is a director attached and simply posting my thought. Silly me, A warning would have been nice, a quick and painful ban for something I was unaware of wasn't very nice. I know C J wa just doing what he thought was right, but sometimes things aren't as clear cut as some people assume. That being said. its a shame that a TV show has the best cast and the movies can't seem to get it right.

[MechaOrga]

Not scary at all, really. I think he's got the likability for the role, I'm just not sure he could play an intimidating Superman.

if you have seen him lately, he looks way more mature then he used to. and "intimidating" may not be an issude if we are going for young, hipster/ emo earth one supes.

Like i said his biggest minus is his voice. its a bit high...

TO ALL:

My point with posting Gosling and Jake is to have us try and think like a studio that doesn't want to take a giant huge chance with casting (like Cudmore/Joe M/and he who must not be named)

I mean they HIRED ZACK FREAKING SNYDER to direct, not Aronofsky.

I say lets get an already GREAT ACTOR and not try to make one from the endless list of, although cool, practically unknowns...

[Eze]

... "intimidating" may not be an issue if we are going for young, hipster/ emo earth one supes...

Scariest thing about this, you could be right. Superman: Earth One was probably preemptive revisionism, so this time when the movie comes out nobody can say it's not faithful to the new "source material."

http://www2.pictures.zimbio.com/gi/Dizzy+Feet+Foundation+Inaugural+Celebration+C16YkH W_OZWl.jpg

Rick > Armie

He's only 6'2", and he actually resembles Superman, unlike Joe M, or Hammertime. Cudmore is a sideshow freak at 6'8" so he's not viable either.

http://www.mentalfloss.com/quiz/uploads/1190608788346.jpg

RICK, RICK, RICK!!!

[RachelDawes]

if you have seen him lately, he looks way more mature then he used to. and "intimidating" may not be an issude if we are going for young, hipster/ emo earth one supes.

Like i said his biggest minus is his voice. its a bit high...

He's going to have to put the fear of God into the villain at some point. I hope he can lower his voice since a high pitch won't scare even a little baby.

[Eze]

... have us try and think like a studio...

Eww. Ick. No.

We're striving to overcome mediocrity, not embrace it.

[Gianakin_]

Scariest thing about this, you could be right. Superman: Earth One was probably preemptive revisionism, so this time when the movie comes out nobody can say it's not faithful to the new "source material."

Rick > Armie

He's only 6'2", and he actually resembles Superman, unlike Joe M, or Hammertime. Cudmore is a sideshow freak at 6'8" so he's not viable either.


RICK, RICK, RICK!!!

Who's this guy? He looks a lot like Superman!

[SuperMike335!!]

Who's this guy? He looks a lot like Superman!

That would be Rick Malambri.

He was in Step it Up 3D, and was also an arm piece for Paris hilton.

I think he has a boyish look to his face, due to his tiny Judi Jetson nose thing going on.

Other than that he has the strong Jawline, and otherwise masculine look. I think he would be worth an audtion.

Not sure about his acting ability, but then that is for the casting director to decide on.

[Eze]

Who's this guy? He looks a lot like Superman!

Rick Malambri.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_ImkJ9Ym4Byc/TE3GkRud0PI/AAAAAAAAA3s/IpLNckNgOhI/s400/Rick%2BMalambri.jpg

Flying high, not sure what the problem is with his nose...but this is a complaint from someone who wants...this.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cb/Ryan_McPartlin_by_Gage_Skidmore.jpg

http://images.allmoviephoto.com/2009_Super_Capers/2009_super_capers_008.jpg

Talk about a wardrobe malfunction.:doh:

[SuperMike335!!]

Rick Malambri.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_ImkJ9Ym4Byc/TE3GkRud0PI/AAAAAAAAA3s/IpLNckNgOhI/s400/Rick%2BMalambri.jpg

Flying high, not sure what the problem is with his nose...but this is a complaint from someone who wants...this.

Talk about a wardrobe malfunction.:doh:

Learn to re-size images before posting please.

What the heck is with you using Strawman tactics to make an argument?

Going out of your way to find the worst pictures you can find of someone to make your argument?

I cleary said that I had no issue with Malambri auditioning, and that he has an otherwise masculine face.

[Eze]

Are oversized pics a no-no? My bad, I'm new here. How do i Do that?

I didn't go out of my way at all to find bad pictures of Ryan M, practically tripped over them. Blondes don't have the same bone structure as brunettes, that's why they don't resemble Superman.

[Zack Snyder]

As for Rick...

People gave Routh a hard time for limited experience but at least he had some :eek: Not to mention a decent voice for Clark/Superman.

I'm not even a Routh supporter. Just noticed the comparison. Let's aim higher in terms of acting ability this time.

[SuperMike335!!]

Are oversized pics a no-no? My bad, I'm new here. How do i Do that?

I didn't go out of my way at all to find bad pictures of Ryan M, practically tripped over them. Blondes don't have the same bone structure as brunettes, that's why they don't resemble Superman.


They don't huh?

Care to post any such proof of this?

Or is this "fact" just your opinion, because I don't believe you.

[JAK®]

A review I read for Step Up 3D said that Melambri was a noticeably bad actor, even when taking into account the usual acting quality of the series...

[Eze]

I hear an echo...

Routh could act b4 SR? :doh: Maybe in YHO, not mine.

I don gotta "proove" nothin to no Ryan M fan club prez wanna be, with daddy issues cause he needs a giant big strong Superman to climb the empire state building and save teh world.:fhm:

[Project862006]

well yes you do lol

atleast other chocies like hammer/hamm/cavill/etc. are good actors and are proven

sorry if we dont jump in open arms to mr step up 3D

[Eze]

A review I read for Step Up 3D said that Melambri was a noticeably bad actor, even when taking into account the usual acting quality of the series...

I just watched a trailer where he delivered more lines than Routh did in SR.

Malambri ain't no Brando, but he's a step up from where Routh was. Why else do you think Routh had no dialogue with Spacy? Step Up 3d may be crap, but it's still experience in a lead role that most other candidates don't have.

If there's gonna be some kind of acting benchmrk in place than no more Cudmore, or McPartin either.:woot:

[C. Lee]

I hear an echo...

Routh could act b4 SR? :doh: Maybe in YHO, not mine.

I don gotta "proove" nothin to no Ryan M fan club prez wanna be, with daddy issues cause he needs a giant big strong Superman to climb the empire state building and save teh world.:fhm:

We can do without the snarky comments towards people who don't have the same choice as you do. Keep it civil.

[Eze]

well yes you do lol

atleast other chocies like hammer/hamm/cavill/etc. are good actors and are proven

sorry if we dont jump in open arms to mr step up 3D

Mike is askin me to prove nordic cheekbones differ from swarthy brunettes.

Hamm is proven, I'd go for that. Hammer is not, good job supporting, never been lead, doesn't resemble Superman, cept he's tall. Thank god i don't have to address Cavill in this thread.

As far as unknowns go, Mr. Step Up 3D is a top contender. But I don't consider unknowns to trump "actors", hopefully a leading man will take up the job. Hammer ain't no leading man.

[Eze]

We can do without the snarky comments towards people who don't have the same choice as you do. Keep it civil.

Fair enuff, I apologize SuperMike335!!

[Slugster]

Fix??? Heres a thought. Do your own!!

I do my own all the time I was helping with the part on the head.
I was not trying to disrespect anyone, just trying to help.
If I upset someone then I'm sorry.

[Project862006]

Mike is askin me to prove nordic cheekbones differ from swarthy brunettes.

Hamm is proven, I'd go for that. Hammer is not, good job supporting, never been lead, doesn't resemble Superman, cept he's tall. Thank god i don't have to address Cavill in this thread.

As far as unknowns go, Mr. Step Up 3D is a top contender. But I don't consider unknowns to trump "actors", hopefully a leading man will take up the job. Hammer ain't no leading man.
WHAT LOL so Rick is more proven for superman because he played the lead in Step Up 3D even Tho Hammer was phenomenal in The social Network

He may even get a nomination but because he was not the lead(even tho the Twins played a gigantic part in the story)

:dry:

[M.O.Steel]

this rick guy isn't bad.

here's the thing, jake G could make a decent superman, but i think he is so associated with other things that it would be hard to take him as superman seriously. but if he were a brand new guy that no one has ever heard of, with the right size, he could be good.

but just like price of persia, far from my top choices

[Eze]

WHAT LOL so Rick is more proven for superman because he played the lead in Step Up 3D even Tho Hammer was phenomenal in The social Network

He may even get a nomination but because he was not the lead(even tho the Twins played a gigantic part in the story)

:dry:

Nomination for what? Marketting accolade to precede his name because he's about to begin a multi-picture contract? Why else do you think they award themselves but to have that nominee precurser, or even better, Award winning actor/actress.

