Originally Posted by Batmannerism
Actually, that was exactly the question, you've answered precisely what I asked.
It feels weird quoting myself but ...
So actually, you did precisely what I was hoping people would do.
Not sure if there was a thread on this already, maybe, but some questions need to be answered more than once.
Oh right I thought you wanted to know the why of one been a classic and the other having divided fan opinion but glad I answered correctly
One thing I've noticed in the modern day is some people think you have to tear one down to say how much you love the other and that is just wrong to me. I personally love both movies and I'm very happy that I have what are two near perfect Superman films to me. I especially didn't want to get into the negatives if why the score for both wasn't a 10 as I want to concentrate on the positives. The internet has become an extremely negative place.