Re: So what DIDN'T we like?
That's true, the Nazis did make a cameo appearance.
Truth be told, I thought the Red Skull looked great, they just didn't give him much to do.
Overall, the movie didn't really give me a World War II feel. There were a few scenes, like Steve at the recruitment office, the lab scene, and the movies that pulled it off, but they were mostly in the first thirty minutes. Other than that though, very little reference to the ongoing conflict. The greatest conflict in history. It was little more than a backdrop, when they remembered it.
The lack of Nazis, the fairly blasť attitudes, and futuristic elements didn't help. It lacked an authenticity, at least in the historic department.