The SuperHeroHype Forums

The SuperHeroHype Forums (http://forums.superherohype.com/index.php)
-   Iron Man 3 (http://forums.superherohype.com/forumdisplay.php?f=492)
-   -   Which comic book hero will reign supreme next year? (http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?t=392855)

YoungPrime 09-03-2012 10:41 AM

Which comic book hero will reign supreme next year?
 
Ironman III, Supeman, Thor2 and The Wolverine are slated for next year. Which do you think will have the biggest box office and why?

YoungPrime 09-03-2012 12:30 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
Does Ironman have the momentum from this Summer's Avengers Blockbuster?
Has The Wolverine learned from past sins?
Will Nolan's influence put Superman back it's rightful spot?
Is Thor great enough to stir an upset?

Duran Man 09-03-2012 02:11 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I think Iron Man 3 will come out on top. It's his third solo outing after two financially successful ones (the most successful of MS after the Avengers), and he's coming off of the Avengers. Thor 2 and Man of Steel will either come in second or third, but I voted second for Thor 2 and third for Man of Steel. Hemsworth and Hiddleston are pretty popular right now, as are their Asgardian counterparts, and anyone who wants to find out what happens to Loki after watching the Avengers will watch Thor 2. I haven't been following the development of Man of Steel, so I don't have much to go on other than knowing that Superman is still one of the most popular superheroes. Wolverine without question will come in fourth. After 13 years and a movie that stunk, I think that Wolverine, or particularly Wolverine played by Hugh Jackman, has run its course. I may turn out to be wrong about the other three, but I'm pretty certain about this.

R_Hythlodeus 09-03-2012 02:38 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I miss the options where Thor 2 is first.

marvelrobbins 09-03-2012 03:41 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
Iron Man 3 will be 2013's top grossing comic book.Rather or not It's is criticaly viewed best Is another story.

I don't really care how Man of steel does.

The Wolverine will do better than X-men first Class without a doudt.

and people need to remember the first Thor did X-Men origins:Wolverine business.

Spider-Vader 09-03-2012 09:26 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
Iron Man will definitely win the Box Office battle. Quality-wise seems like it could go to anyone...for now.

cherokeesam 09-03-2012 11:22 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I think Man of Steel will come out on top by a large margin, but I hope to god the Nolanites don't try to champion this as his doing. If MOS goes platinum, it will be due to Snyder's influence far more than Nolan's.

Then, it's a toss-up between IM and Thor. I don't think either can expect a feel-good boost from Avenger coattails; instead, people will be judging those movies against IM2 and the first Thor. In which case it comes down to whichever one is perceived as far more of an improvement over their predecessors.

Wolverine has a hard row to hoe. X-Fans have already left the Singer (and, ugh, Ratner) era behind and are more interested in the sequel to XMFC. But The Wolverine definitely looks like the solo movie Logan *should* have had instead of that XMO bull****.

Tony Stark 09-03-2012 11:48 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
There's too much unknown about MOS. Granted the last movie sucked, but I don't think Superman has the appeal he once had.

IM3 will likely be the higest grossing Iron Man film, and if they get back to the roots of things, hopefully the best.

The underdog is Thor 2. Why because Chris Hemsworth has become the teenage heart throb of America. Between his work with Thor and SWATH, I expect to see a huge bump from the 2nd.

MOS May be no 2, but I'm going to call it for Thor at the moment.

Steyin 09-04-2012 11:07 AM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I highly doubt Supes will resonate with audiences at this point in time rather than IM, especially after the success of TA. Hell, I even feel Thor will be riding higher thanks to TA. Plus, after SR, Supes has a way to go in my eyes, but it will be closer between MoS and Thor 2 I think. I wouldn't be surprised with:

IM3
Thor 2
MoS
Wolverine

kedrell 09-04-2012 11:08 AM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
MOS and Wolverine are clearly the underdogs in this fight. IM3 is virtually guaranteed to win the year and Thor has more than a little edge over the other two.

marcvader 09-04-2012 11:10 AM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I'm going to guess it'll be a fight between IM3 and MoS for first with Thor and Wolvie bringing up the rear.

kedrell 09-04-2012 11:27 AM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I don't see how MOS stands a chance against IM3. It might slug it out with Thor2 for the #2 spot but that's about the best I could see for it.

Quasimod0 09-04-2012 11:39 AM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
Iron man is HUGE right now. Especially after the avengers. I could see mos doing really well though, if its a good film

marcvader 09-04-2012 11:59 AM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kedrell (Post 24265435)
I don't see how MOS stands a chance against IM3. It might slug it out with Thor2 for the #2 spot but that's about the best I could see for it.

It will be interesting to see what effect Avengers has on IM3. I'm playing it conservative and guessing IM3 makes IM2 money. MOS on the other hand is an unknown quantity. It looks like an interesting take on Supes from the little I've seen and I think this doesn't repeat the performance of Returns but does way better. Not going by much other than a gut feeling that this movie is going to look unique for a Superman movie and be the one he deserves.

Oscorp 09-04-2012 12:53 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
When it comes to biggest box office, I think it'll be:

Iron Man 3
Thor 2
Man of Steel
The Wolverine

When it comes to quality of the film, I think I'll rank them:

1) Man of Steel
2) Thor 2
3) Iron Man 3
4) The Wolverine

jaqua99 09-04-2012 01:01 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
IM3 and T:TDW will be close.

