Would it bother you if:

[Spider-Aziz]

If in the next reboot Ben Parker was made to be the biological father of Peter, and he takes care of him just he always does? I mean just changing this bit of origin and make Ben & May Peter's parents, and they still raise Peter?

[El Payaso]

Nooooo. Whyyyyyyyyyyyy.

[Pumpkin_Bomb]

That would just come off as another stupid, unnecessary change made for the sake of having everything in a neat little connected package, like when they made Sandman out to be Uncle Ben's killer just so he'd have some personal connection to Peter. Being a villain is reason enough for them to fight, just like being his aunt and uncle is reason enough for Ben and May to raise Pete.

[Spider-Aziz]

I wouldn't mind it, I think Richard out of the ultimate comics has no vital role, he was just some random throwaway S.H.I.E.L.D agent

I was asked this question by one of my friends, and was asked if the Spider-Man fanbase would dislike it cause after he told me about Havoc & Cyclops in the new X-Men movie I said "Big Deal"

[TheArachKnight]

No.

[Ajendo]

If in the next reboot Ben Parker was made to be the biological father of Peter, and he takes care of him just he always does? I mean just changing this bit of origin and make Ben & May Peter's parents, and they still raise Peter?

Epic Fail.

[Pac-Master]

If in the next reboot Ben Parker was made to be the biological father of Peter, and he takes care of him just he always does? I mean just changing this bit of origin and make Ben & May Peter's parents, and they still raise Peter?
Yes.

[Alien1495]

Im sorry, but that is really a terrible idea.
It's changes like these that ruin a character. There is nothing in this that would make spider-man better. In fact, it makes him worse

[Spider-Aziz]

I'd like to be briefed on how would that be bad

[C. Lee]

If in the next reboot Ben Parker was made to be the biological father of Peter, and he takes care of him just he always does? I mean just changing this bit of origin and make Ben & May Peter's parents, and they still raise Peter?

No problem with it at all....of course they will need to change Peter's name to George, make him 6'7", a red head, deaf, hate science, stutter, have a limb because one leg is shorter than the other, and have bad breath too or the deals off.

[Franklin Richards]

...and he has to sparkle in sunlight.



:doom: :doom: :doom:

[Ultra Lantern]

Give Peter a sister and an annoying little brother.

[Spider-Aziz]

No problem with it at all....of course they will need to change Peter's name to George, make him 6'7", a red head, deaf, hate science, stutter, have a limb because one leg is shorter than the other, and have bad breath too or the deals off.What inspired those thoughts?

Give Peter a sister and an annoying little brother.What inspired those thoughts?

[bullets]

If in the next reboot Ben Parker was made to be the biological father of Peter, and he takes care of him just he always does? I mean just changing this bit of origin and make Ben & May Peter's parents, and they still raise Peter?



Because it's a lie and we'd all know it...

[Joker]

You know in the comics, Aunt May is really his mom. She f**ked Richard Parker while they were all working at a summer camp.

[bugman]

You know in the comics, Aunt May is really his mom. She f**ked Richard Parker while they were all working at a summer camp.

that's the spirit:yay:.

it would undue a major element of peter's character; peter's love for his aunt an uncle is almost greater than he would have for his biological parents, because he appreciates that they did not have to take him in and treat him as their own. this further compounds his guilt at having let the burglar escape. it's a vital story element in the spider-man mythology.

[Thwip!]

If in the next reboot Ben Parker was made to be the biological father of Peter, and he takes care of him just he always does? I mean just changing this bit of origin and make Ben & May Peter's parents, and they still raise Peter?

OP is trying to eliminate his competition...

http://www.obviously-marvelous.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/unclebens.jpg

[Lord]

I'd like to be briefed on how would that be bad
How would the movie benefit from that? What's the problem with him being an orphan? He's smart because his parents were, and the film also seems to imply some secrets behind his parent's disapearance.

So doing what you said is just very unnecessary, imagine if they changed Batman's origin to make Alfred his real father, or if uncle Owen or even Obi-Wan was Luke's real father, it just makes things more confusing, and for the worse.

[SoNicRaDiATioN]

Thankfully I've read the script. Uncle Ben will in fact be a S.H.I.E.L.D. agent. The whole death scene was a faked S.H.I.E.L.D. operation. A plan put into place by Fury in order to motivate Peter to become the Amazing Spider-Man! Both Ben and his parents are in fact alive. There is a heartwarming scene near the end of the film where they are all reunited in the S.H.I.E.L.D. cafeteria. The scene has a great comic moment as well involving Agent Coulson and banana pudding. But don't worry, it adds a perfectly timed levity to the scene and doesn't undermine the emotional impact in the least. Aunt May plays a part as well but I won't give it all away. It's bittersweet. This will no doubt play a large roll in the sequel.