Puh-leeze, spare me this mockery of greatness called award winning performer.

Hammer doesn't look like Superman, his Clark would be 6'5"(sore thumb), and he has never played a lead role. For no other reason than building upon Social Network Hype, is Hammer a candidate.

Malambri very much resembles Superman without looking like Reeve. 6'2" so his Clark won't be a giant goon, and has lead role experience good or bad, it's experience Hammer ain't got.

CR said the most important thing about getting Superman right is not over acting, letting the suit and the action sell the character. Hammer can't do that, cause he looks like a giant Jimmy Olsen. Possibly a performance could be coaxed outta Malambri, but we'd need plastic surgery for Hammer.

[Adenjo]

Eze, did you by any chance see Hammer when he played in the tv show "Reaper"?
No hint of "Jimmy Olson" there at all.

[Dark Raven]

Although Hammer hasn't played a lead role in a major movie, he did play the lead role as Billy Graham in a TV movie, which would require some acting skills.

That said, i don't think Hammer resembles Superman at all, and would prefer not to have him in the role.

[MechaOrga]

here's the thing, jake G could make a decent superman, but i think he is so associated with other things that it would be hard to take him as superman seriously. but if he were a brand new guy that no one has ever heard of, with the right size, he could be good.

but just like price of persia, far from my top choices

I agree..i bring him up as well as Gosling as "studio" choices...

I actually think acting and voice wise, gosling would be better but thats IMO...

[GreenKToo]

Yee-Haaw, gotta love casting wars. I'm just waiting on some real choices to make the rounds. Things will really heat up then.

[Adenjo]

Just wait till we get an official shortlist :D

[cronosred]

I don't get the whole "This actor doesn't resemble Superman" thing, hasn't Superman been drawn differently many, many, many times over the years and portrayed by many actors who don't look alike? Why is it all of a sudden people are acting like Superman has had only one look which the actor who is hired has to fit?

[archangel_jay]

http://www.flickr.com/photos/26030812@N02/2568520701/ this needs manipping

http://www.flickr.com/photos/35377429@N03/3407163775/

if not welling or routh then the two above are my pics with perhaps garrett hedlund, patrick wilson as outside chances

[GreenKToo]

Just wait till we get an official shortlist :D
it's gonna be good.:word:

[Project862006]

leading experience lol

so does lindsey lohan want her for supes too

[JAK®]

Quick manip of Hammer:

http://i456.photobucket.com/albums/qq282/JAKSaph/hammerman.jpg

Doesn't look too bad.

[Eze]

Quick manip of Hammer:

http://i456.photobucket.com/albums/qq282/JAKSaph/hammerman.jpg

Doesn't look too bad.

He looks like he just got some synthetic kryptonite from this guy...

http://dummr.files.wordpress.com/2009/10/dave-chappelle.jpg

I say this mostly due to his pasty complexion, buggy eyes and bags underneath.

[Astrodust]

Hamm doesn't have a bad look for Superman but it worries me that every pic I've seen of him has him sporting a 5 O'Clock shadow. I think it's genetics too. That and the fact that he would be fairly old if they were planning a trilogy. Staying in shape at 45 is no easy task.

[Man of Steel]

How about Tahmoh Penikett(Battlestar Galactica)? Great actor, 6'3" and looks exactly like the Man of Steel. My second choice, after he-who-must-return-but-cannot-be-named-in-this-thread(hint: rhymes with south).

[Eze]

Oh hells ya, Nice find!

second thot, kinda dopey when he smiles. Worth an audition tho.

[Rust]

Why not? He looks different and otherworldly. And super(hu)man'ish.

But yeah, I seem to remember something funky about his smile.

[SuperMike335!!]

How about Tahmoh Penikett(Battlestar Galactica)? Great actor, 6'3" and looks exactly like the Man of Steel. My second choice, after he-who-must-return-but-cannot-be-named-in-this-thread(hint: rhymes with south).

Tahmoh Penikett is another one I can see working.

So far my list then:

1. Ryan McPartlin
2. Joe Manganiello
3. Armie Hammer
4. Patrick Wilson
5. Tahmoh Penikett
6. Michael Trucco
7. Daniel Cudmore

There are likely a lot of others that would work just as well, that none of us are thinking about.

Be nice if WB just got to casting.

[GoblinWhirlwind]

Hamm doesn't have a bad look for Superman but it worries me that every pic I've seen of him has him sporting a 5 O'Clock shadow. I think it's genetics too. That and the fact that he would be fairly old if they were planning a trilogy. Staying in shape at 45 is no easy task.

Yeah, Hamm is probably the only man with a beard that needs to be shaved often. Have you seen a single ep of Mad Men? Staying in shape at 45? Sly Stallone isn't that far from 70. Unless you've been fat your entire life, you can easily get in shape at 45.

[JamalYIgle]

http://FunnyOrDie.com/m/4o49
Armie Hammer for the Win

[MAN O STEEL]

Sly Stallone isn't that far from 70. Unless you've been fat your entire life, you can easily get in shape at 45.


You don't quite understand how physical fitness works do you?. Sly has been in good shape since his early 30's. Once a certain amount of years go by it comes down to simply maintaining. Which is actually not quite as physically daunting as first getting into shape. Sly can do it at 65 because he's been fit most of his life. Hamm on the other hand has most probably never lifted a weight in his life & the older you get, the less likely you are to ever attempt it successfully. Getting in shape for the very first time in your life, is as hard as passing a stone. It's hard for alot of people in their 20's let alone someone who's just snuck over 40. Keep that in mind mate.




Steve

[GoblinWhirlwind]

You don't quite understand how physical fitness works do you?. Sly has been in good shape since his early 30's. Once a certain amount of years go by it comes down to simply maintaining. Which is actually not quite as physically daunting as first getting into shape. Sly can do it at 65 because he's been fit most of his life. Hamm on the other hand has most probably never lifted a weight in his life & the older you get, the less likely you are to ever attempt it successfully. Getting in shape for the very first time in your life, is as hard as passing a stone. It's hard for alot of people in their 20's let alone someone who's just snuck over 40. Keep that in mind mate.




Steve

Keep your condescending comments to yourself. I'm 24 myself, and I've lifted weights for about ten years. I know all about the trials and tribulations of getting started. Age plays a part in it, but half of the game is mental. If you have the motivation, you can do it.

[Karelia]

Which Hamm doesn't seem to have. Because he keeps saying he's "too old" for the part, anyways.

[Astrodust]

Stallone also admits to doing steroids. Not every actor is willing to do steroids. That's like saying every bodybuilder is willing to do steroids. Some are very against it. And I'm talking pros. They do enter natural bodybuilding competitions though.

[batlovescatDC]

Every time I come here people just keep getting more immature. I cannot wait until Snyder actually casts the role so we can stop hearing all this whining.

[GinsterHead]

Every time I come here people just keep getting more immature. I cannot wait until Snyder actually casts the role so we can stop hearing all this whining.

It'll never stop. EVER. :wow::oldrazz:

[Karelia]

I'm just really curious who they're going to pick. Whoever it is, I know I'll go see the movie, even if I don't like the actor. I'm going to see it for Superman, not "so and so" actor.

[Denny67]

I did not read through the 154 replies but IMO it does not matter. The character is from another planet. As long as whoever plays the role portrays it faithfully, delivers are solid performance, and physically looks the part. I could care less about who they are in real life or where they were born.

[Astrodust]

Every time I come here people just keep getting more immature. I cannot wait until Snyder actually casts the role so we can stop hearing all this whining.

Actually most people here are pretty civil compared to other forums. The thing is everyone has their favorites on who they want to play Superman. I'd rather differing opinions on subjects than a single one. If people didn't have different ideas for casting Superman, I would never get to see some of these inspired choices. Also people make too big a deal when people get into arguments. Unless their is bad language, people should be allowed to be passionate about their choices. Forums have always been a round table discussion to me. It's the same as having a conversation with a circle of friends.

[batlovescatDC]

I have absolutely no problem with debates and different opinions. That's what I come on here for is to discuss things. But when it gets to the point where I see some of the most childish comments I've ever seen in my life posted on here, I'm embarrassed to even be associated with these forums at those times.

