Re: Do you wish Katie was in TDK, or do you wish Maggie was in BB?
I would prefer Katie return. I honestly don't think Maggie was any better in the role, and I almost expected Bale to look at her at some point and say "wow, Rachel, these last few years have been REALLY rough on you."
Above either one of those two, though, I would choose Rachel McAdams, since I remember rumors of her being up for the replacement in Dark Knight. I think she is a better actress and better looking than both, so everyone wins.
This is my signature.