Originally Posted by charl_huntress
I don't get this thread. The question is "What's So Bad About Superman Returns?" Was this question asked to truly understand why some people don't like the film, or to try to convince those people who don't like it they are wrong?
The thread title was inspired by the name of a favorable Youtube review of SR
(see first post). So it was a rhetorical
question intended to highlight the film’s positive qualities - not an invitation to list its faults (plenty of those threads already
Imo, that video was poorly named and was too defensive. A proper
analysis should address the film - not critique the critics.