Re: am I the only one who DIDN'T think Nicholson nailed joker??
As I said before,Hamill's Joker is the only one who truly nailed the Joker to me.
Comparing Jack to Heath is tough,since both got different aspects of the character right.Heath's was better written.Clever and cunning.They got the essence of the Batman/Joker "relationship" right,something Burton's wasn't even close on.("I don't wanna kill you!What would I do without you?")Jack on the other hand,had the showmanship that honestly Heath's was lacking.I prefer a Joker who likes to have fun with victims.(electric joy buzzer,Acid squirting flower,etc)Not an average shmuck that kills with a knife.
In the end,both were good,but Hamill owns them both.