View Single Post
Old 09-20-2012, 06:30 PM   #10
Shaper Savant
pr0xyt0xin's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: United States
Posts: 6,935
Default Re: How close should a comic book movie be to its source material?

I think you can break it down into a few categories but there are exceptions for each:

Powers - Should be indistinguishable from the comics. Best example is Spidey's webshooters. But the counterexample is Thor stamping his hammer on the ground to make thunderstorms.

Origin - Can be altered to modernize, but should hold solid ties to the comics. Bruce Waynes parents need to be murdered, but Tony Stark can be held hostage by terrorists rather than communists.

Villains - The origin and powers of the villains should follow the above criteria. No robotic Green Goblin suit , but its okay that Two Face was burned instead of melted with acid (more realistic/modern?).

Love interest - Almost doesn't matter in most cases. Rachel Dawes: 100% Nolan's invention and perfectly functional. But Peter Parker changes from Gwen's death and almost requires both her and MJ for his story to be told properly.

Chronology - Besides key points (origin), chronological order need not be adapted. Certain things should just be dropped all together if they aren't used. Iron Monger can be Stark's first villain, but Spider-Man has to meet Gwen before he meets MJ.

In the end, as stated above, its case by case. As long as there is Potential for exploring the source material and Continuity within its own developed universe (I'm looking at you X-Men), I say pretty much anything goes.

Logan 9.0 | Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 9.5 | Wonder Woman 7.5 | Spider-Man: Homecoming 8.5 | Thor: Ragnarok 8.5 | Justice League 6.5

Tradition is just dead people's baggage.
pr0xyt0xin is offline   Reply With Quote