No i'm saying I would have preferred it if the creative team had not DECIDED
to go with a plot that ended with Superman having to make that decision.
But I would have been 'okay' with Goyer/Snyders CHOICE
to have Superman kill, if the final product had been quality, and the matter handled respectfully instead of dismissively and unneccesarily brutal.
I don't understand why people keep argueing the 'he didn't have a choice' arguement at all.
As though people think it's Superman himselfs fault for what happened at the end of the movie.
It's obviously not his fault
It's Goyer/Snyder's fault. They made the decision.
What Superman did as a result of their choice is something that cannot be changed.