The SuperHeroHype Forums

The SuperHeroHype Forums (http://forums.superherohype.com/index.php)
-   Batman World (http://forums.superherohype.com/forumdisplay.php?f=230)
-   -   Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)? (http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?t=311990)

C. W. Saturn 09-20-2008 06:45 PM

Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
He is such a self-righteous jerk in that series. If he had behaved the same way in BTAS I would've never become a fan of him. In his own series he was much more likable. But in JL? An ***hole.

pwl4life 09-21-2008 01:13 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
well can you blame him? he's only human yet he's more valuable to the league than half it's members. besides in the comics he was ALOT worse

Etienne 09-21-2008 03:32 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
I agree Saturn, but I still think Superman was more of an ***hole that Batman, and that's saying something.

The fight he had with Captain Marvel and Captain Atom to an extent was unnecessary. In the episode "Clash" he was desperate to "expose" Luthor thus completely ignoring Batman's advice. Of course there was also the episode when Superman wanted revenge on Cadmus without thinking about how the public would perceive the League, his line to Green Arrow "Do I look like Batman to you?" reeked of douchebag. Superman's tone in JLU was a lot different than his STAS counterpart.

Pfeiffer-Pfan 09-21-2008 06:09 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
I think it is only natural that Batman would become more apprehensive as he enters the league. I don't really think the character approved of the whole Unlimited angle of the league and was constantly tested during the Cadmus arc.

Any specific areas were you think he was a self-righteous a88hole?

I'm Old Greg 09-21-2008 06:37 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
i like it, Batmans on a whole other level compared to the rest of em'. :brucebat:

The Batkilt 09-21-2008 06:42 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
I wasn't a big fan of JL/JLU in general. Something about it just seemed off to me, and the way both Batman and Superman were portrayed at times just seemed off. Having said that, the main reason I watched was for Green Lantern and Flash and I quite liked the way Stewart and West were shown.

C. W. Saturn 09-21-2008 07:56 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by spideymoviesfan (Post 15695230)
I agree Saturn, but I still think Superman was more of an ***hole that Batman, and that's saying something.

The fight he had with Captain Marvel and Captain Atom to an extent was unnecessary. In the episode "Clash" he was desperate to "expose" Luthor thus completely ignoring Batman's advice. Of course there was also the episode when Superman wanted revenge on Cadmus without thinking about how the public would perceive the League, his line to Green Arrow "Do I look like Batman to you?" reeked of douchebag. Superman's tone in JLU was a lot different than his STAS counterpart.

I have to agree. The "Clash" episode is so fake. Captain Marvel, okay, he is a kid, and Superman fell for something THAT obvious? Superman (in the whole series) seems like he has to prove something all the time.

November Rain 09-21-2008 08:06 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
They required those story lines because hey ultimately wanted to show the justice league slowly and surely start acting very similar to the justice lords which was essentially the whole point of the cadmus arc.

Evolution of untrusting heroes where the ends justified the means no matter what was at cost.

As for bats, we all know he has never been much of a team player and he eventually leaves the team for one reason or another, even in retirement he kept the last remanining piece of kryptonite on planet earth because he ultimately never trusted superman after the darkseid incident in superman tas.

even in the secret society double parter you can see the strain it puts on superman to work together with other heroes, he's engulfed completely on representing the saviour of hte planet and he's able to see things others can't in luthor. His humanity and prejudice seeps out knowing fully well with all his powers, he can't really do anything to stop him.

I preferred these more complex and oposing personalities, it added something to cartoons that really hasn't been seen in western animation before, a real depth to characters and a solid story arc that had started out decades before with everything coming together perfectly.

the one thing you can't say about dcau is that it has plot holes, the whole universe is pretty damn solid.

C. W. Saturn 09-21-2008 08:26 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by November Rain (Post 15695558)

As for bats, we all know he has never been much of a team player [...]

Hundreds of team-up issues speak otherwise.

GamerSlyRatchet 09-21-2008 03:07 PM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
I completely agree with what November Rain said. Bats' attitude was natural and human, since the DCAU crew knows what its doing.

In the comics, sadly, it's a different story.

DaRkVeNgeanCe 09-21-2008 04:32 PM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
It was ok, but I was never really a fan of the Timm version of The Justice League anyways, I didnt watch it much at all to be honest.

C. W. Saturn 09-21-2008 06:03 PM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GamerSlyRatchet (Post 15697366)
I completely agree with what November Rain said. Bats' attitude was natural and human, since the DCAU crew knows what its doing.

In the comics, sadly, it's a different story.

But he is a FICTIONAL character so there is nothing "natural" about his behaviour. Just how the writers want him!

baerrtt 09-26-2008 08:25 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Batman's wariness of his JLU colleagues was adapted from the modern day incarnation's relationship with other heroes in the comics.

Given the storylines (Justice Lords, Cadmus etc) is it any surprise that the DCAU Batman would be even more controlling and judgemental of his team's actions? Superman's anger at Cadmus's actions if unchallenged could have made them look like criminals.

Etienne 09-27-2008 09:51 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaRkVeNgeanCe (Post 15697827)
It was ok, but I was never really a fan of the Timm version of The Justice League anyways, I didnt watch it much at all to be honest.

You know I agree DV. I've seen every JLU episode on Boomerang but now that I think about it a few things just bugged the crap out of me. The Cadmus storyline just went on and on. While the show is called Justice League Unlimited most of the episodes still dealt with the five or six of the main members. Superman was too much of a bad ass, and to think this is what some Supes fans want to see from the character. :cmad: I can't stand John Stewart and Shayera, I'm just glad the writers somewhat got away from the focus on their relationship.