[Astrodust]

I have absolutely no problem with debates and different opinions. That's what I come on here for is to discuss things. But when it gets to the point where I see some of the most childish comments I've ever seen in my life posted on here, I'm embarrassed to even be associated with these forums at those times.

You'll have to be more specific. I imagine the age group for a superhero forum is quite a range. People come here cause they are fans. I'm not saying people aren't childish but unless people are cursing with each other, what's wrong with being a little silly. I'd say there is the kid in us in most people on this forum.

[DV8]

http://blog.zap2it.com/thedishrag/legacyimages/photos/uncategorized/2008/07/24/adriangrenier.jpg

I'm just gonna throw Adrien Grenier out there as a possibility . . . he's a pretty good actor, can definitely pull off Supes but I've yet to see him in a Clark Kent type of role . . . flame away, fanboys Lol . . . "his hair is too curly" I can hear it already . . .

[batlovescatDC]

I hear an echo...

Routh could act b4 SR? :doh: Maybe in YHO, not mine.

I don gotta "proove" nothin to no Ryan M fan club prez wanna be, with daddy issues cause he needs a giant big strong Superman to climb the empire state building and save teh world.:fhm:


Astrodust... Get what I'm talking about now? I've been on these forums for six years and the immaturity gets worse all the time.

[M.O.Steel]

Every time I come here people just keep getting more immature. I cannot wait until Snyder actually casts the role so we can stop hearing all this whining.

you think that will stop people from whinning?

welling, cavill. why are we still even talking about these individuals? it will never end

[C. Lee]

Astrodust... Get what I'm talking about now? I've been on these forums for six years and the immaturity gets worse all the time.

And if you noticed...I warned him about that.

[batlovescatDC]

you think that will stop people from whinning?

welling, cavill. why are we still even talking about these individuals? it will never end

You raise a very good point my friend. And C. Lee... I didn't notice that at first. Just starts getting on your nerves after a while.

[Alonsovich]

Every time I come here people just keep getting more immature. I cannot wait until Snyder actually casts the role so we can stop hearing all this whining.

Actually that's when it's going to START FOR REAL... :o

[Mostpowerful]

http://FunnyOrDie.com/m/4o49
Armie Hammer for the Win

So that's how he sounds like. He doesn't sound like Superman, his voice is too deep. He comes off as too dark. He sounds like... Batman. He has a decent look, but like others have said, he looks too soft. Not impressed. He may be a good actor, but he doesn't scream Superman to me at all.

[Compi716]

http://blog.zap2it.com/thedishrag/legacyimages/photos/uncategorized/2008/07/24/adriangrenier.jpg

I'm just gonna throw Adrien Grenier out there as a possibility . . . he's a pretty good actor, can definitely pull off Supes but I've yet to see him in a Clark Kent type of role . . . flame away, fanboys Lol . . . "his hair is too curly" I can hear it already . . .
He is literally the only person that would actually prevent me from seeing the new movie.

[That person]

If they're going older, how about Michael Trucco?
http://images.eonline.com/eol_images/Entire_Site/20080807/300.trucco.michael.080708.jpg

[Eze]

And if you noticed...I warned him about that.

I guess nobody noticed I already apologized on my own for that. Ah well...

Grenier? No audition.

Trucco, definitely. Not sure what that Hammer vid is supposed to illustrate, other than Armie plays a very convincing frat boy d-bag.

[JAK®]

Trucco, definitely. Not sure what that Hammer vid is supposed to illustrate, other than Armie plays a very convincing frat boy d-bag.
Which has sealed his fate when it comes to the opinions of internet nerds...

[C. Lee]

I guess nobody noticed I already apologized on my own for that. Ah well...

Actually....if you check out post #3810 http://forums.superherohype.com/showpost.php?p=19132109&postcount=3810 you will see that you apologize after I tell you comments like that aren't needed and for you to act civil.

[Eze]

Yes, but you didn't tell me to apologize. I came up with that on my own, which was the point I was making. Immature people rarely own up to their mistakes.

Which has sealed his fate when it comes to the opinions of internet nerds...

So then I guess ipso facto...you are calling me names now?

[Project862006]

Eze has'nt even been here a month and starting trouble lol

[Eze]

My only crime is luvin \S/ too much, but I'll remember to play nice.

[Venomfan]

Not sure what that Hammer vid is supposed to illustrate, other than Armie plays a very convincing frat boy d-bag.
i can't watch the video, so just by going what you say, doesn't that mean he's a very good actor? to be very convincing is the goal

[C. Lee]

Yes, but you didn't tell me to apologize. I came up with that on my own, which was the point I was making. Immature people rarely own up to their mistakes.

Coming up with the idea on your own would have entailed you making the apology BEFORE I said anything about it. You didn't make it until after I said something....thus, you didn't come up with it on your own. You picked up from my post to you that I was not pleased with the attitude, tone, or the intent.

[Project862006]

^ its a funny or die skit he is being comedic

[Project862006]

^ its a funny or die skit he is being comedic

[SuperDaniel]

If they`re going for an older Superman, Trucco is the best choice, IMO. He oozes Superman in everyway. You should watch a tru calling episode in which he plays a fireman. You can`t get more Superman like than that.

[Eze]

Coming up with the idea on your own would have entailed you making the apology BEFORE I said anything about it. You didn't make it until after I said something....thus, you didn't come up with it on your own. You picked up from my post to you that I was not pleased with the attitude, tone, or the intent.

Yes, but I didn't have to apologize, I could have just walked away. I chose to acknowledge you were right and I was wrong, and attempted to make it right with SuperMike. That doesn't mean anything to you in the grand scheme of things, my loss.

Venomfan, you could be right, I'm a little weary of disagreeing with anyone atm so sure, why not Hammer.:whatever:

[GreenKToo]

Trucco would be great..he was my main pick from last year. Him, hamm, or hammer, it doesn't matter.

[I Am The Knight]

http://blog.zap2it.com/thedishrag/legacyimages/photos/uncategorized/2008/07/24/adriangrenier.jpg

I'm just gonna throw Adrien Grenier out there as a possibility . . . he's a pretty good actor, can definitely pull off Supes but I've yet to see him in a Clark Kent type of role . . . flame away, fanboys Lol . . . "his hair is too curly" I can hear it already . . .

Ugh....I guess this is the moment when I press the "ignore" button...

[I Am The Knight]

Michael Trucco has a great look, although he reminds me a bit of a "happy Bale" if you follow my meaning. That could be good, though...

[Sawyer]

Waaay too douchey for Supes.

Grenier, that is. Not Trucco.

[MAN O STEEL]

Keep your condescending comments to yourself.


No. Learn to know what your talking about in future.




Steve

[GreenKToo]

Michael Trucco has a great look, although he reminds me a bit of a "happy Bale" if you follow my meaning. That could be good, though...
It doesn't matter anyway. we can wish cast all we want but at the end of the day, the pick will probably cause a ''holy shet, I didnt see that one coming'' moment. I'd love for trucco to get it tho.

[JamalYIgle]

So that's how he sounds like. He doesn't sound like Superman, his voice is too deep. He comes off as too dark. He sounds like... Batman. He has a decent look, but like others have said, he looks too soft. Not impressed. He may be a good actor, but he doesn't scream Superman to me at all.

it's called acting.

[Project862006]

so supes cant have a deep voice lol

[Karelia]

so supes cant have a deep voice lol

Nope, he can have a semi-deep voice. :oldrazz:

[FilmNerdJamie]

Considering how great he was in The Social Network, Hammer would be fine as Supes/Clark Kent.

[M.O.Steel]

You don't quite understand how physical fitness works do you?. Sly has been in good shape since his early 30's. Once a certain amount of years go by it comes down to simply maintaining. Which is actually not quite as physically daunting as first getting into shape. Sly can do it at 65 because he's been fit most of his life. Hamm on the other hand has most probably never lifted a weight in his life & the older you get, the less likely you are to ever attempt it successfully. Getting in shape for the very first time in your life, is as hard as passing a stone. It's hard for alot of people in their 20's let alone someone who's just snuck over 40. Keep that in mind mate.




Steve

what is with you, buddy? you're usually a nice guy. where is all this coming from?:huh:

while it is true with muscle memory that it is easier for people like sly and arnold to get in shape than the average joe even at 60+ years, it is not out of reach for jon hamm to achieve a good level. he actually has a great build, and it will be easy for him to get in shape too even at 40. similar to ben affleck and RDJ, while they don't have the body-building physiques from age 20, it is not out of potential for hamm to reach a nice solid level of fitness and muscle definition, even at his age. it is true that it is way easier for any given person to reach the same goals at age 20 than age 40, but with the right trainer, training regiment, and nutrition, it is absolutely not out of reach for him, even if he never stepped inside a gym his whole life, which I find hard to believe considering he played football, baseball, and swimming in high school, but for argument's sake.

