Originally Posted by Anno_Domini
Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close, Hugo, Midnight in Paris, The Tree of Life
The Kids Are All Right
Avatar, Precious, Up in the Air
Milk, The Reader
These weren't good enough, imo, but they still got in.
So your argument for why the Oscar should nominate movies that dont deserve it, is because they have done it before? What a great fracking logic!
Btw, about half of those did deserve it imo.