View Single Post
Old 05-03-2013, 04:13 PM   #200
NosfeRomas's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2012
Posts: 1,586
Default Re: Which villain(s) should the reboot start with?

Originally Posted by Vid Electricz View Post
"Don't push it"? "Push" what? I get that everyone loves the comics and cartoons and Arkham Asylum and they want the live action movies to be "just like them", but pretty much every idea I've seen in this thread sounds awful.

I don't understand how I'm not allowed to be critical of anyone's ideas simply because "we are geeks" (whatever that's supposed to mean). I see it in the Superman and Spider-Man forums as well. Fanboys speculating, offering up ridiculous scenarios that they've gathered from cartoons and video games that have no business being in a live action film (if it's to be taken the least bit seriously).

When I read things like: "I want Professor Pyg to pop up and for Batman to take him down real quick just to establish his status" I'm left scratching my head, because this is something that sounds great as a side-mission in a video game, but would be laughable and ridiculous in a film...and since this is a public forum, these things are fair game for criticism.

These are some of the reasons why I'm glad that none of you have any say in these films lol.
Ok i kinda see your point but how "mad hatter for this and that reason played by this dude" is a "rediculous" opinion ? Just HOW ? we are speculating, discussing, arguing thats the point of a forum and going into a forum you have to expect a bunch of different answers. To my eyes thats how films get made, Joel Schumacher was gay and put nipples on Batman, Tim Burton likes dark romantic fantasy and made his version of Batman, Nolan is a sci fi-ish realist he made his own Batman if an avid video gamer picks the mantle of the Director im sure he will make it look like video game stages. Bad or not thats what makes it different and who knows it might work, Burton did his thing and it worked, Nolan did his thing and it worked.

NosfeRomas is offline   Reply With Quote