[Eze]

Just saw a very youthful lookin Hamm do a promo for the halloween episode of SNL comin up. Third time hosting, guys got wicked range. Snyder's working with him right now too, wonder if Hamm will do anything "super" on the show, SNL that is.

[cronosred]

Just saw a very youthful lookin Hamm do a promo for the halloween episode of SNL comin up. Third time hosting, guys got wicked range. Snyder's working with him right now too, wonder if Hamm will do anything "super" on the show, SNL that is.

I really wouldn't mind Hamm at all, I admit when I saw some photo's of him I jumped on the he's to old wagon but once I started to see him in some tv shows and interviews I thought he came off more youthful, all he needs to do is bulk up some and he would be fine.

[AntMan]

If Hamm is cast I hope they have Superman go through a mid-life crisis. He could get a sports car and use slang terms. "Supes in da hizzy!"

[Rust]

I was wondering how casting happens on a movie like this.

Does WB suggest someone to Nolan who then suggests it to Snyder or is it the other way around?

Or does Snyder or Nolan have their own casting director?

I'm guessing WB wants Nolan to OK everything basically.

[Dark Raven]

Quick manip of Hammer:

http://i456.photobucket.com/albums/qq282/JAKSaph/hammerman.jpg

Doesn't look too bad.

Doesn't look too good either. His face is too round and his eyes too buggy. He doesn't need to look like Chris Reeve, but he should be more chiselled and with a stronger jawline. He looks more like someone dressing up as Superman for Halloween.

[JAK®]

A manip of Hamm as Superman;

http://i456.photobucket.com/albums/qq282/JAKSaph/superhamm.jpg

Looks a lot better than I expected him to.

[Dark Raven]

^^ looks like drunk Superman from Superman 3

I think I know what is wrong with Hammer's face as Superman. He reminds me of a modern day Judge Reinhold. Is that the kind of image people want to see as the Man of Steel?

[GreenKToo]

I'd prefer hamm or trucco, but I have a feeling the hammer rumor may be more than just a rumor.

[SuperMike335!!]

Considering how great he was in The Social Network, Hammer would be fine as Supes/Clark Kent.


Hmmmmmm. :woot:

I got a feeling you may hinting at something...:awesome:

[Lobo]

Considering how great he was in The Social Network, Hammer would be fine as Supes/Clark Kent.

He certainly was good at playing a duel role with different personalities. :yay:

[Gianakin_]

Wow, Hamm looks and sounds less like Superman every day.

[Puckenstein]

Vincent Chase already played Aquaman.

[Timstuff]

I used to think Hamm would have been a good Superman if he were younger-- but now, I just plain don't want him in the role. He doesn't look right for the part and he's not getting any younger. He looks his age, and he's only going to look older in the coming years.

[MegaDexx]

I'd prefer hamm or trucco, but I have a feeling the hammer rumor may be more than just a rumor.


You will all know soon enough.

I will just say this, Warner Bros has had their eyes on Armie Hammer for quite awhile now. Even before his breakout role in The Social Network, he was on their radar for reasons generally known already. But with his performance in TSN it pretty much cemented things for them regarding what he was capable of. Think of it as an out of costume screen test if you will. When things happen in Hollywood it's all about timing. Right now he's on the cusp of stardom but not there as of yet, so signing him to a multi picture deal is what they'll lock up fast. Now when I say you (as in the general public) will all know soon, that's just what I mean. The back and forth battle for publicity between Marvel and DC regarding their upcoming superhero films has already begun. Recently DC announced the title for the Dark Knight sequel, shortly after Marvel countered finally with the release of Chris Evans as Captain America. That move by Marvel was calculated, believe me. Now for DC the Green Lantern stuff is already out there so nothing newsworthy there. Now I can't say exactly when, but their next big gun will be the announcement of Armie Hammer as Superman.

That.... is coming next! :supes:

Stay tuned.

[cronosred]

You will all know soon enough.

I will just say this, Warner Bros has had their eyes on Armie Hammer for quite awhile now. Even before his breakout role in The Social Network, he was on their radar for reasons generally known already. But with his performance in TSN it pretty much cemented things for them regarding what he was capable of. Think of it as an out of costume screen test if you will. When things happen in Hollywood it's all about timing. Right now he's on the cusp of stardom but not there as of yet, so signing him to a multi picture deal is what they'll lock up fast. Now when I say you (as in the general public) will all know soon, that's just what I mean. The back and forth battle for publicity between Marvel and DC regarding their upcoming superhero films has already begun. Recently DC announced the title for the Dark Knight sequel, shortly after Marvel countered finally with the release of Chris Evans as Captain America. That move by Marvel was calculated, believe me. Now for DC the Green Lantern stuff is already out there so nothing newsworthy there. Now I can't say exactly when, but their next big gun will be the announcement of Armie Hammer as Superman.

That.... is coming next! :supes:

Stay tuned.

I wouldn't be surprised, one of the many things Hammer has going for him is his age, if the legal troubles postpone a sequel a few years he would still be young enough to reprise the role.

[Maze]

I would not be surprised that Warner think about him either, if they are looking at a young superman like Snyder tend to suggest.

but i would be surprised, if he was already cast... no offense megadexx, but it's not believable at this point.

[Astrodust]

^^ looks like drunk Superman from Superman 3

I think I know what is wrong with Hammer's face as Superman. He reminds me of a modern day Judge Reinhold. Is that the kind of image people want to see as the Man of Steel?

Albeit a happy drunk.

[Dark Knight]

You will all know soon enough.

I will just say this, Warner Bros has had their eyes on Armie Hammer for quite awhile now. Even before his breakout role in The Social Network, he was on their radar for reasons generally known already. But with his performance in TSN it pretty much cemented things for them regarding what he was capable of. Think of it as an out of costume screen test if you will. When things happen in Hollywood it's all about timing. Right now he's on the cusp of stardom but not there as of yet, so signing him to a multi picture deal is what they'll lock up fast. Now when I say you (as in the general public) will all know soon, that's just what I mean. The back and forth battle for publicity between Marvel and DC regarding their upcoming superhero films has already begun. Recently DC announced the title for the Dark Knight sequel, shortly after Marvel countered finally with the release of Chris Evans as Captain America. That move by Marvel was calculated, believe me. Now for DC the Green Lantern stuff is already out there so nothing newsworthy there. Now I can't say exactly when, but their next big gun will be the announcement of Armie Hammer as Superman.

That.... is coming next! :supes:

Stay tuned.







Meh. I also notice Marvels weak and predictable attempts and trying to steal DC's thunder by always announcing something right after WB's/DCE does.

There is plenty more Green Lantern stuff coming to get the buzz going actually. The trailer is coming out with the Potter film in November and that will be BIG! WB's and Nolan will also be announcing official casting news regarding The Dark Knight Rises soon enough.

Regarding the Hammer info.

Yes, I will admit, my little birdies have been saying keep an eye on him as a potential Superman for over a month now, if the script calls for a younger Superman that is. We'll see regarding the Hammer thing though. I'm not a big fan of his.

However, he has the height and potential build to get bigger as Superman. To me his facial features look soft though and he is only 24 years of age and still has more to prove in the acting department for me at least. What he did or didn't do in the overrated Social Network means nothing to me really.

However, with that being said if he does wind up being cast, then I will not whine, cry and b***h and say stupid things "like my god....I'm not going to see this film now because of Snyder and Hammer. WB's, Nolan and Snyder suck!"..... like what some of you goofs starting doing when Snyder was named the director and how some of you would say if Hamm or someone older was cast as Superman.

I will be seeing this film regardless of who is cast as Superman, whether I'm in favor of the actor being chosen or not.

I'm more of a fan of the TALENTED CREATIVE FILMMAKING TEAM producing, writing and directing this Superman film on the big screen more than anything else.

