Originally Posted by SuperSoldier985
But it was ok when Schindler's List did it? Granted they still used accents, but I don't think it's fair to act as if historical movies should be judged on the such minute terms.
Agreed 100%. There really is no sense for American/ British actors to pretend to be German and speak English with a German accents. I don't know why that was such a complaint that the movie wasn't "authentic". If it was really authentic they'd be speaking GERMAN not English with German accents.