I think Thor 2 will be the best movie of these. But Chris is becoming the alpha male.

Chewy 09-04-2012 01:10 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
IM3 is going to be the clear winner. Wolvy will be the clear loser. Thor and Superman will duke it out for sloppy seconds

Also, lol @ the thread title

Quasimod0 09-04-2012 02:56 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I actually really want to see the new wolverine movie. Even though it sucked, I enjoyed origins. Also next summers lineup is filled with a list superheroes. Doesn't get much bigger than iron man, Thor, superman, and wolverine. Great time to be a comic fan. :up:

YoungPrime 09-04-2012 03:06 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by R_Hythlodeus (Post 24259797)
I miss the options where Thor 2 is first.

Sorry about that.

You know what though..... Thor has the potential of being Marvels "Lord Of The Rings" the same way GotG could be Marvel's StarWars and/or StarTrek.

I mean Thor has enough compelling stories to give even Game of Thrones a run for it's money but the only problem is that it probably won't. The first Thor film was okay. I especially like the parts where they focused on Thor's home world.

So if they make Asgard and the other realms a bigger focus in part 2 and allow the supporting characters to be more likable and relevant, then Thor could be in a class all by itself.

But it remains to be seen.

ThePowerCosmic 09-04-2012 05:06 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I see MoS coming in first in the BO with IM3 close behind, followed by Thor 2 and Wolverine.

BigThor 09-04-2012 05:23 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by marvelrobbins (Post 24260173)
Iron Man 3 will be 2013's top grossing comic book.Rather or not It's is criticaly viewed best Is another story.

I don't really care how Man of steel does.

The Wolverine will do better than X-men first Class without a doudt.

and people need to remember the first Thor did X-Men origins:Wolverine business.

Too bad THOR grossed almost 80 million dollars more than XO:W, I'm sure this thread is about WW numbers not domestic.

Moridin 09-04-2012 07:01 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
Box office-wise, IM3 easily, I think it'll easily cross $800m WW.
Thor 2 likely second with over $600m WW
Supes I think will settle around $500m but could also surpass Thor if it's a great film.
Wolverine - $400 - $500m.

My reasoning, both IM3 and Thor2 are coming off the Avengers high, they're very popular right now. So looking at previous BO - $623m (not in 3D) + $449m (practically unknown character) respectively) it's only going up from there.

Both Superman & Wolverine are in the opposite boat to IM & Thor. They both have to turn the tide that is the GA's perception of them because of previous films + in Supes case he's generally perceived as lame (before someone says "he's the most well known/best/first hero...!!", yes he's known world wide, but 'well known' and 'popular' aren't the same thing, Supes isn't popular. The film can change that, so we'll see)
However no X-Men film has done more than $460m WW and Superman has more potential for big spectacle (especially with Snyder's eye).


Quality wise, I think there's potential for high quality across the board, which is obviously awesome but I do think IM3 stands the best chance of being great with Shane Black writing/directing (with Favreau & Whedon in reserve along with the MS crew in general).

After that I think Thor 2 is most solid, Taylor & Rodat and again MS just seem to have their s*** together.

Wolverine I'm cautiously optimistic about after X:FC, Fox seem to have turned a bit of a corner but you never know.

MoS I'm most leary about. Goyer & Snyder both have very spotty records. If the script is great then Snyder will deliver, but Goyer seems to have sole screenplay credit (with C Nolan getting a story credit), hopefully either Goyer pulls something spectacular out of his ass or J Nolan script doctored.

Fingers crossed.

cherokeesam 09-04-2012 07:21 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I think Superman wins, hands down, because ironically enough, Marvel and DC do a shift in 2013: DC goes for a real four-color superhero with Kal-El, while Thor and Iron Man get the Nolanite "dark and gritty" treatment. And I think that will backfire, to great effect for MOS, and disappointing numbers for IM and Thor.

Granted, Zack Snyder isn't Steven Spielberg; he's definitely dropped the ball on some great potential several times. But so has Spielberg --- *many* times. There's one thing that's a guarantee for Snyder: he is extremely faithful to the source material of whatever comic/graphic novel he's adapting, so it's a given that his Superman will be very authentic to the books --- far more so than Bryan Singer's crap, and even the Donner films, which quickly devolved into Joel Schumacher-like camp over several installments.

Avengers was lightning in a bottle, and the bulk of its success draws from the team aspect. That aspect is, of course, lacking in the solo films; and there's already reports that Feige and the filmmakers are trying to steer away from Avenger references to let IM and Thor stand on their own. This is *not* a particularly intelligent strategy, trying to distance yourself from a box-office gold mine.

I'll be glad to reassess my opinion once we start seeing trailers for IM, Thor and MOS; but for now, everything I've seen puts MOS miles ahead of the competition in 2013.

BigThor 09-04-2012 07:49 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I'm going with Iron Man 3 in 1st, Thor II in 2nd, Man of Steel in 3rd, and Wolverine in 4th for right now.

YoungPrime 09-04-2012 10:48 PM

Re: Which Comic Book Hero will rain Supreme next year?
 
I think Kickass 2 will be better than Wolverine.

I'm kicking myself for not adding them to the poll. Mind you it wont do Wolverines numbers but it'll be a better quality film. Hell "Chronicle" is a better quality film.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:13 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SuperHeroHype.com, A property of CraveOnline, a divison of AtomicOnline, LLC © 2009 CraveOnline Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.