If this poll was posted back in 2000 when Hugh first appeared as Wolverine this would be a tougher choice. I think back then he approached the character with a raw hunger that somehow has been lost over the years. Fassbender is in that place now and I have to say...he scared the f*** out of me in theaters. Ian's version was dangerous in a more refined way but you can see with Fassbender's portrayal how Ian's character became
the effed up ruined man he is.
To illustrate: In X1, Magneto stopped the bullet (and guns) from firing on those cops in the stand-off with Xavier at the Train Station. Fassbender's Magneto would have let s*** fly.
Fassbender's Magneto was ruthless...and he enjoyed it. LOL