Megan Fox or Rosie Huntington Whitely?

[Call Me Darkman]

That's the big question.

[Morg]

and what's the question?

if this is a I'll hit either one thread?

[JonRed99]

Rosie's lips. THEY RUIN EVERYTHING.

[Call Me Darkman]

Do they? I thought it was her sub par acting.

[Episode29]

Megan Fox may not be a good actress, but she has a bit of edge. She has a tangible presence.

Rosie is a blank. A pretty blank, but still a blank.

[PowersOfMind]

Megan Fox may not be a good actress, but she has a bit of edge. She has a tangible presence.

Rosie is a blank. A pretty blank, but still a blank.

My thoughts exactly.

[chrisguyver]

Megan fox period

[Call Me Darkman]

I think Megan Fox had more chemistry with Shia LaBeouf.

[Ace]

Megan Fox. Not only hotter imo but she was the female lead for the first two movies. A little late for her to be replaced, but whatever.

[dark_b]

no matter who wins, we lose..........................:wow:

[B]

This. Thread. Is. Worthless. Without. Pictures.

[Nathan]

http://img819.imageshack.us/img819/3953/rosiehuntingtonwhitelyg.jpg (http://img819.imageshack.us/i/rosiehuntingtonwhitelyg.jpg/)

Are you happy now? Are you? ARE YOU?! :cmad:

[Immortalfire]

Rosie. Even in the first movie, I found Megan to be quite trashy.

[Sith Scotti]

Threeway:awesome:

[dark_b]

Rosie. Even in the first movie, I found Megan to be quite trashy.
like Devin Faraci said. Megan looked like a girl who wanted to f.... you. who wanted to have sex. Rosie in TF3 didnt look like and act like that.

[Darth Megatron]

I would dick em both down but as far as better acting & on screen presence i say Rosie over Megan Fox sex slave

[Paroxysm]

Rosie.

[terry78]

Rosie's lips. THEY RUIN EVERYTHING.

Come again?

[carrrnuttt]

Come again?

That's what she said. :o

[Sith Scotti]

Megan Fox looks oscar caliber compared to Rosie , and Shia was no better in Dark Side of the Moon over Megan fox in any of the films .

[Golgo-13]

I would dick em both down but as far as better acting & on screen presence i say Rosie over Megan Fox sex slave

:yay:

[TAK The Voyager]

Rosie!

[combocaz]

rosie was better off doing a tampon ad. Bay and Spielberg should have just sucked it in and finish the trilogy with fox.

[Jick09]

Rosie. Much better.

[def28]

I like Megan Fox in Transformers 1, I thought she did a good job with the humor and seriously she is really ****ing hot in that movie. Really hot. With ROTF I dont really like anyone in that flick besides Prime and Sideswipe. Both her and Sam annoyed me in that film.

Didnt hate Rosie at all and thought she did a great job for the part. Both girls serve their purpose in the end. So for shallow reasons in Transformers 1 Im going with Megan. Ill usually take anything but I prefer brunettes.

[Sith Scotti]

rosie was better off doing a tampon ad. Bay and Spielberg should have just sucked it in and finish the trilogy with fox.

That or recast the part . The romance in part 3 was just beyond awful . Suddenly marriage talk to a character we have no idea how they met .:whatever:

[bullets]

That or recast the part . The romance in part 3 was just beyond awful . Suddenly marriage talk to a character we have no idea how they met .:whatever:



We actually do know how they met. It's on the same day he got his medal. They actually show a flashback in the movie. He hits on her and accidentally knocks over a table.

[Drizzle]

Bay and Spielberg should have just sucked it in and finish the trilogy with fox.
I agree. I thought Rosie was okay, but I might have preferred to see Megan Fox just for continuity's sake. I feel like I would have been more interested in the Carly subplot (captured by Dylan) if it had been Mikaela instead. Pretty much all of what Carly did in that movie was clearly meant for Mikaela save for the whole meeting at the White House thing. Speaking of which, did anyone else find Rosie to be hotter with those glasses on in that scene?

