Originally Posted by JP
How could it have been Marsden? Cyclops likely wasn't even born yet.
Scott looked to be in his mid-30s tops during the trilogy. That means he was born in the mid 70s.
It made no sense at all for a 16-year-old Scott to be alive in the mid-70s in Origins. That would make him 50 in X3. Nonsense.
Same thing with FC. A teenage Scott can't possibly exist in 1962.
I wouldn't mind seeing Scott as a child living in Xavier's school if Singer does indeed bump up the FC faction to 1980. Scott would have to be 11-years-old tops & not a year older.