Originally Posted by M.O.Steel
actually both evans and reynolds are doing the exact opposite of breaking cast by playing a second superhero.
there are other ways of breaking casts. REynolds in buried, nines, smoking aces, amityville horror. Evans in the losers, street kings, sunshine.
i don't really know which other actors were thrown around during development. and while i do agree that Evans is a much better actor than ackles, but i personally don't think he fits the role.
Cap is a COMPLETELY different character from anything Evans has been known for. Most people can only see him as a womanizing wise-ass.
If he pulls it off (which looks good so far) it would definitely be breaking cast. Its not about the genre, its the role.