Hilary Duff as Supergirl

[cestro316]

I think shes a very talented actress and is gonna go places.I think if they were ever to make something with Superman's cousin Kara/Supergirl, Hilary would be the perfect choice. She looks alot like the supergirl from the animated series. Get this shes making a movie with Tom Welling aka Clark Kent from "Smallville" The movies called "Cheaper by the Dozen" and he plays her brother or something.

:supes:

[Superboy]

Peiper Perabo. Go watch LOST AND DELERIOUS. If you're a fan of DEAD POET SOCIETY or just films with lesbians you'll love it.

[Captain Dumas]

no. no hilary. i cant stand her. maybe its cuz i've only seen her on that god awful show lizzie mcquire. she dont really look like super girl either.

[Lobo]

Elisha Cuthbert should be Supergirl.

[Akira]

no... NO... N-O!!!!... lol nah she isnt a supergirl. I picture supergirl as kind of sassy, older/one i can picture as hot without going to jail :D

[DDRSkata]

I'd say wait at least 3 years for her to become Supergirl (when she turns 18). If she still looks as good then, then OK.

[the Mollusk]

no..mary-kate Olsen LOL

[akut401]

I dont like her but id do her....

[Psycho Hulk]

Anybody Have pics?

[Movies205]

Originally posted by cestro316
I think shes a very talented actress and is gonna go places.I think if they were ever to make something with Superman's cousin Kara/Supergirl, Hilary would be the perfect choice. She looks alot like the supergirl from the animated series. Get this shes making a movie with Tom Welling aka Clark Kent from "Smallville" The movies called "Cheaper by the Dozen" and he plays her brother or something.

:supes:

She is a horrible actress, and she not supergirl material... Ya she pretty but come on she 15! How can you whack off or even think anything sexual about her... Irather think about older and prettier women....

[iron_man7]

Originally posted by cestro316
I think shes a very talented actress and is gonna go places.I think if they were ever to make something with Superman's cousin Kara/Supergirl, Hilary would be the perfect choice. She looks alot like the supergirl from the animated series. Get this shes making a movie with Tom Welling aka Clark Kent from "Smallville" The movies called "Cheaper by the Dozen" and he plays her brother or something.

:supes:

the only place hilary duff is going is in my bed wink wink

[Superfreak]

You, my friend, are a fool. However, have you guys seen her sister? She was one of the Tri Pi's in Sorority Boys. She could be perfect for the part.

[Lighthouse]

How about no Supergirl movie. There are other more prominent women super heros that can be brought to the screen. And isn't this in the wrong forum? Shouldn't it be in the DC Superhero Movie forum?

[NotFadeAway]

Her sister was a tri pi. Which one!!!!!!!!!

[Superfreak]

She one of the two at the end in the boat "you're so tanned" - "you're so thin"

I'd say she was the 'head' tri pi in the football game.

[dorcphish]

I'm still recovering from the original supergirl movie, actually. If I had to pick a new one, though, what about Heather Graham?

[dorcphish]

Did I mention she's legal? LOL

[Superfreak]

Kirsty Swanson is still the best choice out there IMO.

[Jamie Madrox]

Originally posted by Lobo of Krypton
Elisha Cuthbert should be Supergirl.

That's a good choice. But I would rather have Naomi Watts in the role though.

[Immortalfire]

Originally posted by Jamie Madrox
But I would rather have Naomi Watts in the role though. Two words: too old

[lou2099]

I don't think Hilary is a strong enough actress to be Supergirl. But she is short enough, and sure would fill out the costume well.

[Lazarus440]

Originally posted by Superfreak
You, my friend, are a fool. However, have you guys seen her sister? She was one of the Tri Pi's in Sorority Boys. She could be perfect for the part.
http://movieweb.com/movie/sororityboys/co8.jpg
witch one is she?

