Originally Posted by Blackheart
Nope, his boyish charm would've worked wonders as Peter Parker. Hell, I'd even go as far as say that had he gotten the role, he would've done much better than Maguire.
Then Anne Hathaway could've been Mary Jane:
And we could've had some scenes like that of "Love and Other Drugs"
And btw, Anne could've made a great MJ - she definitely looks the part in that photo and has the personality for it.