Re: Rogue or Kitty?
I don't think the question is whether Bryan would want Rogue but WILL Anna Paquin come back to the film. I'm quite certain she would love to work with Bryan Singer again as they were close post-X3.
With her commitments to HBO's True Blood will become the issue. Alan Ball (who adores Anna) is no longer in control of the show she may not have the leverage to do DOFP as she wants.
I can't see the core four without Anna. It was always James, Famke, Hugh and Anna. Will be weird NOT to see Anna in that cast. Kitty being in this film will be to shoe-horned and too forced. Would rather Singer drop that aspect if they can't bring Rogue in.