Re: Judge Dredd Reboot!! - Part 2
I was having a similar discussion on the way back from the theatre. I don't think I'd want to see them done any way but extra dimensional reapers like in the book.
Part of the draw of the dark judges is that they can't be killed easily. Even if you succeed, they can just possess people. The added danger of they killed simply through touch is another factor too.
If they were mutants or drug addicts or whatever, I couldn't see them retaining those powers, and that's just not the dark judges then.
It'd be interesting to see them redesigned to fit this universe though. I may try drawing that.