[Timstuff]

I agree. I thought Rosie was okay, but I might have preferred to see Megan Fox just for continuity's sake. I feel like I would have been more interested in the Carly subplot (captured by Dylan) if it had been Mikaela instead. Pretty much all of what Carly did in that movie was clearly meant for Mikaela save for the whole meeting at the White House thing. Speaking of which, did anyone else find Rosie to be hotter with those glasses on in that scene?

I might have been better for the story if it had been Mikela, but honestly I didn't miss Megan Fox at all. Fox gave them lemons so they made lemonade.

[bell110]

I vote Megan.

[Sith Scotti]

We actually do know how they met. It's on the same day he got his medal. They actually show a flashback in the movie. He hits on her and accidentally knocks over a table.

Whoopty to do . Another underdevoloped scene . They made a big mistake not just recasting the role . Marriage talk in this film was really out of place

[Timstuff]

Whoopty to do . Another underdevoloped scene . They made a big mistake not just recasting the role . Marriage talk in this film was really out of place

Why? Sam and Carly have been in a serious relationship since before the movie begins. :huh:

[iskrew]

megan was more interesting in transformers 1. who can forget her bend in that car scene, and also that bad-ass moment where she drove that truck with bumble bee. but she was bland in ROTF.

rosie was simply a HOT damsel in distress in the movie. no character development whatsoever. i didn't expect to like her but she looked better in the movie compared to pictures. it's also refreshing to see the elegant rosie compared to the dirty girl fox.

t1 megan > rosie > t2 megan.

[Sith Scotti]

Why? Sam and Carly have been in a serious relationship since before the movie begins. :huh:

Yes and imo it hurt the damn romance . I was not vested in their relationship at all

[bullets]

Whoopty to do . Another underdevoloped scene . They made a big mistake not just recasting the role . Marriage talk in this film was really out of place


I'm sure if the guy was willing to run into a Decepticon war zone alone to rescue her then marriage isn't out of the question. Also Bumblebee playing the wedding theme got laughter from the audience. I think it was meant to be taken as a joke.

[PowersOfMind]

. it's also refreshing to see the elegant rosie compared to the dirty girl fox.


That's another thing actually. How is it that she went through all that, in a white jacket and shirt and heels and still managed to be pretty prestine? Points deducted for non-realism right there. No way in hell everyone she's travelling/running around with is bruised and bloody and she is still perfectly put together. My sister even leaned over to me and whispered: "why isn't she dirty?"

Hell at least Megan got down and dirty in the middle of a warzone.

[DW4]

Megan by far.

[Parker Wayne]

Sam's mom dammit!

[War.]

I can't believe people are talking being 'invested in a relationship' in a movie about huge alien robots who turn into vehicles! Absolutely mental. For what it's worth my vote goes to RHW who was just so incredibly hot that for the first time in the trilogy I didn't mind them featuring loads of weak 'character development' scenes in.

[iskrew]

That's another thing actually. How is it that she went through all that, in a white jacket and shirt and heels and still managed to be pretty prestine? Points deducted for non-realism right there. No way in hell everyone she's travelling/running around with is bruised and bloody and she is still perfectly put together. My sister even leaned over to me and whispered: "why isn't she dirty?"

Hell at least Megan got down and dirty in the middle of a warzone.

if she's dirty, she's just like Megan. you can't really think about realism in that movie right? they escaped death through the eye of a needle like tons of times. i'm least concerned about her looking pristine. in fact, we all talked about how glamorous she remained after all that shebang.

[terry78]

I would say it was fridge brilliance on Bay's part because in a cartoon or comic, she probably would end up looking like that, but I ain't giving him that much credit.

[Timstuff]

rosie was better off doing a tampon ad. Bay and Spielberg should have just sucked it in and finish the trilogy with fox.They are better off without her. She was apparently a total witch on the set of TF2 and her referring to Michael Bay as Hitler was the last straw. She is an unprofessional egomaniac and on top of that, her acting in TF2 was even worse than in TF1. She's a bad actress both in terms of acting skill and in terms of cooperating with the director and crew. Her career is pretty much over, whereas with RHW pretty much everyone is saying she was a delight to work with. RHW's acting isn't going to win any awards, but she at least did her job professionally. Megan Fox is over.

