Originally Posted by Anno_Domini
Interesting reply and I get what you mean, BUT...I would consider Anne's performance as Selina Oscar-worthy indeed, though. If you look at the Anne Hathaway/Selina Kyle appreciation thread, you'll find others who feel the same way
What was so oscar-worthy about her performance? She was playing a bad caricature. Femme fatale, done to death, and also much better by all those classic actresses in the 1940s.
I think Anne Hathaway is very overrated. Just because she is popular and stars in many big hollywood films does not make her a good actress.
One actress I love is Jennifer Jason Leigh, but I don't think she ever got an oscar. Despite the fact that she does much more challenging roles than Anne Hathaway.