Originally Posted by Anno_Domini
The only one I really recall saying TDKR will lose all love from fans was Fudgie.
That might be true. I can't remember, and can't be bothered to go and check. Either way there was definitely a fairly vocal group saying that the only reason TDKR was doing that well was from the short term hype surrounding it immediately after release.
The whole reason I made this thread was to find out if that was true, and it's clearly not (although the difference in results between now and then indicates that there was a little bit of "flavour of the month" syndrome going on).