[Episode29]

rosie was better off doing a tampon ad.

Wow, no misogyny here!

[Call Me Darkman]

Close race so far.

[lespaul59]

I pick Rosie. While Megan Fox may be the better looking of the two I can actually believe Rosie being interrested in Sam more than I can Megan Fox. And somebody correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Rosie/Carly a last minute replacement? I just remember pictures of MF on the set. And as far as recasting for Mikela goes People would have been saying why didn't they rename her Carly. Personaly after some of the stuff I read about SAm and Carly's relastion ship and how it would be different I was kinda like I don't know about this. I also thought they should have kept MF. But while I was watching the movie I got it and thought it was an improvement.


I also want to give a shout out to Sam's mom because she isn't that bad looking either:cwink: .

[Call Me Darkman]

I can actually believe Rosie being interrested in Sam

I didn't. The whole backstory was that he "charmed" her at the White House. I just saw Sam being a goofball and Carly laughing behind his back. With Mikela, everything made more sense. Her and Sam were introduced into the world of Transformers together. They went to war and survived. It's the type of experience that makes people bond.

[psylockolussus]

Rosie Huntington Whitely

I was impressed with her. Hello T3 was her first movie ever and I doubt she had acting lessons for this movie. Megan Fox's acting skill in the 1st two movies (especially the 2nd movie) was just terrible and she already did films before Transformers unlike Rosie.

[Call Me Darkman]

Neither of them gave great performances.

[DarthMuppet]

Neither of them gave great performances.

Megan Fox was passable in the first film, but just barely. Her character was just too skanky for my taste and her offscreen persona is just repulsive. While Rosie did have a few rough spots early in the film, for the most part she did a great job. She made Carly such a likable character that I'm willing to give her a pass on the few scenes were she seemed a little wooden. I also though she had much better chemistry with Shia than Megan did. Unlike Fox, Rosie comes across as intelligent and likable in all her interviews.

Also, as it's been mentioned many times, this was her first acting gig. For her to have been as good as she was with no acting experience or training of any kind just makes what she did even more amazing.

[Cmill216]

Megan Fox is not only more attractive, she's a significantly more believable actress. There was an "earthiness" to her character, a spunk, that Rosie completely lacked. Not to mention, Fox was actually given a sense of character. Her character grew up around cars, fixed cars, and eventually used that skill in a key moment in the final battle of Transformers 1. She wasn't a damsel in distress. Rosie just shows up, gets kidnapped, yet manages to manipulate the villain into the dumbest plot turn of the year.

[Nathan]

I don't get it why so many are voting Rosie. It's seems the biggest reason is because she's "nice". Like you'd want to give her a cookie and a hug if you ever met her. Sure, she wasn't terrible, especially for her first acting gig, but she was eye-candy personified. She was a model, hired to be a model. The only reason she's even above any of the background hotties, is because she has lines.

And for anyone saying that this relationship felt more real or natural, are you for real? It's as superficial as you can get. She was nothing but T&A, she didn't even have enough of a personality to care about. As I said in the Review Thread, Mikaela was a hands-on girl, with attitude and who got **** done. Carly is pretty. The end.

With all this relationship build-up in the first two Movies, the smart thing to have done, would have been to re-cast Mikaela. Then that smack talk to Megatron would have made a lick of sense, and the Movie wouldn't have regressed into damsel in distress territory with the girlfriend character.

[Cmill216]

I don't get it why so many are voting Rosie. It's seems the biggest reason is because she's "nice". Like you'd want to give her a cookie and a hug if you ever met her. Sure, she wasn't terrible, especially for her first acting gig, but she was eye-candy personified. She was a model, hired to be a model. The only reason she's even above any of the background hotties, is because she has lines.

It's Megan Fox backlash, pure and simple. Me personally, I don't let perceived off-screen behavior affect my judgement of a performance. Rosie was horrendous, and highlighted everything that was right about Megan Fox's character.

