Re: Bryan Singer: Why 'Superman Returns' Didn't Work
For me, SR came off more as a closure to the Donnerverse/CR Series than the start of a new franchise.
I'll admit that I enjoyed SR, but like BR, there were a good amount of flaws for the film.
Every route that they should have take, thy either missed it or went about it the wrong way, while every route that they shouldn't have taken, they took in a sense.
From the color tone of the film, to the large amount of usage of CGI Superman, to the uninspired villainous plot, etc.
Granted, SR was miles better than the ideas that were being thrown around for a new superman movie prior to SR's release, but SR was still a badly executed film on a great subject.