Originally Posted by CConn
1. Under The Red Hood
2. Return of the Joker
3. The Dark Knight Returns
4. Year One
5. Mask of the Phantasm
Something like that. To me, it's very much to Under The Red Hood as Rises is to TDK, but then again, you don't like Rises, so that analogy doesn't really work.
I do like Rises, I just see a lot of flaws in the story that really stand out.
I'm surprised you rate MOTP so low. Any particular reason?