I honestly didn't mind Katie Holmes in
Batman Begins... so for the sake of continuity I would of preferred if she returned for
The Dark Knight.
BUT Maggie is the FAR superior actress and after watching her in
The Dark Knight, I wish she would have been cast in
Batman Begins. I really thought her performance was great.
So really... I don't know.
The whole character kind of fell flat anyway... But perhaps we would have connected to her
slightly more if she was played by Maggie through the two films.