[Pawe³ Max Henry]

Hilary Duff
Born: 1987
Height: 5'4
http://us.imdb.com/EGallery?source=granitz&group=1936&photo=Events/1936/HilaryDuff_Grani_935531_400.jpg&path=pgallery&path_key=Duff,%20Hilary

Elisha Cuthbert
Born: 1982
Height: 5'6
http://us.imdb.com/EGallery?source=granitz&group=1470&photo=Events/1470/ElishaCuth_Ausse_555344_400.jpg&path=pgallery&path_key=Cuthbert,%20Elisha

Heather Graham
Born: 1970
Height: 5'8
http://us.imdb.com/EGallery?source=granitz&group=1272&photo=Events/1272/HeatherGraham_Granitz_252418_400.jpg&path=pgallery&path_key=Graham,%20Heather

Kristy Swanson
Born: 1969
Height: 5'6
http://us.imdb.com/EGallery?source=granitz&group=1772&photo=Events/1772/KristySwan_Grani_767468_400.jpg&path=pgallery&path_key=Swanson,%20Kristy

Charliz Theron
Born: 1975
Height: 5'9
http://us.imdb.com/EGallery?source=granitz&group=1442&photo=Events/1442/CharlizeTh_Grani_483927_400.jpg&path=pgallery&path_key=Theron,%20Charlize

Kristanna Loken
Born: 1979
Height: 5'11
http://us.imdb.com/EGallery?source=granitz&group=1951&photo=Events/1951/KristannaL_Micks_552908_400.jpg&path=pgallery&path_key=Loken,%20Kristanna

[Superfreak]

The Middle One i think

[Superboy]

Of Max Henry's suggestions, Cuthbert, but I still say Perabo.
http://shadesofnwar.com/spiral/montages/101-200/archive/Vertigo106@RockyBullwinkle-Perabo_Piper-002.jpg

[Superboy]

Actually, Perabo or the other girl in this picture, Mischa Barton, if you want a younger (not by much) Supergirl. I guess the best way to think on that is Perabo for a modern, Earthborn Angel Supergirl and Barton for the Kara Zor-El Supergirl.
http://www.movieweb.com/movie/lostdelirious/co3.jpg

[Lazarus440]

Originally posted by Superfreak
The Middle One i think
nope.

[Gambit_Fan]

she can't act so no

[batmanplaysbass]

Wow. its kinda werid to see a old topic thats been dead a year come back to life, lol

[The Kryptonian]

No way dude! No way. Hillary Duff? Lizzie McGuire? The teen pop star? Ha!

Naomi Watts baby! Or Elisha Cuthbert. ;)

[Strange]

To be honest I do not want to see Supergirl in a Superman movie.

[Webley]

I think Hilary Duff would make a kick ass Supergirl.

[Oldguy]

Hell no. Especially not after she went tooth-pick waify, that bit of baby fat was the best thing going for her.

[Swordmaster]

F**k...no...

[Webley]

I say give her the job looks like Supergirl to me.
http://www.hduff.net/hilary/images/calendar2005/calender.JPG
http://www.famous-people-search.com/hilary_duff/hilary_duff_pictures/hilary_duff_015.jpg
http://radio.disney.go.com/assets/music/artists/hilaryduff/pic_1.jpg
http://dan.olsen-twins.org/gallery/albums/Hilary-Duff/hilaryduff190jo.sized.jpg
http://www.amuseyourself.com/celebrity-symmetry/hilary-duff-xxx.jpg
http://www.aufeminin.com/imworld1/blog/D20050404/23405_571555733_hilary_duff205_H230610_L.jpg

[White_Howling]

I'd say wait at least 3 years for her to become Supergirl (when she turns 18). If she still looks as good then, then OK.

and if she loses all her baby fat.. then she might have a chance

[storyteller]

I would shave my eyes and "bass tape" myself if duff ever became associated with superman(unless its smallville since it already went to hell)

[White_Howling]

smallville already had a kara.. well kind of

[igotatromboner]

a spin-off movie is years away

[Webley]

smallville already had a karaDuff would have made a better kara than the girl on smallville cant wait to see her in the move.

[Showtime]

Why in the blue hell did I find this thread in the Superman Returns forum?

[Mentok]

Nah, give it to Elisha Cuthbert, I would pay to see her running around in that outfit.

[Mentok]

Hell no. Especially not after she went tooth-pick waify, that bit of baby fat was the best thing going for her.

I gotta agree woth you on that :D

[WormyT]

WAHAHHAHAHA
OF COURSE NOT!!
Hillary duff? Supergirl?
A whole thread?!

Whahahahah!

[Super Kal]

can we like, put this in the Misc. Superman films forum now?

[Showtime]

can we like, put this in the Misc. Superman films forum now?

Please let's.

[ROBOCOP CPU001]

WRONG FORUM!!!!!!


sometimes i think some people do it on purpose...Just to get attention to there thread!


please move.

[Supergirl]

No, thank you. Give me someone who has more acting talent than say... I don't know... a Paper bag.

