View Single Post
Old 02-17-2013, 07:21 PM   #174
DACrowe's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Planet Earth
Posts: 29,355
Default Re: Why did the League of Shadows want to destroy a peaceful city?

Originally Posted by the_scream View Post
I'm a fan of TDKR but the biggest gripe I have is a serious issue with the film. In Batman Begins, it is clear that Gotham is corrupt and both Batman and Raas take different ideological approaches to the corruption. Batman thinks it can be saved. Raas believes it is for the good of the world to allow Gotham to perish as it is beyond saving.

Fast forward 8 years or so later. Batman was right. He managed to manipulate the system and work with Gordon and Dent to make a peaceful Gotham. It required Batmans sacrifice but it demonstrated Gotham was not beyond saving.

So, why is it the reformed League of Shadows cares to destroy Gotham? The film toys with the idea that there is still evil below the surface. But this evil is the League itself. The film also toys with the idea that Talia and Bane want vengeance for Raas death. But vengeance means destroying an entire city of people who didn't have anything to do with his death?

My biggest gripe with the film. Would welcome a rational explanation for what motivates the primary villains to want to kill millions of people.
Well beyond Daggett showing that there is still rampant corruption as he iNVITES them to his city and pays them with service to destroy it just to better position himself for a hostile takeover it's simple...

They're ideological terrorists who believe, with almost religious fervor, that Ra's Al Ghul was a god among men and that Gotham must be destroyed (at the very least as a moral example, eg. Bane's lines to Pavlo by the reactor). Look around at real terrorists today. Can you honestly say that a change in public policy for governments or countries they have declared a moral mission to destroy will sway them? For those who already drink the koolaide, probably not.

Honestly, Nolan's LOS is more a ridiculously well resourced and placed terrorist cell. Yeah, they have Ninjas and are led at the end by a guy in a mask that numbs his pain. But they are still more of that line than they are in the comics.

"Let us disappoint the Men who are raising themselves upon the ruin of this Country."

--John Adams

Last edited by DACrowe; 02-17-2013 at 07:24 PM.
DACrowe is offline   Reply With Quote