View Single Post
Old 01-24-2012, 09:21 AM   #17
Newbie First Class
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Russia, Tver
Posts: 17
Default Re: X-Men 3...seriously fans/people--WHY all the hate?

Originally Posted by T-CLIPSE View Post
What is your definition of "so many characters"....two? Scott and Xavier? I already gave the meaning of their deaths in my first post.
Well, Magneto and Rogue and Mystique also kinda "died". Kinda.

There was funeral scene for Xavier to express loss, and even Magneto himself expressed regret about Xaviers death while defending him against Pyro's comments.
But his death wasn't needed for the plot. At all.

He was connected to the man who invented the mutant cure
But he's not connected with the plot. Throw him away, what changes? Nothing. Nothing at all.

Why in the world would The Phoenix be connected to a cure for mutants?
Because you need to connect all your plotlines together. If you do not, you will receive a bad plot. There always should be a reason in adding something in your movie. Having two (or more) unconnected plotlines ruins the whole movie.

whose deaths in my opinion raised the stakes of what is constantly being referred to as a war, PEOPLE DIE DURING WAR
It just doesn't work for me. And for many other people. It's not a matter of you killing or not killing people (mutants), it's a matter of HOW you do it. In this movie it was done awfully. In my humble opinion.

WhiteScorpio is offline   Reply With Quote