Originally Posted by charl_huntress
Not only my opinion. I also think it's BSinger's opinion too, since he readily admits he made mistakes.
At this point, I have come to think of SR as an elseworld that is not even related to anything else in the mythos. It's not even related to STM and SII because that would besmirch those movies by default association. With that said, I can totally see why you and others like the movie, but I do not think it is/was the sort of film that should have been released about Superman..for many different reasons.
We'll to agree to disagree on that...
Your choice, but SR is more connected and faithful to the Donner movies than the prequels were to the original Star Wars trilogy. To each thier own.