[Parker Wayne]

I agree. Mikela was a better character. I wish Bay just recasted instead of had a whole new actress. It would made her getting kidnapped even stronger if it was the same character.

[Nathan]

I agree. Mikela was a better character. I wish Bay just recasted instead of had a whole new actress. It would made her getting kidnapped even stronger if it was the same character.

And she would have probably at least head-butted the douche or taken down a Decepticon. The moments in the first Movie where she took off Frenzy's head or helps Bumblebee to take down Brawl, classic.

[PowersOfMind]

It's Megan Fox backlash, pure and simple. Me personally, I don't let perceived off-screen behavior affect my judgement of a performance. Rosie was horrendous, and highlighted everything that was right about Megan Fox's character.

I agree. As I was discussing with a friend after the movie, Carly/Rosie's role came across as a somewhat subtle " **** you" to Megan.

Carly works for a man who comes to work in jeans and a tee and she's dressed in a figure hugging white dress and stilettos. Mind you none of the other women are dressed that way.

And the character's response is "this is what you get when you play along with your boss' wishes", in reference to the car he "gifts" her with. Those weren't her exact words it was more like "What do you want, Sam?! He's my boss."

Ok she's a curator dressed for a night of clubing or the red carpet, this makes sense how exactly? And her excuse that he's her boss is okay?

I think what happened is they gave Mikaela a bit of depth without really meaning to and Megan realized this. The "she's just the hot girl" argument doesn't fly. Yes, when she and Sam have their first moment she's bent over the open hood of his car, in a miniskirt, but she's also checking the engine and she very knowledgeable about cars. Plus she can drive the hell out of car and hotwire one as well. Now I'm a female so I'm sure that's why I was more focused on her engine knowledge than how hot she is, but I think I fell in love with the character right then.

[Nathan]

She wasn't a completely helpless girl and she knew her way around machines. That immediately elevated her above just being a random hottie. It made her interesting.

[Call Me Darkman]

Megan Fox is not only more attractive, she's a significantly more believable actress. There was an "earthiness" to her character, a spunk, that Rosie completely lacked. Not to mention, Fox was actually given a sense of character. Her character grew up around cars, fixed cars, and eventually used that skill in a key moment in the final battle of Transformers 1. She wasn't a damsel in distress. Rosie just shows up, gets kidnapped, yet manages to manipulate the villain into the dumbest plot turn of the year.

I don't get it why so many are voting Rosie. It's seems the biggest reason is because she's "nice". Like you'd want to give her a cookie and a hug if you ever met her. Sure, she wasn't terrible, especially for her first acting gig, but she was eye-candy personified. She was a model, hired to be a model. The only reason she's even above any of the background hotties, is because she has lines.

And for anyone saying that this relationship felt more real or natural, are you for real? It's as superficial as you can get. She was nothing but T&A, she didn't even have enough of a personality to care about. As I said in the Review Thread, Mikaela was a hands-on girl, with attitude and who got **** done. Carly is pretty. The end.

With all this relationship build-up in the first two Movies, the smart thing to have done, would have been to re-cast Mikaela. Then that smack talk to Megatron would have made a lick of sense, and the Movie wouldn't have regressed into damsel in distress territory with the girlfriend character.

I agree 100%.

[Timstuff]

I agree. As I was discussing with a friend after the movie, Carly/Rosie's role came across as a somewhat subtle " **** you" to Megan.

Maybe that's part of why so many people like her. :awesome:

[terry78]

Rosie's lips in every scene basically looked she was ready to just provide....oral sustenance to whoever was within grasping distance.

[Nathan]

Rosie for me, in all honesty, was a complete distraction. She just looked unnatural, like a living Barbie doll.

[LostSon88]

I just didn't like that scene where she's walking in slo mo with **** blowing up right behind her...

You could just feel my audience :whatever: at that part.

[Timstuff]

I was more like :wow: at that part. Maybe it's because I saw it in 3D. :p

[casy26]

Definitely Megan Fox, that Rosie doesn't bring anything into the movie, she's distracting and she's just a blonde bibmo that runs around in heels and doesn't even get dirty!!!
They would be better off without female character after ditching Megan!!!!
Carly serves absolutely no purpose!!!!!!!!