But yeah I agree Saturn you brought up a very valid point about Batman's demeanor. I've noticed the change ever since TNBA, and in JL/JLU at times ("Dead Reckoning" the Deadman episode) he also seems like the token "genius" of the league. (you know the one who knows everything about everything, the one who everyone goes to when they need some information.)
Quote:

Originally Posted by baerrtt (Post 15724001)
Given the storylines (Justice Lords, Cadmus etc) is it any surprise that the DCAU Batman would be even more controlling and judgemental of his team's actions? Superman's anger at Cadmus's actions if unchallenged could have made them look like criminals.

The thing is Batman never really had a say in the Leagues actions I would even go as far to say that The Question raised more questions (pun intended) and doubt in the League than Batman ever did. I doubt the Justice Lords would have ever been around if Batman would have just intervened at some point.

C. W. Saturn 09-27-2008 10:03 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
In BTAS Batman was angry and intimidating at times, but yet he was still often a "nice uncle". He even made some funny remarks ("Let go off my cape", "I'll drive REALLY slow", Catwoman "I think there is something between us?" - "Yeah, I think it's the law", "I take it out of your salary", "garbage collection is usually mondays"). Even in Nolan's take he is like that.

In JL he is more like the 90s/early-00s comics all the time. As I put it: Unlikeable. Cannot understand why this guy has fans. I mean, look at the episode where the JL members become kids and Wonder WOman asks Batman if he likes it to be a kid again and Batman answers something like "I've never been a child since I turned 9" or something similar. C'mon, THIS is the guy who had a "Grey Ghost's Lair" replica in his batcave in BTAS. :o

Etienne 09-27-2008 10:35 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by C. W. Saturn (Post 15729670)
In BTAS Batman was angry and intimidating at times, but yet he was still often a "nice uncle". He even made some funny remarks ("Let go off my cape", "I'll drive REALLY slow", Catwoman "I think there is something between us?" - "Yeah, I think it's the law", "I take it out of your salary", "garbage collection is usually mondays"). Even in Nolan's take he is like that.

In JL he is more like the 90s/early-00s comics all the time. As I put it: Unlikeable. Cannot understand why this guy has fans. I mean, look at the episode where the JL members become kids and Wonder WOman asks Batman if he likes it to be a kid again and Batman answers something like "I've never been a child since I turned 9" or something similar. C'mon, THIS is the guy who had a "Grey Ghost's Lair" replica in his batcave in BTAS. :o

:funny: That's true but sadly even that was missing in TNBA yeah he was like a "nice uncle" but I still felt WB wanted to make him more of a "bad ass" or more "cool" for the kids out there. TNBA was geared more towards kids than BTAS so their for Bruce Wayne wasn't his slightly phony charming self.

C. W. Saturn 09-27-2008 11:24 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by spideymoviesfan (Post 15729793)
:funny: That's true but sadly even that was missing in TNBA yeah he was like a "nice uncle" but I still felt WB wanted to make him more of a "bad ass" or more "cool" for the kids out there. TNBA was geared more towards kids than BTAS so their for Bruce Wayne wasn't his slightly phony charming self.

Imagine someone of the JL had stumbled upon the GG Lair when they were in the batcave (Thangarian invasion episode). Flash: "Hey Bruce, lookie what I've found". And gone is your grim reputation, Batman. :word:

Grommers 09-27-2008 03:37 PM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
I personally liked his portrayal in JL/ JLU.

Why?

Because, I often felt he was more concerned about Gotham than he was about the league. I do feel if batman intervened it would of been a totally different, but to me he always felt like Gotham was what he was supposed to protect, not the world.

Two-Face=Badass 09-27-2008 08:56 PM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
The problem was in his lack of humanity. Only once was he a majorly explored character in Justice League when he talks to his clone, but even beyond that, that arc became Superman's anyway. Batman is easily one of them most tragic characters of the DCU and one that could be explored endlessly. So naturally Bruce Timm decided to throw that into the wind so he could "make Batman teh Bada$$!111!11!" :whatever:

-Arya- 09-27-2008 09:05 PM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Grommers (Post 15730978)
I personally liked his portrayal in JL/ JLU.

Why?

Because, I often felt he was more concerned about Gotham than he was about the league. I do feel if batman intervened it would of been a totally different, but to me he always felt like Gotham was what he was supposed to protect, not the world.

I agree with you. Most of the time he was "away" doing something in Gotham rather aiding the league. He's technically not a full-time member. Plus whenever he was with the league, I loved how certain problems could only be dealt with through his wits and tactics.

Two-Face=Badass 09-28-2008 12:00 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Arya1369 (Post 15732343)
I agree with you. Most of the time he was "away" doing something in Gotham rather aiding the league. He's technically not a full-time member. Plus whenever he was with the league, I loved how certain problems could only be dealt with through his wits and tactics.

AKA: Making it the "Lets praise Batman hour".

Sonic1002 09-28-2008 12:06 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
As much of an ass he may have been, he wasnt nearly as much of a douche that Superman was...
"The Clash"... NUFF SAID

DrMylesOBoogie 09-28-2008 05:49 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
JLU is perfection

Etienne 09-28-2008 10:07 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sonic1002 (Post 15733084)
as much of an ass he may have been, he wasnt nearly as much of a douche that superman was...
"the clash"... Nuff said

qft!

-Arya- 09-28-2008 10:31 AM

Re: Who else hated Batman's portrayal in JUSTICE LEAGUE (Timm)?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Two-Face=Badass (Post 15733050)
AKA: Making it the "Lets praise Batman hour".

Absolutely :woot:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:25 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SuperHeroHype.com, A property of CraveOnline, a divison of AtomicOnline, LLC © 2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.