Tom Tull, the Nolan Brothers, Emma, Goyer, Deb and Zack Snyder! :supes: :up:

[Eze]

^^ looks like drunk Superman from Superman 3

I think I know what is wrong with Hammer's face as Superman. He reminds me of a modern day Judge Reinhold. Is that the kind of image people want to see as the Man of Steel?
http://i132.photobucket.com/albums/q6/andeverythingnice/Excelsior/StarsSetGossipGirlQU-Evc1YU8Sl.jpg
I know, it's messed up. Sunken cheekbones, doughy face, buggy eyes, blonde hair, receding hairline(five head). He reminds me of a grown up
http://www.hboasia.com/images/posters/282x145/the_boy_who_could_fly.jpg


But he's 6'5", got blue eyes, and ... played two different characters, so he must be Superman. :doh:

[DCnightwing23]

I think Hammer could be a pretty good Superman, i question both his looks and acting. But on the other hand a lot of people questioned Chris Evans as to whether to could be Captain America and with the latest pics that seems to have vanished. Hammer has a really soft almost teenage face and i think he's a tad bit overrated in the acting department i mean TSN was really the only thing even kinda good he's been in. But again it all comes down to what Nolan and Snyder are looking for, i really trust Nolan more then Snyder so hopefully Nolan will have more of a say in the casting decision.

[green]

The back and forth battle for publicity between Marvel and DC regarding their upcoming superhero films has already begun. Recently DC announced the title for the Dark Knight sequel, shortly after Marvel countered finally with the release of Chris Evans as Captain America. That move by Marvel was calculated, believe me.

Ummm there was a day between the announcement of the title and the release of the pics. You really think Marvel scurried over and had EW give them a cover and news story in a day to try and top WB...who by the way owns EW.:doh:

I'd call it a coincidence.

[Eze]

I think Hammer could be a pretty good Superman, i question both his looks and acting. But on the other hand a lot of people questioned Chris Evans as to whether to could be Captain America and with the latest pics that seems to have vanished. Hammer has a really soft almost teenage face and i think he's a tad bit overrated in the acting department i mean TSN was really the only thing even kinda good he's been in. But again it all comes down to what Nolan and Snyder are looking for, i really trust Nolan more then Snyder so hopefully Nolan will have more of a say in the casting decision.

That's what sucks about casting Superman, no mask to hide in, although now that I look at him on that EW cover, he's not bad there either. Not exactly rugged, but not Johnny Storm. I don't envy anyone who has to actually make the call on this one, no way to make everyone happy.

[Night Owl]

http://img248.imageshack.us/img248/6001/armiesup2.jpg

My cast. :woot:

Armie Hammer - Clark Kent / Superman
Billy Zane - Lex Luther
Dominic West - General Zod
Jessica Biel - Lois Lane

[Krumm]

Hammer may be a little doughy in the face - I stress little - but there are versions of Superman out there where he is a little softer (For All Seasons, All-Star). I try to look at comic films not so much as the literal interpretation of the comic on film but more like a different version of the story - a retelling, re-imagining - just like For All Seasons, All-Star, Birthright, and Earth One.

[MegaDexx]

I don't envy anyone who has to actually make the call on this one, no way to make everyone happy.


This statement is correct. There isn't a person in existence that Snyder, Nolan, and Warner's could choose for the Superman role that the general public would be in 100% agreement with. No one at all. Even back in 1976 when they were first casting S:TM some people were screaming bloody murder when Donner first cast Christopher Reeve. Reeve was picked apart then as well, much the same way some people find things to nitpick on Hammer now. Now some may remember and some won't, but back then some wanted Robert Redford, Paul Newman, even Nick Nolte as well as some others to play Superman instead of Reeve. All that of course changed once people saw him in costume and saw his performance, and the rest is history.
Armie Hammer will have his naysayers and that's okay. It happens in this business, no way around that. Remember the huge uproar when Daniel Craig was cast as James Bond for Casino Royale? and we all know how good he turned out to be in the role.
And just let me add a final point, the Armie Hammer you see today is NOT the way he will look when the cameras roll in 2011. Zack Snyder before he began shooting 300 wanted those guys IN SHAPE! They all went through some grueling sessions for that film, Gerard Butler will tell you. Come next year when shooting begins Hammer will have completely transformed himself into Superman shape, which he already has a good build for. Hemsworth and Evans already did that for their roles, but what Hammer's going to do with his body will be jaw dropping. You'll be surprised it's even the same guy.

Stay tuned! :supes:

[Krumm]

And just let me add a final point, the Armie Hammer you see today is NOT the way he will look when the cameras roll in 2011. Zack Snyder before he began shooting 300 wanted those guys IN SHAPE! They all went through some grueling sessions for that film, Gerard Butler will tell you. Come next year when shooting begins Hammer will have completely transformed himself into Superman shape, which he already has a good build for. Hemsworth and Evans already did that for their roles, but what Hammer's going to do with his body will be jaw dropping. You'll be surprised it's even the same guy.


Totally agree.

[GoblinWhirlwind]

People hated it when everyone acted like Routh was the only one who could possibly play Superman, and now they're doing the same with Hammer. Give him Aquaman or something. He's got too much of a babyface... just because he happens to be tall and young, people want him for Superman. I'd be willing to bet that's why some people want that other guy too.

I'm liking Trucco more and more, I definitely wouldn't mind him, especially since Hamm seems to think it'd kill him to get the role.

[DCnightwing23]

Yeah i agree as well, as much as i wanna hate on Hammer, the guy is 6'5 and then you add him get super bulked up for Superman, he could work, his acting isnt too good though and at the moment he's overhyped but id take Hammers height, better acting skills and put it together with Joe Mang's build and he'd be pretty good in fact i think Hammer could get bulkier then Joe since from the TSN interviews he's pretty thick, not fat but thick. My only concern is Hammer's face and acting thats all

[Astrodust]

I find him too tall actually.

[Superark]

The Superman casting thread has gotta be one of the most annoying/frustrating threads on the Hype

[GoblinWhirlwind]

If they're casting around 30, I want Cavill. If they're casting older, Trucco would be good.

[GinsterHead]

I just wish there was somebody out there who was a combination of all the rumoured candidates.

Somebody with the acting ability of Cavill, the height of Hammer, the voice of Hamm and the muscles of Manganiello...

[GoblinWhirlwind]

Lol, that's the perfect Superman right there.

[Man of Tomorrow]

I just wish there was somebody out there who was a combination of all the rumoured candidates.

Somebody with the acting ability of Cavill, the height of Hammer, the voice of Hamm and the muscles of Manganiello...

Hammer is a better actor and he's actually on the Hollywood radar now.

[DCnightwing23]

My top choice is HC but Hammer is on my list as well, he's a bettter actor then Joe M, younger then Hamm and taller then all the other candidates

http://i183.photobucket.com/albums/x41/cgm100/hammersupes.jpg

Just a simple picture of Hammer that i modified, he can look like a pretty good Superman/Clark Kent, give him Joe's build and then he might actually be a damn good choice, while his acting i think is a tad bit overrated i think he's better then most choices except HC. And his face is still a little too soft for me to believe he's superman.

[Superman2007]

http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y252/Superman2007/arm.jpg
He has a bit of potential...

[DCnightwing23]

There is a good example of just how soft and weak his face is, it looks like he still has baby face especially underneath his chin

[C. Lee]

I just wish there was somebody out there who was a combination of all the rumoured candidates.

Somebody with the acting ability of Cavill, the height of Hammer, the voice of Hamm and the muscles of Manganiello...

Sorry....but I can't fit it into my schedual right now.

[Parker Wayne]

Dammit C.Lee, we need you out there!

[LL2K2]

This statement is correct. There isn't a person in existence that Snyder, Nolan, and Warner's could choose for the Superman role that the general public would be in 100% agreement with. No one at all. Even back in 1976 when they were first casting S:TM some people were screaming bloody murder when Donner first cast Christopher Reeve. Reeve was picked apart then as well, much the same way some people find things to nitpick on Hammer now. Now some may remember and some won't, but back then some wanted Robert Redford, Paul Newman, even Nick Nolte as well as some others to play Superman instead of Reeve. All that of course changed once people saw him in costume and saw his performance, and the rest is history.
Armie Hammer will have his naysayers and that's okay. It happens in this business, no way around that. Remember the huge uproar when Daniel Craig was cast as James Bond for Casino Royale? and we all know how good he turned out to be in the role.
And just let me add a final point, the Armie Hammer you see today is NOT the way he will look when the cameras roll in 2011. Zack Snyder before he began shooting 300 wanted those guys IN SHAPE! They all went through some grueling sessions for that film, Gerard Butler will tell you. Come next year when shooting begins Hammer will have completely transformed himself into Superman shape, which he already has a good build for. Hemsworth and Evans already did that for their roles, but what Hammer's going to do with his body will be jaw dropping. You'll be surprised it's even the same guy.