[AdWolF16]

elisha cuthbert should have been the invisible woman but fox dropped the ball.. wb would have to be braindead not to choose her for supergirl if the need arises

[Dr. Fate]

http://img.atpictures.com/estella/1874616_Estel_Cohen.jpg How about 5'9" Estella Warren?

Hilary Duff as Supergirl would be like Lindsay Lohan as Jean Grey or Mera or Mary Jane Watson - it sounds funny but if it were to be attempted, it just wouldn't work.

[CConn]

As hot as she is, has Estella Warren even been in a single good movie? :o

[nosebleed.]

As hot as she is, has Estella Warren even been in a single good movie? :o

Yup...planet of the apes sucked arse.

[Zigno]

theron

[nosebleed.]

This thread needs to be moved to the correct board.

[Outsiderzedge]

As hot as she is, has Estella Warren even been in a single good movie? :o

She was in Kangaroo Jack.

[White_Howling]

she was also in Driver..

and a camera commercial

[Steelsheen]

Supergirl isnt supposed to be annoying...

[OobeDoobBenubi]

Hell No

[Mister Sinister]

Hilary Duff shouldn't be allowed to act.

[SuperVenom]

and if she loses all her baby fat.. then she might have a chance

She's not fat no more. You havent seen her new pics? She is bony.

[SuperVenom]

Elisha Cuthbert would make a great Super Girl, good recommendation. I personally like the Super Girl from the animated series and I think she would fit the profile. Would love to see her duke it out.

[swifty]

Elisha Cuthbert looks the part, but I also like Parabo.....hmmmmmmmmmmmmm!!!!!!

can somebody post some manips?

[SuperVenom]

Whos this Parabo?

[GL1]

Hilary Duff is the only believable high-schooler in that lot... I can pick many other actersses I'd rather see in the role...

[DrMylesOBoogie]

Elisha Cuthbert all the way.

[jbsuperman2]

What about the girl from Eurotrip? Sure, she ain't got tits...but her acting is not half bad. Michelle Trachtenberg....thats her name.

[SupermanArrives]

I think shes a very talented actress and is gonna go places.I think if they were ever to make something with Superman's cousin Kara/Supergirl, Hilary would be the perfect choice. She looks alot like the supergirl from the animated series. Get this shes making a movie with Tom Welling aka Clark Kent from "Smallville" The movies called "Cheaper by the Dozen" and he plays her brother or something.

:supes:she is pretty hot! and would make a good choice!

[Mister Sinister]

no..mary-kate Olsen LOL
Or Ashley Olsen. I mean it's not like they look different!

[Trickyg]

What about Tara Reid?

[SuperVenom]

What about the girl from Eurotrip? Sure, she ain't got tits...but her acting is not half bad. Michelle Trachtenberg....thats her name.

She's too skinny and small. Face also doesn't match.

What about Tara Reid?

Tara Reid looks like one of those "ditzy" girls for a lack of a better term, and just doesn't fit IMO.

[DarkKnightJRK]

Kinda off-topic but...

If you're a fan of DEAD POET SOCIETY or just films with lesbians you'll love it.

Are you insulting Dead Poets Society? If so, then I hope you burn in hell. :mad:

[chrisguyver]

Hey how about the girl that played belma in scooby doo Linda Cardelinni. My wife refured me to here and i was like hell know but then she should me some pics of here and she does have the look of supergirl. What do guys think hers a pic of her.

http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a151/chrisguyver/supergirl9.jpg

[The Kid]

Yes. I like her.

[TwilightPro101]

Elisha Cuthbert would make a great Super Girl, good recommendation. I personally like the Super Girl from the animated series and I think she would fit the profile. Would love to see her duke it out.

Elisha. Drools. :spidey: She's defintely worthy of the part.

[TwilightPro101]

Hey how about the girl that played belma in scooby doo Linda Cardelinni. My wife refured me to here and i was like hell know but then she should me some pics of here and she does have the look of supergirl. What do guys think hers a pic of her.

http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a151/chrisguyver/supergirl9.jpg

Okay, I'm liking the idea of Linda Cardelinia in the part as well :)

[Jlandsw]

Elisha Cuthbert should be Supergirl.

I agree!!!! And sexy avatar btw!! Elisha is hot!!!!!!

