Originally Posted by animexcel
If this is the case with X-M:FC, are you also saying The Dark Knight Trilogy and The Amazing Spider-man are not comic book movies?
I'd somwhat agree for Nolans DK trilogy does not have the feel of a CBM but I'd exclude Spider-man cause 1 and 2 (and as bad as it was even 3) felt like CBMs.
I brought up Godzilla because if you did a search on public opinion on whether they considered the 98 vers and Godzilla film they say otherwise though technically it is a Godzilla film.
Just cause it holds the name doesn't mean the Public Opinion will feel that it should have ever existed and respect the title
For example. Hallie Berry rendition of Cat-Woman
Let me make it clear that I'm NOT
trashing XM-FC as a good movie. It just didn't feel like a CBM and thats just fine but I'm just pointing out Movies that had that feel performed better in the BO