Originally Posted by Krumm
I find this a little confusing. Are you saying that you would've been okay if Superman had choices and still killed Zod (if that's what we're talking about)?
For me, it was the fact he didn't have a choice that made it okay.
No i'm saying I would have preferred it if the creative team had not DECIDED
to go with a plot that ended with Superman having to make that decision.
But I would have been 'okay' with Goyer/Snyders CHOICE
to have Superman kill, if the final product had been quality, and the matter handled respectfully instead of dismissively and unneccesarily brutal.
I don't understand why people keep argueing the 'he didn't have a choice' arguement at all.
As though people think it's Superman himselfs fault for what happened at the end of the movie.
It's obviously not his fault
It's Goyer/Snyder's fault. They made the decision.
What Superman did as a result of their choice is something that cannot be changed.