Originally Posted by ctsketch
he's an actor, if he can't make it believable he isn't doing his job. My favorite actors are those that play bad guys and good guys well
I wasn't arguing his ability as an actor, I am saying his perception with the public is that of an American Icon and pitting Robert Redford, the man, against America is not something I see working in Mr. Redford's favor. The more natural role for Mr. Redford would be to work with Captain America, not against.
Again, I'm not saying you, or anyone else, is wrong, I'm saying I don't see Mr. Redford taking that role.