[CHObiWan]

Anyone but Hilary Duff!!!!! She couldnt act for crap. Then she starts singing........
Funny when all your fans are only 7-9 years old

[MajinShenron]

Supergirl seemed annoying, and so is Hilary Duff. PERFECT FIT.

[TwilightPro101]

Hilary Duff looks way too young for the part. She's got a bit of figure, but again not enough to be Supergirl.

[Symbiotic Venom]

I dont think she can play the part...But you never know these days.

[TheFalcon]

I voted No. Duff isnæt a good choice for Supergirl. I would prefer there not being another Supergirl movie, but if I had to choose an actress I'd say Elisha Cuthbert is the best fit for the role.
A lesser known actress would be even better though.

[Kane]

Whoever voted yes.... Im going to get every single one of you the best mental help that money can provide!

[Speedball]

I suggest Lindsay Lohan....
No wait, i take that back.
I'm gonna say Katee "Starbuck" Sackhoff.

[Kane]

Starbucks too old.

A young teen girl is the way to go, given the age of Brandon and Kate.

Evan Rachel Wood is a great choice.

[Speedball]

hm...
Helen Slater had the perfect look.
hm....
Emmy Rossum, or OMG Michelle Monaghan looks like she could be related to Brandon!
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1157358/

[Speedball]

Hey, Katee's only 26, she's only a year younger than Brandon.

[Abaddon]

Havent you heard??

[Speedball]

Havent you heard??
Heard what?

[Kane]

Hey, Katee's only 26, she's only a year younger than Brandon.

A year younger? For Supergirl?

She should look about 10-15 years younger than Superman. Starbuck looks older than Lois Lane.

The best move is to cast an unknown 15/16 year old for the role.

Evan Rachel Wood looks the part perfectly now, but probably not in a few years.

[tzarinna]

No Thanks

[Speedball]

hm...
Well then Emmy Rossum, or maybe, just maybe Kiera Knightly.

[Kane]

lol both too old.

Theyre old enough to play Lois....or at least look that way.

Supergirl has got to be.....a girl. Theyll never do a seperate Supergirl movie now, so if they ever throw the Kara character into the Superman flicks...she should be played by a very young actress.

[Speedball]

Kiera knightly is 20, and Emmy is 19 too. Hold young do you want them to be,
I mean, evan is 19.

[Abaddon]

Heard what?


Its one of the lyrics to Hilary's song "Supergirl".



Havent you heard??
I'm Supergirl
And you don't wanna mess with me


:o:o:o

[Speedball]

Its one of the lyrics to Hilary's song "Supergirl".



Havent you heard??
I'm Supergirl
And you don't wanna mess with me


:o:o:o
OMG that piece of pop$%#@
Supergirl deserves to go to a girl who's movies haven't tanked at the box office.

[Kane]

Kiera knightly is 20, and Emmy is 19 too. Hold young do you want them to be,
I mean, evan is 19.

Ya which is why I said Evan wouldnt work in the future.

I'd say the best age for Kara is a 15/16 year old girl. They could introduce her in a future Superman film.

Kiera, Emmy, Evan...would all be too old by then.

Theres also the possibility that Singer may do something original, have her appear as a 12 year old child (last Kryptonian survivor) that Superman must save from Darkseid.......and then in the next film, when shes 15/16 she becomes Supergirl...

Until then, shes given to Martha and Ben to raise in Smallville (as they wanted a child).

[Speedball]

My guess is we'll have Superboy before Supergirl.

[Kane]

lol I DOUBT THAT.

Theres too much legal stuff involved with Superboy. He was killed in the comics as a result,....with Superboy Prime also locked away.

Kara Zor-El seems likely.

Mike D said he found the concept of exploring another possible survivor of Krypton as interesting, in the moviehole interview.

[Speedball]

i'm talking about The KID.

[Kane]

lol he doesnt have powers. If hes the son of Lois and Superman, I dont think he'll survive. The book describes him as very frail with serious medical complications (he also has no powers)....the Kryptonian DNA and human may have not been able to mix.

He could be terminally ill................then again, according to Singer, Jason is Richard's son. So we'll see.

The novel doesnt state who the father is.

[Speedball]

Hm.. maybe he's frail now, but then his powers emerge, and he saves his dad in his most desperate hour.
I wonder why Lois and Clark never had a son in the comics, it would make for a great way to shake up the comics a little.

[Kane]

Its coming...but I dont think it will last either.

Im pretty sure Jason doesnt get powers to save Clark and Lois. It was mentioned in a fake AICN review and Mike D (SR Writer) commented it was total BS.

