Re: Rank the Superman films
It's a tie for me between Man of Steel & Superman Returns. Each bring different qualities and each has its own faults (MOS has a very poorly structured script, Returns brings a lot of the camp and bad choices from the Donner films).
All-Star Superman wasn't adapted all that well imo, but it's still quite a good film.
The Reeve films I don't much care for except Reeve as Superman. Too campy and 70s for my taste.