Stay tuned! :supes:

Do you have a source to back you up? Sorry, but I flat-out refuse to believe any of this until WB makes an official announcement.

[JAK®]

There is a good example of just how soft and weak his face is, it looks like he still has baby face especially underneath his chin
The 10-20lbs of muscle that he will likely gain for the role will chop away at any excess fat he may have. Combined with a suitable haircut and the right make-up and it's easily fixed.

[Dark Knight]

This statement is correct. There isn't a person in existence that Snyder, Nolan, and Warner's could choose for the Superman role that the general public would be in 100% agreement with. No one at all. Even back in 1976 when they were first casting S:TM some people were screaming bloody murder when Donner first cast Christopher Reeve. Reeve was picked apart then as well, much the same way some people find things to nitpick on Hammer now. Now some may remember and some won't, but back then some wanted Robert Redford, Paul Newman, even Nick Nolte as well as some others to play Superman instead of Reeve. All that of course changed once people saw him in costume and saw his performance, and the rest is history.
Armie Hammer will have his naysayers and that's okay. It happens in this business, no way around that. Remember the huge uproar when Daniel Craig was cast as James Bond for Casino Royale? and we all know how good he turned out to be in the role.
And just let me add a final point, the Armie Hammer you see today is NOT the way he will look when the cameras roll in 2011. Zack Snyder before he began shooting 300 wanted those guys IN SHAPE! They all went through some grueling sessions for that film, Gerard Butler will tell you. Come next year when shooting begins Hammer will have completely transformed himself into Superman shape, which he already has a good build for. Hemsworth and Evans already did that for their roles, but what Hammer's going to do with his body will be jaw dropping. You'll be surprised it's even the same guy.

Stay tuned! :supes:






Didn't we hear the same things about Routh, how he would look completely different and he would look great as Superman after working out and all the stuff also?

He never did IMO.

[Eze]

Is a suitable hair cut possible? Hammer's got a lot of forehead.

[JAK®]

Didn't we hear the same things about Routh, how he would look completely different and he would look great as Superman after working out and all the stuff also?

He never did IMO.In the film he didn't. But after SR he bulked up even more and now he looks exactly like Superman.

[Dark Knight]

The Superman casting thread has gotta be one of the most annoying/frustrating threads on the Hype





It is! :dry:

[JAK®]

Is a suitable hair cut possible? Hammer's got a lot of forehead.
Uh-huh, and Superman HAS never had a big forehead.

http://i456.photobucket.com/albums/qq282/JAKSaph/curt_swan_2.jpg

What does Curt Swan know about Superman anyway?

[Eze]

Gah! Not the direction I wanna see MoS go.:doh:

[Parker Wayne]

The Superman casting thread has gotta be one of the most annoying/frustrating threads on the Hype

Have you been in the Bat-forums yet? More specifically the Catwoman thread?

[cerealkiller182]

Just a name I want to throw out. i really have no idea his acting capabilities, and he hasnt done much, but I saw Richard Tillman on Bill Maher being interviewed about his brother (Pat Tillman). Thought he looked the part, and hes an unknown for the most part.

http://ia.media-imdb.com/images/M/MV5BMTI3MjYxODY1Ml5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTYwMzI4MDMz._V1._ SX277_SY400_.jpg http://www.gazillionmovies.com/Actor/R/Ri/Pictures/richard-tillman.jpg http://ia.media-imdb.com/images/M/MV5BMTAwMTc5OTI3NjNeQTJeQWpwZ15BbWU2MDQ4NzAzMw@@._ V1._SX400_SY263_.jpg

[JAK®]

Have you been in the Bat-forums yet? More specifically the Catwoman thread?
The worst casting threads will always be the ones for female characters. If you want to see the worst examples of sexist, horny, deluded, ignorant, disgusting and pathetic individuals on the forums then just look in any of those.

[cerealkiller182]

The worst casting threads will always be the ones for female characters. If you want to see the worst examples of sexist, horny, deluded, ignorant, disgusting and pathetic individuals on the forums then just look in any of those.

agreed

[Project862006]

Well Routh said wb and singer said he was getting to big for the suit so instead of making a knew one he had to cut down the weight

[JAK®]

Well Routh said wb and singer said he was getting to big for the suit so instead of making a knew one he had to cut down the weightCombined with a stupid haircut, excessive makeup (which Routh also complained about) and a terrible costume, we got an ideal Superman that managed to not look like Superman in his own movie.

[Mostpowerful]

Combined with a stupid haircut, excessive makeup (which Routh also complained about) and a terrible costume, we got an ideal Superman that managed to not look like Superman in his own movie.

He did to me.

[JAK®]

He did to me.
Okay, a bit of hyperbole there, he didn't look as good as he should have.

[Dark Knight]

Combined with a stupid haircut, excessive makeup (which Routh also complained about) and a terrible costume, we got an ideal Superman that managed to not look like Superman in his own movie.






Yep!

[Eze]

Just a name I want to throw out. i really have no idea his acting capabilities, and he hasnt done much, but I saw Richard Tillman on Bill Maher being interviewed about his brother (Pat Tillman). Thought he looked the part, and hes an unknown for the most part.

http://ia.media-imdb.com/images/M/MV5BMTI3MjYxODY1Ml5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTYwMzI4MDMz._V1._ SX277_SY400_.jpg http://www.gazillionmovies.com/Actor/R/Ri/Pictures/richard-tillman.jpg http://ia.media-imdb.com/images/M/MV5BMTAwMTc5OTI3NjNeQTJeQWpwZ15BbWU2MDQ4NzAzMw@@._ V1._SX400_SY263_.jpg

I think Tillman definitely deserves an audition, he kinda reminds me of a young Dean Cain, but better.
http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2006/10/24/us/24tillman_lg.jpg
Heat vision glare.
http://tradingeights.com/files/7812/7119/2926/Tillman1.jpg
He looks like something Jim Lee draws.

[JAK®]

He looks a bit east Asian to me.

[Frodo]

I still like Malambri the best in terms of look. He appears approachable and friendly look. He doesn't seem like the kind of person you would recoil from if he was saving you. Imo Joe M, Mark Hamm, and Armie Hammer just don't have that quality about them imo. However , I'm not sure about his acting. I watched a bit of Step Up 3D and his acting seemed a bit limited.

[AntMan]

Who is Mark Hamm? lol

[FilmNerdJamie]

Jon's brother?

[AntMan]

I wonder how old Mark is?

[FCEEVIPER]

This is a pretty big deal to some people,and I would like to see what more people think. Should the actor for Superman specifically be an American actor?
No. Doesnt matter.

[hulk24]

I think Tillman definitely deserves an audition, he kinda reminds me of a young Dean Cain, but better.
http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2006/10/24/us/24tillman_lg.jpg
Heat vision glare.
http://tradingeights.com/files/7812/7119/2926/Tillman1.jpg
He looks like something Jim Lee draws.

I agree with you and as far as pat tillman he quit the nfl and joined the army and became a army ranger and in a confusing overwhelming firefight/ambush and died in a friendy fire accident in afganistan. I met the man when I was stationed at fort lewis great guy sad loss

[Dark Knight]

Have you been in the Bat-forums yet? More specifically the Catwoman thread?







The Catwoman threads have nothing compared to this thread as far as being irrational, over the top and flat out ridiculous.

[Dark Knight]

The worst casting threads will always be the ones for female characters. If you want to see the worst examples of sexist, horny, deluded, ignorant, disgusting and pathetic individuals on the forums then just look in any of those.






Calling the kettle black.

Have you seen the amount of pervs who continue to post half naked pics of guys on this thread?

These are guys posting these pics mostly also....not females. :o

[Eze]

Hamm looking Bale-esque here.
http://tv.popcrunch.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/jon-hamm-mad-men.jpg

or is it just me? Def not lookin like Don Draper.

[Astrodust]

I think Tillman definitely deserves an audition, he kinda reminds me of a young Dean Cain, but better.
http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2006/10/24/us/24tillman_lg.jpg
Heat vision glare.
http://tradingeights.com/files/7812/7119/2926/Tillman1.jpg
He looks like something Jim Lee draws.

Funny the guy in the middle looks the most like Superman to me. Actually they could all pass for Superman. I mean if Hamm can pass for an older Supes even the guy on the right could do it.

[DCnightwing23]

Its funny how Hamm looks nothing like himself for magazine covers, its hilarious that photographers have to photoshop hamm's face soo much to even come out decent. Yes the Hamm fans want a Superman thats face is photo-shopped all throughout the film

[Aesop Rocks]

To be completely honest, until someone better than Hamm is brought up, Hamm is the only person I'm going for.

