Originally Posted by Joe Stubbs
Thanks for the answer Moridin.
The Total Film and digitalspy reviews are both 3/5 and rated as Fresh. Empire Magazine defines 3 stars as 'good' so I'm guessing their 3 star reviews mostly get listed as Fresh as well but I don't know.
If I remember correctly, the critic decides if they want the review to be listed as "fresh" or "rotten" when they submit their review.