View Single Post
Old 11-21-2013, 07:08 AM   #348
Dr.'s Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Toronto
Posts: 2,926
Default Re: What's So Bad About Superman Returns?

Originally Posted by Joshua_B View Post
...the way it happened goes all the way back to him and Lois shacking up in "Superman II"...
Problematic - since the SII tryst occurred in ~1978 and Jason is 5 or 6 in 2006. If a viewer had not seen SII (and it’s not a prerequisite) then they’d simply assume that Supes and Lois got together (at least once) just prior to his departure. And that’s all one needs to know.

Not only is he conceived out of marriage...
This is a fairly puritanical perspective. If sex out of wedlock grates your cheese then there’s probably a great deal about modern society and pop culture that you dislike.

...Superman just abandons Lois (and by extension, Jason)...
That Supes left without saying good-bye to Lois is a significant plot element that’s revisited and (finally) redressed during the course of the film. But there is no “abandons” Jason “by extension.” Supes entire arc is about finding/reconnecting to family. And he ultimately finds this by learning of his son’s existence. He would not - and does not - abandon the very thing he was looking for. The discovery of an unknown child (for obvious reasons, this usually happens to men ) is a reasonably common narrative device. TV Tropes calls it Who’s Your Daddy? This can play out in a number of ways. But if the “new father” is a good/sympathetic character, he’ll typically want to develop a relationship with (or otherwise support) his newfound child. And this was conveyed at the conclusion of SR.

Dr. is offline   Reply With Quote