[Anno_Domini]

No.

[MarvelKnight]

Uncle Ben is Uncle Ben. That would be a needless and idiotic thing to do, imho

[The Morningstar]

Pointless changes are the worst ones. It brings nothing to the story of Peter Parker. It just takes away depth and complexity.

[Radioactive]

Father Ben?

[Venom75]

Aunt May is really....CARNAGE!!!

[psylockolussus]

Yes it would bother me!

[PSYLENTGuardian]

How... how could you even ask us such a thing :dry:

That would be like asking if Pa Kent should be changed to actually be Jor-El.

[Rogue Kira]

...

[Rogue Kira]

If in the next reboot Ben Parker was made to be the biological father of Peter, and he takes care of him just he always does? I mean just changing this bit of origin and make Ben & May Peter's parents, and they still raise Peter?

:facepalm:
just stop...

[MarvelKnight]

Father Ben?

Lol..saying that out loud is just so not right.

[GENERAL RAAM582]

Yes, it would bother me greatly.

[pr0xyt0xin]

I'd like to be briefed on how would that be bad

The following is my briefing on how it would be bad:

- Peter is no longer an orphan and has little to no reason to feel like outcast. Therefore if A. he continues being an outcast, he's a dumbass and an unlikable character or B. if he isn't an outcast then becoming Spider-Man doesn't change his character in any significant way.
- Uncle Ben and Aunt May did not choose the responsibility of adopting Peter. It was thrust upon them. Therefore their love and compassion is a feat of their own goodness which they, in turn, pass onto Peter. If they are his parents, Peter was likely an accident (statistically) and they are almost required to love him.
- Uncle Ben's death wasn't the only loss that Peter has grown from. While we all know what Ben's death taught him (with great power comes great responsibility) Captain Stacy's death taught him the risk that comes with being a hero, and Gwen's death taught him that sometimes things go wrong and we can't do anything about it. But his parents death taught him life was precious long before he ever became a superhero.

That's all I got right now. I'll try to think of some more.

- EDIT - More specifically and more relevant recently (with the new ASM movie) without the death of Peter's parents we lose an entire potential story arc and element of mystery to Peter's life.

[Rogue Kira]

The following is my briefing on how it would be bad:

- Peter is no longer an orphan and has little to no reason to feel like outcast. Therefore if A. he continues being an outcast, he's a dumbass and an unlikable character or B. if he isn't an outcast then becoming Spider-Man doesn't change his character in any significant way.
- Uncle Ben and Aunt May did not choose the responsibility of adopting Peter. It was thrust upon them. Therefore their love and compassion is a feat of their own goodness which they, in turn, pass onto Peter. If they are his parents, Peter was likely an accident (statistically) and they are almost required to love him.
- Uncle Ben's death wasn't the only loss that Peter has grown from. While we all know what Ben's death taught him (with great power comes great responsibility) Captain Stacy's death taught him the risk that comes with being a hero, and Gwen's death taught him that sometimes things go wrong and we can't do anything about it. But his parents death taught him life was precious long before he ever became a superhero.

That's all I got right now. I'll try to think of some more.

- EDIT - More specifically and more relevant recently (with the new ASM movie) without the death of Peter's parents we lose an entire potential story arc and element of mystery to Peter's life.

And that is how it would be bad.

[OrgasmicPotatoe]

I don't mind change if it's not an important detail. In this case, one of the themes they were arguing about before Ben's death. Is Ben Peter's father, or not ? So it would change the dynamic between the two.

No, not a good change. The change from pumpkin bombs to simply orange and spheric bombs in the first Spiderman, that's a change I can handle very well. Not this.

[Rogue Kira]

I don't mind change if it's not an important detail. In this case, one of the themes they were arguing about before Ben's death. Is Ben Peter's father, or not ? So it would change the dynamic between the two.

No, not a good change. The change from pumpkin bombs to simply orange and spheric bombs in the first Spiderman, that's a change I can handle very well. Not this.
:up: nice example.

[Spider-Aziz]

How... how could you even ask us such a thing :dry:

That would be like asking if Pa Kent should be changed to actually be Jor-El.No, there's a difference between blood relatives and adoption

I don't mind change if it's not an important detail. In this case, one of the themes they were arguing about before Ben's death. Is Ben Peter's father, or not ? So it would change the dynamic between the two.All he basically does is call him uncle, he still raised him like a father
In a movie it wouldn't be a problem imo, in the comics since Peter parents are important, that's a different thing

[Troy_Parker]

Urm, it would be a problem in the movie, considering this new franchise is all about his parents disappearance and secrets...

lol

[Spider-Aziz]

Urm, it would be a problem in the movie, considering this new franchise is all about his parents disappearance and secrets...

lol
If in the next reboot
This reboot is about the parents