Hopefully the movie will be called Superman Begins.

[I Am The Knight]

To be completely honest, until someone better than Hamm is brought up, Hamm is the only person I'm going for.

Hopefully the movie will be called Superman Begins.

Well, hopefully not. 90's much? Even 5 years ago, Batman Begins was/is an awful title. Superman needs not suffer that. Besides, I'm pretty sure it will be called SMOS.

[elgaz]

I watched The Town last night. Hamm is certainly a decent actor, but at no time did I get a Superman vibe off him - in fact, to be honest, at times he pulls these weird faces reminiscent of Tobey Maguire in Spiderman. He didn't stand out from those people around him, and whilst some will argue that Clark Kent needs qualities like that, the big draw for this film is not the Clark Kent persona but the Superman persona. To me personally, he hasn't got the stature and just looks a little too worn round the edges.

[Dark Knight]

Its funny how Hamm looks nothing like himself for magazine covers, its hilarious that photographers have to photoshop hamm's face soo much to even come out decent. Yes the Hamm fans want a Superman thats face is photo-shopped all throughout the film







Or do you want a Superman that has tons of make up on?

That's exactly what Reeve and Routh had on when they were Superman. Fake darker toned makeup and tons of it.

As Clark Kent....both were pale and then as Superman....the makeup was splattered on heavily.

[Eze]

Funny the guy in the middle looks the most like Superman to me. Actually they could all pass for Superman. I mean if Hamm can pass for an older Supes even the guy on the right could do it.

The guy in the middle, his brother Pat Tillman, made the ultimate sacrifice. I agree tho, he looks like a Bogdanove Superman.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/d/df/Superman_Man_of_Steel_1.jpg

[AntMan]

What about Owain Yeoman? (He plays Rigby on The Mentalist.) He's 32 and 6'4.

[Dark Raven]

What about Owain Yeoman? (He plays Rigby on The Mentalist.) He's 32 and 6'4.

But he always looks as if he's unsure of himself and lacking in confidence slightly. Is Risgby actually written to be like that? He gives off that vibe even when standing normally during the series. He might be okay for Clark Kent. Don't know about Superman. He might be a better fit for Captain Marvel.

[AntMan]

Yeah I'm sure that's how Rigby is written. Owain seems pretty sure of himself when not playing the charactor.

[Kryptonian Warrior]

Who is Mark Hamm? lol
Mr. and Mrs. Hamm's son? :oldrazz:

[JAK®]

Calling the kettle black.

Have you seen the amount of pervs who continue to post half naked pics of guys on this thread?

These are guys posting these pics mostly also....not females. :o
In male casting threads you do tend to get competitions on who has the most muscle-mass but it usually stops there.

At least some of the time people suggest actors because they believe they fit the role and have studied their filmography and acting ability.

When it comes to female characters, all of a sudden it's about how 'hot' you find an actress and then it devolves into posting pictures of that actress half-naked and then people quote those pictures just to say 'hot'.

When it comes to acting abilities; that is rarely taken into consideration. In fact you're more likely to find models suggested than actual actresses. The worst example was in the Wonder Woman casting thread where someone suggested an 'actress'. Her qualifications? She was Miss Brazil!

[SuperMike335!!]

What about Owain Yeoman?

He is another choice I like.

[AntMan]

Yeoman is the best of both worlds. He's mature but he dosen't look too old.

[Night Owl]

Ha he reminds me of the allstar supes. It could deff work i think :yay:

jez 6ft 4 too

[SuperZer0]

Speaking of Armie Hammer, his face sometimes reminds me of the young Superman in S:TM, played by Jeff East.

http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/7572/armie20hammer200001.jpghttp://img831.imageshack.us/img831/5038/superman6.jpg

[TheWatcher]

^HA!

I'm glad I'm not the only one.

[Eddie Dean]

It's uncanny!

[AntMan]

Yeoman all the way baby!

[Frodo]

I suggested Yeoman a while ago but people where complaining about his looks. Then again , who ever gets the part is gonna get grief from Fanboys for not looking their image of Superman ,so I guess his name can be thrown into the hat. The guy is a good actor and Rigsby is basically Clark Kent.

[Eze]

Speaking of Armie Hammer, his face sometimes reminds me of the young Superman in S:TM, played by Jeff East.

http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/7572/armie20hammer200001.jpghttp://img831.imageshack.us/img831/5038/superman6.jpg

Lmao! Separated at birth, Hammer would need a wig too.

[SuperMike335!!]

Lmao! Separated at birth, Hammer would need a wig too.

The hollywood makeup crew cannot just dye his hair black?

[Eze]

Dye job isn't gonna help Hammer's receding hairline.

[Project862006]

The hollywood makeup crew cannot just dye his hair black?

Armie has natural brown hair imo
http://static.tvguide.com/MediaBin/Galleries/Shows/G_L/Gi_Gp/GossipGirl/season2/gossip-girl259.jpg

[Mike22]

And just let me add a final point, the Armie Hammer you see today is NOT the way he will look when the cameras roll in 2011. Zack Snyder before he began shooting 300 wanted those guys IN SHAPE! They all went through some grueling sessions for that film, Gerard Butler will tell you. Come next year when shooting begins Hammer will have completely transformed himself into Superman shape, which he already has a good build for. Hemsworth and Evans already did that for their roles, but what Hammer's going to do with his body will be jaw dropping. You'll be surprised it's even the same guy.

Stay tuned! :supes:

All the muscles in the world isn't going to make his face look like more like Superman. You speak a lot of muscles and physical transformation, but you completely neglect the fact that he doesn't look a single thing like Supes.
The facial features are literally the complete opposite to those of Superman.
I know there are some people here that want to move on from the typical square jawed look Superman has always had, but I'm not one of them. His work in The Social Network was really good, and no doubt the kid's got the acting chops, but he fails quite miserably appearance wise. And for me. that's gonna kill the movie, so I really hope you're just screwing around, and that this guy hasn't been cast, because frankly I don't like the choice ( although he would be much more preferable than Routh, since Hammer can actually act) and also, you offer no evidence what so ever for these statements of yours anyway, so there's really no reason to believe you, and I can still have hope that they'll just cast an unknown that actually looks like Superman.

[Eze]

What about Owain Yeoman? (He plays Rigby on The Mentalist.) He's 32 and 6'4.

Only thing I got against Yeoman is what someone else said, he's a perfect Captain Marvel.

[JAK®]

The facial features are literally the complete opposite to those of Superman.

That's a bit of a silly thing to say.

He looks less like Superman than this guy?;

http://i456.photobucket.com/albums/qq282/JAKSaph/dj_qualls-2-hustle_and_flow.jpg

[Parker Wayne]

^ We found our Superman! :woot:

[Eze]

The War is over, huzzah!

[<(o_o)>]

Speaking of Armie Hammer, his face sometimes reminds me of the young Superman in S:TM, played by Jeff East.

http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/7572/armie20hammer200001.jpghttp://img831.imageshack.us/img831/5038/superman6.jpg

The other guy Jeff East always looked like he was wearing a prosthetic nose in the Superman movie anyways.

[BenReilly]

The other guy Jeff East always looked like he was wearing a prosthetic nose in the Superman movie anyways.

That's because he was wearing a prosthetic nose. :hehe:

Along with a hairpiece and they re-dubbed all his lines with Christopher Reeve's voice as well.

[M.O.Steel]

Speaking of Armie Hammer, his face sometimes reminds me of the young Superman in S:TM, played by Jeff East.

http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/7572/armie20hammer200001.jpghttp://img831.imageshack.us/img831/5038/superman6.jpg

the resemblance is uncanny.

[Project862006]

besides being white where is the resemblance ?

[Eze]

http://i1127.photobucket.com/albums/l623/Hronm33r/kent-2.jpg?t=1288522469
This looks like a job...
http://i1127.photobucket.com/albums/l623/Hronm33r/FCurl-1.jpg?t=1288522680

...for Jon Hamm!

[AntMan]

I hope Owain Yeoman gets a screentest. He's a solid actor, He looks the part, (reminds me of All Star Superman and Superman for all Seasons) and he is 32 so no worries about age.

