I chose Anne. Michelle gave an awesome performance for what was written for her. But what was written for Pfeiffer was ridiculous in my opinion. It wasn't Selina or Catwoman at all, even though she looked like a great Catwoman visually.
Originally Posted by RustyCage
Michelle is a more natural actress and I liked her version a lot, but Anne's take was simply much more in line tonally with the version of the character that I love (which is more of a sly Robin Hood than a psycho).
I don't think either of them would match up to each other's performances if their roles were reversed.