View Single Post
Old 08-06-2012, 12:08 AM   #96
DogofKrypton
Banned User
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: California, USA
Posts: 533
Default Re: What's So Bad About Superman Returns?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bruce_Begins View Post
No, it doesn't as I have already explained, Iron man's success can be attributed to skills and presence of Robert Downey Jr. without hin (say Colin Farrell as Tony Stark /Iron man would not be as successful, of course this is mere speculation on my part but that is due to Iron Man being a B-List Marvel character and most of Colin Farrell's movies not doing well at Box Office.)
Wow. So you are ADMITTING 'Iron Man' was a better film, and that means it doesn't "count" because it had a far better actor in the lead??

Sorry, you fail.


Quote:
Comparing movies that are already established as Successful franchises and getting sequels like Iron Man 2, Spider-Man 3 and X-men 3 to a franchise like Superman Returns which was coming back to big screens after a period of 19 years and after the last two attempts that bombed (Superman 3, Superman 4) is not fair.
Fair? Did you say "fair"?

You're right. Comparing a B-list comic book character with ZERO live-action history against one with FIVE live-action films prior to SR, FOUR television series with one running current when SR came out, and at least FIVE animated series is definitely "unfair".

To "Iron Man".

Quote:
And why compare 300 with SR ? that is not a superhero movie, it is more like a war movie based on a GN.
"300" is a comic book film. Just because YOU don't want to admit that it is, doesn't mean that it isn't.


Quote:
Oh, come on, SR was in IMAX 3D in only a few IMAX theaters and Thor was released worldwide in mostly 3D format (some theaters had 2D Thor but they were a small percentage)
Wrong.

Quote:
and only 20 minutes of SR was in 3D (at IMAX) not the whole movie.

source
And the ticket prices were still for full IMAX 3-D. So you fail again.

Keep making things up though. Maybe WB will scrap "Man Of Steel" and do a sequel to a boring, bland flop instead...

DogofKrypton is offline   Reply With Quote