[elgaz]

Owain Yeoman certainly has the build and height but facially he's a bit too bland in my opinion. Would make a great Captain Marvel as stated, or a 50s era Superman, but I just don't think he would work for a modern approach to Superman.

http://images.tvrage.com/people/11/32780.jpg

[RachelDawes]

What about Eion Bailey? I think he's about the right age and has the right looks to play an established or a rookie Superman.

besides being white where is the resemblance ?

You really don't see it? The second guy looks like Hammer in a wig.

[romeogbs19]

All the muscles in the world isn't going to make his face look like more like Superman. You speak a lot of muscles and physical transformation, but you completely neglect the fact that he doesn't look a single thing like Supes.
The facial features are literally the complete opposite to those of Superman.
I know there are some people here that want to move on from the typical square jawed look Superman has always had, but I'm not one of them. His work in The Social Network was really good, and no doubt the kid's got the acting chops, but he fails quite miserably appearance wise. And for me. that's gonna kill the movie, so I really hope you're just screwing around, and that this guy hasn't been cast, because frankly I don't like the choice ( although he would be much more preferable than Routh, since Hammer can actually act) and also, you offer no evidence what so ever for these statements of yours anyway, so there's really no reason to believe you, and I can still have hope that they'll just cast an unknown that actually looks like Superman.

I have to agree here. The kid can act but I don't see Superman in his face at all. Put his face next to Routh, Reeve, and the comic books' Superman and it becomes clear he doesn't look the part.

The question is how much will that matter to Nolan/Snyder. It mattered a whole lot with the first Superman movie. A big reason it did so well was because when Donner and the Salkinds selected Chris Reeve and his photo was circulated, everyone -- and I mean everyone -- was convinced this guy looked like Superman (if Superman ever were to exist in real life).

Routh certainly had the look to him that allowed most to believe he was Superman. The plot just didn't carry the day.

Given the sour reception to Returns and the need for this film to be epic, blockbuster-ready, Nolan/Snyder must know that whoever they cast has to not only be likable and a good actor, but must also LOOK like the Man of Steel come to life.

Hammer doesn't fit the bill, IMHO.

I'm still rooting for Hamm.

[bizbaz20]

I haven't been reading alot about Superman for a while now but can I ask a question.

Is Clark/ Superman supposed to be a fresh newbie at the Planet, is he supposed to have been Superman for a while, or something like 10 years?

What I'm basically asking is what age is Clark supposed to be based on news so far.

[SuperMike335!!]

But he always looks as if he's unsure of himself and lacking in confidence slightly. Is Risgby actually written to be like that? He gives off that vibe even when standing normally during the series. He might be okay for Clark Kent. Don't know about Superman. He might be a better fit for Captain Marvel.


He comes off very confident here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBSB2WhUdRc&feature=player_embedded

[AntMan]

Yeoman rules! My #1 choice for Superman.

[JamalYIgle]

I have to agree here. The kid can act but I don't see Superman in his face at all. Put his face next to Routh, Reeve, and the comic books' Superman and it becomes clear he doesn't look the part.


I think some people need to be reminded that Christopher Reeve almost didn't get the role of Superman because no one, including Richard Donner, thought that this skinny
http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c7/JamalIgle/51462815.jpg

Soap Opera Actor from Princeton NJ
http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c7/JamalIgle/51462810.jpg

looked anything like the comics version of Superman.
He was blond, weighed 170lbs soaking wet and was an untested actor with no drawing power but he impressed them enough that he got the part after testing 200 other actors.
Of all the actors other than Hamm that people have bandied about Armie Hammer has the size and the presence to be Superman, to me. He can act, handling more than one part effectively. So I personally think that if Routh isn't coming back, which would be a damn shame, Armie Hammer should be our next man of steel.

[FilmNerdJamie]

I think some people need to be reminded that Christopher Reeve amlomst didn't get the role of Superman because no one, including Richard Donner, thought that this skinny
http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c7/JamalIgle/51462815.jpg

Soap Opera Actor from Princeton NJ
http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c7/JamalIgle/51462810.jpg

looked anything like the comics version of Superman.
He was blond, weighed 170lbs soaking wet and was an untested actor with no drawing power but he impressed them enough that he got the part after testing 200 other actors.
Of all the actors other than Hamm that people have bandied about Armie Hammer has the size and the presence to be Superman, to me. He can act, handling more than one part effectively. So I personally think that if Routh isn't coming back, which would be a damn shame, Armie Hammer should be our next man of steel.

If there was an Internet in 1976, I swear to God fanboys would have **** a lung when the news hit of Reeve being cast and they took one look at his original red-ish blond, tall and pencil-thin demeanor.

Hell, they'd have complained how Guy Hamilton quitting (because he was behind the most popular James Bond films) spelled doom for the productions and how "the Omen guy" was going to **** it up.

[Asgard]

Who's that skinny twerp holding the phone? No way hed ever be Superman. Ill boycott the movie I swear to God if they cast that guy.

[Micah12345]

This casting discussion has been going on so long I'm dying for them to just make an announcement already.

[Frodo]

Something tells me who ever is cast is gonna have to move heaven and earth to please the fan boys.

[Micah12345]

Val Kilmer was good. RDJ was good. Edward Norton was good. Don't remember much whining about those.

[Karelia]

This casting discussion has been going on so long I'm dying for them to just make an announcement already.

Seriously. That's the one news article I keep waiting to pop up on here. But still... nothing.

[Eze]

I think some people need to be reminded that Christopher Reeve almost didn't get the role of Superman because no one, including Richard Donner, thought that this skinny Soap Opera Actor from Princeton NJ looked anything like the comics version of Superman.
He was blond, weighed 170lbs soaking wet and was an untested actor with no drawing power but he impressed them enough that he got the part after testing 200 other actors.
Of all the actors other than Hamm that people have bandied about Armie Hammer has the size and the presence to be Superman, to me. He can act, handling more than one part effectively. So I personally think that if Routh isn't coming back, which would be a damn shame, Armie Hammer should be our next man of steel.

What kind of exercises can Armie do to change his face so he looks less like...
http://img221.imageshack.us/img221/7572/armie20hammer200001.jpghttp://img831.imageshack.us/img831/5038/superman6.jpg

Sure Reeve had to gain weight, but unlike Hammer, he always had the face and the hairline. You're trying to compare gaining wait with cheek bone implants, and a hair transplant/wig like they are all apples. Other than building upon Social Network hype, and drawing in that demographic, Hammer is a weak candidate for Superman when there are so many comparable unknowns who resemble the character more.

One thing I do agree with, however, is it will be a damn shame if they go with a younger Superman that doesn't rhyme with South. The media still refers to him as Superman, I can't imagine how confusing it would be to the general public to replace him with another young face.

[C. Lee]

He comes off very confident here:

NBSB2WhUdRc

Yeah...it's funny how when an actor acts shy or uncertain...people think they are shy or uncertain. So of course there's no way they can play a confident person....because you know....that would be acting.

[AntMan]

Too true C. Lee. That shows how good of an actor Yeoman is.

[PreK]

The media still refers to him as Superman, I can't imagine how confusing it would be to the general public to replace him with another young face.
This exact statement could apply to Welling back in '05. Or any other Superman actor preceding another, actually. It's ridiculous to assume a role that's been embodied multiple times over the years can't transition well from actor to actor. ESPECIALLY when the general populace aren't terribly attached to the actor. There have only been 2 Superman actors to get such mass acclaim, and that's George Reeves and Christopher Reeve. The rest merely have their own little fanbase.

[Eze]

Tom Welling has never been anything to the public other than Clark Kent. As far as mass acclaim goes, bear in mind that SR is the only \S/ movie that has been merchandised on any significant level. Routh and SR have been plastered on more stuff than CR and GR combined. That's how impressions are made, oodles of merchandise.

that being said, Yeoman is impressive on that vid.

[AntMan]

I'm so glad I thought about Yeoman for Superman. I was starting to think I woud never find a choice I really liked.

[Eze]

Have you seen the odds-on-favorite (http://www.sportsbookgurus.com/news/odds-say-jon-hamm-will-play-the-next-superman)?

...and I thought we were hardcore. Some people could lose their homes over this, end up handing out porn cards on the strip in Vegas!:woot:

[Parker Wayne]

Some of the names listed are hilarious. These are the ones I think are funny:

Ryan Reynolds 16/1

Hugh Jackman 33/1

Ed Norton 18/1

Aaron Eckhart 40/1

Nicholas Cage 40/1

Mark Wahlberg 50/1

Clive Owen 66/1

Jamie Foxx 66/1

[AntMan]

I hope those people lose that bet.

[Eze]

What I wanna know is, how did Ed Norton rank that good?