[Ken-Kaniff]

If I judge by the looks, I choose Megan. I am no fan of how she looks nowadays, it's totally unattractive, but in both TF movies, she looked AMAZING, especially in the first, while Rosie is nothing special and I don't really like her face.

In terms of acting (although in this type of movie, you don't need amazing skills), I'd choose Rosie. She was alright aka better than Fox.

So there you go, it's a TIE for me, but I couldn't care too much about either of them, it's the robots that matter most to me.

[Matt]

Fox, simply for the sake of consistency. "Hey Sam, I know you saved the world twice and put your life on the line countless times for me just like, two weeks ago....but I think we should break up."

[dark_b]

I just didn't like that scene where she's walking in slo mo with **** blowing up right behind her...

You could just feel my audience :whatever: at that part.i think i heard some complaining about that scene. if i remember.

it was so funny to see that scene. it made no sense. :awesome:

[Cmill216]

Rosie for me, in all honesty, was a complete distraction. She just looked unnatural, like a living Barbie doll.

THANK YOU.

I've been saying this since the first teaser. She doesn't look like a "hot girlfriend". She looks like a supermodel. And we're supposed to believe she's dating a jobless stump like Shia? At least with Megan Fox there was an earthiness to her.

It makes no sense. Why cast a supermodel when there are dozens of young, hot actresses who can at least emote believably? Blake Lively, Amber Heard, that chick from Glee, etc. They're not great actresses, but they can convincingly play the love interest without looking blatantly out of place.

[dark_b]

i could accept a girl like her dating Shia in a Bay movie.

the problem is how she looked in the White House and her job before meeting Shia.

[dark_b]

THANK YOU.

I've been saying this since the first teaser. She doesn't look like a "hot girlfriend". She looks like a supermodel. And we're supposed to believe she's dating a jobless stump like Shia? At least with Megan Fox there was an earthiness to her.

It makes no sense. Why cast a supermodel when there are dozens of young, hot actresses who can at least emote believably? Blake Lively, Amber Heard, that chick from Glee, etc. They're not great actresses, but they can convincingly play the love interest without looking blatantly out of place.and any of those girls would be a lot cheaper. not saying that Rossie got millions. but she was more expensive then an unknown girl

[PyroChamber]

i could accept a girl like her dating Shia in a Bay movie.

the problem is how she looked in the White House and her job before meeting Shia.What was wrong with that?

[WildcatNC]

I'd need to test drive them both before making a sound decision. :woot:

[Snare]

Megan Fox definitely. Mikaela was extremely hot, but also pretty cool and knew how to handle herself when needed.

[terry78]

The only other part that seemed blatant was when she was changing into the blue dress, that **** was hugging that booty like nobody's business. Bay has no shame in his game.

[Marx]

Rosie :up:

[LostSon88]

Can anyone explain to me where they were going with that scene in ROTF when Sam is talking to Bumblebee in the garage and Mikela changes into that white (wedding?) dress? Then when Sam comes out she's standing there holding a bouquet and smiling.

...then nothing happens and Sam just leaves for college.

Wtf? :huh:

[PyroChamber]

Yeah, I didn't get that part either; especially considering that she was changing outside with firemen still out there.

[LostSon88]

Can anyone explain to me where they were going with that scene in ROTF when Sam is talking to Bumblebee in the garage and Mikela changes into that white (wedding?) dress? Then when Sam comes out she's standing there holding a bouquet and smiling.

...then nothing happens and Sam just leaves for college.

Wtf? :huh:

...I hate being at the end of a page. :oldrazz:

[LostSon88]

Yeah, I didn't get that part either; especially considering that she was changing outside with firemen still out there.

Seriously it made absolutely ZERO sense.

...much like the movie.

[Nathan]

It wasn't a wedding dress. Just a white dress. I guess she did that to remind him that he has a hot tail of ass waiting a home, and shouldn't forget that while he was at college.

