Originally Posted by slumcat
Yeah Superman is supposed to be a bit "simple" but I think Evans as Captain America plays a similar boyscout character so well. He's also a very very very nice guy, but also strong and noble and can be disarmingly funny and candid at times. I think that's the way to play a very good guy. You don't need to be depressed if you are playing a goody two shoes guy.
I found Evans Captain America goofy in some parts. specially in the Avengers. That's not charisma. Sorry.