Originally Posted by Gilpesh
Suddenly it is he can't make a movie because he is mainly television and comics... Now it is just cause he can make a movie doesn't mean he can make a good one.
Box office? That's what you rate a good movie on? Shame.
Thanks for proving your own point of you couldn't make a good X4.
Though I hate to admit it, the box office is THE deciding factor on a movie's rate. Why? Because in the end it's the only way to decide on whether or not a film was able to capture the interest of general audiences. Serenity... really didn't.
But back on topic...
I don't want Whedon in there because, yes, I didn't feel that Serenity was all it could be. And yes, I don't like the idea of letting Whedon jump from the comics to the film.
And I don't want a fanboy to put his hands on the movie at all. Hell, I'd rather have someone with only meager knowledge to be given X4... Let a director take time out, evaluate the material, and adapt it well. Fanboys will bring biases.