Yeah, I didn't get that part either; especially considering that she was changing outside with firemen still out there.

It's not like she got down to her underwear and put on dress. She already had the dress on under her other clothes.

[LostSon88]

still doesn't explain the bouquet of flowers in her hand as soon as Sam walks out of the garage...

[Nathan]

Good bye flowers? Anyway, the scene is not as bad as you guys make it out to be. The college stuff and the scene with the Mother is way stupider.

[PyroChamber]

Even though she's getting all this exposure now, I'm willing to bet that once DOTM is out of theaters Rosie will be forgotten.

[Spider-Who?]

I say Rosie. If only because I don't feel like I'd end up with a greasy hand if I touched her.

[Spider-Who?]

Even though she's getting all this exposure now, I'm willing to bet that once DOTM is out of theaters Rosie will be forgotten.
Agreed. At least on a cinematic level. She's still got her modeling, which having her face plastered all over the earth for DOTM, will only help keep her modeling going. But I'd be quite surprised to see her in another film.

[Liam_H]

Rosie did fine for her part but still prefer Megan Fox. The opening shot of this girl in the movie walking up the stairs told us all we needed to know. Shes just there to look good. Fox was treated similarly in the past two films but at least we had a connection to her.

[Nathan]

Man, I've just been to the TFW2005 board. Almost nothing but Rosie drones. It's like they use their d**ks to type.

[Liam_H]

Man, I've just been to the TFW2005 board. Almost nothing but Rosie drones. It's like they use their d**ks to type.

Considering a good number of those people think DOTM is one of best movies ever, its not surprising they fawn over her superficial qualities. Is it me or did Rosie having the accent make her acting seem better than she actually is?

[Sawyer]

Rosie. BY FAR.

For one thing, she actually seemed like she gave a ****. :o

[Project862006]

megan is far more attractive imo

[bullets]

Considering a good number of those people think DOTM is one of best movies ever, its not surprising they fawn over her superficial qualities. Is it me or did Rosie having the accent make her acting seem better than she actually is?


The accent did help a lot

I voted both. I do think Megan was better but Rosie did well enough.

[Cmill216]

For one thing, she actually seemed like she gave a ****. :o

...How?

[superborn]

I like Megan Fox also, but I am not sure why. Maybe because she is more believable? Or maybe I am just used to her.

[TwilightPro101]

Both.

[PyroChamber]

When you think about the hot women Bay's put in these movies, it seems like the only one he didn't do anything crazy with is Rachael Taylor.

[bell110]

Can anyone explain to me where they were going with that scene in ROTF when Sam is talking to Bumblebee in the garage and Mikela changes into that white (wedding?) dress? Then when Sam comes out she's standing there holding a bouquet and smiling.

...then nothing happens and Sam just leaves for college.

Wtf? :huh:

I think it was supposed to be some sort of romantic gesture. After all, they were having trouble saying "I love you" to each other.

[CyclopsSummers]

Megan Fox iwas better!!

[EliteF50]

Rosie is a much better actress.

[mclay18]

Rosie. She was likeable and pretty, while Megan just had that trailer-trash look from the start. She was beautiful, but not likeable.

Rosie all the way.

[vshen]

Both are beautiful and sexy, I do prefer Megan though. Having said that, I believe we need an actress that can really act so she can contribute some deep and meaningful emotions in a transformers movie because most of the robots should be the eye candy. The humans need to contribute the emotion and sense of purpose.

[Ultra Lantern]

I chose both.

[Ultra Lantern]

edit

[Szetsilya]

Gotta go for Megan, black hair and blue eyes is a tab of mine. She also had spunk at least in the first movie, in the second she was rather bland. I don't mean to be cruel but Rosie looks like she had bad lip injections.

[uniqueweasel]

Megan Fox, without a doubt.

[Nathan]

Still can't believe how even the poll actually is. None are going to win Oscars, but come on. Were people mesmerized by Rosie's ass that much?

[terry78]

Whitely was tossed in there partly out of spite from Bay. Fox isn't the best actress, but at least she IS one.