View Single Post
Old 02-24-2013, 07:27 AM   #107
SHIELD Director Coulson
cherokeesam's Avatar
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Cherokee, NC
Posts: 12,044
Default Re: Thor 2 Dark World news, speculation and pictures possible Spoilers - Part

Originally Posted by Incredible Hans View Post
So you mean all the legends (or most of them) aren't true? Interesting idea.

But in the real world, all people familiar with Norse mythology know that Loki is of frost giant heritage. Do all people on earth in the MCU know that? And if they do, why is Loki's heritage common knowledge on earth but a secret in Asgard (only Odin and Frigga knew it before Loki found out).

So Kenneth Branagh created some problems with his version of Thor. There are, however, several explanations how you could solve this problems:

A) All that "myth stuff" isn't true. These stories were made up by the Vikings. Thor never lifted the Midgard Serpent, he never disguised as Freya, Loki never killed Balder. And in the MCU, there is no mythological Viking story that tells of Loki's giant heritage. So the fact that Loki is a frost giant was a secret in Asgard and Midgard.

B) All the "myth stuff" is true. However, it didn't happen to the current versions of Thor, Loki, Odin etc. Ragnarok already took place once, Asgard had been destroyed, all the gods were reborn. Thor in his first life lifted the Midgard serpent (and that's what the Vikings tell us about in their sagas). The current Thor didn't, he was a small boy during the Viking age. The first Loki was a son of a frost giant (so that's the reason why the Vikings and all scholars of Norse mythology knew it), but the current Loki didn't know that this was also true for him.

C) All the "myth stuff" is true, but it didn't take place during the Viking era, but some centuries later. Loki and Thor weren grown-ups then. In the MCU, there are no Viking stories about adult Thor and Loki - all these stories come from the Icelander Snorri Sturleson (who was a Christian and no Norse pagean) who lived in the 12th/13th century. So Snorri knew Thor and Loki when they were adult and wrote down their stories.
Or maybe the Asgardians had a "PR man" who told the Vikings to write down those stories, and the stories have little to no basis in the reality of what the Asgardians experienced.

For a character who's based on mythology and pagan gods, Thor has never been "properly" dealt with by Marvel. The elephant in the room has always been that this guy was worshipped as a god by large numbers of humanity, was later described by Christianity as just a lie, and has now come back and proven to the whole world that he definitely exists. So everyone on this planet (and maybe others) is going to want to know just how many OTHER truths in Norse myth (and other pantheons, for that matter --- just wait 'til Hercules shows up in the MCU) were buried by the monotheist Christians.


...They move like slick cotton on oil.

---Echostation, 3/18/2014
cherokeesam is offline