[Logan Howlett]

I'm actualy all for her playing Supergirl, she has the personality and the look :)

[Kane]

:down Gross

http://www.funfry.com/data/510/medium/hillary_duff-corpse_bride_resize.jpg

[Speedball]

OMG, the corpse bride would make a better supergirl.

[Logan Howlett]

Oh don't get me wrong, ONLY if she got her weight back on, I would NOT take an anerexic Duff as SuperGirl, no way!

[Kane]

She'll still have those new giant horseteeth......she doesnt seem to want to take those out.

[Speedball]

nah, Hilary is too.... Disney to be Supergirl.

[Logan Howlett]

This to Disney for ya?

http://www.robbscelebs.co.uk/noops235/hilary_duff0120.jpg

[Speedball]

This to Disney for ya?

http://www.robbscelebs.co.uk/noops235/hilary_duff0120.jpg
what too disney?

[Logan Howlett]

The uber sexieness that is! AGH! FINE! Lets try another.......

http://image.blog.livedoor.jp/cyber_1trance7/imgs/2/8/28e54403.jpg


Before her tits went into the Phantom Zone

http://www.pornspirit.net/celeb/Hilary-Duff/Hilary-Duff-1.jpg

And this is just hot!

[Speedball]

http://www.pornspirit.net/celeb/Hilary-Duff/Hilary-Duff-1.jpg


She's no Tricia Helfer, but this pic is Nice
but now her face looks wierd to me.

[Kane]

Hilary Duff is too busy with her latest box office poison:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWqcrviiV2M&search=duff%20frank

[Logan Howlett]

Ok, I'll admit, I just laughed my ass off!

[Speedball]

Hilary Duff is too busy with her latest box office poison:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWqcrviiV2M&search=duff%20frank
OK, thats why i love Robot Chicken
thats going on my myspace.

[Doright]

There are worse ideas than her but I'd rather they get someone unknown.

[Morg]

Elisha Cuthbert should be Supergirl.


yep :D



http://img82.imageshack.us/img82/8739/supergirl4sb.jpg

[Speedball]

hm..
yeah, she'll do

[Calendar Man]

yep :D



http://img82.imageshack.us/img82/8739/supergirl4sb.jpg

She could work.

[Aarowned]

http://img82.imageshack.us/img82/5682/hilary7gu.jpg

[Calendar Man]

http://img82.imageshack.us/img82/5682/hilary7gu.jpg

She looks like the Wicked Witch of the West.

[CConn]

I won't say no, but how about n...na...n...nnnnn...ah **** it, no.

[CConn]

She was in Kangaroo Jack.Ah, I had forgotten about this.

Oh, Outsiderzedge, always such a card.

[WolfCypher]

Supergirl isn't fat! You're silly! How can Hillary play Supergirl!

[trustyside-kick]

Heck no...Hilary in a Superhero film? Don't think so.

[Gohanssj]

Infact, the 2004 Miss Universe, Aussie Jennifer Hawkins, has had actual statements that she has been aproached to play Supergirl.

http://www.insomniacmania.com/news_default.php?id=2243

http://www.joblo.com/index.php?id=7642 < (heheheh, thats an awesome pic or Jen, I have it as a poster on my wall, im talking about the first one of her standing infront of the water.)

Jennifer Hawkins :O man, I love that shes from my country, and shes only young (23), shes just so cool, not just looks, but her attitude (shes on tv here in australia on like 3 shows)

I would love to see how she would do (even though this is most probably not going to happen) Im all behind it...but im a sucker for her i guess lol...id watch ANYTHING with her in it...

[Bad Superman]

There shouldn't even be another Supergirl movie.

[Ultimate_Superman]

If were talking about this Hilary Duff then yes

http://netmode.vietnamnet.vn/dataimages/original/images631907_hilary_duff_003.jpg


If we're talking about this one then NO

http://www.hilaryduff.nl/cosmo7.jpg

['N']

**** NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! im all for elisha cuthburt (sp?)

[NHawk19]

That Jen Hawkins chick if she can act or Elisha would be fine with me.

The Duff is just not that hot anymore.

[Kane]

http://www.popstarsplus.com/images/JenniferHawkinsPicture.jpg

http://people.freenet.de/damnhotpics7/jennifer/jennifer_hawkins5.JPG

I could live with Jen Hawkins in that role... :)