View Single Post
Old 02-07-2013, 06:58 PM   #799
Vid Electricz
Banned User
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 2,845
Default Re: Paul Giamatti IS Rhino

Originally Posted by DigificWriter View Post
^ I really think you're over-emphasizing the 'realism factor' when it comes to TASM. We're talking about a comic-book movie; Webb gave TASM a pastiche that was more grounded in reality than the Raimi films, but that's all this whole 'realism' thing is: a pastiche. Having another recognizable member of Spidey' s rogues gallery make a glorified cameo at the start of TASM 2 in no way, shape, or form 'automatically lowers the film to the juvenille level of a cartoon'. As I noted, it is totally in keeping with the film's synopsis and the parameters established by and in TASM 1.
Allow me to quote myself:

Yes. we all understand suspension of disbelief. Again, realism's got nothing to do with it. Spider-powers are inherently unrealistic. Yes, we know that and we accept it. This is basic storytelling.
You're taking what I wrote and you're interpreting it quite literally. I'm not even sure what you're on about here. It's not about "realism" or being "serious" . It's about the filmmakers establishing a tone and sticking to it. Not lazily dropping in fanservice characters with no explanation in a world with no precedent for it. Might as well be watching a cartoon at that point.

Making it "realistic" and making it "grounded" are two completely different things. The Nolan batfilms were not realistic at all, but they were grounded in a reality that made it easier to suspend our disbelief that these events were taking place. Same goes for TASM.

Vid Electricz is offline